2,266 karma · joined March 20, 2025
The existence of problems does not imply there cannot be more plentiful, more diverse, and more severe problems in the near future.
Maybe you shouldn't take commentary like "you don't understand basic tenets of this idea" and "you don't understand the basic set of stakeholders in this ecosystem" as personal insults, and instead a helpful note that there's more to learn if you wish to form informed opinions about a topic.
Landlords and developers have distinct and often diametrically opposed incentives, so it's quite alarming (and should be alarming to you!) that you do not know the difference between them.
It was actively propagating various anti-semitic conspiracy theories, it was creating teams of commenters to spell the word "n**r" together, it was specifically identifying individuals as participating in the vast Jewish conspiracy to exterminate White people, etc.
We know for a fact that Elon is meddling directly in Grok's outputs to yield the political valence he personally wants. That is censorship.
Or do you think Grok -- uncensored and neutral interpreter of salience in the universe -- just suddenly gave a fuck about the plight of white South Africans? Absolutely laughable that people can still say stuff like "no censorship" with regard to anything Elon touches.
> this policy forces people who bought affordable homes decades ago to either pay significantly more or sell when their neighborhoods gentrify.
Correct. The alternative is that these people freeze a region in time while prices continue to skyrocket due to the increasingly Sisyphean efforts of those around them to grow the local economy.
> who benefits when they're forced to sell? developers who can afford both the LVT and development costs.
All of the people who are moving into an area and developing its economy further? Yes, developers get a cut for the work that they do of developing the area to meet the new demands on it. What's wrong with that exactly?
> you still haven't addressed how LVT solves the actual constraint
Yes I have. LVT makes it cost-prohibitive not to develop land to its highest use. In a hot real estate market, highest use will be to build more units. It has nothing to do with land availability.
Yes, if you hold land in a place where a lot of people around you (and/or the state) is investing in economic development, your carrying cost will increase and the ultimate goal is for you not to be able to extract uncapped gains from the appreciation that people around you are generating.
> you will raise taxes on their now-high value urban SFH because they aren't producing anything (aka "fully utilized")
This is the type of statement that makes me suspect again you do not understand LVT. You don't raise taxes because they aren't producing anything. The tax goes up as the value of the land goes up as already occurs with property taxes. The only difference is that if you decide to build a second house on your property, your taxes would not go up under LVT, whereas under the current property tax regime, it would go up dramatically. This has the net effect of incentivizing people to fully utilize their land, but does not require any determination of their utilization nor does it "raise taxes" on them for failing to utilize.
> like you said, it's a neutral shift. if the cost of the property goes down because of a higher tax, then it's a neutral shift
This is not what's described by "neutral." It's neutral because right now your property tax is already both an LVT and a tax on the improvements. LVT would increase the LVT component and decrease the improvement component.
If the introduction of LVT reduces the value of a property, then it would accordingly reduce the carrying cost of that property. Your two variables are mutually exclusive under a revenue-neutral scheme.
LVT doesn't require any such determination.
Anyway, I'm not opposed to the solution you mention as well. We should subsidize supply of housing, and supply at any price will serve the same purpose of driving prices down, so yes I agree we should build public housing for higher price points.
It is absolutely possible to stumble upon things, as is often the origin of hypotheses that develop into drugs, but 99.999% of these will still end up being false.
It's way more likely you found a thing that convinces you it does something desirable in the body than that you actually found something that does something desirable in the body.
Land prices rise with income. Through all places in all points of history.
The solution is a land value tax.
> well it's something, isn't it?
It's probably not!
If you want to say such remedies produce a placebo effect and that's sufficient for such purposes, IMO that's a valid approach.
No that's not true
"Well it's true that I think that."
You got me!
For other readers: OJFord doesn't know what s/he's talking about and you should look up tests for the specific brands for the specific spices you're looking to buy, especially if you have children and/or you use spices liberally in your food. The US does not systematically test spices for contamination like this and it does show up in high levels in the American spice supply. Unfortunately it doesn't seem like there are brands that are across-the-board good on contamination.
The real issue with those fires was the unfathomably fast growth rate and the gigantic wilderness-urban interface.
Municipal water supplies are (correctly) designed to put out house fires. A few at a time. They are not designed to put out thousands of house fires in high wind.
Also: California's early warning system did work correctly -- IIRC the fire was detected when it was 10 acres. Within 60 minutes, the fire was 300 acres. 3 hours later it was 1200 acres.
The issue was explosive growth.
Nobody said it's without cost to hold non-consensus views. The point is that those costs are incurred by the marketplace of ideas itself (people being "mean" to you, not the state beheading you) and that, in the long run, correct views become the consensus through winning such competitions over and over again.
There are alternative regimes where incorrect views can reign indefinitely because they choose to prevent people from criticizing each others' views.
Step 1. More billionaires
Step 2. ???
Step 3. Functional society!
There are plenty of very mainstream industrial brands with all sorts of contamination.
> I don't think you need to worry buying it from a store that's imported it properly
This statement is not true.
Reasons which typically don't include "can sustain infinite visitors"
It sounds like you're a Brit who opened a pub in Spain for other Brits to get sloshed at. Is this wrong?