[1] I find it really odd, based on the headline, that the article doesn't even mention this possibility.
2,655 karma · joined December 30, 2008
[1] I find it really odd, based on the headline, that the article doesn't even mention this possibility.
However, some questions and feedback:
- You don't have an example of what the digest looks like - what does it reduce messages into? I thought that one of the things in the sidebar might have been a link to a page with more details, but nope.
- Why only gmail? Shouldn't it work with any service that allows forwarding of messages? Or do other email providers have their own verification step that you haven't added support for yet?
I generally don't just mark messages as spam because I don't want them in my inbox - that's what archiving mail is for (things which I don't need to see but might want to look at in the future). Spam is for when I don't want to receive messages and I can't find a way to get myself taken off of the mailing list after reading through one of the messages.
I'm not saying that it's sketchy, just that it makes her seem like a very irrational actor. Which could be completely believable - maybe she's gotten a bit paranoid, or is having issues trusting people, both of which would be perfectly understandable - but when combined with the conflicting stories and lack of definite information (and all the conflicting information out there), it seems odd.
How the hell is he getting that from the article linked there? It's a long rant about PG posting something on HN claiming how the article it was a comment on is inaccurate. In no way is that "investors ... lean[ing] on publications ... to stop reporting the story."
Therefor, I suspect that your mentions of legality may be specific to the USA; of course, if I'm wrong, I would love to be enlightened.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country#Un...
Of course, that's not going to happen, because of the large contingent of users who want karma and think that this is interesting. This story is a really good way to get karma right now, as well as playing into the current meme of bashing Airbnb that's going around (last week it was bashing G+, before that it was bashing Dropbox. I treasure the moments when HN is not up in arms about something).
EDIT: Am I being downvoted for my (admittedly cynical) analysis of why this story is so prominent? It would be nice if one of you would explain why, so I can avoid making the same mistake in the future.
(Also, is it legal to read books in the UK? The brain and eyes make a temporary copy of any inputs, and memory could be considered to be a derivative work.)
EDIT: And your comment is now in the positive. Which lets me point out that a really standard pattern on HN is for comments to be downvoted before being upvoted - since the first people who get to comments tend to be those who blindly downvote anything they dislike, and are then followed by the ones who actually look at comments. Complaining and freaking out about it can only make it worse.
(The correct interpretation is "An Australian who is alleged to have hacked hosting has been arrested", but I only came to the conclusion that that was the right one after looking at the article - which has a different and much better headline).
Also, complaining about having to use POP or IMAP to pull out your email? Seriously? It's a standard, it lets you import them into any email program you want, and just giving you a compressed archive of everything would be a nightmare of compatibility if you wanted to do anything with it but read the messages in a text editor.
So how does a small group reach 10%? This description of their model appears to claim that it is impossible for the beliefs of the majority to change (because every group begins with below 10% adoption of their ideas).