HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on The Portuguese can no longer afford to live in Portugal
It's hard to empathize with a belief system that thinks pricing a native population out of their own country is fair. I suppose if you hold that everything should be subordinate to economics, including community and nationhood?
tarakat··on Cloudflare Tries to Ignore the World
> It only dropped support for the Daily Stormer after Heather Heyer was killed in Charlottesville, Virginia, in 2017 during a white supremacist rally.

When someone calls for censorship because speech leads to violence, ask yourself: Is the list of violent incidents used to justify censorship representative, or cherry-picked to include only the author's political opponents? Hint:

The same press outlets that portrayed Mr. Rittenhouse as a white supremacist have had remarkably little to say about the racial identity of Darrell Brooks, the black suspect in Wisconsin who is accused of plowing his car through an annual Christmas parade last month and killing six people, including an 8-year-old boy, all of whom were white. Given the suspect’s history of posting messages on social media that called for violence against white people and praised Hitler for killing Jews, you’d think that his race and the race of his victims would be relevant to reporters. Race is all anyone would be talking about if a white man had slammed his vehicle into a parade full of black people. Yet suddenly the left has gone colorblind. - https://www.wsj.com/articles/waukesha-killings-make-the-medi...

How many sites with hateful rhetoric were deplatformed due to the Waukesha killings? How many were deplatformed when Xavier Johnson killed 5 white cops and injured nine, saying he "wanted to kill white people, especially white officers" [1]?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_shooting_of_Dallas_police...

tarakat··on International Council of Museums Redefines “Museum”
> Open to the public, accessible and inclusive, museums foster diversity and sustainability

This sounds less like a definition and more like a goal. It is absurd to consider an institution that ticks all the other boxes, but does not "foster diversity", as not a museum. By this logic, a museum in China dedicated to Han heritage isn't a museum.

tarakat··on DeSantis sues Biden administration over Canadian drug importation program
I hope that since this is an issue both 'teams' agree on in this case, the discussion can be fruitful, and not devolve into partisan bickering.

I am especially curious why progress has been so glacial, given that both sides of the aisle, at least publicly, support this program.

tarakat··on [dead]
A story was submitted on this topic. I don't wish to give the right-wing site that published it more exposure, but the top comment [1] is falsely defaming the website and giving cover to Google's deception, and should be corrected.

It claims the article misquotes Google, that where they cite "additional nominees must self-identify as a woman, Black/African American..", Google didn't use "must", but "we strongly encourage".

While I doubt even "strongly encouraging" is legal (try "strongly encouraging" white candidates), Google in fact did use "must", then silently changed it, probably in response to the publicity. The "must" version can still be seen through the linked archive, included in the story itself.

Any journalist worth their salt has by now learned to archive websites, as companies like to alter them, then gaslight us that the incriminating version never existed.

It should also be noted that Google's 2022 US workforce is 48.3% white [2], while the US is 57% white [3]. So Google setting caps on an already underrepresented group.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32667463

[2] https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/about.google/en//... page 31

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...

tarakat··on Google’s Complicity in Israeli Apartheid: Google Silences Palestinians
> On June 22, 2020, a month after George Floyd’s murder, the director of Google.org emailed the Jewglers listerv, to formally apologize to Jewish employees. He cited concern from Jews at the company that Google’s donation to the Movement for Black Lives, M4BL, had unintentionally been antisemitic.

> The reason? Jewglers leadership had issued formal complaints to company leadership about the donation, saying it was antisemitic because M4BL, a coalition of dozens of groups, included organizations that had expressed their alignment with the perspectives and language of Palestinian-led groups.

> The apology from Google did nothing to protect against antisemitism. Instead, it only pitted us against one another, which divides us and makes us less safe. The world is better when all marginalized communities can work together to fight injustice everywhere.

Can you really call yourself "marginalized" if you can make Google grovel like that?

But don't worry, thanks to US' robust democracy, you can vote for a candidate that will address this issue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8KY2_qaROFY

tarakat··on Visual Studio Code is designed to fracture
"They warned me to wear a seatbelt but I didn't and was fine"
tarakat··on Rights, Laws, and Google
> We don’t know how many of those children were subsequently rescued, but a question worth posing to anyone unilaterally opposed to Google’s approach is how big that number would have to be to have made it worthwhile? [..] how big the number of false positives would have to be to shut the whole thing down?

There's nothing worse or more myopic than this kind of "pragmatic", numerical approach towards liberty. As if living in a panopticon cage is desirable, as long as the wardens never make a mistake.

Why is it myopic? Well, if being forced to use technology that betrays its user is okay as long as one number is sufficiently larger than another, then why not force all new houses to come with indoor microphones and cameras, always listening and watching - only for the most heinous crimes, of course!

Are you "unilaterally opposed" to such a measure, despite how much sexual abuse and domestic violence and murder it would prevent? What about tracking and shock collars for everyone? How much violence could be stopped if everyone was forced to wear those!

Don't like it? Not even if the false positive rate was zero?

tarakat··on The Big [Censored] Theory
Yes but at least that episode of Peep Show was clearly marked and advertised as censored, right? They didn't try to pass it off as unaltered, right?
tarakat··on SMIC reaches 7nm without access to western equipment and technologies
You speak as if China and the West are hermetically sealed-off from each other. The West is worried because, just like every other strategic industry, China will try to take over the global market.

Yes, that's exactly what the West also tried. That doesn't mean it doesn't imperil the West to be on the receiving-end of these tactics.

tarakat··on Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers
As the sibling replies illustrates, this is now more akin to paying the Danegeld, than paying for a service.
tarakat··on What Does Israel Fear from This ‘Terrorist’? (2021)
> Are you arguing that I should be sympathetic?

No, I'm arguing that you should be grateful. But nothing is ever enough, and that you heap the sins of the Nazis even on those that fought against them (or rather, on their descendants) shows how unreasonable you are.

If there is a single collaborationist in Poland, all of Poland must feel guilty, forever? Meanwhile,

Poles were, by nationality, the most numerous persons who rescued Jews during the Holocaust. [..] Of the estimated 3 million non-Jewish Poles killed in World War II, thousands were executed by the Germans solely for saving Jews. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rescue_of_Jews_by_Poles_during...

3 million Poles killed - half as many as Jews killed in the Holocaust, in Poland alone. Despite such casualties, they still used their very limited resources to rescue Jews. And what was their reward? Having their country given to the Soviets by the Allies, approximately zero movies commemorating their sacrifice, and getting blamed by people such as you.

tarakat··on What Does Israel Fear from This ‘Terrorist’? (2021)
Despite killing and dying to stop Hitler, and seeing many of their countries razed, they're guilty for not doing more to help the Jews? At a time when they were themselves in existential peril?

> They could have bombed railways. They didn't (US didn't either).

They did bomb railways [1], and sabotaged them too [2]. Many partisans were caught and executed for it. Yet you deny their sacrifice. To say nothing of actually showing gratitude.

> They could have bombed the camps. They didn't.

Let's ignore that "could" here means flying deep into enemy-controlled territory, with all the anti-aircraft defenses that entails, and focus on what would happen had they done that. What would happen if they dropped bombs on a camp full of prisoners, to those prisoners? What happens to anyone if you drop bombs on them?

And I see many countries attended that conference [3], not just from Europe. And the US was an ocean away. At that point, you may as well blame the whole world for not accepting the refugees. Yet you reserve your blame for the US and Europe.

> They did little/nothing to stop the atrocities. That they knew were happening.

Have you heard of the fog of war? The atrocities were not nearly as well publicized as they are today (least of all to the Germans themselves [4]), their scale was not yet known, and they had to contend with many other atrocities. Let me remind you Stalin killed 20 million of his own people (and Ukrainians) [5] around that time. Shall we feel guilty for them too? They were our allies, after all, and we generously gave them much of the Eastern Europe that they invaded and terrorized, and filmed hardly any movies about those deaths [6] - I guess some things are okay to forget?

And finally, since you so generously appoint hereditary guilt not just for inaction, but even for insufficient (by your standards) action, which nation would be guiltless by this standard? None. Certainly not Israel.

[1] Strategic bombing during World War II involved sustained aerial attacks on railways, harbours, cities, workers' and civilian housing - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_bombing_during_World...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_sabotage_during_World_...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89vian_Conference

[4] In October 1944, Reitsch claims she was shown a booklet by Peter Riedel which he'd obtained while in the German Embassy in Stockholm, concerning the gas chambers. She further claims that while believing it to be enemy propaganda, she agreed to inform Heinrich Himmler about it. Upon doing so, Himmler is said to have asked whether she believed it, and she replied, "No, of course not. But you must do something to counter it. You can't let them shoulder this onto Germany." "You are right," Himmler replied. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanna_Reitsch

[5] https://www.nytimes.com/1989/02/04/world/major-soviet-paper-...

[6] https://reason.com/2000/06/01/hollywoods-missing-movies/

tarakat··on What Does Israel Fear from This ‘Terrorist’? (2021)
"Europe"? Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't more than half of Europe fight, kill, and die to stop the dictator that was killing Jews? But you'd rather the whole continent feels guilty, instead of proud of their sacrifices?
tarakat··on What Does Israel Fear from This ‘Terrorist’? (2021)
Given the significant financial and military aid the US provides Israel, this video illustrates who a US voter can pick if they are concerned about Israeli human rights violations:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8KY2_qaROFY

tarakat··on Robert's Rules of Order (1876)
Are there any prospect of continuing such protests? There are still apartheid states companies do business with, to say nothing of other corporate misdeeds.
tarakat··on How 'Namaste' Flew Away from Us
I assume next in this article series, NPR will pick some element of European culture that is not treated with sufficient reverence or authenticity by others, and expound how terribly this makes Europeans suffer.
tarakat··on UK energy bills are soaring to record highs
And now that "legitimate government" is collaborating with a foreign invasion, and owes a huge debt to the foreigners who put it in power for the explicit purpose of exploiting the country's natural resources.

Will it still be seen as "legitimate"?

tarakat··on Art is Fundamentally Social (2021)
I think of it as art itself being the goal.

While artists may hope their art will also fulfill other goals, I wouldn't want to live in a world without art, where those goals are instead fulfilled by expending equivalent effort to turn the crank of some machine. I suspect neither would the author of this article.

tarakat··on Zuckerberg says FBI warning prompted Biden laptop story censorship
Are the higher educated from Brazil, Russia, China, Egypt, Japan, Poland, and Algeria also aligned in this same direction? And do you know what happens to the higher educated that don't toe the line? Here's a hint:

James Watson's DNA Nobel Prize sells for $4.8m - https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-30346903

And here's more than a hint: unless you're publicly committed to this same political direction, 20% of all academic jobs in the US are officially closed to you [1]. The un-official denial rate is surely even higher.

[1] https://freebeacon.com/campus/study-diversity-statements-req...

tarakat··on Zuckerberg says FBI warning prompted Biden laptop story censorship
Isn't plausible deniability great? They get the benefit of the doubt, while at the same time jealously guarding their secrets.
tarakat··on Clinics win battle over meaning of 2016 FOIA amendments
Seife was seeking to obtain documents from the FDA related to its approval of a controversial drug – Exondys 51 – created by pharmaceutical company Sarepta. The FDA largely rejected Seife’s request for information pertaining to the drug’s approval, asserting that the clinical trial data and other information he sought could be withheld under Exemption 4 since Sarepta considered it confidential. While ultimately affirming the FDA’s decision to withhold much of the information, the 2nd Circuit rejected its contention that information can be withheld under Exemption 4 simply by virtue of its being confidential.

[..] The email posed a simple inquiry – “lawsuit?” – as a possible way to promote transparency for clinical trial data in the wake of multiple scandals involving drugs that turned out to be less safe and effective than suggested by the analysis of the confidential trial data conducted by the pharmaceutical companies themselves.

It beggars belief that any clinical trial data used for FDA approval can remain confidential. That the safety analysis is conducted by the same companies hoping to sell the drugs makes this utterly farcical.

It's good the lawsuit managed to slightly increase transparency, but my God, what a small victory...

tarakat··on Remote scan of student’s room before test violated his privacy, judge rules
Being able to look things up, even in seconds, is not equivalent to knowing them. When someone suggests "let's do X", you cannot reply with "but that would cause Y", if Y is buried in some pdf file on your computer, or one Bing search away - how do you know you should search for Y, when there are infinite other things you could search for.
tarakat··on SEC Gag Orders Silence the Accused
> I am comfortable with a criminal plea deal not allowing someone to say they are innocent.

I am not. How are we then to learn about corrupt prosecutors?

tarakat··on The AI startup erasing call center worker accents
Dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32591912
tarakat··on “Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans”
Good thing this practice has since ceased, and is entirely absent from movies and news reporting, where care is taken that even the most maligned groups are represented by, well, representative individuals, instead of cherry-picking the most unlikable members.
tarakat··on “Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans”
Okay. Then let's censor science, and put an asterisk next to every published study: "If the results had been different, they would not have been published."

And when someone claims "research shows your prejudice is unfounded", one can justifiably answer with "because the findings have been cherry-picked to support a pre-determined conclusion. So I will trust my gut instinct, because the scientists have admitted their research is subordinate to propaganda."

Though I have a feeling social science will try to be very discreet about what kind of filtering they're doing, and will hope that, when they disseminate findings they like, that we will have forgotten they're self-confessed propagandists first, and scientists second.

tarakat··on “Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans”
Yet, people can be harmed indirectly. For example, research may — inadvertently — stigmatize individuals or human groups. It may be discriminatory, racist, sexist, ableist or homophobic. It may provide justification for undermining the human rights of specific groups, simply because of their social characteristics. [..] Advancing knowledge and understanding is a fundamental public good. In some cases, however, potential harms to the populations studied may outweigh the benefit of publication.

"The teachings of the Church must not be undermined by heliocentrism or evolution research, so findings in those areas will be strictly filtered for heresy before publication.

But those findings that support the Church will be permitted, and loudly trumpeted as scientific proof of our dogma."

tarakat··on The AI startup erasing call center worker accents
So, AI-powered cultural appropriation? Literally tricking people into thinking they are dealing with someone from their culture. Ethnic fraud. But the Guardian predictably frames it as if the people being tricked are at fault, instead of the victims. That if only they were more virtuous, they wouldn't need to be tricked.

I wonder how The Guardian would react if e.g. the British were using AI when doing business in South America to trick the locals into thinking they were doing business with other locals. Would they also be accusing the locals of xenophobia?

tarakat··on SEC Gag Orders Silence the Accused
> SEC doesn't have the power to unilaterally silence someone

No, but it does have all the power of the State to legally threaten and prosecute people. Do we want state agencies using their power to threaten people into silence? How does that help fulfill SEC's stated mission?

Again, how would you feel if criminal plea deals came with NDAs? Would that destruction of transparency improve the justice system? If not, why is it a good idea for the SEC to do so?

← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →