898 karma · joined May 24, 2024
meet.hn/city/us-Boston
But what I stated is plainly true, and many people simply don’t want exterior shades (or just don’t think about it).
The point I was trying to make was just that there are thermal implications to the orientation, and you should think those through (using thermal simulations can help detect these issues) and come up with appropriate strategies (thermal simulations can help validate them). Maybe you don’t want shades, but you would be okay with emissivity coatings for your windows. Or maybe you just want to position windows on both sides of the home with continuous air volumes connecting them to promote natural ventilation. Maybe you can take advantage of thermal mass. The list goes on…
Same goes for the slab/foundations (which can also have substantial thermal transfer in many contexts).
So it’s not universally applicable - but it is absolutely true that it will increase solar output!
But yes, distributed solar will not be the general solution to decarbonizing our energy systems as a whole. Does serve a meaningful role though and there is no reason to not do both.
I find this especially true while working on data science tasks - slicing and dicing data, visualizing, fitting initial models, etc - things where the larger more complex data generation pipelines are already taken care of and the data (or temp data/subsets of data) are readily available and you are free to rely on the improvisational skills you have developed working on similar data science tasks countless times over.
Also feel something similar when working on frontend wireframing/laying out and styling dashboards with no reference design.
Anyways, point is, it’s definitely feasible to enter into a flow state where you mind is a few steps ahead of your fingers and is actively solving problems that your fingers catch up to.
I guess I’m not sure it’s obvious where the right line to draw the boundary for “intentional human thought” is? Surely there is a lot of cognition and representation going on at extraordinary speeds that exist in some hazy border region between instinct/reflex/subconscious and conscious thought. Still, having said that, I do see what you are saying about trying to compare the complexity of the formal path to the solution, or at least what the human thinks their formal path was.
I’m generally of the mind (also, ha) that we won’t really ever be able to quantify any of this in a meaningful way in the short term and if anything which qualifies as AGI does emerge, it might only be something which is an “I know it when I see it” kind of evaluation…
Where are you getting 300W from? The body only dumps 100W of heat at rest and uses like 300-400W during moderate physical activity, so I’m a little confused about what you are describing there. The typical estimates I’ve seen are like 20W or so for the brain.
Edit: I should also say that what you describe does seem like a great way to compare solutions between computational systems currently being developed and a good one to use to try to push development forward; it just seems quixotic to try to be able to use it comparatively with human cognition or to be able to meaningfully use it to define where AGI is, which might not be what you were advocating for at all, in which case, sorry for misinterpreting!
This isn’t my area of expertise, but it seems plausible to me that what you said is completely erroneous or at the very least completely unverifiable at this point in time. How do you quantify how many bits it takes a human mind to solve one of the ARC problems?
That seems likely beyond the level of insight we have into the structure of cognition and information storage etc etc in wetware. I could of course be wrong and would love to be corrected if so! You mentioned a “tiny portion” of the human mind, but (as far as I’m aware), any given “small” part of human cognition still involves huge amounts of complexity and compute.
Maybe you are saying that the high level decision making a human goes through when solving can be represented with a relatively small number of pieces of information/logical operations (as opposed to a much lower level notion closer to the wetware of the quantity of information) but then it seems unfair to compare to the low level equivalent (weights & biases, FLOPs etc) in the ML system when there may be higher order equivalents.
I do appreciate the general notion of wanting to normalize against something though, and some notion of information seems like a reasonable choice, but practically out of our reach. Maybe something like peak power or total energy consumption would be a more reasonable choice, which we can at least get a lower and upper bounds on in the human case (metabolic rates are pretty well studied, and even if we don’t have a good idea of how much energy is involved in completing cognitive tasks we can at least get bounds for running the entire system in that period of time) and close to a precise value in the ML case.
I guarantee you will like this paper!
Awesome paper on how powerful particle based methods can be:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187775032...
And a fun image of a DEM solid model of fracture:
I think doing so would be especially important in a paper on DR techniques which are already so fraught in how they are deployed (often with little thought) in many applied contexts, and when so much of their putative utility comes from their interaction with human visual perception. I would have loved to see some discussion of actual engineering use cases where PaCMAP proves more useful than t-SNE - I’m sure there are many! Really just nitpicking from me though, will probably try it out on my own cases in the next few days.
This looks like a cool project in the same spirit!
This textbook/walkthrough is great: https://a.co/d/9dWXDTK
Take a look at De Luna et al, Science 364 2019 [1]
Discovering PyMC and the excellent accompanying textbook was game changing for me! Being able to write full hierarchical models in a handful of lines of code hooked up to pandas data frames already is so wonderful.
The more tools for this the better!
Point is just that it seems a little silly to try to reductively do these calculations - seems meaningless to try to compare without more information…
See the CBE Thermal Comfort Tool to interactively determine comfort bands in relation to various ASHRAE standards for computing thermal comfort with all of these affecting parameters:
For once I can feel mild pleasure at seeing the tables turned…
To be honest I don’t know why all my projects are always in USE1, I guess it’s just because that’s where we have always had them for my lab so I’ve stuck with it for no good reason…
There’s been a big boom in research related to dispersal of things (CO2, biological materials etc) lately though due to the increasing accessibility of CFD to building scientists + COVID.