HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

spoondan

1,301 karma · joined November 17, 2008

submissionscomments
spoondan··on Flying Cars Get OK From Department of Transportation
It appears that there is no specific prohibition against polycarbonate windshields for cars. The exemption in this case is required because the polycarbonate windshields that Terrafugia currently uses do not pass the required abrasion tests: basically, they scratch too easily and are too prone to reduced visibility.

Terrafugia requested the exemption because it is still searching for a vendor that passes the compliance tests and meets the vehicle's unique requirements. Apparently, vehicles with the current windshields will be required to undergo regular and frequent inspection and repair.

See the page numbered 38273 in the PDF:

http://www.terrafugia.com/pdf/2011-16222_NHTSA_EXEMPTION_GRA...

spoondan··on Clever Names Aren’t Always a Good Thing
Until I read the post about how the name was selected from a list of computer-generated options, I (and apparently a few others here) thought it was a play off of, "ni' night." This made sense to me: you start Ninite to do unattended installs and then head off to bed.

Regardless, I think the name is actually pretty good. The issue for me is that the site has so little branding and personality to it that nothing reinforces the name. It's great that it gets you to the functionality right away, but I think you can preserve that quality and add some branding elements that reinforce the name.

Two ideas jump immediately to mind. The first is to play off, "ni' night," and use a darkened children's room, the night sky, or a children's bedtime book theme. You could add a dark background with a memorable graphical element such as a poster bed or the moon. The second is to conceive of "Ninite" as some sort of cool new chemical element -- a laboratory, the periodic table, or chemical structure diagrams could serve as themes.

Regardless, I'd move "Featured In" to be a horizontal set of badges below the screenshot and place a large logotype to the left of the screenshot with the tagline, "The Easiest, Fastest Way to Update and Install Software."

spoondan··on The FBI stole an Instapaper server in an unrelated raid
They can just confiscate those servers too, where the content is most likely also in plaintext.

I imagine that many companies are better prepared to deal with the FBI than this data center was. I have a hard time imagining the FBI going into a Google data center and easily walking out with a few racks. But even if that's too optimistic, I doubt the FBI could go about seizing servers for very long. If nothing else, this would eventually piss off big companies who will lobby Congress to curtail the FBI.

spoondan··on Chrome to block insecure resources by default
The browsers aren't going to be disallowing CDNs any time soon.
spoondan··on Node.js is Backwards
The Google Web Toolkit (GWT) is a widely used Java-to-JavaScript compiler:

http://code.google.com/webtoolkit/

spoondan··on Tagsistant: a reasoning semantic filesystem for Linux and BSD
Can you provide meaningful prefixes for conflicting files? When you detect a file name conflict, construct a distinguishing prefix for each conflicting file from the difference in tags on the conflicting files. (If all the tags are the same, then fallback to a synthetic prefix or overwrite the file or error out or whatever.)

For example, let's say you have /photos/london/DSCN0001.JPG and /photos/vienna/DSCN0001.JPG, where "london" and "vienna" are both included in "europe". This could yield paths like /photos/europe/london:DSCN0001.JPG and /photos/europe/vienna:DSCN0001.JPG.

The big trouble here (and, if I understand, with what you're suggesting as well) is that changing the name or tags of one file can alter the path to another as a side effect. So if I started with just /photos/vienna/DSCN0001.JPG, I might reference it as /photos/europe/DSCN0001.JPG somewhere. But when I go back and add /photos/london/DSCN0001.JPG, my reference to the photo of Vienna breaks because its name is no longer unique. As TeMPOral points out, this is a general class of problems afflicting a system like this.

spoondan··on Apple causes ‘religious’ reaction in brains of fans, say neuroscientists
I suspect that this was originally intended as a bit of fun, not to be taken seriously. Alas, it's being reported as if it were serious and I feel like someone must point out the obvious, grievous flaws:

According to the article, the finding is based on an MRI of exactly one subject, Alex Brooks. Brooks seems to be exceptionally ardent and there's nothing to suggest he is at all representative of anyone but himself. It is never really safe to draw broad conclusions from studying one subject. But it is ridiculous to do so with someone you've specifically selected because they are exceptional.

Yet even if Brooks were representative, there's nothing within the article to suggest that the brain activity detected has anything specifically to do with religious thoughts or feelings. Yes, those areas light up when religious images are shown to religious people. But there are obvious alternate explanations that aren't addressed. Perhaps those areas of the brain light up when shown familiar visual stimuli. An Apple fan strongly recognizes an iMac. A Jesus fan strongly recognizes the crucifix. Or perhaps this brain activity is just caused by seeing something you like. You could control against these confounding factors, but they evidently have not.

Basically, unless the article has glossed over a lot, there is no finding here at all and this is the BBC pretending at science.

spoondan··on PSN has been hacked again
Wait. Please tell me I'm misunderstanding. You needed only to enter a user's e-mail address and birth date to change his/her password? So, even without the previous (actual) hack, you could use this page to change the password of a family member, friend, co-worker, and nearly anyone else you've ever exchanged e-mails with if you know their birthday (or they publish it on Facebook)?

How does someone even conceive of something like that without realizing the glaring problem with it? How does it pass muster at a major corporation that has hired security consultants? This is utterly flabbergasting.

spoondan··on A conversation about open source licenses
This feels like a simple misunderstanding. I think Ryan just assumed that Zed knew they were already talking about Node.js. With that assumption in mind, when Ryan wrote, "this is included in some of my other projects," he really meant, "this is also included in some of my other projects." That seems a more likely interpretation than Ryan trying to trick Zed into re-licensing the code.
spoondan··on Splinter: Python tool for acceptance tests on web applications
You could think of it as an alternative API for Selenium WebDriver. It uses Selenium to be able to drive Firefox and Chrome, although the idea might be to add other back-ends in the future. Splinter's API may or may not be better, but Selenium's major advantage is that many test cases can be written with little to no code using Selenium-IDE. QA can generate test cases without programming resources.

Splinter seems to inherit some of Selenium's weaknesses. There's no way to test HTTP status codes and headers, so you can verify that the user sees the error but you can't verify that the user agent sees it. You can't test that static resources are being properly cached (or not).

It also seems to add new limitations. Selenium has complete support for drag-and-drop, moving the mouse around, etc. I don't see equivalent functionality in Splinter.

Timeouts seem to be handled worse than Selenium. There's a default timeout of 2 seconds for requests. I guess your test is expected to assert that the content is there after each request, to fail on timeout. Since partial content can be delivered (on rendering errors and possibly on timeout during rendering), I guess you need to check for the footer's presence. Timeouts seem like such an exceptional condition that I'd just throw.

Perhaps because of the version of Selenium they're using, the sample sleeps for 10 seconds after doing an asynchronous file upload because it can't wait for the IFRAME to load. This means that the test case can't finish faster than 10 seconds (a problem for large suites) and the test can fail (if the file is large enough or the network is slow enough) even when the application's behavior is correct. Selenium (in trunk, at least) has waitForFrameToLoad/wait_for_frame_to_load that looks like a better solution.

None of these are fatal problems, especially for a young project. A good API can be a very worthwhile thing.

spoondan··on IOS 4.3 sources are available
The 'make-generated-sources.sh' script does exactly what its name says. It creates source files. Take a closer look at DerivedSources.make: all of the (non-phony) targets (start of a line, before a colon) are .c and .h files. It never even invokes a compiler or linker, and doesn't even reference the vast majority of the code, so it certainly isn't a makefile for the entire thing.

Also, you can run 'make-generated-sources.sh' on pretty much any Linux or UNIX (probably including Cygwin).

spoondan··on IOS 4.3 sources are available
There are also makefiles provided in the release.

Are you sure there's a working build system included? There's a file named "Makefile", but it just includes "../Makefile.shared", which--as far as I can tell-isn't included. There's no XCode project file to be seen, so the build directions on webkit.org don't seem operative. Are you actually able to build this?

spoondan··on Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iOS 4.3.x
Civility plays an important part in effective communication. You may feel that you are merely stating your opinion directly and with force. But an argument is only as strong as its ability to persuade. When you put people on the defensive--when you force an emotional rather than rational reaction--you rob an argument of its power.

Aside from that, there are two other reasons to be more civil. One is that it's just a nice thing to do to treat people respectfully even (or especially) when you're telling them they're wrong. But if that doesn't persuade you, it's worth remembering that civility is explicitly required in the HN Guidelines.

spoondan··on Why the password "this is fun" is 10 times more secure than "J4fS!2"
Let me decide whether I care if someone gains access to my account on some rinky dink web app.

Complexity requirements aren't targeted for you. You're making a conscious decision about what risks you're willing to assume. Most people aren't aware of the risks, even if told their password is weak. That is who complexity requirements target. (But the requirements probably aren't altruistic: they're really there to help protect the application and its developers from the perception of insecurity.)

This is one reason why application developers should get out of the business of building authentication systems. At least then the problems belong to someone else who we'll trust to have dealt with them.

spoondan··on Safari to join "Do Not Track" crowd, leaving Google behind
The point is that some marketers are still honest

So DNT is a mechanism for blocking the honest marketers that we trust to respect our communicated wishes, while still permitting the dishonest marketers to do what they will? As far as I can tell, DNT requires enforcement legislation to be effective.

some also realize that it's smart to not piss off people

How would someone tell that an advertiser is not respecting DNT and therefore be pissed off? Looking for suspicious cookies from third-party sites? The ads seem too personalized?

spoondan··on IE10 platform preview available - with native HTML 5
In discussing why IE9+ will not be available for XP, they write:

Others have dropped support on Windows XP for functionality that we think is fundamental to performance.

This is completely disingenuous. What they are actually referring to (and link to) is Google disabling GPU acceleration and WebGL on XP starting in Chrome 10.0.648.114 due to stability issues. Importantly, Google intends Chrome 11 to re-enable these features on XP for known-good drivers. Here is the relevant ticket:

http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=72975

The thing is, I actually agree with Microsoft's decision to not support XP. XP, like IE6, is a fundamentally flawed platform and the sooner people move off of it, the better. I just wish they'd make the argument honestly.

spoondan··on It should be easier for me to give mice brain tumors.
The standard for an article's appropriateness is whether it's something "that good hackers would find interesting", not whether it's "relevant to most hackers."
spoondan··on Apple alleged web crippling: "not to be fixed by exec order"
Why do you need this fixed? Your app, even running in full screen, probably runs faster on iOS 4.3 than it did on any previous version of iOS.
spoondan··on Putting the Science back in Computer Science
This is an old topic. Auguste Comte and Emile Durkheim, both foundational to the social sciences, each sought to bring empiricism and the scientific method to the study of social institutions. I would argue that they were largely successful and it is a shift in our modern understanding of science that questions whether Social Science is "real" science.

Specifically, I think the power of mathematics as a tool for objective description of natural phenomena has given us the impression that any field without underpinning equations is soft, subjective, and inherently unscientific. Biology is Chemistry is Physics is Math, but the study of social institutions resists reduction to "hard" sciences, to the objectivity of equations. I have even seen people say that Chemistry is not science!

In this view, Sociology seems inherently less legitimate than Biology. And I think that is dangerous. If this is how we are to understand science, then we are doomed to belittle and ignore the possibilities for better understanding society and intelligent behavior.

spoondan··on Amount of profanity in git commit messages per programming language
Gaming companies, start-ups, anyone looking for a "Ninja" or "Rock Star" all seem more likely to tolerate swearing and less likely to be using PHP. Additionally, I'd wager that PHP projects on GitHub tend to get fewer commits from hobbyists and other non-professionals.
spoondan··on YouTube Says It's in Negotiations to Stream Live NBA, NHL Games
The NFL's TV deals are arguably fan unfriendly. But satisfaction probably isn't high on the NFL's list of success metrics. The deals are successful in that they're very lucrative.

I don't know if I'd blame the NFL if it thinks there's little value in addressing the common complaints about its TV coverage.

spoondan··on Solving The Hacker News Problem
That thread contains this comment decrying the state of HN:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=237127

Admittedly, it wasn't voted up, but there was some agreement with it. You're looking back wistfully at a point where another user thought HN had fallen off precipitously.

I don't see a significant difference between HN now versus about 3 years ago (when I first started lurking), and I believe the community could and (on most days) would have the very discussion you've linked. There are cycles where many of the submissions aren't interesting to me. I usually chalk those up to slow news days. And there have been situations where I've been appalled and infuriated by (what I perceived as) the poor quality of articles/comments that the community was voting up. Some of that is the community offending my own biases. Some of that is just bad days. You can't discern the climate by just looking at today's weather.

The other cycle I've noticed is these efforts at self-policing and reflection. I'm almost annoyed by them because I don't see HN as getting worse. But I'll allow that others are more sensitive to HN's quality. Perhaps these reflective posts are what keep HN's quality high enough for my tastes. Or maybe, as I suspect, they are more about the tastes and perceptions of the long-time users changing. It's more than a little reminiscent of the "golden age" thinking of older generations, where the past was simpler and more innocent because they were younger and insulated from the time's complexity and injustice.

(Sorry for rambling there.)

spoondan··on Motorola Xoom will ship without Flash support
I think he meant that the Xoom is capable of replacing a desktop or laptop; not that it emulates them.
spoondan··on Nissan Leaf
Hixie answered your specific question, but I think you're missing a very important point: "Doesn't every major browser release leave less and less that Flash alone can do?" There are some things (not this one) that Flash can do that browsers aren't yet able to do. The present limitations dictate what you can do today, but they have little relevance to the long-term discussion.
spoondan··on Nissan Leaf
How exactly are Flash and JavaScript different? I don't see the separate niches you envision these technologies occupying for the rest of their existence.

And how can you say JavaScript "will never" kill Flash? Aren't Apple and JavaScript already hurting Flash's market share? Doesn't every major browser release leave less and less that Flash alone can do? Aren't we looking at an example of a major, mainstream brand avoiding Flash for a site? What is going to change over the next few years to reverse these trends?

spoondan··on Urban sql injection
I think the photos are meant to imply that the system is reading external input as text and so might be vulnerable to an injection attack like what the bottom picture shows. I don't think it was intended to suggest that the system has actually been hacked in that photo.

Of course, the whole thing is meant as a silly joke (and that's one of the reasons I wish it wasn't posted here). It's unlikely that the camera would recognize something that's so obviously different from a license plate, let alone use a SQL database.

I'd love to see a real discussion on how the ubiquity of computers creates interesting vectors for attacking infrastructure. It seems inevitable that these systems will be connected to higher-value targets and that non-traditional input devices can still be used for launching attacks.

spoondan··on The Secret to a Happy Marriage: Do the Dishes, Put Out, Don’t Talk So Much
Sure, but I don't think your complaint is with the book. You can't blame the evidence for the case the prosecutor makes.
spoondan··on The Secret to a Happy Marriage: Do the Dishes, Put Out, Don’t Talk So Much
The vast majority of women marry for social or financial status, but it's an unconscious mechanism. In the end, it's all about optimizing genetic fitness and resource availability. Our genes do this automatically, and it's not limited to humans.

Are you saying that the book cites research to backup these extraordinary claims? While I'm little more than a dilettante, I can't see how I could completely avoid hearing that a social behavior as complex as marriage had been pinned to genetics.

What I've heard is that surveys have shown women will find a man more attractive if they believe he's wealthy. I have not seen it shown that this is wholly unconscious, let alone genetic (rather than cultural). And I have not seen it claimed that this effect dictates why women marry particular men.

spoondan··on The Secret to a Happy Marriage: Do the Dishes, Put Out, Don’t Talk So Much
It's the difference between "do" and "should". He's saying the book claims to explain human behavior; it doesn't recommend or justify that behavior.
spoondan··on Instructure Launches To Root Blackboard Out Of Universities
It's now deployed in most if not all California State Universities.

Most of the CSU campuses are still using Blackboard. MOODLE is used by around 6 of the 23 campuses and is being piloted by a few others.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →