HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

spolsky

7,821 karma · joined November 20, 2007

CEO and co-founder of Stack Exchange (the people who bring you Stack Overflow)

Co-founder of Fog Creek Software (the people who bring you Trello, FogBugz, and Kiln)

Mostly retired writer of Joel on Software.

Find me at @spolsky, joelonsoftware.com, and joel@joelonsoftware.com.

submissionscomments
spolsky··on Has Joel Spolsky Jumped the Shark? (2006)
Wow, ancient history, but this later became a standing joke, and Jeff mostly recanted. See http://pvm-professionalengineering.blogspot.com/2010/05/jump... (although why that site exists, I cannot say.)
spolsky··on Ask HN: What happens to unvested equity in an acquisition?
It depends on what the options contract says, so read it and you'll see. Sometimes there is a provision for partial acceleration of vesting in the event of an acquisition.
spolsky··on Trello is running on a diesel generator and may go down at anytime
due to flooding in the basement and diesel fuel spilled everywhere, they wouldn't power up the elevators even if they could. The building's entire electrical system is under salt water/diesel mixture.
spolsky··on Trello is running on a diesel generator and may go down at anytime
The bottom line is that people just don't plan for 100 year storms. I suspect that's because the number of things that go wrong once every 100 years is so large and the cost of handling each one is so disproportionate to the risk that it's not cost effective. Think about it this way: under what circumstances would you double your hardware budget to avoid 1 day of downtime every 100 years?
spolsky··on Trello is running on a diesel generator and may go down at anytime
Let me update this: we've been working all day on moving Trello to AWS, a project which is now underway. If all goes well (fingers crossed, etc) we'll be up and running on AWS very soon. There are still other services in the flooded New York data center (FogBugz, Kiln, Copilot) and we are making plans to physically move servers to a new data center as quickly as possible if the flooded data center falls over, but a physical move of 5 racks could take a whole day so I hope that doesn't happen.

Separately, Stack Exchange, which is in the same data center, is running off of its hot backup in Oregon.

We would have liked to have completely redundant data centers for FogBugz on Demand and Kiln on Demand to avoid even a few hours of downtime, but because those services rely heavily on giving every customer their own SQL database, there is almost no reasonable way to get fast failover to a different data center. We can do it with Stack Exchange because there are only a couple of hundred databases. We've been building a SAN solution which will make it possible to hot swap out to another datacenter, one day, but that project is not complete.

spolsky··on Trello is running on a diesel generator and may go down at anytime
I suspect that's for ventilation reasons
spolsky··on Trello is running on a diesel generator and may go down at anytime
Last we heard it's a bucket brigade doing 5 gallons at a time. Fog Creek president Michael Pryor is participating but mostly it seems to be the crew from Peer 1 networks doing the hard work, we don't want to take too much credit.
spolsky··on Fog Creek is about to go down
Geo-redundancy is a tough engineering problem. We're building a long term solution but it's a lot of work and it's not in place today.

If this is the kind of problem that excites you, we're hiring :-)

spolsky··on Fog Creek is about to go down
I'm kind of an optimist; I believe it'll only be a matter of hours total outage. The generator is fine, the equipment is fine, the internet connectivity is fine... the only problem is getting fuel up to the generator on the 17th floor, while the fuel pumps in the basement are submerged. Someone will carry it up 17 flights if need be.
spolsky··on AskPatents.com: A Stack Exchange To Prevent Bad Patents
I love that idea!

Until that happens, we actually expect that companies in patent-happy industries will monitor filings by their competitors and spend some of their own money and resources blocking competitors from building bad patent portfolios (there was enough of this on Peer To Patent, a very small-scale experiment, to give me confidence that it will happen)

spolsky··on AskPatents.com: A Stack Exchange To Prevent Bad Patents
It is definitely true that a lot of companies over-protective legal departments have persuaded their engineers never to read patents.

I don't think that you should optimize for the case where you've actually lost a patent suit. First of all, that's a pretty rare case. But more importantly, it's cowardice. It's the moral equivalent, in my mind, of carefully crossing to the other side of the street when you see the neighborhood bully approach. Yeah, it's "the most logical course of action," but the better course of action is to get your own gang together and shut them the f* down!

spolsky··on How Eduardo Saverin Sold Facebook Ads in 2004
Al Pacino.
spolsky··on StackOverflow unwinding?
It's not weird, it's intentional, and desired. The short and to-the-point answer is marginally more helpful if it arrives sooner, because it solves the problem quickly, so it will tend to earn a little more reputation. Coming back later and embellishing the answer with details, sample code, whatever, and you will earn a flood of well-deserved reputation. Doing both--providing a quick answer and then embellishing the details so that the Internet has a great resource--is the ideal outcome and therefore rewarded with the most reputation.
spolsky··on StackOverflow unwinding?
And yet, Stack Overflow gets 7000 questions a day, and manages to maintain a very high quality compared to sites with less moderation.

The very moderation which detracts from the community feeling is what's keeping the quality of the site up and helping create a valuable permanent resource on the Internet, which is our primary goal. Like Wikipedia, strict rules are what lead to a valuable artifact. Stack Overflow's rules and values are not intended to create a warm and cuddly discussion area for long-winding, far-reaching conversations, social networking, and "community" whatever that means. They are intended to create a body of precise questions and answers which are peer-reviewed, editable, and high-quality that you can search with Google.

spolsky··on StackOverflow unwinding?
None of the actual metrics of the site bear this out. I don't know what "myspacing" is, and "floundering" is pretty subjective, but in terms of actual measurable things, we have more questions asked, more questions answered, more people active on the site, more sites with more activity and most metrics are up about 100% in the last year. Some of the things that we track pretty closely (like number of users who ask or answer 5 times monthly) are steadily growing.
spolsky··on Stuck due to “knowing too much”
although programmers.SE was originally meant to be the "anything goes" dumping ground for subjective conversations to get them off of Stack Overflow, that is not its current mission. See the FAQ (http://programmers.stackexchange.com/faq)
spolsky··on Stuck due to “knowing too much”
This is a rambling discussion, which Stack Exchange is not really intended for. There are lots of good places to have rambling discussions. We focus on answerable questions with specific answers, not long-winded, open-ended conversation starters. There are plenty of other sites for long-winded, open-ended conversation starters, including Reddit and Hacker News.

After a decade or so of operating sites for programmers on the Internet, I've learned that, left by themselves, ALL programmer online sites will rapidly deteriorate into:

* I hate my job, woe is me ("I hate my job too!")

* I'm not productive any more, oh dear ("Oh my god you took the words right out of my mouth!")

* And some nonsense about H1B visas.

These kinds of conversations are endless because, I'm sad to say, they represent a common problem among programmers. Discussing it as a means of therapy is a wonderful thing, but DO IT SOMEWHERE ELSE, because Stack Exchange is 100% focused on questions with specific factual answers.

This hard and fast rule is actually WHY you love stack overflow so much. It's WHY the network works. It's WHY you click on the stackoverflow.com link in the Google results even if it's third. If we weren't strict about this stuff we wouldn't have such consistently high quality ANSWERS.

Just because "moderators" (actually, users) have deemed to close a question on Stack Exchange, doesn't mean it's a bad question, or that the person who asked it is bad. It just means that Stack Exchange is an edited, curated environment, not your livejournal. The very moderation that people complain about every time a popular question is closed is what has been making the site work so well.

spolsky··on Smart Working at Credit Suisse - 2000 workspaces for 2500 employees
Here ya go: http://www.fogcreek.com/careers.html

(Scroll to the bottom of the page for a slideshow of Fog Creek's setup with individual private offices for developers)

spolsky··on My Doctor's Office Asked Me To Lie
Did you have a lawyer to represent you? That's their job... to make sure that the contract you're signing is OK. Actually reading a contract without knowledge of the law, case history, and background can get you into just as much trouble as not reading it at all. That's why you have lawyers review important contracts.
spolsky··on The Only Reason My App Worked Was Due to a Slow Database
Press the TURBO button on the front of your PC.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo_button

spolsky··on Yahoo Crosses The Line
Union Square Ventures, of which Fred Wilson ("the OP") is a partner, is an investor in my startup (Stack Exchange). They never put pressure on us to generate patents. They have been consistently anti-patent for quite some time. They have complained frequently that a third of their portfolio is under attack from patent trolls. They have organized fundraisers and meetings which I have attended with Senator Chuck Schumer from New York to press their position for patent reform.

Maybe YOUR stone-age, backward-ass VC thinks that startups should generate patents, but don't tar Fred Wilson with that brush.

spolsky··on $1B of TSA Nude Body Scanners Made Worthless By Blog
Is it possible that the TSA actually observed the metallic object at your side, but decided that it wasn't threatening based on its shape?
spolsky··on StackOverflow
"Fix my code" questions are considered "too localized" and should be closed as such.
spolsky··on StackOverflow
Co-founder of Stack Overflow, here.

A lot of the people who were involved in some way in Experts-Exchange don't understand Stack Overflow.

The basic value flow of EE is that "experts" provide valuable "answers" for novices with questions. In that equation there's one person asking a question and one person writing an answer.

Stack Overflow recognizes that for every person who asks a question, 100 - 10,000 people will type that same question into Google and find an answer that has already been written. In our equation, we are a community of people writing answers that will be read by hundreds or thousands of people. Ours is a project more like wikipedia -- collaboratively creating a resource for the Internet at large.

Because that resource is provided by the community, it belongs to the community. That's why our data is freely available and licensed under creative commons. We did this specifically because of the negative experience we had with EE taking a community-generated resource and deciding to slap a paywall around it.

The attitude of many EE contributors, like Greg Young who calculates that he "worked" for half a year for free, is not shared by the 60,000 people who write answers on SO every month. When you talk to them you realize that on Stack Overflow, answering questions is about learning. It's about creating a permanent artifact to make the Internet better. It's about helping someone solve a problem in five minutes that would have taken them hours to solve on their own. It's not about working for free.

As soon as EE introduced the concept of money they forced everybody to think of their work on EE as just that -- work.

spolsky··on Building trello.com for multiple devices
We are both brave and mad!

Just kidding.

Imagine a traffic chart. The x-axis is time. Trello will last for 20 years, so imagine it going from 2011 to 2031.

The y-axis is usage. The numbers climb up and to the right. We think we can get to 100 million. So imagine either a linear curve or geometric growth or whatever you want, climbing from zero to 100,000,000.

Now think of the area under that curve.

What percentage of it is using IE 8?

Is it worth spending much money on them? Is it worth slowing down to build something for a small group of users that will be gone anyway, and which are only a tiny percentage of the overall usage of Trello over 20 years?

spolsky··on SOPA is a Red Herring
TL;DR - Adam is saying that the new top-level domains will require that you prove your identity when you register with them.

First of all, I don't see any evidence of that. None of the links that he provides include any such claim.

Second, he is claiming this only applies to the new global top level domains. So, who cares? Nobody's going to use those anyway. They're going the way of .biz and .info -- a permanently boring ghetto.

Adam also says "The entire reason for even trying to get a DNS provision into law is because it is nearly impossible to track down the owner of a website, or domain name, through today's registration tools."

That's not, actually, the reason. The reason to get the DNS provision into law is to shut down websites operated from outside the United States where the US does not have jurisdiction.

It is relatively easy for law enforcement to track down the owner of a domain. It resolves to an IP address. The IP address is routed by hardware. The hardware is located in physical space. As long as it's all in the United States, it's just not that hard to find the operator of a website based on the domain name, and that is not what the entertainment lobby is concerned about. They are concerned with what happens when the operator is outside the US and they don't have jurisdiction, so they want laws passed to ensure that US-based ISPs are obliged to block access to foreign infringers.

Adam's analysis in this case is flat-out wrong.

spolsky··on Stack Exchange grew from 16M to 32M uniques in 2011
I think it was because the default buttons were slightly different sizes and looked terrible next to each other.
spolsky··on Alexis Ohanian vs NBC - Debating SOPA
This law is too complicated for the average TV viewer to understand. Debating it on the merits is going to make you lose. You have to find counterpoints that the average TV viewer WILL understand. They have to fit comfortably in a tweet.

When they say, "This is a jobs bill," you say, "This is a typical big government attempt to meddle in something they don't understand."

When they say, "This won't affect American sites," you say, "Search engines don't pirate movies. Neither do Visa or Paypal. Going after them is just unfair." [Note: Search engines. Not DNS. The minute you say DNS you lose.]

When they say, "Google profits from pirated software," you say, "Not as much as the congressmen are profiting from the $95 million dollars in lobbyist money that paid for this bill."

Other talking points: "How come congress can't seem to agree on anything that matters to the country? Unemployment, the deficit... they're totally gridlocked. But when the entertainment industry pays lobbyists $95 million to get a bill they wrote passed, both Republicans and Democrats line up to co-sponsor it."

Trying to say something that actually gets to the merit of the bill is a waste of time on a Sunday morning talk show... it's just too complicated an issue.

spolsky··on The Elephant in the Room: Google Monoculture
In that era we're talking about people like Hejlsberg (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anders_Hejlsberg) -- architect of Turbo Pascal, Delphi, C# and .NET. Almost certainly worth $1,000,000 -- I hope his signing bonus was a lot more than that. Clearly not paid to sit on his thumbs. Nothing monopolistic about paying top $ to hire people away from the competition.
spolsky··on The Elephant in the Room: Google Monoculture
Nice theory, but the data doesn't support it.

We have other sites (cooking.stackexchange, diy.stackexchange) that are much more representative of the population at large. Even on those sites, you see a similar ratio... the second largest search referrer sends 1.6% as much traffic as Google (about twice as much as it sends to StackOverflow, but still virtually insignificant.)

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →