HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on Create-React-App 3.3
No, because what these CLIs actually provide is a preconfigured build system, not the straw-man overstuffed boilerplate you are suggesting they do.

Do I miss spending hours configuring Webpack builds, CSS and HTML processors, JS compilers, linters, unit and e2e testing frameworks, dev servers and npm dependencies before I can even start coding on the problem I really want to solve? No, I do not.

stupidcar··on John Carmack: I’m going to work on artificial general intelligence
Which is presumably the research he intends to do over the next few months? E.g. reading around the subject to determine where best to focus his efforts.
stupidcar··on Snake game made in Go
Just a silly joke. one of the more famous example programs that came with QBasic for MS-DOS was a snake game called Nibbles: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nibbles_(video_game)
stupidcar··on Snake game made in Go
Finally QBasic has a serious competitor.
stupidcar··on Monty Hall Problem
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Citing_sources#Citat...

Basically, Wikipedia does not mandate a citation style, it just has to be consistent throughout an article. And once set, another editor can't change it simply for personal preference. Presumably the original author, or whichever editor first added citations, was more familiar with this style, and so it has stuck.

stupidcar··on What should have been an IMG element became this
This is a big problem, but calling it over-engineering seems too generous. I'd characterise it as under-engineering: Developers unwilling or unable to give proper consideration to non-functional requirements such as performance and design an optimised solution, and instead just layering on more and more dependencies.

There's a happy medium between serving a single <img> tag and this monstrosity. It would be totally feasible to use PWA techniques and a lightweight JS framework to build an image host that was performant and still provided all the other features Imgur does.

But let's face facts: It's not going to happen, no matter how many angry Twitter threads get posted to Hacker News. The web platform is completely unsuited to mobile, and there are simply too many perverse incentives in commercial web development to expect that most developers will expend the effort to build an optimised PWA when they can slap something together with React, knowing it'll work fine on the CEO's iPhone on office wifi.

The only real fix would be a complete reinvention of the web to fix the myriad design flaws. That is what Google's AMP was supposed to be, but people seem to hate it and see it is proprietary and evil. Maybe it is, but from a technical perspective, it's likely the only kind of solution that has a chance of working.

stupidcar··on Boeing 2016 internal messages suggest employees may have misled FAA on 737 MAX
Quelle surprise
stupidcar··on Building China's Comac C919 airplane involved a lot of hacking, report says
By "different principles", you presumably mean totally in the service of an autocratic, hegemonistic nation bent on the brutal oppression its own citizens and its rise to become an unchallengeable global power able to curtail the social, political and human rights of anybody, anywhere on Earth, who it deems an enemy?
stupidcar··on Tim Cook’s Company-Wide Email on Hkmap.live Doesn’t Add Up
No, the complaint is not that Cook is not providing direct evidence, and it is a complete misrepresentation to suggest so. It makes your protestations of disinterest rather suspect, as those of supposed "devil's advocates" so often seem to be.

The complaint is that Cook's claims are extraordinary and seemingly impossible on their face because of the fundamental nature of the app in question. Its purpose is to show the aggregated position of large concentrations of police, so as to let users avoid confrontations with them. How can such an app be used to "target individual officers for violence", since it provides no information about individual officers?

When so extraordinary a claim is made, hearsay evidence isn't the issue. What is necessary is an explanation of how the seemingly impossible is possible. Cook does not provide this or even address the apparent problem. A neutral person, reading Cook's memo without the proper background, might be mislead into believing the app in question does provide tracking of individual police officers. I don't accept this is an accident on Cook's part. I think he is deliberately attempting to mislead his own employees regarding the nature of the app, and as a consequence his decision to ban it.

Cook's cited but unenumerated "credible" information received from a government body and users only compounds the situation. Cook could provide plenty of additional material to support his claim. He could provide more detailed information on exactly what information was received, in what volume, and in what form. He could explain the efforts the company undertook to perform independent corroboration of the evidence. He could provide a detailed account of why, in this case, he believes an autocratic government currently conducting a brutal repression of its own citizens can be trusted to communicate honestly about it, given neither it, nor any similar autocratic government, has ever spoken honestly about similar situations in the past.

