HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sorcerer-mar

2,266 karma · joined March 20, 2025

submissionscomments
sorcerer-mar··on Maintaining weight loss
All good tips but I think it really boils down to the last bit: sustainable changes. This doesn't help one understand how to differentiate a sustainable versus unsustainable change.

In my experience, the single most important factor is realizing that the sensation of hunger is your primary enemy and that you can attack it head-on.

Satiety is not dictated by how many calories you've eaten but (mostly) by the physical weight of your stomach. If your goal is to eliminate the sensation of hunger while consuming the least number of calories, the nutrition label tells you everything you need to know: eat a lot of low caloric density foods.

What you'll find over time is that foods widely regarded as unhealthy are simply ultra-dense (e.g. peanut butter is an engineering miracle) while healthier foods tend to be extremely low-density (e.g. non-fat Greek yogurt and fresh vegetables).

The biggest error I see in people dieting is thinking they just need to muscle through the feeling of hunger. It doesn't work in the long run. Accept that it's an important sensation but it's distinct from actual starvation, and address it directly!

sorcerer-mar··on U.S. intelligence intervened with DOJ to push HPE-Juniper merger
[flagged]
sorcerer-mar··on U.S. intelligence intervened with DOJ to push HPE-Juniper merger
[flagged]
sorcerer-mar··on Meta's Vision for Superintelligence
Yes but even this ignores the more important dynamic at play: rent rises to eat nearly all the productivity gains.

If you add technology to your workplace your wages should go up (not to eat all the gains of the technology, but a decent portion via wage competition), but then once your wages go up, the local rent goes up anyway.

sorcerer-mar··on Meta's Vision for Superintelligence
> How can I be free to do my gardening whenever I want when the landlord is asking for $11K rent in my SF flat?

This is the fatal flaw. It's been recognized explicitly for at least 140 years that the price of land rent rises in lockstep with productivity increases, guaranteeing there is no "escape velocity" for the labor class regardless of how good technology gets.

sorcerer-mar··on Trump Administration Weighs Patent System Overhaul to Raise Revenue
Sure, the model that you propose here sounds a lot better than the one being proposed by the current administration.

It seemed like you were suggesting that a property tax (which does not function how you just described) was a good idea, based on your initial comment which called it a good idea.

sorcerer-mar··on Trump Administration Weighs Patent System Overhaul to Raise Revenue
A patent definitionally only has market value (i.e. a value to be taxed) if it's something people want.

Right, I'm aware there's a spectrum from bullshit patent owners to non-bullshit patent owners. Why would you write a tax code to punish the latter while doing effectively nothing to the former?

You're fixating on the existence of bullshit patents which no one disputes. The question is whether this policy is a sensible way to address that, and you continue not to substantiate (or even articulate) any of your disposition toward that.

sorcerer-mar··on Trump Administration Weighs Patent System Overhaul to Raise Revenue
And so... how does a property tax fix any of what you're describing? If it's a bullshit patent that's not being deployed to the market, it can't possibly be very valuable, ergo will have no carrying cost. Only the patents that are deployed to the market and valuable will have high carrying costs.

> But all too often it's a malign fantasy.

All too often to severely destroy the incentive to invent new drugs? Yeah, gonna need a better source than your intuition as a patent lawyer to substantiate that.

sorcerer-mar··on Claude finds contradictions in my thinking
Obsidian is a personal knowledge management system which is unique in that, yes, it's ultimately just a pile of Markdown files! Obsidian gives you a good UI to interact with it though: obsidian.md
sorcerer-mar··on Trump Administration Weighs Patent System Overhaul to Raise Revenue
> allowing patent holders to try to levy (what amount to) taxes that are paid indirectly by the public.

What are you referring to here? The premium that a patent holder (one who created or purchased novel, valuable IP) is able to extract?

This is a reward for taking risk in R&D and for sharing the result with the public via patent disclosures, not a tax.

sorcerer-mar··on Danish Study: No link between vaccines and autism or other health conditions
But again: Alex Jones' and Limbaugh's hugely popular shows pre-date that. So does the libertarian strain on the right. Modern MAGA definitely spun out of the Tea Party which didn't originate at all in leftist education.
sorcerer-mar··on Danish Study: No link between vaccines and autism or other health conditions
Interesting theory but anecdotally doesn't fit with my experience.

The most compliant, least critical, and laziest thinkers in my acquaintance are all squarely "anti-institutional" now.

> Alt-media arose in maybe the last 10 years. Most of these anti-vaxxers were fully baked (intellectually) by then

This isn't true. There was definitely a crunchy left-wing anti-institutional anti-vax cohort that's very old, but the modern energy behind the movement is not from this group. And alt-media is much older than you give it credit for. Rush Limbaugh premiered in 1988. Alex Jones' InfoWars was founded in 1999.

sorcerer-mar··on Danish Study: No link between vaccines and autism or other health conditions
No, they really didn't.

Institutions made mistakes, sure, as they always have. None of these mistakes, individually or in aggregate, justify anything close to the discredit they've received.

Had there been similarly ignorant, ideologically motivated, and orchestrated media to report on all these institutions' past failures, they would've "failed" long ago. But because there wasn't, the institutions carried on despite their "failures" and delivered huge amounts of value to society.

For every modern transgression I can point to analogous historical ones. You can say "see, they've always been rotten!" and my response is "yet despite that they've delivered value." Almost as if real life is full of tradeoffs, complexity, tensions, and imperfections everywhere.

sorcerer-mar··on Danish Study: No link between vaccines and autism or other health conditions
The problem is that a massive orchestrated campaign to sow distrust of institutions can succeed well beyond what's needed to achieve their destruction.

The actual truth and institutional trust are both far harder to establish than they are to destroy. I'm not sure how institutions survive in the presence of this asymmetry, alt-media's conscious effort to exploit it, and freedom of speech.

sorcerer-mar··on 4k NASA employees opt to leave agency through deferred resignation program
Grievance politics amplified by an assembly of the most astoundingly dumb people you’ve ever seen behind a podium

That’s it! That’s the strategy!

sorcerer-mar··on US AI Action Plan
No the implication is that you’re repeating press releases from extremely biased parties as if they are fact. They are not, and this discredits you.
sorcerer-mar··on AccuWeather to discontinue free access to Core Weather API
Not true, there’s been a huge jump in deportation of people with no criminal record. You’re right though there has been only a marginal increase in deportations specifically of criminals.

https://www.cato.org/blog/65-people-taken-ice-had-no-convict...

The effective tariff rate on American consumers is above 20%…

https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/state-us-tariffs-july-23...

Just because there can be MORE deportations and MORE tariffs doesn’t mean he’s not doing them lol. You’ve done a fine job of revealing your motivated reasoning anyhow. Clearly one shouldn’t take your predictions on NWS seriously.

sorcerer-mar··on Writing is thinking
I disagree. Not sure how common this workflow is, but I write by putting all the different unsynthesized ideas down and rearrange them as the latent structure "reveals itself." At the end you have something synthesized.

Sure some type latent structure was there all along (thus why I put them down), but it wasn't necessarily visible to me, nor optimal, nor did it include/exclude all the right points. The need for iteration itself proves that the act of writing is actually doing the synthesis.

sorcerer-mar··on AccuWeather to discontinue free access to Core Weather API
6 months ago were you saying "there's no way he'll do broad tariffs" or "there's no way he'll do a mass deportation campaign?"
sorcerer-mar··on US AI Action Plan
Okay you have a point. AI probably would do really well when short case abstracts start walking into clinics.
sorcerer-mar··on US AI Action Plan
Here’s how this is working in practice:

There’s a fast-growing cottage industry of companies using AI to figure out how to bill insurers “better”

And there’s a fast-growing cottage industry of companies using AI to figure out how to deny claims “better”

I see no reason to expect improvements to the patient or provider experience from this. A lot more money spent though!

sorcerer-mar··on US AI Action Plan
I will bet $1,000 you don’t work in a clinic and you’re instead spouting press releases as fact here?
sorcerer-mar··on US AI Action Plan
Yep! What ya gotta do when you spot a problem, is just throw whatever objects or topics are immediately at hand at it.

Then blame regulation and that pesky Other Side

Ta-da! Fixed!

sorcerer-mar··on Why are we abandoning our research on Mars?
Yes we should disincentivize continuation of these practices and incentivize adoption of different practices.

No, we obviously shouldn’t be so extreme that we trigger famines. This isn’t even remotely necessary anyway given that the people you mention aren’t major polluters.

sorcerer-mar··on Why are we abandoning our research on Mars?
Tax emissions, incentivize density, and let the market work.

We have already made massive strides against this problem. Yes it will require some sacrifices (like wealthier nations helping developing nations to leapfrog into lower-emission technologies), but what is the alternative? We just sit here and die? It's a bit premature to have come to this conclusion.

sorcerer-mar··on Why are we abandoning our research on Mars?
China's urban per capita emissions are growing slower than their national average (https://www.nature.com/articles/s42949-023-00084-2)

So are you proposing that we prevent the developing world from developing?

sorcerer-mar··on Why are we abandoning our research on Mars?
Tax emissions, incentivize density, let the market work.

We have both natural and artificial incentives in the opposite directions. Get rid of them then let's see what else needs to be done after that.

I've given my proposal. What's yours?

By the way, the top emitters per capita are the developed countries and those who produce energy for the developed countries. Not sure how this angelic developed country meme came to emerge among people who vaguely gesture at developing nations "exporting people" to developed countries to do bad things, but it's not correct.

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/deterren...

Sounds good

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
> I don't think this is possible. I think it's better to pursue a world where violence is unnecessary and aberrant.

I didn't say it was possible. I said it's worth striving for, and then you stated the same thing with different words. We agree.

Ah so you think societies that did public hangings tended to have a strong and reasonable sense of justice.

You are wrong.

Justice in the sense of "punishing people who are legitimately antisocial" tends to yield less indulgent punishments because they recognize that true justice must be dealt cold and with solemnity.

Or do you think it's only a coincidence that the most abhorrent justice systems on the planet do public executions and "civilized" justice systems do not?

sorcerer-mar··on Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing and mobility problems
This would be an excellent rebuttal to the claim that everyone who experiences a specific type of hardship later has a specific outcome.

But for the claim you're responding to, this appears to mostly just be some cringey self-aggrandizement?

Page 1 of 28Next →