HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on Sued for copyright infringement for putting legal materials online
The text of the laws themselves are open-source. It's the annotations that are the issue and this is, at least, an area where there is a reasonable ambiguity. Hopefully one that will be resolved in favour of greatest openness, but the state's position is at least not totally unreasonable.

What is unreasonable, and why this is getting attention on HN is because Malamud's actions in publish the annotations has been described as "terrorism". Perhaps this is just one boneheaded lawyer speaking carelessly, but maybe it's a deliberate attempt to conflate political activism, which may often involve breaking the law or defying authority in a harmless way in pursuit of a political goal, with terrorism, which involves breaking the law in a violent or dangerous way for the same ends. It's important that such a distinction is kept, and the state cannot depict any and all political motivated misbehaviour as "terrorism"

stupidcar··on China is blocking all language editions of Wikipedia
> If you're looking for a way to describe how good your government is and you come up with "Think how much worse it could be!" then I think the government has failed in its duty.

Yes, it would have, but many governments, including the UK, can be described in far better terms than this, and my point was that living under such a government can blind you to them.

The UK government does many things that it would not bother to do if it was only concerned with a wealthy elite (note that I said "only", obviously the government does plenty of things that are for a wealthy elite). It funds welfare programmes and state pensions that have no direct benefit to the rich elite. It enforces a minimum wage that have no direct benefit to the rich elite. It enforces worker rights and safety regulations that have no direct benefit to the rich elite. It has a progressive tax regime that has no direct benefit to the rich elite. It allows ordinary citizens a degree of freedom of movement, expression, political affiliation and democratic expression that has no direct benefit to the rich elite.

And yes, it's easy to find examples in all these areas where the implementation falls far short of the theory. But nonetheless there is still a huge difference between both the theory and implementation of government in the UK vs a country like China, North Korea, Iran, etc.

Criticism of every government is useful and important, but criticism should be grounded in reality. In a fair and reasonable assessment of what is done right as well as what is done wrong. Instead, most criticism I see of western governments by their own citizens is incredibly facile; uninformed by fact, and ignorant of both the history and reality of its political institutions, substituting nuance for lazy stereotypes and received opinions about the supposed inherent corruption and incompetence of all politics and politicians.

stupidcar··on China is blocking all language editions of Wikipedia
It's you. This kind of lazy pessimism strikes me as a peculiar privilege of people who've grown up accustomed to living under a government that, while unavoidably imperfect, does in fact give consideration to the rights and desires of ordinary citizens. They don't take notice of all the ways their government chooses not to oppress them, because they wrongly imagine this is some natural state of things.

On the other hand, immigrants I've spoken to from countries with autocratic regimes, while not starry eyed about the nature of western governments, have no problem explaining why the situation in their countries of origin is much, much worse, and why the government of their new country is much fairer and functional.

stupidcar··on Windows gets a new terminal
So your contention is that Microsoft decided to deliberately annoy its customers, and presumably many of its own employees, by forcing updates for no good reason?

Sorry, but I don't buy that. If Microsoft did this, I think it was for a reason. It's very easy to sit on HN and opine about how Apple can persuade iPhone users to upgrade. But we're not the ones at Microsoft with the job of dealing with the reality of millions upon millions of desktop computers that simply aren't ever being patched, no matter how hard we prod our users, with the result that they are being exploited en masse, used for criminal purposes, and as a result our reputation is getting trashed and governments and other powerful actors are demanding we do something to fix this problem.

stupidcar··on Notre Dame Re-Imagined with Glass Roof
It's intended as marketing, not a serious proposal. It's like how graphic designers publish unsolicited redesigns of Facebook in their portfolio. It's not because they expect Facebook to use them, but because they're a good way of getting attention.

The agency in question here isn't even an architecture firm, it's just a company that produces renderings of the kind you see in marketing collateral when buying off-plan properties. Someone there realised this Notre Dame business was a good opportunity to get some publicity by publishing a deliberately radical idea, and it seems to have worked.

stupidcar··on Twisted graphene has become the big thing in physics
> The only real barrier is cost.

I feel like this could almost be a slogan for the human race at this point. Our grasp of science and engineering has reached a level where's there's very few things we might want to build where we couldn't conceivably do it. We could build the most outlandish megastructures, infrastructure and space bases if we really had to, but it all just costs too much.

stupidcar··on Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance
It seems to me that the range of human error is rarely smaller than that of malice, so again I'm not sure there will be much apparent difference between an exhaustive verification of either sort.
stupidcar··on Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance
Yes, of course trust is a spectrum, and socially important, etc. But none of that answers my question: In the case of "trust but verify", how does this trust manifest in a provable way?

Consider it like this: For me, trust is feelings/thoughts. I might trust you a little, a lot, etc. But for you, my trust can only be demonstrated by my actions, because you can't peer inside my head and tell whether I'm genuinely trust you, or I'm only claiming to.

"Trust but verify" recommends adopting a mindset of trust but a pattern of behaviour externally indistinguishable from distrust. If I'm verifying everything you do, that does't signal trust, whatever the reasons I might give for it.

stupidcar··on Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance
You've just restated the original post and ignored my question. Again: how does this definition of supposed trust differ from distrust in any verifiable way?
stupidcar··on Microsoft, currently the most valuable company, is having a Nadellaissance
How is verifying everything because you don't trust people not to make a mistake operationally different from verifying everything because you suspect bad faith? To the supposed trusted party, the result is the same: you not taking them at their word and instead checking whatever they do. Even if you're being honest about only verifying to avoid mistakes, you can never prove it.

This definition of "trust but verify" would be better reduced to "verify", since it essentially claims that trust is, if not impossible, not practically applicable in any situation.

stupidcar··on Why We Think Galaxy Folds Are Failing
I'm more interested in how Samsung ever got so far down the road with a such an apparently flawed design. Samsung's engineers must have known it had big problems. Was this a classic case of dysfunctional corporate culture meaning nobody wanted to give the bosses bad news? I'm guessing so.
stupidcar··on Svelte 3: Rethinking Reactivity
Odd that they don't mention Angular amongst the component-based frameworks, as what they're describing sounds very similar to Angular's compiler and change-detection system.
stupidcar··on Half of England Is Owned by Less Than 1% of Its Population, Researcher Says
No, because the rich in this case didn't buy the assets, they inherited them from people who were gifted them for being lieutenants in an invading army 1000 years ago. England is still an occupied country, and the only solution is to revolt against the occupiers.
stupidcar··on 26 States Now Ban or Restrict Community Broadband
The argument is that government, at any level, shouldn't be competing with the private sector. It should regulate the market, but shouldn't participate in it, because, on a practical level, it's often not too good at it, but also because it can create perverse incentives. For example, say municipal broadband became ubiquitous and popular enough that the income from it is now an important source of revenue for the authorities in these towns. Then they are incentivised to make things difficult for any commercial rival, even if the commercial offering is cheaper and better. Given how dysfunctional and kleptocratic municipal politics tends to be, almost everywhere, it's hard to say such concerns aren't entirely unfounded.

Of course, there are plenty of decent counter-arguments, and counter-counter-arguments. This is just one of those tensions that exists and is fundamentally irresolvable in any capitalist democracy.

stupidcar··on Why I Switched from Visual Studio Code to JetBrains WebStorm
Maybe the fact that they don't install such extensions indicates that they don't actually need them? I switched from IntelliJ to VSCode precisely because it was too slow and cluttered due to the sheer amount of extra features it provided, most of which I never used.

Even if all those extra features are useful, I'm still willing to compromise the core experience of editing and navigating code, as that's always what I'm going to be spending the majority of my time doing. I need that to be fast, easy and reliable, which is not what I have found to be the cast in IDEs, vs editors.

stupidcar··on Julian Assange arrested in London
It says it applies to the generic repatriation of refugees, not the specific repatriation of a political asylum seeker like Assange. There's also no evidence that Assange faces political persecution in the UK. His stated concern is about extradition to the USA, in which case he should apply for political asylum in the UK.
stupidcar··on Battery Reality: There’s Nothing Better Than Lithium-Ion Coming Soon
I think maybe you missed the point of the article, which is the scientific breakthroughs alone aren't enough. Even if you create a battery technology that is, on paper, cheaper and better performing than li-ion, the advantages inferred by incumbency mean the odds are stacked against the newcomer.

I do think li-ion will be disrupted eventually, but it will be more like the process of solid-state drives replacing hard-disk drives. Only a combination of diminishing returns on incremental improvement of li-ion tech, and a competitor technology that is fundamentally superior, battle-tested in high-performance niche applications, and mostly a drop-in replacement, will create the conditions necessary for an industry switch. And even then the process will likely take many years to complete.

stupidcar··on Who has the fastest website in F1?
These kind of websites are just a brand box-ticking exercise. They're farmed off to a low-bidding contractor or agency who have no incentive to care about performance. So long as the site runs fast on the client's iMacs using office wifi that's good enough.
stupidcar··on The key to building an idea seems to be blind faith
If Google's founders had done this, they would never have started the business, as at the time search was considered a poor market, already carved up between a few dominant players, and with no effective means of monetisation.
stupidcar··on Observables, Side-Effects, and Subscriptions: Some Reactive Best Practices
It's ironic that the author's recommendation of using `shareReplay(1)` actually leaks a subscription as well. Unless the operator is a supplied with `{ refCount: true }` config parameter, it does not unsubscribe from the source observable, even when all its subscribers unsubscribe: https://github.com/ReactiveX/rxjs/blob/master/src/internal/o...

Sadly, issues like this seem to crop up all the time when using reactive programming. I'm not as anti-reactive as most other commenters here seem to be, but there's no doubt that certain areas, particularly memory safety, sharing and buffering, seem hard to understand and get right.

stupidcar··on Why Is It So Hard to Build Profitable Robot Companies?
I think in the end, like most industries, robotics will end up being dominated by a handful of big firms. Each will have a mature hardware/software platform that is theoretically capable of building any a robot in any configuration you can imagine, but in practice the industry will settle on a handful of units with sizes and shapes that have proven themselves well suited to general purpose operation in a wide field of tasks. Most clients will standardise on a single vendor, and a particular unit and software pack, with limited customisation, and only Governments and very large companies will pay for completely bespoke robots.

Innovation and investment will shift away from companies trying to build a whole robot of their own to innovating on a single component type that fits within one or more of the large vendors supply chains, or plugging into standard units at the hardware and/or software level.

stupidcar··on Experimental rejection of observer-independence in the quantum world
I don't understand this metaphor. It sounds like if the river represents the events that will happen to us throughout our lives, then our free will is how we navigate through it. So does God know that ahead of time? Can He see me approaching a rock and know I will go around it on the left or right? Does He know I'll get smashed on it? If he doesn't, then that means there is a limit to His omniscience. If He does, then my "free" choices are predestined.

Furthermore, in this metaphor God doesn't just see the river, He created the river, and all the people on it. He laid out its twists and obstacles, with a perfect understanding of how it would affect the humans afloat on it. Moreover, at the moment of creation, He had an unbounded freedom to create the river in any other way He saw fit. If I get smashed on a rock half way down, it's because He chose to create the river in such a way that I would get smashed on it. If He didn't know this, or didn't have a choice, then He is either not all knowing, or not all powerful.

This, for me is the fundamental problem with any theist philosophy that holds that God is both omniscient and the prime mover of creation, but still suggests concepts like free will and morality have any meaning. Not only are "our" decisions predestined, they're a direct result of another being's free will, and the concept of us then being judged on them by that same being is farcical. It's like a puppeteer putting one their puppets on trial.

stupidcar··on Tapering of SSRI treatment to mitigate withdrawal symptoms
I discovered this when coming off Citalopram. The waking nausea and discomfort were unpleasant, but the worst part was undoubtedly the lucid, extraordinarily intense and violent nightmares that would begin the moment I fell asleep and continue, for hours at a time, for the entirety of my sleep.

After trying to quit cold turkey a couple of times, I researched about tapering strategies online, bought some pill cutters and started a very gradual dose reduction. So long as I only halved the dose every 2-3 days, I was fine. But I had to go down to a minuscule fragment of a pill before I could quit completely. Until that point, missing one of the reduced doses would still induce withdrawal symptoms just as intense as the full one had.

stupidcar··on Google siding with Saudi Arabia, refuses to remove government app tracking women
"Slippery slope fallacy" defined. Simply agreeing to outlaw some things — child pornography, incitement to murder, violation of human rights — doesn't set you on an irreversible course to outlawing everything. Partial regulation by community consensus is a fundamental tenet of all human civilisation.
stupidcar··on Apple's move to ARM-based Macs creates uncertainty
I don't think it's negotiating tactic, or any complex strategy. I just think Apple look at the MacBook and Air and see them as mobile devices far closer in market fit to the iPhone/iPad than the MacBook Pro. And given that they're already manufacturing their own chips with the power/perf profile as needed for mobile devices, why not use them?
stupidcar··on CSS Grid the Right Way
Recently I've been using CSS Grid to layout quite a complex component, where the number of rows and columns needs to by dynamic based on the component's input data.

I've consistently been surprised by the fact that, everytime I hit a requirement that I think is going to be be impossible or require a hack, I find that it's a use-case that's been considered and catered for by the spec.

If flex was the first CSS layout that didn't feel like it was actively hostile to the functional needs of building UI, then grid is the first one that feels like it genuinely considers both functional needs and the needs of writing elegant and maintainable cdoe . I agree with the article that it requires quite a bit of learning to absorb all the new terminology and concepts, the payoff is more than worth it.

stupidcar··on Mars One, which offered 1-way trips to Mars, declared bankrupt
Yep, and as often happens when a scam involves science or tech, many journalists helped out by promoting their ridiculous claims without due challenge or skepticism.
stupidcar··on Google Docs gets an API for task automation
Can you be more specific about what's missing that will be a disaster?
stupidcar··on No Thank You, Mr. Pecker
The problem I have with most super rich people is that they consider genuine risk far less important than potential embarrassment. E.g. they won't dare taking a stand politically because of the chance that someone will go public with some scandalous nonsense. Bezos on the other hand seems willing to calculate differently. I have to say, this has changed my opinion of him a lot in his favour. On the very remote chance you're reading this Jeff, good on you!
stupidcar··on Chrome Never-Slow Mode Prototype
Firstly: Too bad. The dysfunctional practices of corporate software development doesn't override people's right not to have their own computer's performance trashed by shitty websites. It's their right to run whatever browser they like, including one that doesn't allow slow, bloated and poorly engineered software to run, no matter how hard it makes life for the marketing departments of the world.

Secondly: For decades computers operated with extreme limits on their available memory and their processing capacity, relative to today's computers. Despite this, people managed to write software, even including companies with marketing departments and idiot VPs. It might take these people a while to accept that they can no insist on pushing whatever garbage they want, because the cost is borne entirely by the end user, but eventually they will. Or they won't, and these dysfunctional companies will die out. Either way, users win.

← PreviousPage 8 of 26Next →