Fundamentally, the problem isn't whatever evidence does or does not exist. It is that Cook's memo is a weak, politician's attempt to justify a misdeed by making absurd claims for which he provides no evidence at all. He is trying to make a problem go away, not engage with a difficult situation as a human being.

stupidcar··on New In Postgres 12: Generated Columns
Why do you think placing business logic into the database system is a layering violation?

Just because most developers use their DB as a dumb store doesn't mean it needs to be. There are also plenty of successful software systems that place the majority of their business logic and use a generic programming language and runtime only for the presentation layer.

If you're comfortable fully exploiting the capabilities of your DB, then the intelligent combination of a relational model with custom data types, constraints, triggers, views and stored procedures can make the DB the perfect place to implement business logic.

stupidcar··on Capitalism, Alone
Interesting piece, but there seems to me to be contradiction in its thesis: If people have become so devoted to monetary success alone, how can all these industries that rely on vice exist? Indulging a vice is inherently wasteful. It costs time that could be spent working, and money that could be better spent on self-improvement, or invested or saved.

And while we may have accepted greed to the point that there is nothing distasteful about saying one desires a better car or house, or a better paid job, in practice most people do not work day and night, spurning all other opportunities, to make it happen. In practice, most people make decisions every day that place other desires, both traditionally "good" and "bad", above the simple pursuit of more money. So to say that people have internalised capitalism to the exclusion of all else seems incorrect.

I have a different take: The development of capitalism and commodification had a mutually reinforcing relationship with the fluidity of labor and the fungibility of goods. Many "traditional" bonds between individuals and communities were really a consequence of local monopolies: There was only one local doctor, shopkeeper, school, etc., and a small pool of potential employers. As such, relationships were inevitably more personal.

As technology, law and institutions allowed civilisation to become more mobile, it allowed the possibility of markets in many areas of life where it was previously impossible. This is unavoidable. Even if you personally choose to stand still, the people around you move, meaning your relationships and interactions are nonetheless more transitory and impersonal. In such a world, commodification emerges not as the consequence of internalised capitalist ideology, but because it is the only way to manage constant interactions with strangers.

So it is commodification itself that has become internalised, not capitalism. Indeed, most modern society isn't arranged around acquiring capital and leveraging it or maximising its value, it's about the consumption of things and experiences—driven by materialist, emotional and spiritual instincts—using money as a points system used to ration them out. Most people approach their work in a simple way: they want to earn enough points to meet their basic needs, and indulge their desires to a point of equilibrium between effort and general satisfaction, after which they don't work any harder or longer.

stupidcar··on What do executives do, anyway?
The management methodology The article presents is interesting, but a little too neat. It fails to address some of the obvious practical problems that would come from applying it (though perhaps the book does). In particular, what happens when two reports simply cannot agree?

Many business decisions are time-sensitive. They cannot be endlessly deferred until a consensus is reached. And even reasonable people, with access to the same information, can reach opposite conclusions that will never be reconciled. In these cases, somebody has to break the tie, as even a sub-optimal decision may be better than a non-decision.

Also, in the matter of strategy, it's true that knowledge workers are better informed within their domain, but they are also usually blind to larger scale factors. The individual soldier knows the ideal outcome is to defeat the enemy, and is best informed as to how to overcome a particular local strong point. But it doesn't follow that he is best placed to make the tactical or strategic decision to attack or not. Nor does it follow that a war-winning strategy will spontaneously emerge.

stupidcar··on Ray Tracing Denoising
What's fascinating to me about this is that it sounds like future renderers may end up working very much like we think the brain does. There is a virtual world, but very little raw data about that world is used directly, just a small sample, and the rest of the image is filled in by a neural model that is able to infer how the whole scene should look based its a priori understanding of how things like light and depth work.
stupidcar··on Thomas Cook Shuts Down
This article has them as the 11th largest West European airline: https://centreforaviation.com/analysis/reports/aircraft-flee...
stupidcar··on AgileFall – When Waterfall Sneaks Back into Agile
No, it's worse.

An up-front design is sometimes necessary and valuable, in both agile or waterfall projects, but it always carries a risk of including mistakes or mistaken assumptions that result in dangerous flaws.

When such a flaw is discovered, especially late in the project, it is often very expensive and difficult to fix, because it has become foundational to the solution. This is true regardless of whether an waterfall or agile process has been adopted, and there will often be significant pressure to implement a hacky fix, instead of the truly correct one.

Where agile differs from waterfall is that it does, at least, philosophically accept that nothing is set in stone, even at a late stage. Discussions regarding how to address a flaw can then proceed on a basis of cost vs. risk vs. difficulty, and a hopefully rational choice can be made.

In contrast, the rigidity of the waterfall process is frequently used as a bureaucratic weapon to prevent these discussions from even happening. Decisions made in the project's initial stages are held to be settled and unalterable, and those seeking to overturn them usually have to fight a horrendous, uphill battle to do so, even when they're in the right.

I would liken the difference between design in agile and waterfall to that of scientific theory vs religious dogma. Neither necessarily has a monopoly on truth: A theory might be mistaken while dogma, by chance, might be correct. And challenging well-established scientific theory can, in practice, be almost as difficult and painful as disputing dogma. But science at least accepts the possibility of change, however hard it may be.

stupidcar··on Inkscape 1.0 Beta 1
Why does Inkscape's UI feel so... sloppy? I mean, Blender is a cross-platform, open-source design tool, and it manages to have a tight, professional looking UI. So how does Inkscape's UI still contrive to look like the first Java AWT application I wrote in the 90s?

I know it's just a surface thing, and there's a lot of great functionality there. But it's still not exactly a sight that helps inspire you to create beautiful content using it.

stupidcar··on The boring technology behind a one-person Internet company (2018)
Totally disagree re. SPA frameworks. Having mastered one of the popular ones, I've found I can now turn out fairly complex apps that I never could have contemplated building solo a few years ago.
stupidcar··on A book from Alan Turing and a mysterious piece of paper
A real shame that Wolfram gives credence to "handwriting analysis" pseudoscience in what is otherwise an interesting piece.

> “The writing style is entirely different. Personality-wise, the writer of sample B has a quicker, more intuitive thinking style than the one of sample A.”

How can anybody of Wolfram's intelligence unquestioningly accept this nonsense?

stupidcar··on A recent paper proposes to bring zeppelins back
According to the article, these new zeppelins would be 1) huge, 2) hydrogen-filled, and 3) uncrewed and automatically piloted.

If there are any Hollywood producers reading this, I suddenly have a great idea for an action film involving maleovelent hackers and a slow moving fleet of explosive destruction.

stupidcar··on [dead]
What the article describes is not a new phenomenon, but just another incarnation of an anthropological pattern wherein behavioural feedback loops act to enforce ever-more rigorous standards of social, cultural or ideological "hygiene". Throughout history people have competed to be the most puritan adherents of their particular sect. As recently as the Victorian age, the middle classes engaged in an internecine competition to adhere to ever more obscure and asburd formal standards and rituals that were justified on the basis of ethics and what was considered "proper" in civilised society.

If the 20th century was characterised by a gradual relaxation, at least in the West, of those socially demanded standards of dress, attitude and behaviour, it's perhaps unsurprisingly that, eventually, the needle would begin to swing the other way. People will, of course, find ways to justify these new standards on the grounds of impartial ethics and rationalism in the same way people in the past justified them on divine action and the gospels.

Such cults of cultural hygiene can be relatively harmless, except to the social standing of those who choose not to participate. However, in the event that true believers gain real power, they can be extremely dangerous to those same persons. History does not instill much confidence that this is something humanity has grown beyond.

stupidcar··on Foods Linked to Better Brainpower
This reads like a BuzzFeed listicle. Vague references to unlinked studies, with no critical analysis. It's about as genuinely empirical as asking the local witchdoctor.

Edit: And it seems they're trying to sell some ebook "nutrition" guide for $20 a copy. This is garbage.

stupidcar··on AMD lands Google, Twitter as customers with newest server chip
I'm curious, since I don't follow hardware that closely: Is the current battle really best framed as a fight between Intel and AMD, or between Intel and TSMC? I.e. is AMD's recent resurgence due to better chip design, or because Intel's fabrication is struggling, whereas TMSC isn't?
stupidcar··on The human body is already close to thermal limits in many regions
Why is less mobility necessarily "going backwards"? We have the technology for large-scale remote working, but companies still require employees to be on-site mostly for historical cultural reasons. If the government brought in regulations requiring companies to provide remote working as a choice, unless there was a good reason to require employees to be on-site, I don't think people would see that as "going backwards", so much as being forced to go forwards.
stupidcar··on Three people play a Tetris-like game using a brain-to-brain interface
The Neuralink presentation a few days ago made the important point that the physics of neurons makes it impossible to read and/or write their state with any kind of accuracy without getting very, very close to them.

As such, these kinds of completely non-invasive methods of interfacing with the brain are a dead end. Barring breakthroughs in scanning technologies that completely upend basic laws of physics, you will always be limited to a low-bandwidth channel that only works by reading the crude, aggregate state of the whole brain or a large area of it, and requires extensive training for participants to learn how to send basic signals.

Since the limits here are hard physical ones, not ones that can be engineered around, there's no way for this to be gradually refined into a more useful system. It will ways be a hack. If we're going to produce high-bandwidth brain-machine / brain-machine-brain interfaces that allow useful collaboration, it's going to require getting inside the skull and getting up close and personal with brain matter, whether we like it or not.

stupidcar··on China's rising tech scene threatens US brain drain as ‘sea turtles’ return home
I'm sure it's a very widespread view, amongst "entrepreneurs" benefitting from a ready mass of overworked and under-compensated workers, and workers one generation past poverty who have been culturally indoctrinated with a belief that accepting extreme workloads is a sign of virtue. That doesn't excuse it being uncritically repeated by others rather than treated as the toxic and exploitative sentiment that it is.
stupidcar··on China's rising tech scene threatens US brain drain as ‘sea turtles’ return home
Except the article doesn't say anything about visas or better salaries back home. Its whole slant is that apparently Chinese graduates are moving away from Silicon Valley because those darn US labor laws mean they can't work nine hours a day, six days a week, for lower wages.

The article is such a pathetically transparent piece of anti-labor rights astro-turfing: China is going to out-compete the US unless US workers can be forced to accept equally shitty working conditions, that I cannot believe Hacker News is taking it seriously.

stupidcar··on EU's GPS satellites have been down for four days in mysterious outage
Given that the project is funded by €10 billion of EU taxes, I hope we'll get transparency sooner rather than later on exactly what's gone wrong, regardless of who it might embarrass.
stupidcar··on Giant batteries and cheap solar power are shoving fossil fuels off the grid
I wonder what the wider economic effect will be if the price of solar continues to improve and the fossil fuel industry can't find a way to remain competitive. Since some places are far more suitable for solar power generation than others, will those areas end up with a significant advantage in the cost of living? Could that in turn lead to a major migration of people and economic activity to those areas?
stupidcar··on Surveillance cameras debunk the bystander effect
Um, what? The article doesn’t do this at all. This is straight from the 2nd paragraph:

“The “bystander effect” holds that the reason people don’t intervene is because we look to one another. The presence of many bystanders diffuses our own sense of personal responsibility, leading people to essentially do nothing and wait for someone else to jump in”

It’s clearly talking about individual behaviour in the presence of a crowd. You basically restated this exact point, then claimed the article didn’t make it!

stupidcar··on Microsoft Attempting to Destroy the Careers of Its Critics
This article veers into conspiracist territory as it goes on, with the idea that Microsoft is engaged in some grand, secret scheme to infiltrate open source and destroy it from the inside.

Microsoft will always have its share of bad actors, make mistakes, and act in unpleasant ways. Any large company or institution will do. The question is whether these occasions represent standard operating procedure or just the statistical expected baseline quantity of misbehaviour.

There's no doubt that, in the past, Microsoft had a culture that allowed and encouraged bad behaviour at an individual, tactical and strategic level. I'm not convinced that is the case anymore. However, the aforementioned baseline misbehaviour means you will always be able to cherry-pick a collection of individuals and incidents to support a pre-ordained narrative of evilness, if that fits your worldview.

← PreviousPage 6 of 26Next →