HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sshumaker

1,535 karma · joined October 16, 2009

email ===== work: scott at persona-ai dot ai personal: sshumaker at gmail

Product-focused tech executive with 20+ years experience building consumer and enterprise products. Currently co-founder of a stealth startup building something outrageously ambitious.

Previously VP at Microsoft and at Credit Karma. Ex-Googler and former gamedev.

submissionscomments
sshumaker··on Source code of “Delores: A Thimbleweed Park mini-adventure” released
GOAL wasn’t a scripting language - the entire Jak and Daxter series, including renderer, physics etc was written in it. It compiled to native PS2 code for the EE and VU processors.
sshumaker··on Hundreds join line at NYC ATM to access unemployment benefits
People are unbanked for various reasons. Banks are not well optimized for those of lower socioeconomic conditions (and in fact don’t really want them as customers). Here are a few examples where banks fail them:

1. Speedy access to money When you deposit a check into a bank account, you have to wait a few days before the cash is accessible. Many people live paycheck to paycheck and they cannot wait. Hence check-cashing services.

2. Overdraft fees These are incredibly regressive - punishing those who have low funds. Some banks were caught with predatory behavior - rearranging transactions in a day so the largest hit first and they could trigger multiple overdraft fees (since it is per-transaction) until laws were passed to prevent this behavior.

3. Other hidden fees (low-balance, etc) that aren’t very transparent and really painful when every dollar counts.

Not to mention cultural issues etc. Long-story short, there is a reason people use check-cashing services even though at face value they seem a worse deal than traditional banks.

(Source: was VP of ENG at Credit Karma)

sshumaker··on Uber Eats removes delivery fee for Black-owned restaurants
Here’s the argument from the book: how we define racism also determines how we battle it. If we have cancer and it makes us vomit, we can commit to battling nausea and say we’re fighting for our lives, even though the tumor will likely still kill us. When we look at racism simply as “any racial prejudice,” we are entered into a battle to win over the hearts and minds of everyone we encounter—fighting only the symptoms of the cancerous system, not the cancer itself. This is not only an impossible task, it’s a pretty useless one. Getting my neighbor to love people of color might make it easier to hang around him, but it won’t do anything to combat police brutality, racial income inequality, food deserts, or the prison industrial complex.

So using “systems of power” in the definition enables more effective action to address it.

sshumaker··on Uber Eats removes delivery fee for Black-owned restaurants
Being a person of color in the US absolutely means you are confronting systemic racism throughout your life. So absolutely, yes, compared to white restaurant owners. Example: If you are black, you are less likely to get a small business loan, and if so you are likely to get worse rates [1]. They also are encountering more resistance to accessing COVID-19 bailout funds [2]. These are just two examples specific to being a business owner, not to mention the systemic racism they face as individuals.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/jan/16/black-owned... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/10/business/minority-busines...

sshumaker··on Uber Eats removes delivery fee for Black-owned restaurants
A more useful definition from So you want to talk about race:

Racism is any prejudice against someone because of their race, when those views are reinforced by systems of power.

This definition is useful in the sense that it helps focus efforts on what needs to be addressed - systemic racism - vs trying to convince 100% of individuals to stop being racists in their day-to-day.

sshumaker··on Microsoft announces Lists, a new Airtable-like app
Really? I found it significantly more limiting than what I can accomplish in Google Sheets / Excel (although admittedly I'm a power user). The UI and mobile app is way better though.
sshumaker··on Roman Finger Counting
60 has nice properties, in that it is evenly divisible by 2,3,4,5,6,10,12,15,20,30. Helpful as a base since you can divide it into smaller units easily (monetary, measurement, etc).
sshumaker··on Nintendo has reportedly suffered a significant legacy console leak
Adding to this - for much of the pre-digital distribution era, piracy+retailers+rentals sucked out nearly 80% of the profits of the ecosystem. It made it impossible to break even as a studio unless you had a top 20 title released that year. The economics always sucked there - publishers fund development against royalties, break even happened after recouping this advance plus whatever costs the publisher larded on, per-unit royalties were often as little as a few bucks per game sold, and the publisher owned the IP. As a studio you had to get a continuous string of big hits as a single flop might put you out of business.
sshumaker··on Intuit to buy Credit Karma for $7B
https://www.creditkarma.com/faq/howitworks
sshumaker··on What happened to Mint?
This space is really difficult to crack for a few non-obvious reasons. The first is that the total TAM is less than you think; for most people, tracking their spending to manage budgets just doesn’t appeal to them. For many consumers, just seeing all of their finances is incredibly depressing. I suspect the 13mm Mint users are a large portion of the addressable market for this kind of product. So without a strong monetization engine that will work incredibly well at only ~10mm user range, you’re in trouble. Lead-gen isn’t sufficient here; Credit Karma has 10x the userbase and much stronger signals of intent, which is why they dominate digitize acquisition. When I was there, we put a lot of thought into how to crack personal finance, and ultimately felt that “spending” was too complex and too niche. The fact is you need radically different products for different parts of your consumer audience. That’s why you’ve seen a rise of more focused products like Robinhood, Wealthfront (going after the high end), savings apps like Acorn and digits, banking apps like Chime, etc (being a bank is profitable) that have incredibly strong revenue models attached.

I think you could run a reasonable lifestyle business here if you don’t take VC, but I’m skeptical this can ever be truly mass-market.

sshumaker··on 'Break up big tech's monopoly': Smaller rivals join growing chorus
That’s what people said about AT&T before we broke it up in 1982 - that it would hurt innovation. This was the company that had Bell Labs after all.

Instead, we had an absolute revolution in communication technology since - from fax lines, to modems, to cell connections, to the commercial internet.

It turns out that innovation happens more often when there is a lot of competition in the market. And the market figures out how to build standards for interop - you don’t need all of the products from the same company to get them to work together.

sshumaker··on Peter Thiel at Center of Facebook’s Internal Divisions on Politics
Russia spent money on democrat positions too. Their intent was to sow discord in the US populace and increase polarization.
sshumaker··on Microsoft REST API Guidelines
Http2 has efficiency gains at the transport later but not typically at the application tier. Having a single http request lets you things like handling authentication, fetching common state (user object), etc a single time for a batch request. Http2 doesn’t help you here.
sshumaker··on What skills are most crucial for running small internet companies?
I disagree, and this is the mistake I made earlier in my career. Having the market is most important. I have built great products that flopped and ok products that were incredibly successful.

Quoting Andy Rachleff: If your startup addresses a market that really wants your product, you can screw almost everything up and still likely be successful. On the flip side, if you are really good at execution, but the “dogs aren’t eating the dog food”, you have no chance at winning.

“When a great team meets a lousy market, market wins. When a lousy team meets a great market, market wins. When a great team meets a great market, something special happens.”

sshumaker··on Successfully Merging the Work of 1000 Developers
Xoogler here. When I left in 2015 there were definitely teams that used merge queues (i.e. TAP presubmit). Generally these were teams with a more monolithic architecture, like YouTube that had a massive Python mono.
sshumaker··on Baking a Better Loaf of Bread
Glyphosate, perhaps?
sshumaker··on Why Drugs That Work in Mice Don't Work in Humans
Look up the statistics. Majority of abortions are before 21 weeks (only 1.3% after). The vast majority of late-term abortions are for medical reasons, such as non-viability of fetus or endangerment of mother. The point of the law is to prevent the government from interfering in a doctor’s ability to provide medical care. Northam made a gaffe when speaking, but he is an actual doctor who has witnessed the actual terrible tragedies that can happen during pregnancy, as opposed to armchair quarterbacks who are jumping up and down to get their religious worldviews validated by law.
sshumaker··on Is Philanthropy Anti-Democratic?
As a mechanism of governance, it’s the best we’ve found so far at achieving prosperous, stable societies over a long time horizon. Perhaps the single biggest advantage well-run democracies offer is peaceful transfer of power.
sshumaker··on Anxiety and burnout: why kids are consumed with worry
(If you live in SF feel free to PM me for a suggestion).
sshumaker··on Anxiety and burnout: why kids are consumed with worry
I’d recommend finding a good therapist that specializes in generalized anxiety. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in particular can be really helpful at giving you tools to manage it.
sshumaker··on The Friendship That Made Google Huge
Not exactly; there are 3 levels of VPs and 3 for SVPs (at least in 2015). It’s just not publicized.
sshumaker··on The link between premarital sex and marriage stability
The article mentions that this data is not available (and that men are also less reliable w.r.t. accuracy)
sshumaker··on The link between premarital sex and marriage stability
From the article: unfortunately, the NSFG doesn’t have full data on men’s premarital sexual behavior, and in any event they recall their own marital histories less reliably than do women
sshumaker··on Why use GraphQL, good and bad reasons
First off, schemas are stored so they are accessible to the GQL server (not with FE code).

Maintaining API contracts is much easier with GraphQL than with REST (even if you layer on top a contract system like Swagger). The major advantage to GraphQL (which has a powerful schema system) is that you can explicitly know which fields are being accessed. The query itself represents what the client understands (capabilities). This makes it much easier to maintain backwards compatibility. You can even monitor traffic per field to deprecate features.

Re: BE code breaks, that’s what integration tests are for.

sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (July 2018)
Credit Karma | San Francisco, Charlotte | Full Time, Onsite | https://creditkarma.com

Credit Karma's mission is to make financial progress possible for everyone. We have over 80 million US users and are a true mission-oriented business, a rare case where our incentives are aligned with our users - we succeed by helping our members attain financial progress.

We've been growing rapidly over the past few years (hypergrowth) and are hiring across a wide range of positions. On the backend side, we are building Scala and Typescript node.js services as well as investing heavily in GraphQL. Our native iOS and Android apps are written in Swift and Kotlin and are the top apps in Finance. Our website is built in React + Redux. We’re always on the lookout for experienced data scientists to help explore some of the richest data sets around and unlock financial insights for our members.

If you're motivated by growth and impact Credit Karma is one of the best places to work in tech today. We have solved product / market fit and distribution, but compared to our peer unicorns there is still so much work to do. If you look at the gap between our product today and what we are well-positioned to become - the main touchpoint for consumer finance - there is tons of opportunity for people joining now to take on responsibility and ownership and have a meaningful impact.

If you have questions I’m happy to answer them - scott.shumaker at creditkarma.com.

To apply, visit https://www.creditkarma.com/careers

sshumaker··on Google vs. Google: How Nonstop Political Arguments Rule Its Workplace
What does this even mean? There are a lot more engineers, designers and product managers at Google devoted to what you deem “marketing” than ads. (Source: I’m a xoogler). People on those teams believe strongly in their missions and their KPIs are mostly not revenue-related. In general, there was a strong underlying philosophy while I was there that “if you do right for the user it will work out in the long term.”
sshumaker··on Why Can't Hollywood Make a Good Video Game Movie?
It’s more nuanced than you might think. All of the other elements do contribute to the fun factor. As a former game developer, there were times where adding particle effects or even sound suddenly made a sequence fun, as if suddenly a threshold had been crossed.

Human beings do respond to rewards and payoffs; it can be the satisfying sound of a coin being collected or animation of your character wall-jumping and grabbing onto a ledge. These things DO matter.

sshumaker··on Amazon won't sell you a Chromecast, but they will sell a counterfeit
xoogler here, one of my teams implemented cast functionality in google photos. IIRC, this was definitely not the reason; the protocol was initially very limited and it was changed to make it more secure while also adding capabilities.
sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (March 2018)
Credit Karma | San Francisco, Charlotte | Full Time, Onsite | https://creditkarma.com

Credit Karma's mission is to make financial progress possible for everyone. We have over 80 million US users and are a true mission-oriented business, a rare case where our incentives are aligned with our users - we succeed by helping our members attain financial progress.

We've been growing rapidly over the past few years (hypergrowth) and are hiring across a wide range of positions. On the backend side, we are building Scala and Typescript node.js services as well as investing heavily in GraphQL. Our native iOS and Android apps are written in Swift and Kotlin and are the top apps in Finance. Our website is built in React + Redux. We’re always on the lookout for experienced data scientists to help explore some of the richest data sets around and unlock financial insights for our members.

If you're motivated by growth and impact Credit Karma is one of the best places to work in tech today. We have solved product / market fit and distribution, but compared to our peer unicorns there is still so much work to do. If you look at the gap between our product today and what we are well-positioned to become - the main touchpoint for consumer finance - there is tons of opportunity for people joining now to take on responsibility and ownership and have a meaningful impact.

If you have questions I’m happy to answer them - scott.shumaker at creditkarma.com. To apply, visit https://www.creditkarma.com/careers

sshumaker··on Ask HN: Have you successfully done a career do-over, and how did you do it?
Is the 40 year old comfortable taking the same salary as an early/mid career dev? Therein lies the rub.
← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →