HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sprout

1,500 karma · joined June 10, 2010

submissionscomments
sprout··on PayPal robbed my bank account
"Make payment easier" is a bad idea. The difficulty is designed to make it easy to track. Making it easier makes money harder to track, which is a Bad Thing.
sprout··on Canonical, Ltd. On Record: Seeking Open Core
That was more a hypothetical.
sprout··on Why I love text files
Actually he uses it, I imagine, so that he will be able to read it next year.

I haven't even tried to use any todo apps, (the text file has always served me well) but what experience I have with proprietary formats is that they're a poor choice for storing data, since either they're poorly designed or the designer is constantly redesigning them and invalidating your data.

sprout··on World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything'
Wow, that's a load of non-sequiturs. Monopoly is a side effect of the massive corruption plaguing Mexico. Microsoft doesn't even come close.

As for aid in Africa, that's a specific charity you worked with in Africa. There are people who do good work there. Dismissing aid because people are bad at it is like dismissing software development because people are bad at it. One way or another it's necessary.

sprout··on Ohloh shows scary decline in open-source project commits
Well, in contrast to the second theory, there's the possibility that open source commits and closed source commits look pretty much the same. They're mostly done by people looking to get a paycheck, and without a paycheck the quantity drops. People aren't necessarily being pulled off open source to work on closed source, they're just being laid off (which seems supported by the unemployment stats.)
sprout··on Ohloh shows scary decline in open-source project commits
Seems to shadow the recession. I wonder how this compares to closed-source commits.
sprout··on It Pays to Hire Women in Countries That Won't
Enumerating a list of successful people who didn't attend public school doesn't say anything about the utility of the public school system, especially without looking at the people who did.

It also ignores the armies of undergraduates and computers (the human kind, mostly public school educated women sitting at adding machines) that made most American discoveries and inventions possible. Individuals do make some leaps, but on the whole it's massive collaboration that advances science and technology.

sprout··on Why the CBC banned Creative Commons music from its shows
That's incorrect. Their position is that there's not a significant amount of CC licensed music without an NC attached, and it's too difficult to tell the difference, so they're banning all CC music regardless of whether or not it's CC-NC.
sprout··on Deleted Facebook photos persist in CDN cache 16 months later
It's a completely unfair expectation. Yes, in some users' mental model, when they delete something it's gone for good. That mental model is objectively wrong. If you share something on the Internet, it is fundamentally impossible to ensure that it is deleted.
sprout··on A winning solution for SimCity
I always defined success at the game as growing your city while all power sources were renewable and you had ample schools, colleges and trees.

It's a sandbox game, the cost function you try to optimize says more about you than it does about the game.

sprout··on HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Android Phone
If you've bought a G2, you are a copyright holder for the code in question.
sprout··on HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Android Phone
http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-10393136-37.html

You'll note it only hit jailbroken iPhones.

sprout··on Ubuntu 10.10 (Maverick Meerkat)
10.04 here... split panes work great.
sprout··on Why programming languages?
Why not _why?
sprout··on CBC agreement with talent agency prohibits use of Creative Commons music
Have there been any surveys done to see what CC licenses are in use?

I mean in any case it seems a little silly that one would ban all of them and not just ones marked "noncommercial."

sprout··on Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society
I read the emails that supposedly show fraud. There's nothing indicative that it's systemic.

Furthermore, the 'ClimateGate' emails only barely show fraud. No, I haven't read them all, but every source I saw pointed to the same exact 'trick' emails, and no one could show anything dirty in the rest.

sprout··on Women Don't Want To Run Startups Because They'd Rather Have Children
The offense taken at this article is intentionally undertaken to change the norm, to encourage men to take more responsibility for their children and for women to take more responsibility in society at large.

The offense is not at the statement of fact, the offense is that the fact is stated as if it were the good and proper order of things. The good and proper order of things is equality.

Now, you're free to disagree, but don't misunderstand us.

sprout··on Hal Lewis: My Resignation From The American Physical Society
>I want no part of it, so please accept my resignation. APS no longer represents me, but I hope we are still friends.

This guy has a lot of gall to end with that after making such flimsy allegations of fraud against an entire academic discipline. His hyperbolic screeching about the "flood of money" would better be directed at the oil industry.

That's not to say the climate change crowd is without its biases, but if he honestly thinks that they are intentionally committing fraud for love of money and prestige, he is deluded.

Personally, I think that the people he slanders are acting honestly, but I might present a more modest hypothesis:

The people who do research on the climate and on the environment have a dramatic love of forests and lakes and natural, untouched wilderness. Anyone who stands in the midst of the mountains cannot help but see why this is. These people might even be willing to lie to protect them. Money, I assure you, has nothing to do with it. But unfailing love of the natural world? Sure, there are people who would lie without hesitation to protect that. But money? Money has very little importance to people who advocate for reductions in fossil fuels, and I think Hal Lewis' focus on money shows how little he understands the people he maligns.

I don't include myself among them because I am no such researcher, but I share their values, their love of the wild things. Lewis, I'm not entirely sure what he loves. I find it difficult to believe he's really interested in science. I can't believe a rationalist would look at any of the evidence available and be so convinced of fraud.

sprout··on Android is Google's Agent Smith
Consumers aren't going to tolerate that kind of lock-in, and in many cases will use Google just the same.

In order for Microsoft to actually get anything out of this, they're going to have to treat Android as a first-class platform, and beat the user experience of Google Maps, Search, Voice Search, Gmail, Goggles, and so on on Android.

Microsoft doesn't have those kind of engineering chops. They can barely even manage a decent UX on Windows Desktop. (We'll see about Windows Phone 7, but I will be very surprised if it's legitimately better than Android, even Android with Bing baked-in.)

sprout··on Caught Spying on Student, FBI Demands GPS Tracker Back
Firstly: America's airports represent a minority of the daily commutes in America. In order for America's airports to be police states, they would have to be states. They're not. They're airports.

Secondly, while there are 'checkpoints' of sorts in NYC, I don't believe they're the variety staffed by heavily armed guards. I haven't been to NYC in around 5 years, but as I remember it interacting with police, heavily armed or otherwise, would be an extraordinary event on a daily commute.

Of course my definition is arbitrary, but I stand by it.

sprout··on Caught Spying on Student, FBI Demands GPS Tracker Back
No, a police state has checkpoints and men with semiautomatic weapons clearly visible during most daily commutes. This is a very bad thing, but it is not a police state. Nothing was done.
sprout··on Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups
Not at all. Dbingham identified a possible root cause that is more specific and actionable than the originally stated problem. You took a qualified hypothesis and claimed it was stated as the totality of the situation.

More importantly, the possible root cause could conceivably be mitigated by a variety of solutions we know how to build - webapps for improved meal planning, recipes, health information, and so on.

sprout··on Making it Suck
Windows XP has a broken security model. Age has very little to do with it (aside from the fact that support ends in 2012, so it's only worth using for another couple years.)
sprout··on Faster Web Development With Virtual Machines at deviantART
A VM is a constant time investment, doing it for every language is linear with the number of languages.

Unless there's some serious increases in clock speeds, I'm not sure doing it for every language is worth it. As it is, VMs are a great, general purpose system that are easy to set up, use, and replicate.

sprout··on A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person
If a six character variable name is a real word and the 5 character variable name isn't, in my mind you've increased the number of objects in every statement that variable appears in from 1 to 5.

Now, there are some really common ones that are more or less idiomatic. i is iterator, ct is count. That said, those save a lot more than 1 character.

sprout··on Facebook allows Force Joining of Groups
Do you remember what Zuckerberg said with this announcement? The 'pristine' social graph?

That's the whole point. He's trying to restore the meaningfulness of saying someone's a friend. Friends don't enroll friends in NAMBLA. I have to say, for the second day in a row I kind of agree with Zuckerberg. This isn't going to be popular, but it could actually lead to Facebook being less of a distraction and more of a genuine form of communication.

sprout··on A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person
I think the author means to say that a minimalist lifestyle does not make him a better person.

He really has no idea who any of us are, or what our goals are, or more importantly what our vices are. Some of us probably would benefit from a more minimalist lifestyle.

sprout··on MIT proposes to Reinvent the 737 for 70% greater fuel efficiency
Sure, but presumably the 737 would not be getting its optimal fuel efficiency if it went slower (every vehicle has some sort of a target speed that it's optimized for.)
sprout··on "When dealing with RMS, keep the following things in mind"
Possible, but not trivial as Jess considers it.

Furthermore, politesse is not a lingual phenomenon. The politesse of a Texan is different from a New Yorker is different from a Minnesotan is very different from a Londoner.

sprout··on Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information”
Glad to hear Zuckerberg has made good on his previously stated commitment to openness.
← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →