HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

song

1,318 karma · joined March 6, 2008

submissionscomments
song··on Training for Discontent
I went to an top ranked university (so called Grande Ecole) in my country. Since I graduated, I've never really had a use for the prestige of my university.

Of course, part of the reason is that I've worked almost exclusively abroad and there nobody knows that my university is well ranked but I strongly believe that what really matters in the end is the actual skills you have and not where the diploma comes from.

I find it sad when kids waste their childhood because their parents push them to got to the one perfect ivy league school. I don't think it's beneficial for a kid to choose extracurricular activities based on how the admission committee will look at them. I also do not believe in hours of homework that prevent the kid from having time to assuage his natural curiosity and to have fun.

song··on Santa Monica council votes 7-0 to crack down on Airbnb
In my apartment building there's an apartment that is rented out through Airbnb. There's also an apartment rented out to two students...

We have a lot more issues with those two students and their friends than with all of the Airbnb short term renters. It's anecdotical but I don't believe that short term renters are more likely to cause issues.

Airbnb's concept is also not new. Before Airbnb people rented apartments on Homelidays. It's interesting that thanks to the critical mass of Airbnb and their marketing people become more aware of it.

song··on How I Got Converted to G.M.O. Food
Well yes but it's also what they did that's a bit of an issue. The roundup ready crops are crops that are engineered to be resistant to the Roundup herbicide which is a bit more iffy than the example given in the article of a eggplant with a gene transferred from Bacillus thuringiensi which is allowed to use in organic farming.

On Monsanto side, the controversy was originally about the use of Roundup (which the G.M.O. permitted) and the potential toxicity of glyphosate.

song··on How I Got Converted to G.M.O. Food
I blame monsanto for the G.M.O. hysteria, they gave G.M.Os a bad name and now people who call themselves environmentalists behave irrationally because they can't be bothered to look past the name and actually look at the facts... In a lot of cases G.M.Os are safe and are actually better for the environment because they can reduce the amount of pesticides used (or reduce deficiencies in the target populations).

G.M.Os should be studied on a case by case basis.

It's the same with nuclear power. Banning nuclear power and all research on nuclear power (e.g. Thorium) is short-sighted.

song··on This French tech school has no teachers, no books, no tuition
I wouldn't say either that a Rails app is low level. Developing a rails app that can handle really high level of traffic does need a lot of specialized and deep knowledge.
song··on This French tech school has no teachers, no books, no tuition
No I didn't, but then I do have to say it's not a huge sample size (6 people altogether 3 from Grande Ecoles, 2 from Supinfo, 1 EPITA) but the effect of lack of actual practical experience and slowness due to that was flagrant for the Grandes Ecoles.

It was for Rails web application which I have to say requires somewhat less pure CS theory (although it is very useful to reason with).

song··on This French tech school has no teachers, no books, no tuition
I come from a French grande ecole but from my experience, I prefer people coming out of Supinfo and Epita/Epitech than people fresh out of a French Grande Ecole.

The problem of most people coming out of grande ecoles is that they lack experience, after a few years on the job, they can become great, but newly graduated engineers from Grand Ecoles are not very efficient at the beginning on average.

On the other hand, I've seen great candidates from Supinfo and Epitech who learned a lot of the CS theory on the side by themselves and were really good...

I think learning CS Theory without a good practical background is actually wasted a bit and that more Grandes Ecoles should try to get students to have more practical experiences which would help them connect the theory to actual situations they've had.

song··on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early
I didn't know gun ownership in Germany was that high, anecdotically, the only people I know with a gun over there keep it in the hunting/shooting club and not at home (It's more of a gun used for sport than for protection).

In term of cultural homogeneity, I don't actually think there's much less cultural homogeneity in Europe compared to US. We do have a lot of immigrants from different cultures actually...

I do agree in term of poverty factor, for a country that is seen externally as being rather powerful and rich, there's a lot of inequality in the US with a very sizable underclass and a seemingly low upward mobility. This is the one thing I rather appreciate in Europe, education is almost free and opens a lot of opportunities that I probably wouldn't have had if I were american (even my tuition when I was an exchange student in the US was free thanks to that).

song··on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early
Sure, it might be a selection bias, I was a student in all three cases and, by definition, students tend to be more educated.

What I mean by external factor is the laws, the way the criminal system is setup, the lack or not of reinsertion opportunities for ex-cons and so on. You might say that in a democracy all of this is decided by the people, but there's a certain inertia that sets in that mean that people have very little influence in changing things and there are powerful forces that try to keep things as they are (for profit or different reasons).

song··on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early
I've spent quite some time in Germany and well I'm sorry to shatter your bubble but Germans do cross an empty street when the light is red. I've even seen people party in nightclubs and go outside to drink vodka or other drinks they bought in their car.

And to further tear your argument, Spanish who have a "reputation" in Europe of crossing by red light and of having a bit more of loose attitude towards rules have a similar murder rate. 0.9 for Spain, 0.86 for Germany.

I think the factors are external rather than internal. I don't know exactly what causes it though. The higher availability of guns in the US? The fact that the prison system in the US does not reform but punishes instead and convert first time convicts into hardened criminals? Other factors?

I don't know but having lived in all three countries, I don't see that many differences in term of people's character that could explain the difference in murder rate.

song··on Google warns of unauthorized TLS certificates trusted by almost all OSes
To be fair Tom-Skype predates Microsoft's buyout of Skype.
song··on Learning Vim while playing a game
I'd love to be able to reassign some keys. I use colemak and for example h,j,k,l need to be reassigned to actually be usable (otherwise, the layout hardly makes sense).
song··on Andrew S. Tanenbaum's FAQ
I strongly recommend reading all of his books. They are very clear and non boring and the knowledge you get from understanding them is really the basics of what any programer should know I believe (well except maybe for the distributed systems book).

After reading this faq, I'm very curious about the travel book.

song··on “Sierra… well, it was the poor victim of a hostile takeover by criminals”
Unless I'm very confused, there wasn't any kickstarter for Spacebase DF-9. Just the initial investment and then the early access sales. The first two weeks of the early access sales recouped the $400k investment from Indie Fund and others which makes more sense (it would have been very hard to defend them had they used kickstarter to raise money and give it back to investors).

There was a kickstarter for Massive Chalice but that's a different game.

song··on “Sierra… well, it was the poor victim of a hostile takeover by criminals”
The initial project was to develop an unspecified games and go along for the ride even if it crashes and burn. Compared to later kickstarters Double Fine Adventure was not very specific about what it would be...

I personally liked Act 1 (even if the puzzles were a tad simple) and I'm really looking forward to the Act 2.

Now, I personally see backing on Kickstarter as Patronage. I'm giving money to artists because I like what they've done in the past or because I think that they should do well but I'm not looking on a return of investment. For me, I'm giving money in order to support arts that I like and in the hope that more of the kind of arts that I like is produced but I fully acknowledge the risks and the fact that I'm paying a lot more as a backer than if I just waited to pick up the game on sale a few month later.

song··on The sound of the dialup, pictured and explained (2012)
Thanks for that... I miss that sound, lots of memories.
song··on A shrinking Firefox faces endangered species status
That's interesting, I've switched back to Firefox because Chrome was getting slower and currently for my usage (I tend to have 100+ tabs open) under Yosemite, Firefox wins hands down compared to Safari and Chrome.

I thought that they've improved a lot in recent times whereas Chrome has become more and more bloated...

song··on Understand contracts before you sign them
I clicked on Register Now and got a 404 page.
song··on Ask HN: I have $2k for books, training and confs. What should I spend it on?
Yes but the subset from Safari Books Online is quite restrictive. I ended up having to get Safari separately to access some of the books I wanted...
song··on How Spelling Keeps Kids From Learning
Well, I'm French and have a much easier time with spelling in English than in French... Joke aside, I guess having multiple sequence of characters map to the same sound have more of an effect on making spelling difficult.

While I think that indeed a given sequence of characters is generally pronounced the same what is confusing for children is the plethora of consonants that are not pronounced. So ils chantent and il ment. écoles et les and so on... There's also the liaisons that adds a lot of confusion between what's written and what's actually pronounced. But maybe you're right and this is more of a problem in English.

song··on How Spelling Keeps Kids From Learning
In term of spelling French is much worse than English. I wonder how they compare in term of education level. My anecdotal experience living and going to school in both England and France as a kid leads me to believe that the level of British primary school is not very high and that basic knowledge in math and reading is introduced slower there.
song··on Hacked. A Short Story
And that's why I'm quite excited by the concept of Coreos and the way they do updates.
song··on Hacked. A Short Story
Still, he provided a service that was important for the customer. And, the customer wanted him to configure exim4 because a lot of the emails sent were marked as spam. The compromise was most likely the biggest reason for that.
song··on Wireless lossless digital audio
Great, I'm going to test that :-) The delay with a bluetooth setup is very annoying...
song··on Notepad ++ hacked for Je Suis Charlie comments(web archive link)
I actually didn't know about this (was out of France when it happened). Reading on it, it seems according to some articles by people familiar with the situation that part of the reason for this is that there was an internal conflict between the editor and Siné who used this to fire him.

In term of drawings, there's been a few offensive cartoons of jewish as well as christians (but then again, their caricatures and drawings have traditionally always been more offensive than their columns). See for example: http://www.jewpop.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/ROD0070417.... or http://www.jewpop.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/antisemitis...

I haven't read it that much (I read it a bit more when I was a student) but I definitely never associated that journal with racism in that they've always seemed equally handed in their offensiveness.

song··on Battery life: Apple's solving for x
For me, the iphone 6+ has been the first iphone with a truly confortable battery life. It lasts 2-3 days on average for me when my iphone 5 often didn't even last a single day.
song··on Notepad ++ hacked for Je Suis Charlie comments(web archive link)
Actually a slogan I saw a lot in the Marche republicaine here in France is:

I'm Muslim, I'm Jewish, I'm Christian, I'm Atheist, I'm a Policeman, I'm Charlie

Which I think is much better and is a much more inclusive symbol.

The thing though is that Charlie Hebdo is not a publication that only published offensive cartoons about Mohammad, they published offensive cartoons about everybody and were quite equal handed in the offensiveness... It's very far from being a racist publication, on the contrary.

song··on Sony Reveals an Even Bigger Attack on the Internet – the MPAA Is Behind It
I used to pay for netflix in the US and access it with a VPN when I was living in China (a country where most content is only available through pirating). I did this both for convenience and because I wanted to pay for the content I was consuming.

But eventually I got tired of having to jump through hoops because of region locking and other inane rules decided by the MPAA and equivalent. I'm now in France, Netflix has a rather poor catalogue (I joined this month to check it out), The Master for example is not available (and I don't know any easy way to stream it).

So, instead of bothering to jump through hoops, I just download it on Bittorrent. It's quick, it's easy and it saves me time. It's also more confortable using Mplayer or Plex to play a video than any of the streaming website players.

When you say that 25-30k people torrent the movie, I'm sure there's a lot of people in my case. And excluding the foreign language versions won't help because a lot of people in Europe download the original version.

song··on Why I Drilled Holes in My MacBook Pro and Put It in the Oven
I administer about 40 servers under linux (well mostly with Chef and docker), I used to use linux on my main computer for 6 years (debian, gentoo and ubuntu). I have a freebsd server at home that I use for fun. And yet despite all that, my main computer for work nowadays is a mbp retina because I like OS X as an OS and as a GUI (despite some of it's bugs and annoyances). So I don't really agree with you.

In term of hardware, I've had a few lemons and I've complained loudly but under Applecare, Apple replaced the mbp retina I had that failed 3 times with a new model (which runs perfectly fin) so I can't really complain.

I've also had very long lived devices from Apple, my first ibook lasted 4-5 years until my parents sat on it, my wife's old powerbook lasted 6 years until it was stolen, my first generation iphone still works perfectly fine...

One thing I did learn though is never to buy a first generation model from Apple, they tend to be unreliable (at least in my anecdotical experience)

song··on The Workman keyboard layout (2010)
I use colemak and I love it but I do agree with him about the he bigram in colemak. At this point though, I don't think his improvements would make it worthwhile for me to learn Workman.

Switching to Colemak was very good for me but it also was a big time investment since the loss of productivity when learning a new keyboard layout is not negligible. I had wrist problems which stopped after switching to Colemak so I really had an extra incentive to slog through the tranaition.

← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →