HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stillsut

1,149 karma · joined August 10, 2013

submissionscomments
stillsut··on As an investor, why is crypto so hard to value?
But what's easy to value is public pensions. Do the existing reserves and projected inflows match the liabilities? Of course not, they are underwater by trillions of dollars. How will fifty very different state governments and the federal government distribute these losses? Impossible to say, because different factions are already lining up different schemes with vastly different outcomes.

In contrast, we already know exactly how bitcoin works presently and how it works in the future. It's right there in the cpp file. It doesn't matter who the Senator from California is, it doesn't matter who is the chairman of the Fed is.

So bitcoin competes with other currencies by being a system with transparent and predictable behavior. Meanwhile the current dollar system - which is valuable precisely because the government always meets its obligations - is being valued by pretty much just ignoring all its underfunded obligations in the hope that some unknown solution will be arranged when it becomes a crisis.

To tie these findings back to the concept of financial "valuation", I think the author elides the role that predictability plays in it. And specifically overestimates the predictability of status quo at a time length of five to thirty years.

stillsut··on Twenty percent of a picture of a dog
NFT's represent a rather beautiful but whacky idea: that money supply is controlled by the critical reception of new artwork. Not the opinion of the snobby art world, but a completely democratic market for art populi - where the aesthetic leans meme - think less MOMA and more favorite contestant on American Idol.

This means NFT's have the ability of dynamically change the money supply based on the prevaliling Keynsian animal spirits across society, versus bitcoins pre-determined money supply schedule. This is a novel feature to the crypto ecosystem: in a way it's moving the activity of mining for block rewards from a robotic and silicon-based process into a creative human process of mining for memetic uptake.

Another interesting opportunity is for patronage to sponsor our society's artists. Just like Florentine status competitions of religious paintings supported Da Vinci's works, our crypto merchants could be supporting the man who will still be going viral five hundred years later. Let me know if you find him.

stillsut··on Einstein's missed opportunity to rid us of 'spooky actions at a distance'
Thanks for the help. I just want to point out this [detector orientation] is likely a big area where non-physics people might get tripped up:

If you told me causally this detector which measures electrons/photons/whatever and varies by the cosine of the orientation, I don't think any (non-physics person) would bat an eye; it seems like a pretty normal thing a sensor might do.

stillsut··on Einstein's missed opportunity to rid us of 'spooky actions at a distance'
Your answer seems to focus on the key un-addressed subtlety.

Why is the difference in orientation of the detector necessarily linear? What is the control aspect of this experiment where classical-system shows this linear pattern? Or can the argument be made more fundamentally?

stillsut··on Cells are fast and crowded places (2011)
Is there not some local disturbances in the circulation of cell contents that not all interactions are i.i.d? Some kind of repelling force on a large molecule that would keep similarly charged molecules at arms length. And in some cases act as a cell wide tidal force to diffusion?

I'm thinking of the atari pong ball where you can ricochet the ball between the top of the court and bricks repeatedly; is there some locality in the cell which takes advantage of positioning to increase likelihood of collision?

stillsut··on Challenge to scientists: does your ten-year-old code still run?
It's not academia but Kaggle that's really been on the forefront of building portable and reproducible computational pipelines.

The real key is incentives and there are two that standout to me:

- Incentive to get others to "star" and fork your code makes the coder compete to not only have an accurate result, but also prioritize producing code/notebooks that are digestible and instructive. That includes liberal commenting/markup, idiomatic syntax and patterns, diagnostic figures, and the use of modern and standard libraries.

- There is an incentive to move with the community on best practices for the libraries while still allowing experimental libraries. Traditionally, there is the incentive of inertia: e.g. "I always do my modelling in Lisp, and I won't change because then I'd be less productive". But with kaggle, to learn from the insights and advances of others, you need to have an ability to work with the developing common toolset.

In academia, if these incentives were given weight on par with publication and citation then we'd see the tools and practices fall into place.

stillsut··on Open Problems in Robotics
The pile of problems in Robotics reminds me of the challenges faced by computer vision before modern methods were developed. To generalize the issue: humans learn and perform vision and navigational tasks "below" the level of language.

To use a vivid example, you can use language to teach a child how to hold a pencil and write, how to recognize digits, and how to do two digit addition. But there's some cognitive ability "below" the level language a child needs to be capable of in order to take the hints from language and develop the desired skills. In computer vision, we now have something like this in ConvLayers.

In today's robotics we see the hyper-systematization and mathematization of natural concepts like getting an agent to recognize its own bearing. This is what I refer to as "at the level of language", and I think as long as we try to solve these individual navigation problems from mathematical first principles we'll never arrive anywhere near the performance of animal "instinct". We need a new framework that doesn't look like an enumeration of commands within an imperative program.

stillsut··on Turkey Now Has Swarming Suicide Drones It Could Export
Agree. Even the murderdrones black mirror scenario posits a two-stage system: ~5 mile transport/breech-stage + 100-foot-range intercept unit. All to attack a stationary school building. So yeah, intercepting jets is going to need a another stage. And I think the intercept stage might look more like a guided mortars than a quadcopter.
stillsut··on Turkey Now Has Swarming Suicide Drones It Could Export
I largely agree at this point in the proposed capabilities. As you say these are just hand grenades that fly in cool looking formations. Independently guided aerial buck shot.

But the game changer is when these cheap independent systems can communicate and coordinate an intercept task against SOTA weapons systems - namely jets and nuclear subs.

As we know from birdstrikes, just a collision at the speed jets are moving at will probably neutralize it. To do this, the swarm will create several layers of buckshot that the jet can't avoid every one of them. If the jet is able to evade this first cloud, that cloud will now have very accurate targeting data to relay on to the next cloud.

And there will no longer be five billion dollar, 100-person manned subs to intercept other subs, all we'll need is an omni-present net of autonomous buoys that can "collapse-in" on any detected threat.

stillsut··on Turkey Now Has Swarming Suicide Drones It Could Export
It's foolish for a state actor leave the remnant pieces of an advanced weapon (like an autonomous drone) at the scene of a crime during an assassination. First because the uniqueness of the technology makes the actor identifiable, second because the country targeted will react more cohesively to this novel kind of cassus belli (e.g. news coverage of 1 drunk driving death vs 1 autonomous vehicle death)

The good old fashion alternative is just a gunman. It's more plausibly deniable - e.g. still nobody is exactly sure what was going on with Lee Harvey Oswold and Jack Ruby - and it doesn't put the targeted country immediately on a war footing.

stillsut··on Is a trillion dollars’ worth of programming lying on the ground?
It is difficult to align worker-incentives in large off-shore contractors with the client's needs.

Someone mentioned that contractors don't write tests unless you explicitly tell them which ones to write. Well, even if they did, are you going to be able to promote them? That dev's manager is probably hyper-focused on spec completion and billable hours. Even if you paid more for test coverage you start paying for things like assert sum(1,1) == 2.

High quality code often comes from people coding for "the job they want" not the job they currently have. In-house work usually has this carrot of a senior role that can be attained by taking initiative and thinking outside the spec for the missing pieces. This is a form of compensation and incentive missing in low end contracting work.

stillsut··on Show HN: A basketball hoop to maximize shots that go in [video]
The design idea is also similar to the the original stealth fighter design, the "hopeless diamond"[0], in that it's optimized to bounce all possible radar waves away from returning to their receiver.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Have_Blue

stillsut··on Urbit for Normies
Even in the case where the Urbit container and network are perfectly implemented and widely adopted, I'd imagine privacy as of the average user if not most users would continue to be compromised:

The plebs would end up authorizing liberal permissions to to watch some out-of-network UrbitTikTok video, even as we screamed at them not to. And the devs would be forced to enable some phone-home capabilities in exchange for access to their pro tools. Or go the jailbreak route and play a constant game of cat and mouse. In essence, if you're on the consumer side, it seems like you're not in a position to negotiate privacy terms regardless of whether you access the network in a centralized or p2p way.

stillsut··on The Glorious, Profitable, Inescapable Art of Addiction
Me: I can't see how people can put money into a slot machine or a video game and take pleasure from that.

Also me: gcp compute model.fit(epochs=20) watches error trend downwards

stillsut··on Sam Altman’s leap of faith
AGI is our generation's Nanotechnology. From first principles, it's reasoned, it could build anything - including itself! Despite this 100 Quadrillion dollar idea looming on the horizon for two decades, nobody ever makes material progress, or, gets all that excited about it anymore.

Instead of General intelligence, AI will be deployed for several decades as a suite of Specialized intelligences. I think it will completely transform creative work, where writing, music and visual arts, and "streaming content" are almost universally produced with a human as a first mover but the computer doing rendering, and major assists in brainstorming and editing.

On the other hand, I think it's going to be very difficult to replace the average middle manager with Watson 12.0 - it's hard for me to articulate why but it comes down to who I'd want to work for. Meanwhile, I'd have no problem with watching GoT season 33 where 1,800 frames of a Peter Dinklage sprite are churned out every week in Adobe Simalacrum.

The point as it pertains to OpenAI's value prop is that I think they are targeting the wrong market, and their secrecy and insularity will be counter-productive when success relies on helping content producers produce. In personal computer terms: you want to be the AppleII company, not the company that wins the contract for the Dept of Defense's mainframes.

stillsut··on McDonald's Acquires Machine-Learning Startup Dynamic Yield for $300M
The first half of Schultz's Pour Your Heart Into It.

Even its title, similar to Kroc (his: Grind It Out).

stillsut··on McDonald's Acquires Machine-Learning Startup Dynamic Yield for $300M
If you liked the story of Ray Kroc, you'll like the story of Howard Schultz scaling Starbucks; the similarities are spooky.
stillsut··on The New 30-Something
Really informative and inspiring comment.

But I wanted to ask if you ever consider the counterfactual where instead of flying planes you're peeling potatoes for four years? Let's just say due to bad luck or a twist of fate - I didn't know he was Colonel's son!

I mean nothing post discharge sounds like it was too associated with your role as pilot - the benefits are available to any veteran. But it does seem like you live life with a healthy amount of initiative and I wonder if you think about starting life with less role-responsibility or have ever compared peer outcomes in this way?

stillsut··on Sir David Attenborough: Climate change 'our greatest threat'
The problem is coordination of a Public solution where the will to act lacks a political majority or super majority. The opportunity is the most progressive eighth of the first world really wants to address it.

Then the solution is a Private sector one - for this high net worth eighth of the population to invest the vast majority of their savings portfolio into green energy sector. But this would be even more effective if we made investments outflows less possible, so we should create a hedge fund that would require around one decade of a commitment period. This will supercharge R&D into this sector leading to better solutions, maybe one a political majority will support.

It does seem risky to tie your personal finances to the progress of green energy, but since the climate threat is already the greatest risk of all, it seems a worthy swap. And since it seems like green energy is a "no-brainer" / inevitability, then the investment is almost a sure thing to pay off in the long run. So in the end you'll not only help the planet but help yourself.

stillsut··on The Most Misread Poem in America (2015)
The problem boils down to the poem being taught in high school when the average American teenager has yet to have made any independent choices, nor have they ever really had to live with the consequences of some decision made when they were a younger, different person.

Most middle class kids live a very scripted lives, but are constantly hammered with the idea that soon they will be called upon to make their own decisions - usually characterized by a binary to continue the scripted path - college, corporate job, marriage in late twenties or thrities - or a second, riskier outlet into 'there be dragons' land. In this context, it's not surprising that the poem has become a concise stand-in and beautiful articulation of contemporary middle class social consensus.

If I'm remembering this correctly, I came across this poem in the wake of a solo startup disaster. And I instantly got the second meaning without any need for literary deconstruction or critical nudging. I vividly remembered the excitement of the choice at the start. I now knew about how we tend to ponder what might have been. And could list many "founder success stories" told ages and ages hence of how I - I chose Angular2, and that has made all the difference.

And that is genius of this poem, that it can (only?) be read differently by those with a certain amount of lived experience. It hides its meaning in plain sight and straight forward vocabulary (unlike Wasteland) and let's the reader insert himself and his entire life into this tiny vignette.

stillsut··on Fleets of drones could aid searches for lost hikers
How well would sound work? As in listening for the person to yell out to an autonomous vehicle flying above the canopy.

Obviously drones are noisy, so maybe fixed wing. Or maybe you could have a microphone suspended on a cable fifty feet below a quad, with an apparatus that shields noise from above. But there seem to be promising characteristics too for this situation: 1.) human voice is very different than propeller hum, 2.) wildernesses have very minimal background noise. Filter and classify outliers.

I say this as someone whose only SAR situation was getting himself out of the Vermont woods at dusk by hiking roughly a mile towards the sound of a barking dog.

stillsut··on Subject: Airbnb (2011)
It is an impressive accomplishment; but like GPA, not an indicator-of-success in venture.
stillsut··on Actuarial science ranked as most valuable college major
Former actuary here. Let me try to explain some of the frustrations that occur in the profession:

Technical ownership is distributed from the top down and can not be overridden from bottom-up process improvements. Even if it made sense to integrate two departments that regularly pass each other data, that will be fought because that interferes with someone's corporate fiefdom.

There is no clear high-level diagram of how the whole company functions. So unlike a web-app with a client-frontend-routing-backend-database pipeline that a smart 15 year old could learn to conceptualize, instead you're expected to learn the inter-process requirements in a piecemeal fashion, one detail at a time as it arises in a weekly task. In the best case, this big picture starts to emerge ~5 years into a full time job. In the more likely case, your tasks never expose you to some part of the company's operations and they remain a blackbox and you'll be unable to reason about.

While inter-process communication remains opaque, complexity within each process proliferates. If you do life insurance, you need to support every product you sell for fifty years, so you deal with often poorly documented product rules and hard core legacy systems. Note - you can't deprecate anything because must honor those complicated agreements made decades ago.

Basically the frustrations boil down to doing interesting systems/data work but with being forced to do it in a worst-practices fashion.

stillsut··on Genoa Bridge Collapse: The Road to Tragedy
What I find unusual is - according to the infographic - both southern cables broke in the initial stage. And then that was followed by the northern cables breaking in response to the load shifting.

I presume the two southern cables are independent components and support independent platforms. Why would they both break at the same time, if not for some exogenous event?

stillsut··on New Video of F-117s Flying Out of Tonopah Despite Their Fates Being Sealed
Yeah today it's PRISM and Stuxnet.

But less sarcastically, there was that stealth helicopter destroyed during the Bin Laden raid, but I haven't seen much talk about it since.

stillsut··on George Hotz is on a hacker crusade against the ‘scam’ of self-driving cars
It seems likely that autonomy will not be first adopted by the US but instead in the 'wild west' of BRICs - Brazil, Russia, India or China.

Also maybe in a country small, rich, authoritarian, and organized enough to build infrastructure around it and limit liability like Singapore or Luxembourg.

And oh look, a cheap and open source solution that gets you started in CommaAI. I think they (or a fork of them) are quite good candidates for the first system to reach one trillion miles driven. There will no doubt be carnage. But the benefits of self driving are going to be first on display outside of US markets.

stillsut··on A new $100M fund for women founders of color
There's something of "In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges" in your victimhood concept. Or updating the concept to current times, forbidding those who can couch surf indefinitely with friends in a dozen cities and the friendless from sleeping in their car.

In aggregate, the white people I know do have more couch surfing opportunities than women of color. And more VC access. But individually, some do not, through no fault of their own, only the circumstances they were born into. To take an extreme example: Elizabeth Holmes, who is also a "victim" of this fund, is never actually going to need this fund; her father has a direct line of communication to Henry Kissinger and was able to raise 10x this funds entire capital. What I'm trying to say is this kind of concept actually doesn't victimize the most privileged like Holmes, and maybe you (?) but it does exclude some who exist on the margins of startup space.

Empirically, what this could mean if this concept becomes a trend, is that people with good ideas and the ability to execute may be less likely to do a startup, considering it a rich person's game. A little like saying just move to Brooklyn and become an artist. We're still very far away from that but I don't think it's absurd to imagine us ending up there; if you talk to people outside the US, there's a strong belief that only the "right kind" of people can raise capital.

stillsut··on A new $100M fund for women founders of color
There are currently two competing narratives about what is racist: On one side, it's considered racist to make decisions based on race. On the other side, it's considered racist to make decisions without considering race, and the history of power and oppression that comes with it.

One side sees a productive way to move forward by not repeating the mistakes of the past. The other side sees a way to make the future better by correcting the mistakes of the past. It's one of the most difficult we face as both as a society and as individuals: often in literature a character will be driven to avenge a past injustice and at the height of narrative arc, will be forced to consider his motivations and the consequences of his goal. The YA novel A Long Way Down and the movie Blue Ruin both explore this concept poignantly, without ever giving us easy or generalizable answers.

Because racial politics can be so mentally poisoning, a far more neutral thought experiment is to consider a fund reserved exclusively for funding military veterans. That's a kind of situation where almost everyone can see both sides to the issue: how can you deny their contribution and sacrifices? And yet how can you fail to see the unintended but inevitable consequences that creates?

stillsut··on The F-35 Is a $1.4 Trillion National Disaster
The F-35 is a weapons system designed to continue the US's ability to easily win a conventional war against a high 2nd tier state power in their own territory. What this might look like is the total rout in 1991 of Iraq, which had the fifth largest army in the world, and advanced surface-to-air defenses, defeated in large part by stealth technology. This fighter is basically stating to these threats: you are not going to be able to defeat or stalemate us at our own game.

I know this isn't a popular sentiment around here but consider the difference in outcome between the 1990 invasion of Kuwait vs the 2013 invasion of Crimea: only in the one where we had absolute military superiority did the US - or "the UN" if you prefer - actually get a say in how it turned out.

Who does this entail today? The big two are clearly North Korea and Iran. Stretching it, I'd add Taiwan, Ukraine and the Eastern bloc, India on the China border, Philippines, and Venezuela becoming some type of Cuba situation. Then there are proxy wars between major powers like Syria, which will likely continue to occur in the middle east and Africa for several decades. Even if we don't enter these fights, we'll be able to give our allies this plane. (Or maybe they'll turn down the most advanced plane ever built because the pilot helmet has issues in high humidity situations /sarc.)

This isn't going to neutralize the other two main powers, it will continue to be an imperfect - maybe even useless - weapon against their anti-ship and surface-to-air capabilities. It can't defeat the 3rd world and it can't defeat a superpower. The question is: is the price worth what it can do (which is defeat 2nd tier powers / proxy adversaries for the next ~25 years)? Or is there something which can do that better?

stillsut··on Toward a Mature Science of Consciousness
A good start towards defining consciousness is to box it in with edge cases: a person in coma? a severely mentally retarded person? a person on hallucinogenic drugs? a dog? The answers to these edge cases can help us separate possibly entangled concepts that seem to come under the umbrella of consciousness.

I would concentrate on collecting empirical evidence, at the expense of developing further theoretical speculation along the lines of "p-zombies". I could see a Darwin-like figure traveling widely and recording detail minutely, and using it to make the case for simple unifying force behind an enormous spectrum of variation.

← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →