Why do people think that this has been successful for DARPA? DARPA has spent billions on all kinds of ideas that don't work, including prize competitions. Once in a while they have a "hit" and they publicize that like crazy. DARPA is also known (notoriously, one could say) for operating a good-old-boys system, where you have to butter up the DARPA program managers to get any funding. So no, I don't agree that prizes have been successful for DARPA.