HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sponnath

71 karma · joined September 22, 2023

submissionscomments
sponnath··on Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]
Reddit and YouTube are such huge social media platforms that it really depends on which bubble (read: subreddits/yt channels) you're looking at. There's the "AGI is here" people over at r/singularity and then the "AI is useless" people at r/programming. I'm simplifying arguments from both sides here but you get my point.
sponnath··on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short
I agree that it's the right answer if it truly doesn't know but I don't think that changes the fact that it failed regardless.
sponnath··on Generative AI coding tools and agents do not work for me
Can you actually demonstrate this workflow producing good software?
sponnath··on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short
Toxic positivity is also not good.
sponnath··on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short
Didn't they start failing well before they hit token limits? I'm not sure what the point the source you linked to is trying to make.
sponnath··on First thoughts on o3 pro
I think it's easy to ignore all the times the models get things hilariously wrong when there's a few instances where its output really surprises you.

That said, I don't really agree with the GP comment. Humans are the bottleneck if we knew these models get things right 100% of the time but with a model like o3-pro it's very possible it'll just spend 20 minutes chasing down the wrong rabbit hole. I've often found prompting o4-mini gave me results that were pretty good most of the time while being much faster whereas with base o3 I usually have to wait 2-3 minutes and hope that it got things right and didn't make any incorrect assumptions.

sponnath··on The Gentle Singularity
We are now many years into full AI SWEs will become a reality in 12 months.
sponnath··on Claude 4
DeepSeek did more than just "recycle". Let's not downplay their achievement.
sponnath··on Claude 4
Maybe I'm weird for doing this but I always test the models like this to gauge its confidence. Like you just showed a lot of times it'll just say whatever it "thinks" will satisfy the prompt.
sponnath··on Watching AI drive Microsoft employees insane
People see that these things generate code and due to their lack of understanding they automatically assume this is all software engineering is.

Then we have the current batch of YC execs heavily pushing "vibe coded" startups. The sad reality is that this strategy will probably work because all they need is the next incredulous business guy to buy the vibe coded startup. There's so much money in the AI space to the point where I fully believe you can likely make billions of dollars this way through acquisition (see OAI buying Windsurf for billions of dollars, likely to devalue Cursor's also absurd valuation).

I'm not a luddite. I'm a huge fan of companies spending a decent chunk of money on R&D on innovative new projects even when there's a high risk of failure. The current LLM hype is not just an R&D project anymore. This is now being pushed as a full on replacement of human labor when it's clearly not ready. And now we're valuing AI startups at billions of dollars and planning to spend $500B on AI infrastructure so that we can generate more ghibli memes.

At some point this has to stop but I'm afraid by that point the damage will already be done. Even worse, the idiots who led this exercise in massive waste will just hop onto the next hype train.

sponnath··on Silly job interview questions in Haskell
Not all programming languages are obvious derivatives of C. Haskell is pretty readable once you spend some time getting to know the syntax.
sponnath··on Claude 4
I feel like the opposite is true but maybe the issue is that we both live in separate bubbles. Often times I see people on X and elsewhere making wild claims about the capabilities of AI and rarely do they link to the actual output.

That said, I agree that AI has been amazing for fairly closed ended problems like writing a basic script or even writing scaffolding for tests (it's about 90% effective at producing tests I'd consider good assuming you give it enough context).

Greenfield projects have been more of a miss than a hit for me. It starts out well but if you don't do a good job of directing architecture it can go off the rails pretty quickly. In a lot of cases I find it faster to write the code myself.

sponnath··on OpenAI to buy AI startup from Jony Ive
I don't think ChatGPT really disrupted Google search? It definitely forced Google to release Gemini + related products though. Google still has millions of users and they now have AI integrated with search. The latest Gemini models are also as capable if not more than some of OAI's models.

I don't see how Altman is going to disrupt Apple with just Ive and a company no one's heard of before.

sponnath··on AlphaEvolve: A Gemini-powered coding agent for designing advanced algorithms
Machines have been outperforming humans at a variety of tasks for quite a while now. I'm unconvinced that AlphaEvolve can lead to some sort of singularity.
sponnath··on People are just as bad as my LLMs
A decent conversation about what?
sponnath··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
Spot on. Current models all lack agency. I don't see how something can be AGI but have zero agency. If we can tame it, then it's not AGI.
sponnath··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
We haven't seen any evidence of this happening ever. It would be groundbreaking if true and OAI's pricing would then make sense.
sponnath··on GPT-4.5
If this were true wouldn't we be seeing a massive devaluation of software? (or alternatively increased demand for complex software)
sponnath··on TypeScript types can run DOOM [video]
I think what's more important is a company's / team's ability to onboard new hires to their way of working (so what you should be testing is humility and open-mindedness). Ability to work in a team is such a vague measurement when different teams have different ways of working with each other.
sponnath··on You can’t build a moat with AI (redux)
Copilot does seem to be catching up in some areas but from my testing Cursor still has better UX. There's substantial value in the "glue" that Cursor provides, one that Microsoft has failed to replicate so far.
sponnath··on Introducing deep research
One of the biggest issues with these things is reliability. o3 likely increases that quite a bit. The idea itself isn't novel but I don't see why this wouldn't be useful?
← PreviousPage 2 of 2