HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

syats

317 karma · joined October 12, 2013

submissionscomments
syats··on The secret Thinkpad powerbutton code to bring dead laptops back to life (2007)
Also works on ideapad, in case anyone is wondering
syats··on Scala projects are difficult to maintain
I have only marginal experience with both but.. isn't this the case also with java nowadays?
syats··on Rent controls have split housing in Berlin into two distinct markets
Let us recall that that inflation in Germany is close to 0. Thus, saying that policy X is responsible for a price hike is hilarious. There is no reason to raise the prices of unregulated apartments (second plot), except the greed of those owning the units.

Another way to read this article is "this rent control is bad because we real-state speculators are now focusing our greed on a smaller number of people, instead of focusing it on everyone else".

That being said, it is not clear from the plots that the overall amount of money that is being spent, city-wide, on housing has increased or decreased. I would argue this is the only valid metric to asses how effective this particular policy is.

syats··on Ask HN: Why are e-ink note-taking devices so expensive compared to iPads?
Out of the box, the SaaS thingy is not really needed, you can just signup and use the device without ever logging in or downloading their mobile app. They're just kind enough to keep all your notes for you and thus, by default, need a bunch of battery power for the sync process.
syats··on Solid Project: All of your data, under your control
Linked Data does have a concrete definition: RDF data that is accessible through SPARQL, with well defined semantics. That is, following a published ontology and re-using existing vocabularies as much as possible.

Linked Data itself is not novel: https://www.w3.org/standards/semanticweb/data

syats··on Show HN: CVservant: CV Creator for Academic Types
All that happened was a "Sorry, there was a problem typesetting your CV." without any latex output. If I change to a different template, or remove my publication list, all works as expected.

(Thanks!)

syats··on A Review of the Semantic Web Field
I agree with this. It is common to hear "Partial SPARQL 1.1 support"... or "Partial OWL compatibility" or "A variant of SKOS is supported". While it is true that full ECMA6/HTTP2/IPv6/SQL is also rarely provided by implementations, this doesn't hinder their use in productive environments. I think it is rare to reach the parts of ECMAscript that aren't implemented, or the corners of SQL that Postgres/MariaDB don't support. In many of the "Semantic Web Stack", however, one quickly reaches a "not implemented" portion of the 500 page owl standard.
syats··on Show HN: CVservant: CV Creator for Academic Types
I like the idea of generating several CVs, the minimalist style very much, and also the the no-email-required policy (but see below). Here are some points I see for improvement:

* There is no way to set the order in which publications appear in the CV, default ordering is a bit weird, so this must be customizable.

* Latex error messages could maybe be helpful when something goes wrong.. maybe it's some special character I input?

* It's nice that it's not tied to an email, but I am a bit reluctant to give money to a place where I could loose access any time. If something goes wrong on your side and you loose my credentials, how will I be able to re-identify? Also, how does this go with GDPR?

* Also in this vain.. are answers to secret questions hashed and salted? if they are, maybe this should be stated as the minimalist retro style suggests they are stored plain text.

* There are some standards out there that could make your life easier, and also help users interoperate better. I am not an expert, but there is the european CV xml schema[0], as well as the skills and occupations thesaurus[1]. Also, linkedin and such service GDPR::have to offer some export functionality.. it would be nice to be able to import these.

* Several national funding agencies have their own lousy CV creation tools, maybe it could be a businesses model to approach them and re-do it for them. Of course, they are interested in other things (e.g. application tracking, scienciometrics, etc), so just thinking out loud here.

* There are tools out there that keep track of your publications, and not all allow for bibtex exports. Maybe make crawlers for these? subcontract with the devil (e.g. access scopus)? or make import for the other formats people use for bibliographies (endnote, etc.)

* The approach is nice, so it might be a good idea to keep an eye on the pitfalls of other such ventures, namely:

* we are stuck with your style decisions regarding templates, we might not like them, they might run out of fashion, or in an attempt to mitigate this you will create millions of templates which are difficult to search for, hell to maintain, and most likely a growing nest of bugs (already my publications won't render with the "awesome" template).

* If you want to allow more customization, complexity in the UI will grow (and bugs), and at the end users will be frustrated and just download the data and write their own latex template (or move to another service).

* Malicious actors hosting stuff (allowing for uploads without email-verification / captchas) is, imho, playing with fire.

The best of lucks!

[0] https://europa.eu/europass/en/eportfolio-interoperability [1] https://ec.europa.eu/esco/portal/download

syats··on A Few Words About the Telex (2017)
Great article, and the bit at the end is also very informative.
syats··on Ask HN: How to increase SWE salaries in Europe?
I would like to pose the question: why do you think these salaries have to increase?

I work in Europe in a SW company, earning a well above country-average salary (around 2.5x). I live quite well. My colleagues live quite well. The company is doing quite well.

Do keep in mind, that every extra euro that ends up in my savings account, is an euro that is not ending up in someone else's wallet in the country where the customers are. That is, if my company decided to raise our salaries, the customers would have to raise prices on their customers, and so on, I would have more savings, but someone else wouldn't be able to have a coffee or pay their tuition money.

Why then, would we want the already well above average salaries raised?

syats··on Show HN: After 10 years my side project has hit $8k/mo in revenue
This is basically saying: "You got them hooked, now squeeze every cent you can out of them", which I think is very dishonest advice. There is at least one costumer who won't (or can't) pay a penny more than they are currently paying, and "experimenting with prices" would be like telling them: "well, go away, there's a guy here in line with more dough than you". Given the very-skewed distribution of wealth, this line of thought leads to very expensive services for the rich, and the poor having to leave without them (housing market, I'm looking at you).
syats··on Ask HN: How to run analytics on data without access to the data?
I'll tell you about International Data Spaces Assocation, just for the sake of completeness, and because others have mentioned some sort of certification of apps, etc. Finding a general solution to the problem posed by OP is quite difficult, as it requires a lot of extra infrastructure, technical and non-technical.

One idea would be:

1. distribute to the data owners a base system (something that can "run" stuff on their premises). People here have mentioned browsers, but for a more intensive processing this might not be enough.. so think of a docker daemon, keys for some docker registries, etc.

2. have a trusted "app store" (e.g. a docker registry where images are built in a reproducible manner from code which is inspected and certified, and then are cryptographically signed)

3. make a well described interface to the apps to consume the data (thinking of the general use case here.. if you just want to analyze fb info then you can make an adhoc parser...)

4. Have the data owner download, check the signature of, configure and run the app on their premises.

Things get even more interesting when the analytics need data from different non-trusting partners, so that Homeomorphic Encryption becomes necessary.

There is at least one specification that aims at supporting all of this: https://www.internationaldataspaces.org/wp-content/uploads/2... although implementation is, so far, lagging behind.

syats··on Aurora 7 Prototype – 7 Screen Laptop
In my dream world, "decision makers" (gov officials, top managers) attend their fancy meetings with one of these, and have on-screen info, fed by an army of people in different parts of the world, to minimize the amount of bullshit said, and make government / admin more efficient. Yes, they could also have the setup at home, but I think they like the going around in black SUVs, having doors opened for them, shaking hands and all that.
syats··on Ask HN: Wouldn't it be great to be able to follow fellow HN users?
This would incentivize the rock-star attitude, leading to a large number of posts created by people to have followers. This, in turn, will lead to the exclusion of stories and comments from people who don't want to spend time gaining followers.

Rock-star is the antithesis of hacker, imho.

syats··on Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab
Just wanted to mention Redmine, which is actually GPL and can be installed on premises.

Looks a bit dated and somehow hard to customize.. but at least you keep your data (ai models, you say?) you get to keep it when "free" is no longer a valid business model.

syats··on Project Cybersyn
I think this same argument holds for any mention of "dashboard".
syats··on In spite of an increase in Internet speed, webpage speeds have not improved
The article this thread is about clearly shows that your second statement is not true.
syats··on An Open Version of WordNet
Wordnet is like a dictionary in that it contains definitions and synonyms of words. It goes beyond a dictionary in that it also records relationships like hypernym (broader) and hyponym (narrower), which can be useful for "understanding" (what ever that means) text. It is a graph, that connects different senses (called synsets), and also senses to words. It used to be released under some close license and poorly maintained, now there's a fork of it on github to which all can contribute.
syats··on Show HN: MathLingua – The Language of Mathematics
This is an awesome effort!

Regarding a comment on possible use cases.. One component that would really compliment this would be a programming-language specific checker of definitions. In the documentation's example of "integer" it would be straight forward to write in python a function that checks if a given variable is an integer. The same can be for other definitions such as "invertible matrix" or "set of orthonormal vectors".. other languages could provide such checks for more symbolic stuff like "commutative ring" etc.

Once you have this in place, you can load your nice data into a (e.g.) numpy.ndarray object, and checks would be triggered for all possible properties. This would automatically tag your data as, e.g. "stochastic matrix" and then you could even get suggestions of the sort of "build a time-discrete stochastic system based on this matrix?". This is would be very helpful for "data scientists" who are a bit far from theory.. at least I know I would use this very often.

There is of course the issue of expressivity to be taken into account. Much of mathematical progress involves invention of new notation, not all of which is neatly written in "left to right English with only binary operators" (think of commutative diagrams for example). While the language can of course be expanded in this direction, there will be a very big temptation (and I would guess frequent pushes from the future community) to change to more and more general languages. In this case, please always keep in mind the very expressive but useless notation of Russell & Whiteheads's Principia. There is a big theory of language and expresivity, and there are also practical examples (think of OWL or other semantic-web languages) of how to reach a compromise that allows for enough expressivity for the use cases of interest.

syats··on Making a Googol:1 Reduction with Lego Gears [video]
The video is very good. i) It teaches basic gear-ratio concepts ii) it showcases an amazing repertoire of reduction modules, iii) it poses interesting questions regarding power transmission like: how much power is being dissipated throughout the system? or.. where is all the power of the motor going if you leave it running for 1 hour? iv) it motivates borderline philosophical question like: is the figurine at the end actually moving at all due to the gears? v) it has really good video editing / camera work
syats··on What's Behind Technological Hype?
Indeed, ML is vastly deployed, I do not doubt that. And maybe those "AI-powered" companies are making money, or making lives better.

But I was referring explicitly to existing processes. Your poacher detection example is a good one, there was a process (based on some other tech/skill/k9 units?)and then it was improved with AI. My assertion is that there are very few such examples.

Contrast that to new enterprises that use AI/ML. Of course, if you create a whole new market and corner it, whatever technology you use might seem like the recipe of your success. But in the case of ride hailing apps, they created a brand new market of taxis-called-directly-by-the-user (and still not making money), Facebook created a whole new market of personalized matchmaking between people and ads, etc. Yes, they are kings in their markets, yes, they use "AI", but what portion of their market dominance is due to the use of that specific technology? I would say close to 0.

syats··on What's Behind Technological Hype?
I like this article very much. As someone who makes a living from R&D funding into hyped technologies, this made me do some amount of introspection.

AI, however much we love it, and however good computers are at chess and go, has done relatively little to increase productivity in already existing processes. Yes, it's nice to tell apart cats from dogs with F1=0.98.. but, what bushiness actually added image classification into their processes and made money out of it? Furthermore, as any one searching for specific stuff on Google and being frustrated by synonyms being substituted or search terms being ranked in importance, can tell you, F1=0.98 isn't enough to really outsource human "intelligent" work onto computers.

The same goes for big data.. yes, we love our fancy Sparks and Airflows and Kafkas, yes, I've pushed to build "big data" pipelines several times.. yes, fancy dashboards can come up. But any increase in productivity or quality of life could have also been achieved with shell scripts and a bit of patience. Uber your say? they use big data to foo and to bar...yes, but not in real time, for real money making purposes: even if you ignore the fact that they are still in the negatives, the computations that have to be done real fast for their service to be usable, are all "small" as in, they-can-be-done-in-a-mobile-phone small.

syats··on Ask HN: How to avoid over-engineering software design for future use cases?
Thanks for sharing wordsandbuttons, it is full of very interesting content, which is, after all, the only thing that humans consume from it. It is a very good answer to OP. Furthermore, the site is very satisfying to navigate, specially with the dev console's network tab on. I'd just love if the whole web was like this again. Keep up the good work!
syats··on University of the People: Tuition-Free, Accredited Online Degree Programs
"tuition-free" is a misrepresentation of USD 4K for an undergrad degree. That might seem cheap for US (does it? really? compared to community college for example?), but it's crazy expensive for most "people" out there.
syats··on Show HN: XgeneCloud – Instant REST and GraphQL APIs on Any SQL Database
Related project: https://sciencedb.github.io/
syats··on The Impending Doom of Expiring Root CAs and Legacy Clients
This will also be an issue with some docker images built some years ago with an outdated cert store somewhere in there. Unmaintained images are, in effect, frozen in time.

I'll just mention glassfish here in case someone in the near future wonders why this or that application is failing: it has it's own cert store (different from the JVM one), and it is a bit out of date. Yes, I just ran into a github project whose last commit was 3 months ago (march 2020) and that wouldn't work with LE certificates, all because deep down the docker matrioshka, there was a glassfish with outdated certs.

syats··on AWS services explained in one line each
Is there something similar for Apache projects?
syats··on Experiment that ended in 1767 still linked to higher incomes, education levels
I would be ashamed to publish the graph with the "trend", the fit is so incredibly bad.
syats··on How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the State Machine
Another in the series "Show HN what is it that people actually learn in their first two years of undegrad CS"
syats··on JMESPath – A query language for JSON
One more alternative to many listed here is SPARQL-Generate. A single query language that works for XML and JSON, and has syntax borrowed from SPARQL.

https://ci.mines-stetienne.fr/sparql-generate/playground.htm...

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →