798 karma · joined March 1, 2021
https://gist.github.com/sshh12/f2c402db02eb00982100f645519bd...
It shouldn't be that surprising that a post advocating for using more AI is written using AI.
Typically human equivalent time is based on a single person given all the potential information they need up front (which is not today how a lot of work is done).
"Instead of a bloated API, an MCP should be a simple, secure gateway... MCP’s job isn’t to abstract reality for the agent; its job is to manage the auth, networking, and security boundaries and then get out of the way."
You still need some standard to hook up data to agents esp when the agents are not running on your local dev machine. I don't think e.g. REST/etc are nearly specific enough to do this without a more constrained standard for requests.
[1] https://blog.sshh.io/p/how-i-use-every-claude-code-feature
Part of it is the snappy more minimal UX but also just pure efficacy seems consistently better. Claude does its best work in CC. I'm sure the same is true of Codex.
You can do anything you want via a CLI but MCP still exists as a standard that folks and platforms might want to adopt as a common interface.
If theres enough interest, I might replicate some examples in an open source project.
It's much easier to review larger changes when you've aligned on a Claude generated plan up front.
Skills doesn't totally deprecate documenting things in CLAUDE.md but agree that a lot of these can be defined as skills instead.
Skill frontmatter also still sits in the global context so it's not really a token optimization either.
I think if it literally as a collection of .md files and scripts to help perform some set of actions. I'm excited for it not really as a "new thing" (as mentioned in the post) but as effectively an endorsement for this pattern of agent-data interaction.
Wrote about a similar supabase case [0] a few months ago and it's interesting that despite how well known these attacks feel even the official docs don't call it out [1].
[0] https://blog.sshh.io/i/161242947/mcp-allows-for-more-powerfu... [1] https://supabase.com/docs/guides/getting-started/mcp
- "Generate a depth map image" + https://depthy.stamina.pl/#/
- "generate a 360 pano" + https://renderstuff.com/tools/360-panorama-web-viewer/
- "generate a detailed greyscale top down height map (#fff max height, #000 min height)..." + https://cpetry.github.io/NormalMap-Online/