The option for the company is between the "more money" and "less money" option. There is a general sense in which the average individual benefits from the "more money" option; websites are better funded, they can provide better services, etc. There is also a incredibly minor way that they are worse off, in that some of their data (consisting of a field that says when they viewed certain news articles) might show up in a data leak in the future. But when you put it as "do you want to be tracked", of course it sounds bad, so all else being equal most people will say "no".
The "informed consent" framing of this issue is quite ridiculous. When someone is asked to pay for an item at the store, we don't say that they should also have the choice to take the item for free, and only pay for it if they want to. We recognize that, individually, most people would rather pay less, but that we collectively benefit when businesses are profitable. The situation with cookies is even worse, because unlike with money, most people have no idea what a website even uses their data for.
Th EU trying to rewrite the issue as concerning "consent" is thus idiotic, and innevitably lead to the cookie banner issue. If you think tracking is bad, then ban it, and let websites figure out how to target ads and improve their product without it. If you recognize tracking as overall beneficial, then permit it, and throw out this charade of informed consent. The EU can't make this decision themselves, so they expect every single individual to make this decision for themselves, every time they visit a website. This despite the average individual having no idea what their data is even being used for.
The issue is existential for websites, since it concerns their ability to remain profitable. As such, the website that stays in business longest is the one that can coax the most people to hand over their data. It is entirely inevitable that websites would go up to and beyond the letter of the law in pursuing this.