2,268 karma · joined June 23, 2010
https://textlog.cc/u/stagas
mailto:gstagas@gmail.com
Edit: also I don't see it very similar to insurance, since insurance is withholding wealth in order to distribute it occasionally when needed because it's zero-sum. But if distributing it all the time everywhere is a net positive gain, that's entirely different than the insurance game.
Edit: here is also the source code for the cooperative coin, if it helps the discussion https://github.com/lmlhub/ee_web_apps/blob/main/cooperating_...
So, yes, waves are an abstraction, how can you not see it? When you look at the sea you don't see waves, you see colors moving around and then when you try to describe what you see, you define the concept of "waves" and come to the conclusion that these are waves you are looking at. But that happens entirely inside your mind. Waves is a concept like frequency.
There are two possible claims:
1) The belief that the world is out there and is intelligible and I have the means to know about it. Which means whatever I think I know, must be based on some absolute truth that was there before me knowing about it.
2) The belief that whatever I think about the world, defines the world and whatever I think about the world is something I am making up right now.
If you adhere to 1, then all of your actions are justifiable for you, because the only place to lookup for confirmation is still just your own mind, and you believe that the mind reflects "a world that is out there and is intelligible" then whatever you do or think must be based on some truth, including harming others. Wars are a perfect example of that. In the minds of the people conducting it, it is justifiable because that's their version of reality and they believe that reality as something concrete and unchanging. Nations, ethnic categories etc. are all things that people made up and hold strong beliefs about them.
If you adhere to 2, then you are more humble in how you approach matters. Whatever you might imagine, you know that is just a product of the mind, and is malleable, since the world isn't intelligible and therefore can't be known. The lack of concreteness creates doubt, and in doubt you (usually) don't take actions. You allow the space for others experiencing their own version of reality however they feel like, as you do yours, without an inclination to indoctrinate them into your own version, since the metaphysical claim is that anyone has their own, and that's how things are. You could say this makes you catatonic, but i claim that it better directs your attention to the things you find interesting, rather than others telling you what you need to pay attention to. You are free to create your own ethics, based on your own experiences of what's good or not according to you, for your own space.
When you adhere to 1, the ethical framework is already given to you and imposed on you by other people hallucinating their reality, and if they say "lets go to war" you go to war, because that's what you believe must be true. There is no doubt, since there's no subjectivity, it must objectively be the case that you need to go to war. That's the only possible outcome of a belief that the world is out there and is intelligible.
However, I'm not saying that things don't exist, it's that they do exist but not independently of the conscious agent that has the experience of them. The universe and the thinking agent that is currently perceiving that universe, come into existence simultaneously, in the act of perceiving/thinking.
The mind arises out of the necessary universe that is required for a mind that observes it to exist.
There could be infinite of other universes (or other things "out there" i can't experience), but those claims makes no sense since because for something to exist it must have a conscious agent experiencing it as existing. There can't be a universe in the void, simply rocks. Even "rock" is something that is defined by thought and can't exist independently of it.
Reality is perception. It is one set of logical possibities that allow the thinking agent to exist and to produce the thoughts it is producing right now. It is the output of a pure function in which it creates itself and maintains its existence, constantly feeding its output to its input.
Dreams are the exploration step of that function. Once in a while, the function creates a sandbox, feeds it with output gathered and classified as semi-coherent (adding in a few random bits), it simulates outcomes and picks out those fragments that didn't crash it.
Those are then integrated back into its main code, into the world it imagines it inhabits, "reality".
edit: And it's strikes me as odd that you'd want to basically screw over all the demographic of what is your "power users", meaning those that have the ability and the desire to tweak things.
Because we have structured society and our culture in such a way that some people can only feel safe when inside a small thick wall cell with the door locked behind them. That's terrible though, my proposition is to invert that, what would allow people to sing in the streets without any fear of judgement, and use that as a basis. Privacy as an idea suggests "let's put more doors with locks" when in fact that doesn't help at all. It doesn't address the problem that necessitates those doors with locks to exist.
I understand what you're saying but my point is if we didn't try to protect X, it would eventually be normalized, become part of daily life and not noticeable as a thing that needs to be protected AND that it seems that when putting protections for X, that protection implicitly includes the assumption that X is bad. A naked body isn't inherently an invitation for rape, unless you implant that idea into someone's mind through the ban of public nakedness, and being gay isn't a thing to judge, unless you make it a taboo and discourage its public expression.
I'm not convinced, the real life evidence in actual tolerant societies seem to suggest that the more open we are, the less secrets we keep and the more transparent we are, life improves.