HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sorcerer-mar

2,266 karma · joined March 20, 2025

submissionscomments
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Are you really comparing a living arrangement where adults regularly have sex in front of you due to overcrowding to "seeing your parents having sex?"
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Right, you prefer other conditions because they're better.

We have decades of research to show that more space and privacy is not merely a matter of comfort. Or, if it is, that "comfort" affects more things than one would expect.

I've already linked to them above.

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
I said we should want a world free of violence, and not purposely exposing people to violence as a matter of daily life (such as public hangings) is an important step towards that. Both in the direct sense that public violence is obviously violence, and indirectly in that there's good evidence that exposure to violence increases proclivity to violence.

Two simple questions:

1. Do we want a world without violence?

2. If yes, is public hanging a step towards that world, or away from it?

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Because if you need to spend time in a classroom, or a workplace, or form romantic relationships, it's important that you have attitudes that are somewhat in line with meaningful portions of the society around you. Obviously.
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
> Maybe we need to bring back superheroes who beat the shit out of the bad guys.

Superheroes don't exist and never have. People who work tirelessly to chip away -- often imperceptibly -- at sources of badness exist. That's it.

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Do you want your kids to grow up in a single-room household with 4 adults and 8 children?
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Is public hanging "teaching kids about bad stuff?"

No.

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Spoken like someone who lives in the least violent era of human history.

Does the fact that you can't ride a unicorn to work compel you to settle for walking 7 miles barefoot? Or is the sensible thing to do to constantly chip away at sources of badness in the world, even if you can't achieve unicorns?

It cracks me up how you try to assert the "realist" position while holding an opinion that only makes sense in a university ethics course. Public hangings don't "prepare" a child for a world with non-zero levels of violence, obviously. Living 4 adults and 8 children to a single-room household doesn't "prepare" a child for anything you'd willingly sign them up to do.

Bad things are bad. They should be avoided. You actually think this too and will take action to avoid most bad things that you can. But alas, the Internet comment box is here for you to wisely consider: Maybe bad things are not bad. Very smart, lol.

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
[flagged]
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
Yes, and that was bad. If you prefer a society free of violence (I do), then exposing people to violence in their daily life is bad.
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
The issue is that we raise kids into this world, and not a different time and place. They grow up to be maladapted to this world.
sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
No but the living conditions were atrocious, dangerous, unsanitary, and probably quite psychologically traumatizing (e.g. kids growing up in households where adults would have sex in the same room have all sorts of problems)

Edit: Since HN contrarians who'd never want their children living in some particular conditions find it so confusing how others might not too:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01452...

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3805127/

Overcrowded living quarters is a well known vector for a huge array of problems. Academic underachievement, sexual abuse, substance abuse, mood disorders, abusive relationships, the list goes on. Even after controlling for socioeconomic status!

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
I think urbanists should be a lot more cautious of throwing Austin around as a success story. It is still too early to say whether they've found a good equilibrium in supply/demand that limits price increases or they're cresting a major COVID-triggered speculative glut which will be very damaging to the city.

I'd bet that Miami is just a few years ahead of it (entering serious decline) and within a decade Austin will be seen as an obvious-in-retrospect cautionary tale.

sorcerer-mar··on NIH limits scientists to six applications per year
Strongly disagree. I know a lot of losers with a lot of money, and most people around them think they're fundamentally losers too.
sorcerer-mar··on NIH limits scientists to six applications per year
It's called being a loser and we should ostracize such losers at every turn. Making money won't make them less of a loser. Can't wash it off, actually.
sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
Oh okay it’s like Hulk. Got it.
sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
I think you should consider reasoning about reality in real terms instead of offloading to metaphors that, by design, don’t add any more information to the discussion than your own conclusions.

By the way, it’s a “binocular” system. “Bicameral” refers to a design for institutions like legislatures.

sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
1. Autopilot is not FSD

2. Autopilot, being a typical ASAD, is used exclusively on highways and in conditions where typical ASADs work reliably

Weird to brag about being unwilling to apply even first order criticality to a press release but you do you.

Thank you for reaffirming that in fact you do not have the data required to substantiate your claim.

sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
And with no [hypothetical] growing pains [not including the obvious practical growing pains we are all witnessing with our eyes currently], with FSD working on novel, untested roads [plus or minus a bunch of Teslas driving around with camera arrays mounted in specific, limited areas, but besides that totally novel untested roads definitely work].
sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
> Human bicameral driven cars are unreliable too, but FSD is more reliable.

You do not have the data necessary[0] to substantiate this claim.

[0] Accidents per mile controlled for at least vintage of car and driving conditions

sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
It's hilarious to see Tesla fans try to act like designing for an undefined operational domain is somehow extra brilliant and not one of the stupidest fucking ideas anyone has ever come up with.
sorcerer-mar··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
Tesla doesn't release the data required to assess this.

And from that information alone, you can get the gist of what that data says!

(inb4 you post the accidents per mile chart which is very obviously useless and designed to mislead midwits, as it is not controlled for age of automobile or driving conditions)

sorcerer-mar··on The U.K. closed a tax loophole for the global rich, now they're fleeing
Real estate inflation is a pretty obvious way it does that.
sorcerer-mar··on The U.K. closed a tax loophole for the global rich, now they're fleeing
Just tax land and you'll get 80/20
sorcerer-mar··on The U.K. closed a tax loophole for the global rich, now they're fleeing
"slightly more indirectly" is an interesting way to say "by distorting local economies and politics around the idiosyncratic needs and desires of a very small number of uber-wealthy foreigners."
sorcerer-mar··on TSMC to start building four new plants with 1.4nm technology
You underestimate how gobsmackingly dumb this administration is, IMO. They've cancelled extremely important, multi-year or -decade long clinical trials just for funsies.
sorcerer-mar··on Babies made using three people's DNA are born free of mitochondrial disease
The mapping from DNA to health outcome is unbelievably chaotic/high-cardinality, then mixed in with various environmental/social/cultural factors that don’t show up in DNA at all.

Drugs are in fact how we come to understand this chain of causality, piece by piece.

So yeah, what you describe is obviously the dream (hand waving through some ethical considerations) but we just don’t know anywhere close to enough about the biology.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
So in other words, the original poster who I replied to is wrong, and I am correct.

You are now saying the exact thing that I stated above.

sorcerer-mar··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
You can go do some reading on Third Party Doctrine if you'd like.

SCOTUS ruled there are some instances where private use of a service is 1) effectively necessary for modern life and 2) leaks a huge amount of information about the person, then the government cannot utilize it without a warrant even if handed over or sold willingly by the third party.

I am suggesting that we likely need to expand Third Party Doctrine to things beyond cell tower data because 1) we don't have absolute control over how/where our images are used and associated with our names, and 2) the technology to later affiliate our always-on/always-visible identities (like faces, gaits, or fingerprints) with our names is getting better and better.

You're right that today this is not illegal, but I am pointing out that your argument for "what to do instead" is literally the precise argument for why it should be: it chills protected expression.

sorcerer-mar··on NYPD bypassed facial recognition ban to ID pro-Palestinian student protester
“Don’t post your photos on social media” is precisely describing a chilling effect on people’s expression, i.e. the exact thing the First Amendment is designed to protect against.
← PreviousPage 2 of 28Next →