HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sturgill

893 karma · joined December 31, 2012

chris at the domain thesturgills.com
submissionscomments
sturgill··on Cryptocurrency investor robbed via his cellphone account sues AT&T for $224M
I prefer both options: opt-in by obscurity.
sturgill··on Changes in midlife death rates across racial and ethnic groups in the US
One of my favorite lines of the Bible are these simple words from Jesus Himself: "They that are whole need not a physician; but they that are sick." It turns out that most of us are more like the Pharisees that Jesus railed against: convinced of our own moral superiority. I think that's a natural instinct of human nature (independent of one's professed religious beliefs).
sturgill··on Changes in midlife death rates across racial and ethnic groups in the US
My issues weren't with drugs or alcohol (there are plenty of other things to get addicted to in this life). Nor am I judging myself harshly. I'm a data guy and love that math doesn't have feelings. When you are adequately educated of the consequences and jump in anyway there is a manifest fault in judgment. Mercifully I've been able to recover, but life would have been a lot easier had I made different choices when I was quite young rather than clean up messes when I was much older.
sturgill··on Changes in midlife death rates across racial and ethnic groups in the US
Even that I'm on the fence about. It can be perfectly appropriate to punish people for making poor choices while at the same time helping them overcome some of the natural consequences of those choices.

I don't know where I stand on the issue of incarcerating people for drug use. But on its face I am not opposed to putting people in jail for selling highly addictive substances to young kids. This is one issue I have with the pro-legalization theory. Alcohol absolutely destroys lives (my grandmother drank herself to death when my mom was 13 in order to have some mental escape from the physical abuse of my alcoholic grandfather). Prohibition didn't seem to work very well, but general acceptance also seems to be failing.

It's a complicated issue, and I don't know where I stand on every aspect of it. But on its face I don't think punishment and help are mutually exclusive. And the fear of punishment _can_ be an effective deterrent. (Education being, in my opinion, the best deterrent. I've never had a drop of alcohol both because of my religious beliefs and the growing understanding that I'm very likely a drunk trapped in a sober body.)

sturgill··on Changes in midlife death rates across racial and ethnic groups in the US
Addiction is a disease. And I also think it can be a moral failing to play around with addictive substances. I say this as one who has a long family history of addiction and who has struggled with his own addictions: I was wrong to get involved with certain things.

When I reached out to my parents my (normally quiet and ultra-supportive) mom’s first words were, “I thought you were smarter than that.” And her next sentence was, “How can we help you?”

Once someone is trapped preaching ceases to be helpful. But preaching the morality of good decision making to avoid the pitfalls of vice can help prevent people from entering the funnel.

My view is unlikely to be popular on this board, but I think your point is a classic example of the either-or fallacy.

“Playing around with biohazards is bad. Oh, the bottle broke and you’re sick? Well... let’s get you to the hospital.”

“Drugs and alcohol have the potential to absolutely destroy your life and the lives of people you love. You’re an alcoholic? Let’s get you the help you need.”

sturgill··on Very few owners of Alexa-powered devices use them for shopping
With three kids, a two story house plus basement? Yes.

And I imagine you probably carry a listening device with built-in locator that surveillance states can use to track your every move any way. All for the convenience of being able to make phone calls (or, more ironically, check Facebook).

At this point in the game, privacy is an illusion. So I might as well enjoy telling Alexa to “turn off the basement lights” on my way to bed every night.

sturgill··on Very few owners of Alexa-powered devices use them for shopping
First world problems, but “Alexa, broadcast ‘dinner is ready’” is just amazing. Or, “Alexa, drop in on [child’s] room” to remind them about X.

Also timers, light switches, and playing music to the surround sound from a Bluetooth connection to the receiver...

We didn’t own one when we lived in Brooklyn, but they are all over my house in the suburbs. I don’t apologize for my love fest. But I won’t use it to order anything. Add something to lists? Definitely. Make a purchase decision? Ha!

sturgill··on The Allure of Small Towns for Big City Freelancers
There isn't an easy or quick fix for it. Though there are small towns in America that are predominantly Muslim (lots of refugees relocated to specific locations). But this is completely reasonable: if I were an ex-pat living abroad, it would also be hard to raise my children in an area where they would be the only white Christians. That is a real trade off that is hard to account for outside of certain pockets within the US.

I think Anti-Semitism is fairly rare (though it does exist). But it would be hard being one of the five Jewish families in my entire high school. I was good friends with them, and Christmas was a hard time for them. It would be very challenging to be a Muslim in good parts of America (outside of major cities; where, if we're being honest, it still isn't easy being Muslim).

sturgill··on The Allure of Small Towns for Big City Freelancers
There are certainly more opportunities in cities to be part of a wider expanse of recreational activities / groups. There are "more things to do." We never repeated weekend family activities in NYC (outside of things in our neighborhood).

I'm still unconvinced that cities tolerate "weirdness" better than small communities. I'm a religious conservative who works in the tech scene. People were "superficial[ly] polite" (for the most part), but it was obvious my "mere existence [made] people uncomfortable and [my] hobbies or views or whatever '[weren't] right.'"

I didn't move away from Brooklyn because of that, but it was a very real thing. I was fortunate enough that when I moved to the city I was already pretty successful in my career. I didn't have to kowtow or apologize for who I was because I didn't really have to care what people thought of me personally. But my kids definitely caught flak for it (even from the parents of their friends -- it was strange seeing a 40 y/o father debate the existence of God with my then 10 y/o daughter who finally, in exasperation said, "Listen, I'm just religious, okay?").

But I completely agree with tech meetings, veganism (though it's growing in popularity even in smaller towns), frisbee, etc. That is a definite trade-off. I used to grab lunch with players from pretty much any and every company. This week I'll grab lunch with a guy from Shipt, and... that pretty much sums up Birmingham.

The trade offs are very real. I happen to be at a point in life where my community consists largely of my wife and kids. Once the kids are gone (or once they bore of me), I'll probably reinsert myself into other social groups. But right now, I don't want to spend Saturdays playing frisbee with other adults. I want to spend it hiking with my kids.

Those things are possible in the city. But as a family we prefer the trade offs of living in the county. I think the secret is that you don't have to have the same preferences that I do. And if you find the city more embracing of your goals, appetites, life style, or whatever then that's great. But every time I sit in my car all by myself in near silence, I breath a long sigh of relief.

sturgill··on The Allure of Small Towns for Big City Freelancers
I was off the F-line at 15 St PPW. The commute into Manhattan was not usually too bad. The commute home was terrible (my stop was 23rd St and the trains were usually quite full by the time they got to me).

Life is about trade offs. We did our best to make Brooklyn home for our family and didn’t expect to leave. There were some incredible highs. There were also some very challenging lows.

We spent a lot of time in Prospect Park and were very blessed to live within walking distance. I would frequently meet the family in the park for picnic dinners on the way home from work (in the spring / summer). But as a counter example, I now live 5 miles from a massive state park. Yesterday we spent the morning swimming in the lake and the evening hiking to a waterfall (where we then climbed down the rock wall for a dip). It’s a very paddle friendly park as well and we plan on buying kayaks and paddle boards for next season (we only just moved here in February).

The best part of all of that is that it was just a normal Saturday. No pre-planning required. When we got home and realized my son had left his life jacket at the lake, I made dinner while my wife circled back for it (okay, I ordered pizza from my phone...).

I will say, we miss Seamless. Like a lot.

I’m on the fence about cities being more inclusive than towns. As a family we’re very active in church and community service so YMMV, but I find no shortage of opportunities to work, play, worship, and serve with people of varying backgrounds. There are certainly fewer types of communities (Jews and Muslims are underrepresented in the south). But I’m not completely sold that’s the same as inclusivity. My experience in the city was that bias exists in humanity no matter how many people you cram into a square mile. It can take different forms in the city, but it certainly isn’t absent.

sturgill··on The Allure of Small Towns for Big City Freelancers
I was in Brooklyn for 2.5 years living in South Slope just off of Prospect Park. Now I’m in a suburb of Birmingham, AL. I basically live in a forest. Have a 5 bedroom / 6 bathroom home that is significantly cheaper than my 3 bedroom / 1 bathroom apartment. Raising three kids, I am just so incredibly happy with life out here. My commute is a 10 min drive through beautiful woodlands in a comfortable car. Any time I get slightly annoyed by traffic, I remember jamming myself in a crowded subway where I’d be lodged between sweaty body parts of strangers for 45 min and I just grin.

Public transportation is great, except for rush hours. And the nights and weekends scheduling.

Don’t get me wrong: we loved our time in NY (and, like most people in NY we also hated it; it was a bipolar relationship). And my career might takes us back that way. But I hope not. It’s not really built for single income families raising multiple children.

I’m perfectly happy if you’re happy with the city trade offs. Because they are just trade offs. But I prefer the trade offs of living in unincorporated county outside a small city.

sturgill··on Why it’s so hard to fix banking: An interview with Simple’s exiting CEO
Another shout out to Ally. Not affiliated with them; have just used them for many, many years. They reimburse ATM fees (used to be unlimited; now capped per month); no minimum balances; and have interest checking.

The only times I get frustrated are when you need a lot of cash (think buying stuff from Craigslist). Incoming wires are free; outgoing wires are reasonably priced (and is how I submitted funds to the attorney in a different state to close on our house).

The few times I’ve had to contact customer support my wait time was in the single digit minutes.

Many other things I could add, but I already sound like a shill. Schwab is also great for ETFs. No experience with their other banking products.

sturgill··on Subscription Hell
I’d disagree in that you can buy an MP3 and listen forever using whatever device. But Spotify isn’t required to sell you MP3s (or guarantee perpetual playback). And, it turns out, that people (in aggregate) really like the Spotify model. One fixed cost to consume all the music you want vs buying entire albums to listen to the 2-3 songs that were decent.

There are still two markets in music. That’s not the case with most online services, but I’m comfortable with that.

sturgill··on Subscription Hell
For me, those two points are inseparable. But I’ve also spent the last several years of my career focusing on maximizing profits within consumer subscribeables...

There are only so many ways to make money: ads, once off charges, term payments, and recurring charges. A consumer license to use vs physical ownership is incredibly interesting. Buying a Mario Brothers cartridge for the original Nintendo vs games delivered online. You could see a compelling case for the Nintendo Switch to offer a subscription service giving access to X games every month.

I don’t find either right or wrong. They just “are” so to speak.

sturgill··on Subscription Hell
“You’ve found market price when buyers complain but still pay.”

Subscription revenue is great business. And the optimization of price to maximize profits is a set of fun math problems.

It sounds to me like the author doesn’t love how much he spends on things but isn’t willing to do without. Also known as optimal pricing...

sturgill··on StreetLend.com shuts down, citing GDPR regulations
If you're a big multinational, these uncertainties are a cost of doing business. You have a dedicated team of in-house attorneys and many other high priced lawyers on retainer. If the worst happens, you start private negotiations on settlements. When I worked for a firm owned by a very large multinational, our parent company basically had an IRS auditor with a dedicated office inside of the parent's headquarters. But you can absorb that cost across multiple entities.

Within society "in general" there are usually other forms for quantifying, and spreading, the cost of uncertainty among larger groups. We usually call those markets "insurance." Car insurance, life insurance, health insurance, disability insurance, homeowners insurance, landlord insurance... all of it exists to "cope" with uncertainty.

If you're running a small operation that's hovering at or below breakeven, it's reasonable to look at the existing uncertainty surrounding GDPR and find that the only winning move is to not play.

I'm not a FUD guy; I'm a numbers guy. Uncertainty is real and entire markets exist to deal with them. Where there are _not_ markets that allow you to quantify uncertainty, it is reasonable to look at the potential downside and say, "that's not worth the risk."

I'd be very hard pressed to run a business that catered to the EU at this point until the first N lawsuits happen. There's a reason why in the US people prefer to incorporate in Delaware: it's not because it's the most business friendly state, it's because there is so little uncertainty in case law.

I am making no claims as to whether GDPR is a good thing or a bad thing. Simply that it's an unknown thing. And unless you have the pockets to play in unchartered legal territory, it is perfectly reasonable to shake one's head and walk away.

sturgill··on StreetLend.com shuts down, citing GDPR regulations
"...then you are likely covered." "it's looking unlikely..." "...run this site from a limited company..."

I can understand why a small project that isn't immediately profitable can take a look at the uncertainty and say, "no thanks."

sturgill··on StreetLend.com shuts down, citing GDPR regulations
Also their marginal cost of delivery approaches zero. High fixed costs in creating the software and almost negligible marginal costs. The return on capital can be astronomical.

Online services have “real consequences.” But not of the type as goods in the physical world. PCI and HIPAA have tried to mitigate against some of the most egregious crossovers of failed software. GDPR scares me. Not in the “I don’t like the consequences” but in the “I don’t know what this does and how screwed I might be.” I’m very happy to be on the other side of the pond where I can safely observe the fallout. Feels like buying a first generation Apple device: I’ll wait a few years and let the early adopters go through the pain for me...

sturgill··on Wells Fargo Hit with $1B in Fines
I manage most of this with Ally.com. Each bill has its own savings account (most with automatic payment set up on the account side). My direct deposit is automatically transferred on a recurring basis into that pay period’s portion of each bill.

You can open multiple checking accounts (and we have multiples for those services that don’t draft from savings accounts), but we only have one debit card. All weekly expenses come from that account (which is funded every week by auto transfers).

We aren’t the type that care about “entertainment” vs “food.” Some weeks we eat out more; other weeks we play. If there’s cash in the spend account, buy what you want.

Savings and investments are automatically transferred as well. When we have a specific thing to save for, we open a new savings account and modify the transfer rules.

Not perfect, but works very well for us.

sturgill··on The Illusion of a Profitable Amazon Prime Now and Prime Fresh
I just relocated to Alabama from NYC and one of the only things I miss is Prime Now. I’m happy to pay a small premium to get something “now” without having to leave the house. Cables / electronics / “just thinking of you” presents for my wife / “crap, we’re out of X and the kids are actually playing happily...”.

I would frequently get heads down on a project, realize I needed widget X, would order on Prime Now, continue my work, and have the widget when I needed it.

As soon as it’s introduced to Birmingham my suburban life will be complete...

sturgill··on Analytics data integrity is tough
I’d recommend the event producer send a UUID that is then the primary key on the events table. The producer should also send the timestamp the event occurred.

I could be missing something, but that seems to solve both the duplicate event firing (an upsert command based on the UUID makes duplicate event writing a non-issue) and the timing issues.

Though I’m still incredibly skeptical of “real-time analytics.” The number of business cases that require actual real-time analysis are pretty limited. High frequency trading and...?

sturgill··on Like Peter Thiel, Tech Workers Feel Alienated by Silicon Valley ‘Echo Chamber’
And when did Brendan Eich make public comments? When he privately donated to a cause?

You can be dismissed from leading a company today by privately supporting conservative causes. And there’s very little threat of a liberal CEO being dismissed independent of his private/public statements.

I have no desire to speak to any particular political subject in this forum; but it’s incredibly disingenuous to pretend this only happens to people who take public conservative positions.

Though even the charitable reading of your statement suggests that you believe that conservatives should stay in the closest. Which is a fascinating turn to say the least...

And, as a religious conservative guy in tech I’ll add my point of view: it’s okay to talk politics at work as long as you agree with everyone else. Those of us with dissenting world paradigms spend most of the day quietly wishing these conversations would end. Because there isn’t debate to be had at work; dissenting views are not welcome.

sturgill··on The Empathy Gap in Tech: Interview with a Software Engineer
This exists in all human interactions. A simple example, take this political posturing: "This bill is too complicated; we haven't had time to read it. This is too important to be rushed."

Reference to health care or tax reform?

It's hard not to conclude that everyone is a hypocrite.

sturgill··on XPS 13 developer edition 7th generation available
I can personally speak to the fact that Barton means what he says. When Sputnik first came out in Beta, I bought a developer edition that had some keyboard issues. I dropped a casual note on Twitter and Barton went out of his way to make sure the issue got resolved.

I keep contemplating a full transition to Ubuntu as my work machine, but there are still certain environment impacts (like connected devices and the need to run some Mac-only software on occasion) that has prevented it.

But if I could convince myself to take the dive and go Linux-only, I wouldn't hesitate to run with the XPS line.

Disclaimer: Absolutely none other than Barton is a great guy who helped a random stranger that once complained on Twitter.

sturgill··on Discretion still matters – don’t hurt your career by sharing too much
Having a trusted group of advisors is strongly recommended. Confusing everyone in your office as your professional advisor is ill advised.

Find people that have had success in fields that interest you and cultivate relationships with them. And explicitly ask, "Would you be willing to be one of my professional advisors?" You'll want 3-5 of these.

From time-to-time, grab lunch or coffee. And ask the advantages of an MBA or whatever certification. Ask "does job X seem like a good next move for me given my career goals?" Then pick up the tab.

But never, ever confuse lunch at your company's cafeteria as the time or place to raise professional doubts. Absolute confidence at work; and raise your personal insecurities in private with people you can trust and that are expecting that kind of conversation.

Here's my current advisor group:

My mom and dad. I'm mid-30's with three kids of my own. My own parents are a great sounding board for "how is my work/life balance? Am I focused too much on cash at the expense of time with my kids? Will another relocation be too much to ask of my children?" They don't know much about what I do and can't help me build business models, but they raised 5 kids and can effectively call out my B.S.

The dean when I got an MBA. We did a lot of work together while I was at school. He's an incredibly connected individual and is someone I trust to guide me with business ethics. In a failed startup I had some private issues. I met the dean for coffee and he gave me some of the best advice I've ever received: "keep your chin up, your mouth shut, and your integrity intact." Basically "That sucks, move on." He's a "big picture" / "career arc" kind of guy who could help me get a conversation with just about anyone I want. And he's a wonderful person I consider a good friend.

A previous co-worker who is a marketing executive. We hit it off at work. I'm passionate about quantitative marketing. He was more brand oriented. Enough overlap where we had shared interests; different enough we weren't direct competitors at the office. He's been around and knows the pitfalls of business. Sample advice: "ignore all 'Growth hacker' job listings. They're brutal jobs and the first to get axed when numbers are missed. You'll be held accountable for the things you are least likely to be able to control."

None of these conversations happen casually. They are planned discussions with people I have a close relationship. And none of them work in my org (I asked my old coworker to be an advisor _after_ he left).

Be purposeful in what you say to whom.

sturgill··on Busting myths about BigQuery
Most of our use case is storing raw event data: user clicked on X; interacted with feature Y; was bucketed into test group Z; audit logs for subscription data points (joined, upgraded, downgraded, paid, payment denied, etc). Basically everything we care about, but that doesn't matter as a core concern of providing the service.

The main app needs to know if a user has access to entitlement A, but the history of that process is outside the concern of the app itself.

We throw everything into BQ/Redshift. Then when we find a need for it, we bring it into a separate reporting dataset in Redshift via ETL.

The nice part about this is you can join your sanitized ETL data against raw event data if you need to run a once off query like "for everyone put into variant A of experiment B, how many converted from a free trial to a paid subscription?" I haven't found a great way to programmatically recreate ETL data into BQ without recreating a new dataset every day (because of the history of immutable data). It's not that it's impossible, it's just not as great (imho) as an upsert type workflow.

Occasionally we'll have a once off query we access by hand, but that's relatively rare at this point. Jobs run around 1am and everything is ready to go when the team gets in in the morning.

You have the odd job where you have to manage distkeys, and that's rarely fun, but it's a trade off we're comfortable making.

And, while I'm pimping other people's services, Redshift + Looker is incredible.

sturgill··on Busting myths about BigQuery
Redundancy across providers. BigQuery storage costs very little. It was implemented first and we introduced Redshift later to deal with data issues we didn't want to handle long-term in ETL. It didn't make sense to kill off the bigquery integration and I've decided for $20/mo or so that the backup storage on a separate provider is worth it.

Redshift and BigQuery are both solid services. And BigQuery has gotten better with time. But I still have some reservations with it as a pure Redshift replacement.

sturgill··on Busting myths about BigQuery
We dual write event data to BigQuery and Redshift. BigQuery is incredibly cheap at the storage level, but can be pricey to run queries against large datasets. Personally I am not a fan of paying per-query.

Historically BigQuery data was immutable. You could delete a table, but you couldn't modify or delete a single row. That support was added recently, but there are daily limits imposed on those actions.

I'm a big fan of immutable data, up until you find that someone made a mistake somewhere. Naturally you can make modifications in ETL, but if you do that long enough your ETL job is a mess of time-based if statements.

We originally moved to also support Redshift because of BigQuery not supporting row level updates at that time. Someone on the content site would forget to put an & between URL params and our source data would be busted. Like I said, immutable data is great as long as you never make mistakes...

I'm also not a huge fan of nested records. If you use BigQuery, do yourself a favor and make sure you have a uuid field (it's a good practice any way). When you get data back from the client it can be a pain to piece records back together (nested records come back as single rows for the most part). This makes certain queries really fast, but it can be a pain to work with in aggregate.

My preferred setup these days is to dual write to Redshift and BigQuery. We run almost all analysis off of Redshift, but have a natural backup of data stored elsewhere. And like I said, BigQuery storage rates are dirt cheap. And if our Redshift cluster goes down for any reason, we can hop over to BigQuery to find what we need (and backfill any missing data points).

sturgill··on Ask HN: In your company, how important is code quality vs. getting things done
What's wrong with waterfall? I've got a buddy who works at Lockheed on the f22 and a brother who's a pilot in the Air Force. I prefer certain systems be completely spec'd out before a single line of code is written.

Moving fast and breaking things isn't the only way to write code.

sturgill··on Ask HN: In your company, how important is code quality vs. getting things done
The great part about this process is that, in my opinion, it highlights the importance of pragmatism. Google, as multi-billion dollar ad company, is understandably (and I would say, correctly) risk adverse when it comes to changes to its bread and butter.

But if a new startup tries to replicate a process whose aim is to produce code that "[runs for] years without need for massive intervention" before they've established product/market fit, they will run out of cash.

Google has very specific needs. Code quality requirements for banking software is different than a CRUD app.

IMHO, the best path is to be honest with where you are as a company. Some times you need to just see what works, and multiple cheap iterations that you have no plan to support in the future can be critical to success. Other times you're making billions of dollars and the most important thing is to not screw up. With every variation in between.

So at my company: our subscription and payment handling is designed to run for years. Not screwing up is the most important. Certain product features are pushed as quickly to market as we can, with an eye towards future stability. "Good enough" being good enough.

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →