HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on [dead]
It's astonishing a party wants to increase immigration to get more voters for its side. I thought parties should win by having better policies that win over existing voters, not by abandoning them and diluting them with new voters.
tarakat··on How does Google get away with this?
Yes, the software (at least the not Play-store parts, into which more and more functionality is moving) is nominally open-source.

The restriction is on hardware - phone manufacturers that wish to sell phones with Google's software preinstalled are contractually forbidden (by Google) from selling versions with Android forks. Meaning you cannot hire any phone manufacturer if you want to sell phones with forked Android installed - you have to set up your own production lines.

You could root phones, but then the many apps (such as banking) that detect this will refuse to work. You would not have a commercially viable product, because only geeks will buy it.

Essentially, Google made sure that any kind of privacy-first alternative cannot develop, because it would involve burning too much money, even for billionaires.

tarakat··on How does Google get away with this?
In the video, Louis Rossmann's complaint is about Google's anticompetitive practice of

In particular, Google has prevented manufacturers wishing to pre-install Google apps from selling even a single smart mobile device running on alternative versions of Android that were not approved by Google (so-called "Android forks"). - https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_18_...

Meaning a billionaire was unable to hire OnePlus/Motorola/Samsung to build a privacy-first phone running GrapheneOS, because their contracts with Google prevented them from manufacturing such a phone.

tarakat··on SEC charges owners of New Jersey Deli with a $100M Valuation
No matter what your opinion on economic equality, letting fraudsters profit at the expense of their more honest counterparts harms the economic health of a country. Eventually workers will feel it too.
tarakat··on Where online hate speech can bring the police to your door
Archive: https://archive.ph/zQdix
tarakat··on Italy's right wing, led by Meloni, wins election, exit polls say
Which policy that Meloni promised do you think could lead to war?
tarakat··on The Unmagicking of Disney
Tangential to the article, I urge the reader to read Andersen's original Little Mermaid, and not settle for Disney's beautifully animated, but watered-down (heh), bowdlerized version. And I don't mean the remake.

The same could be said for most of their works.

tarakat··on Israeli Army Installs Remote-Control Crowd Dispersal System at Hebron Flashpoint
> The video says it, but it’s all more important to emphasize that Palestinians including women & children were killed at this checkpoint by Israeli forces.

That's odd. I don't recall seeing anything on the news about this.

tarakat··on China will monitor bus drivers emotions using wristbands
They are in public, and if an expert in body language and facial expressions were sitting next to them paying close attention, he could monitor those emotions just as well. So one cannot say they have a "reasonable expectation of privacy" for their emotional state, and therefore this is not an invasion of privacy even according to US law.

Or perhaps the "reasonable expectation of privacy" is used in an utterly insane manner in US law. One or the other.

tarakat··on Oppose PayPal’s assault on liberal democracy
> Your statement in italics is new to me and quite insightful, I think.

You can credit Frank Herbert for it.

tarakat··on Oppose PayPal’s assault on liberal democracy
> Surprisingly

Nothing about this is surprising. When I am weaker than you, I ask you for freedom because that is according to your principles; when I am stronger than you, I take away your freedom because that is according to my principles.

Free speech is simply not the main value of what can loosely be called the left. Nor is historical truth or even opposition to slavery, as a review of The Woman King [0] (and the film itself, casting Black slavers as heroes and White abolitionists as villains), and alternating ignorance of or apologetics for the historical Middle Eastern slave trade [1,2,3,4] or present-day African slavery reveal [5].

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32967317

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbary_slave_trade

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Saharan_slave_trade

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_slave_trade

[4] How Islam moderated slavery - https://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/history/slave...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_contemporary_Africa - nominally they are against it, yet reserve all their moral outrage and rhetoric only for cases when whites were slavers. The 600 thousand dead, sacrificed in the civil war to end slavery, failed to appease them.

tarakat··on Alternate History: An India Without Colonialism
Maybe something like...

More Indians own property in London than the English - https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/more-indians-own-p...

tarakat··on Sisterhood and Slavery in “The Woman King”
> Ironically, Dahomey’s rehabilitation is undercut by the demonization of Oyo, a fascinating society in its own right.

How naive of me to think the article might also lament the demonization of Europeans, whose role in this conflict was flipped upside-down, from fighting to abolish slavery, to fighting to preserve it. The article excuses it with "Why, then, should “The Woman King” be held to a moral standard ignored by the thousands of period dramas about violent Western states" - proof that even the worst historical lies will be excused as long as they harm the correct group.

> Viola Davis’s new feature is a rousing tribute to the world’s only all-female army. But how true is the story it tells?

To save you reading the drawn-out article and its tepid conclusion: as true as a civil war movie where the North fought to impose slavery on the South.

tarakat··on Silicon Valley slips back to Bro culture
> let's talk about it in realistic terms and figure out how to make it go faster instead of focusing on the outliers

The media's power lies in focusing on (emotionally charged) outliers. That and wordplay (e.g. a NYT article said "whites and Asians dominate" some top-ranked schools, when whites alone were in fact underrepresented [1]).

Asking them to stop is asking the king to give up his crown.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/17/nyregion/high-school-admi...

tarakat··on Hertz is still having rental car customers wrongfully arrested, lawsuit claims
Something similar to your suggestion is in fact an (albeit rare) legal possibility:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil

tarakat··on The South Asian Polycrisis
The World Lost Two-Thirds Of Its Wildlife In 50 Years. We Are to Blame - https://www.npr.org/2020/09/10/911500907/the-world-lost-two-...

> There is no freezing or turning back the clock without the suffering of billions.

Do you believe developed countries with below-replacement fertility are suffering? Or does "turning back the clock" refer to something other than population shrinkage?

tarakat··on The South Asian Polycrisis
> The west is captured by Malthusian thinking, and their solution is “less brown people,”

Ironic then that brown people is the only group still growing in the west then:

America’s white population declined for the first time [..] Meanwhile, there was significant growth among minority groups over the last decade. - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/aug/12/us-2020-cens...

tarakat··on Censorship by big tech at the behest of the U.S. government?
But that's just it - the silent re-ranking of stories, algorithmic or editorial, can also flip elections. Not just elections, it can entirely change the direction a culture is headed.

And it causes no backlash - you wouldn't even know it was happening, unless you laboriously compared statistics with how much exposure stories (not just news stories, films and books shape our perception of the world just as much) get, for the few sufficiently objective categories where a meaningful comparison can be made.

tarakat··on Banned Books: The 'dangerous' books too powerful to read
Another of those banned books articles that only lists books the author likes, and wouldn't dream of mentioning any of the books banned so effectively that they never made it into school libraries and reading lists:

In 2019, Amazon purged dozens of books from right-wing authors, including 16 titles from Counter-Currents Publishing, such as Greg Johnson’s White Nationalist Manifesto. Four books by American Renaissance founder Jared Taylor were banned, including 2011’s White Identity: Racial Consciousness in the 21st Century - https://truthout.org/articles/after-activist-pressure-amazon...

tarakat··on Celeste Ng’s Dystopia Is Uncomfortably Close to Reality
How very brave of a Chinese-American, whose country or origin was 94% ethnically Han in 1953, and is still 91% Han in 2020 [1], to write a story where the evil whites in the US (87% in 1970, down to 61% a short 50 years later, and falling) [2] are culturally genociding her group.

Uncomfortably close to reality? It is reality - in China, for the Uyghurs.

Accuse your enemy of what you are doing. The more the US opens its borders, the more it is demonized.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_China#Ethnic_g...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...

tarakat··on Censorship by big tech at the behest of the U.S. government?
Ironically it's the kind of censorship the Biden laptop story got that scares me the least. Brazen, obvious, and now widely known about.

What's really scary is the silent implicit algorithmic ranking that decides which stories, channels, websites get traffic. Invisible and much more effective, leaving no big "banned from Facebook" banner a victim can point to. Just a mysterious, gradual dwindling of traffic. It could be for legitimate reasons, or because someone has their thumb on the scale, for political or economic reasons.

tarakat··on US Military Bought Mass Monitoring Tool Including Internet Browsing, Email Data
> Do you work at a company that handles netflow data? Do you work at an ISP distributing that data? Or do you know anything else about the trade or use of netflow data? We'd love to hear from you. Using a non-work phone or computer, you can contact Joseph Cox securely on Signal on +44 20 8133 5190, Wickr on josephcox, or email joseph.cox@vice.com.

Say you do. A new article is published, containing information you leaked. Your company makes a list of lets be extremely generous and say 10,000 employees with access to the leaked data. Then they look at the reporter's social graph, and make a list of everyone 1-2x removed. Then a list of websites where all of these people's contact information or articles have appeared. Then a list of their employees who have seen these articles/contacts on their non-anonymous browsing, sorted by recency and proximity to the author.

How many names does that leave?

Now they look at VPN purchases or downloads of Signal or Tor. Or if you were stupid enough to buy an "anonymous" phone/laptop with a credit card, they can now compare its browsing fingerprint to web searches for Tor/Signal/Vice/etc. originating from your area. Or they buy phone or license-plate reader location data and see if their employees visited any computer stores, but left without making a credit-card purchase.

How many names are left now?

You have nothing to hide, until you want to share something of substance with a journalist. Then you see the cage all around you.

tarakat··on [dead]
And people followed your advice, and when not every group was equally successful, were accused of racism, because we know ability (in every area... well, every intellectual area) is equally distributed, so what else could it be?

And not just ability, but behavior too. So if one group has more violent interactions with the police, it is, again, entirely due to racism.

But not sexism. Because everyone knows men are more violent than women, so it doesn't raise any alarm bells that men are over-represented in prison 13 to 1 compared to women:

https://www.statista.com/chart/11573/gender-of-inmates-in-us...

tarakat··on Do University Diversity Statement Requirements Violate the Constitution?
A study from 1985 found that:

The authors also submitted different test studies to different peer-review boards. The methodology was identical, and the variable was that the purported findings either went for, or against, the liberal worldview (for example, one found evidence of discrimination against minority groups, and another found evidence of "reverse discrimination" against straight white males). Despite equal methodological strengths, the studies that went against the liberal worldview were criticized and rejected, and those that went with it were not. [1]

In 1985 in social psychology, liberals outnumbered conservatives 4 to 1. In 2012, it reached 14 to 1 [1]. If the research was biased even in 1985, imagine how bad it must be now, with a faculty 3x more politically biased. Now add the diversity statements on top of that.

Regardless of constitutionality, it boggles the mind social science has any credibility left.

[1] https://theweek.com/articles/441474/how-academias-liberal-bi... summarizing a

tarakat··on Wiley’s removal of hundreds of titles from ebook collections
This would be impossible with paper. Digitization enables so much business innovation.
tarakat··on Banned in the USA: The Growing Movement to Censor Books in Schools
That's the privilege of institutional power - you can control reading lists and access to books, and it doesn't register as a ban.
tarakat··on Banned in the USA: The Growing Movement to Censor Books in Schools
[flagged]
tarakat··on Banned in the USA: The Growing Movement to Censor Books in Schools
Books that are actually banned aren't in school libraries, reading lists, and Amazon won't carry them [1]. But the temptation to feel like a rebel for buying a "banned book", prominently advertised in a large corporate chain bookstore, is just too great.

That is when they're not accusing free speech of being a white supremacist value.

[1] https://truthout.org/articles/after-activist-pressure-amazon...

tarakat··on Germany's blanket data retention law is illegal, EU top court says
And we must ensure that choice remains economically viable, and not just for the largest member states. Because a union maintained by compulsion, even economic compulsion, is not a union, but an empire.
tarakat··on Public buses across country adding microphones to record conversations (2012)
1. You're using "no privacy" to mean both "overheard by the grandma in the next row" and "recorded by a centralized mass surveillance system to be analyzed and correlated with the millions of other data points it has on your and your social circle, wholly subservient to the ever-changing will of the state".

So are the courts. By some twisted logic, they concluded that because you can't expect that a random passer-by hears you, you have no reasonable expectation that everywhere in public isn't infested with microphones and cameras uploading everything to intelligence agencies or corporate headquarters.

2. We should be careful, as ever more spaces are becoming "private, open to the public". Perhaps most notably the parks in Wall Street. Soon we may have to travel out of city bounds for any meaningful privacy, if that isn't already the case.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →