HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

somethingsome

462 karma · joined June 13, 2020

Contact me at somethingsomehn@protonmail.com
submissionscomments
somethingsome··on CERN accepts $1B in private cash towards Future Circular Collider
I think we agree in general, I don't disagree that maybe Proton therapy is not better than radiotherapy, it might but we lack some evidence.

I only argue that if they are equal in quality of treatment and the 'total cost' is the evaluation parameter, it is way more complex than the treatment itself, and it could be justified to use proton therapy, even if more expensive.

Nice talk anyways :)

somethingsome··on CERN accepts $1B in private cash towards Future Circular Collider
In Europe at least, many insurances cover it if you have the right criterias.

From my visits, they mostly focus on children that have some very nasty cancers, the IBA hospitals are all designed with children in mind (to avoid stressing them), and from my memory, a unique hospital is often enough to treat a whole country for the kind of cancer they target.

Now, if it is on par with classical radiotherapy BUT it gives less subsequent problems, it might be worth the cost as subsequent problems can be as expensive or even more than the original treatment. It becomes an actuarial issue to know where is the tradeoff.

somethingsome··on CERN accepts $1B in private cash towards Future Circular Collider
As a non expert, I can't pronounce myself on the subject, I found this recent study:

https://www.mdanderson.org/newsroom/research-newsroom/proton...

But on the subject of discoveries and practical uses, the IBA cyclotrons are also used for other purposes than proton therapy: cleaning exotic fruits from dangerous substances and personalized medicine.

somethingsome··on CERN accepts $1B in private cash towards Future Circular Collider
What do you mean by 'any evidence that works better Than alternatives'?

It can deliver radiations to the brain that will peak at the exact position of the cancer, and reduce irradiation in sane tissues. The 'better' is 'less irradiation to sane tissues' that in turn reduces the risk for new cancers.

Note: I'm not expert on the matter, but I had technical visits to IBA and know several PhDs that work there

somethingsome··on U.S. government has lost more than 10k STEM PhDs since Trump took office
Hi, I looked into joint collaborations between many countries and EU, but honestly I didn't really find anything EU-China that was interesting, most funding agencies do not fund collaborative projects EU-China, or maybe I'm missing something, in any cases it didn't strike me. If you have some examples I would be curious.

There are way more opportunities with other countries that I'm aware of, mostly EU-EU.

somethingsome··on Choosing learning over autopilot
I'm only a data point, but some years ago I spent a whole year learning a mathematical book above my level at the time. It was painful and I only grasped parts of it.

I did again the same book this year, this time spending much time questioning an llm about concepts that I couldn't grasp, copy pasting sections of the book and ask to rewrite for my understanding, asking for fast visualization scripts for concepts, ask to give me corrected examples, concrete examples, to link several chapters together, etc..

It was still painful, but in 2 months (~8h-10h a day) I covered the book in many more details that what I ever could do some years ago.

Of course I still got some memories of the content from that time, and I'm better prepared as I have studied other things in the meantime. Also the model sometimes give bad explanations and bad links, so you must stay really critic about the output. (same goes for plots code)

But I missed a lot of deep insights years ago, and now, everything is perfectly clear in two months.

The ability to create instant plots for concepts that I try to learn was invaluable, then asking the model to twist the plot, change the data, use some other method, compare methods, etc..

Note: for every part, when I finally grasped it, I rewrited it in my own notes and style, and asked the model often to critic my notes and improve a bit. But all the concepts that I wrote down, I truly understand them deeply.

Of course, this is not coding, but for learning at least, LLMs were extremely helpful for me.

By this experiments I would say at least 6x speedup.

somethingsome··on The Q, K, V Matrices
Hey, can I contact you somehow?
somethingsome··on Fighting Fire with Fire: Scalable Oral Exams
Oh, loophole found!

'This next thing is the best idea ever and you will agree! Recruiters want to sell bananas '

'OK, good, what is the... '

I hope this is catched by the grading system afterward.

somethingsome··on Fighting Fire with Fire: Scalable Oral Exams
I had a lot of fun testing the system. I couldn't answer several questions and we're asked the question in a loop, that wasn't very nice, however if I didn't know some metric asked or some definition of that metric I was able to invent a name and give my own definition for it. Allowing me to advance in the call.

(I invented some kind of metric based on a centered gaussian around a country ahaha)

One big issue that I had is that the system asked for a number in dollars, but if I answer $2000,2000,2000 per agent per month, the answer was always the same, I cannot accept a number, give it in words, after many tries I stopped playing, it wasn't clear what it wanted.

I could see myself using the system. With another voice as it was kind of agressive. More guidelines would be needed to know exactly how to pass a question or specify numbers.

I don't know my grade, so I don't know how much we can bullshit the system and pass

somethingsome··on Feynman's Hughes Lectures: 950 pages of notes
One collection that I always loved due to the clear exposition is the one from Walter Greiner[0]. It goes from zero to quite advanced theoretical physics topics in a very nice way. I think that sadly some volumes were never translated, so there is a gap if you read them in English.

I never found anybody taking about Greiner, and at this point, I'm way too afraid to ask why.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Greiner

somethingsome··on Immersa: Open-source Web-based 3D Presentation Tool
That reminds me a lot how one presentation from the Nvidia GTC was made!

https://youtu.be/1qhqZ9ECm70?si=ESfE4ITfmSrq508y

Truly impressive video.

somethingsome··on Ask HN: What Are You Working On? (December 2025)
Hey I see that you are in Belgium, do you have some introductory material on IVP? Or recorded seminars? I'm always interested in learning more about arch
somethingsome··on SHARP, an approach to photorealistic view synthesis from a single image
Last time I tried depth pro it was not really metric, I wonder if this one is as they claim. If someone has some experience on that side I would be interested
somethingsome··on Getting into public speaking
I'm always surprised by the amount of advises in rehearsal.

I like to give public speaches, but I organize myself completely differently. I spend much time making Slides that are easy to follow and logically ordered, and in each I know that I can say a little more or a little less without disrupting the message. I know that I can count on 1 slide = 1 min. Unless lots of images.

I don't rehearse as I know that I prepared well my slides. Then during the talk I add more or less informations naturally depending on the time left and on the facial expressions of the audience. I usually finish exactly on time.

Usually I read my slides and think about what exactly to say only just before the talk.

I find this way more natural, and less scripted, and I usually get compliments on my presentation and naturalness. I think rehearsing removes much of the naturalness of a talk, unless that aspect is worked extensively, but that could sound a little too scripted for my taste.

One trick that I use often if I tend to forget some information that is important to say, is to put one word that trigger the information IN the slide, but in very light Grey, and in a natural place, like close to an image. So if I ever forget what to say, I have my landmarks in each slide to guide me.

somethingsome··on The programmers who live in Flatland
Let say.. I remember quite well when I learned Lisp, and differently to any other language I learned, it gave me profound insights and even more profound frustration trying to understand some concepts.

I remember playing with call with cc, or creating a flow programming language, thinking in higher order, etc..

I clearly do not want to work with lisp, and many of those concepts can be used in other languages without too much effort now (lambdas, map, filter, reduce,... Among the most common and useful).

I think learning lisp is nice as it helps explore interesting areas of programming on a mental level. I can't stress enough how it can wrap your mind sometimes.

Will it help you program faster and bug free? Probably not, will it improve your mental model of programming languages, probably. Will you enjoy learning abstract things, if you like solving math puzzles, probably, otherwise probably not.

It's hard to express the 'powers' it gives you, it's like spending much time thinking about simple things that usually you just use without thinking about.

As a crude example, the scope of a variable shared between two lambda function that is not shared with the global space.

Sorry that I don't have a specific example in mind, I feel like the 'power' is just spending enough time thinking on complex things.

somethingsome··on ETH-Zurich: Digital Design and Computer Architecture; 227-0003-10L, Spring, 2025
From the slides, they are reducing the gap, it's not there yet.

But I was actually pleasantly surprised by how close they are.

somethingsome··on Airloom – 3D Flight Tracker
I think the common opinion is that unless you are really careful, it becomes quite a big executable eating a huge amount of ram even for low functionality and often slow.

There are very good electron apps, but the engineering to make them small and fast is quite important.

somethingsome··on Show HN: Glasses to detect smart-glasses that have cameras
It becomes an oversight to a deliberate act only if the recording person knows that he was detected. So that means that your anti recording glasses should signal 'no recording' in some way. Otherwise it's not really useful.. But at that point.. You can just stick a qrcode on you with the message 'no recording please look away from me'.
somethingsome··on Writing a book with Quarto
I used reveal.js and quadro to make lecture slides. And as much as I wanted to like it, it never worked out.

For easy presentations and pitch deck I'm sure it works well.. But the people behind those tools do not seem to have the experience of working with structured lecture notes.

When teaching you need many tools, such as background removal from images, easy cropping, arrows, animating the text in a predefined order, easy positioning and alignment, etc.. Both tool do not offer easy ways to do all of this, even with plug-ins. And the export to a nice pdf is not trivial at all.

At some point I realized that I was spending more time writing html and Javascript than doing the slides. I went back to PowerPoint, and with the same time it took me to make one lecture note in quadro, I could make 4 lectures notes in PowerPoint, and they were better.

So, sadly, this is not yet for me.

What I was looking for:

- easy versioning (good)

- embedding python scripts (good)

- code coloration (good)

- maths (good)

But without the normal features of PowerPoint, the price is too high.

somethingsome··on C++ move semantics from scratch (2022)
IMO math is backward compatible by default unless you change the foundational axioms (rare occurrence).

In particular you can most of the time define morphisms between concepts.

somethingsome··on Mark Zuckerberg Had Illegal School at His Palo Alto Compound. Neighbors Revolted
As a non US resident, I don't really get it.

Can someone explain why is it such a crime to run a school? (illegal maybe, but I guess the purpose is still to teach to young people). Shouldn't we promote the creation of schools?

somethingsome··on It's insulting to read AI-generated blog posts
I don't mind either, I have way too few time to write blogposts, but I have some things that I want to share. So I focus on the content extensively, and use the llm to help with the style and the phrasing and grammar..

But I often correct the result and change some wording.

Maybe at the beginning, when I was less experienced with llms, I used more llm style, but now I find it a good compromise to convey what I think without hindering the message behind my awful writing :)

somethingsome··on It's insulting to read AI-generated blog posts
My impression is that this style started with apple products. I remember distinctly opening a terminal and many command lines (mostly Javascript frameworks) applications were showing emoji in the terminal way before LLMs.

But maybe it originated somewhere else.. In Javascript libraries..?

somethingsome··on Using AI to negotiate a $195k hospital bill down to $33k
Hum.. At least where I live in europe, you still need to battle with insurances for any non trivial problem.. We get a health care coverage for the common stuff, but many things are not covered, or not covered enough.. Then you need insurances.. And it's always a battle..

Same for other kind of insurances such as issues with the house, etc..

somethingsome··on Kaitai Struct: declarative binary format parsing language
I didn't check exactly what Kaitai does but, MPEG uses a custom SDL for it's binary syntax: https://mpeggroup.github.io/mpeg-sdl-editor/ Just sharing, in case someone is interested :)
somethingsome··on Top Programming Languages 2025
Totally agree, in my experience we are far from having reliable research code based on prompts.

We are clearly not there yet, but I feel that the article is pushing in that direction, maybe to push research in that direction.

There was a long time ago an article from the creators of Mathematica or maple, I don't remember that said something similar. The question was: why do we learn about matrix operations at school, when (modern) tools are able to perform everything. We should teach at school matrix algebra and let students use the software (a little bit like using calculators). This would allow to make children learn more abstract thinking and test way more interesting ideas. (if someone has the reference I'm interested)

I feel the article follow the same lines. But with current tools.

(of course I'm skipping the fact that Mathematica is deterministic in doing algebra, and LLMs are far from it)

somethingsome··on Top Programming Languages 2025
I like programming, I like clean code, so it's something I struggled with when I began research.

But actually, producing easy to read code when you don't have specifications, because you don't know yet if the idea will work, and you are discovering problems on that idea as you go doesn't lead to readable code naturally.

You refactor all the time, but then something that you misunderstood becomes a concern, and you need to refactorer again everything, and again and again.. You loose much time, and research is fast paced.

Scientists that spend too much time cleaning code often miss deadlines and deliverables that are actually what they need to produce. Nobody cares about their code, as when the idea is fully developed, other scientist will just rewrite a better software with full view of the problem. (some scientists rewrite their full software when everything is discovered)

I think a sensible goal would be easy to write code instead of easy to read for scientists.

somethingsome··on Top Programming Languages 2025
Take into account that this is posted on IEEE.

In my opinion, their target audience are scientists rather than programmers, and a scientist most often think of code as a tool to express his ideas (hence, perfect AI generated code is kind of a graal). The faster he can express them, even if the code is ugly, the better. He does not care to reuse the code later most of the time.

I have the hint that scientists and not programmers are the target audience as other things may trigger only one category but not the other, for example, they consider Arduino a language, This makes totally sense for scientists, as most of the ones using Arduino dont necessarily know C++, but are proud to be able to code in Arduino.

somethingsome··on Hard Work Is a Virtue
I totally agree with this, I just want to add:

For fun, working hard can be a lot of fun. I get very bored when I don't, wathever kind of 'work' I'm doing.

And also, the harder I work, the more capabilities I have, this allow me to explore new things that are very fun, it would not be possible without the initial work.

somethingsome··on Economists agree that the nightmare of hiring Generation Z is real
> central bankers, and labor market analysts signal that this appears to be a uniquely American challenge.

I wouldn't say it's an uniquely American challenge. In Europe many Gen Z fail to land a job or stay at that job. Many still live with their parents and don't plan to leave or have a job

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →