I’d love to see a “modern” web app built in pure JavaScript without a framework.
1,318 karma · joined November 6, 2016
Formerly at Palantir, Apple, and co-founder at Symbolica AI. Currently at GitHub.
I’d love to see a “modern” web app built in pure JavaScript without a framework.
If there was one time when we could have escaped the client side hell that is JavaScript it would have been then, when chrome had astonishing market share, and Dart could compile down to JS to ease the transition until native support became standardized.
But nope, here we are with anotherone.js every week.
The quagmire of subtly different JavaScript frameworks is definitely the leading reason I avoid front end work like the plague.
Want to know how a lot of that data is generated? Microsoft excel. Arguably without excel there would be less data to act abusively with. If only Microsoft just refused to sell excel to the government.
People are happy to accept that excel is general enough that it isn’t made for that one purpose, but refuse to apply the same reasoning to Palantir; that may seem like whataboutism, but they genuinely are comparable tools if you take away the marketing and fear mongering.
As for your analogy, it’s more like you own shop that makes metalworking tools, and someone buys some. You don’t know what they are going to do with it, and (here’s where it gets opinionated) you shouldn’t need to care. You sold a tool to someone. Can the tool be used to make a gun? Sure. But it can also be used for anything else involving metal work. At some point we need to accept that the responsibility for how a tool of used needs to be placed on the person using it.
I’m not saying it’s perfect, but scapegoating the company is avoiding the real issue, which is the government policies or the enactment thereof.
I'm talking about neutering the surveillance state. That's not something that demonizing individual companies is ever going to do. You need to push for that change at the government level.
Unless you're pro-surveillance, but your previous comments made it seem like the opposite.
The hits were all more or less expected, a bunch around their home and the precinct, local supermarkets, etc. But then a weird grouping way out of town. Detective insisted it was a mistake and wanted more data, thinking someone stole his license plate (insert eye roll here).
Anyways, zooming in and looking at the highest density of hits, it ended up being a strip club that he frequented. He got bright red and his buddies didn't stop giving him shit for it all day.
And this was a detective, not a beat officer.
The irony to me is that when I was at Palantir they talked extremely openly about all their technology. A ton of it was open sourced, and in depth tech talks were posted to YouTube, but almost no one watched them.
I think people just like writing them off as shady or sketchy because it’s easier than needing to reason about the clear ethical nuance that exists in the government contractor space.
The software was also used to run double blind clinical drug trials - the acl granularity was great at that; you could have different roles for drug manufacturers, doctors, and patients, none of which had absolute information. Then trial supervisors could open up the data for analysis at the end of the trial.
At that same time, the ability to use GPS phones to upload data over unreliable networks was used when they teamed up with the Clinton foundation and Team Rubicon to improve disaster relief coordination for hurricanes.
Myself or coworkers (“Palantir staff”) worked on all of these.
Do you ever use uber? They work to keep their drivers legally declared as contractors, despite treating them employees in all other regards. That’s pretty immoral, so I hope you don’t encourage it by supplying them with business.
If you want to see change that is more than just superficial, that’s where you need to make it.
We could absolutely stop all weapons production in the US, I’d just ask for some time to learn Mandarin first.
Everything has a domain it operates in, so I believe that statement has nuance. In particular when you look at how general or specific the domain is.
From the perspective of something uploaded to S3? It sure is like any other file.
From the perspective of a website dedicated to the dissemination of child porn? It clearly is more than "just bits" in that context.
How about from the perspective of a search engine, where that site may be indexed? Welcome to the grey area that all of these debates are rooted in. Technically it's just indexed strings or ngrams, so it is like any other type of file. But there's an argument that a search engine should "know more" than just the raw data, and should be able to understand that context somehow.
Palantir is in this grey area. The software isn't built for spying. It's built for managing and understanding vast amounts of data. Can this be used for spying? Yes. It can also be used for double blind clinical trials. Or maintaining insurance systems. Or coordinating disaster relief efforts.
It operates technologically in a very general domain, but their flexible user-defined ontology makes it very powerful at operating in more specific domains. So it's a lot less cut and dry than the dissenters make it seem, IMHO.
HN won't let me reply to that, so I'll do it here. I didn't feel the need to offer a "defense" of Palantir there since I already outlined it above and don't feel like there's value in repeating myself.
But you asked, here you go - The government is going to use the data regardless, so long as they have it. The only effective recourse is to make them collecting or storing the data illegal, but good luck with that, seeing as even when it is illegal they do it anyways (see: Snowden).
Do you think is Palantir weren't there they'd just say "Ah well, I guess that's that" and be done with it? Nope; they'd go to Lockheed, Raytheon, IBM, or another long-time contractor to build a replacement almost immediately. The technology is genuinely nothing special. It federates searches across disparate database, and stitches results together.
But for me, having worked at Palantir, I know what mechanisms are provided to attempt to mitigate abuse. So as long as that data does exist and is going to be used, I'd prefer to have it be as well controlled and audited as possible. And sure, you can argue that the government may forego auditing, or be entirely corrupt, but that doesn't seem to me to be a good reason to not use tools that at least provide that capability.
I’d love to be in the utopia world where there is no war and the entire planet gets along. But even the US has political bipolar disorder, so we’re a looooong way from global peace.
I do think we spend an absurd and inappropriate amount on defense, but as long as we are forced to develop weapons due to the global geopolitical climate, I’d consider it preferable to work on making them more targeted.
My problem is I don’t like or agree with the people picking the targets, but that’s a whole other argument.
If so, please don’t tell me you’re a DBA.
If you’ve never worked with a government agency before, let me tell you, Hanlon’s Razor is in full effect. Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.
The higher ups know that free reign for their officers to look up anything is a recipe for legal nightmares. The individual officers are often just too dumb to realize that they shouldn’t search for something, and do so out of curiosity. Having blocks in the way like requiring a case number be entered to run a search, and knowing that that search and results are forever associated to that case, cut down a lot on abuse.
Are all forms of abuse the same, or so easily mitigated? No, but I’d like for some system to audit that and at least try to enforce it.
But Palantir has been the “tech boogieman” since before I even left in 2014, so it probably always will be. It is admittedly easier to blame a smaller tech company as a scapegoat than try to address the larger governmental or organizational actors that you actually have grievances against.
Just know it won’t do anything. The people who complain online aren’t their target market and never will be. And the paranoia lends way more credence to their dressed up search engine than it really deserves on technical merit alone.
So in a way the people complaining about it are making the issue they’re so upset about worse.
If you don’t like the bullshit the government does, that seems like an issue you should take up with the government, no? You’re using a tech company as a scapegoat.
If you don’t like the data that organizations record, I’m right there with you, but demonizing the tools that allow them to access data more effectively is an absurd stance to take. Their system also does things like add an immutable audit log, or enforce requirements on how data can be accessed.
Working with law enforcement, before Palantir there was nothing preventing an officer from looking up their ex husband or wife, or celebrities, or anyone at random. With it, there’s an audit trail of every search, and most of them need a case number as justification. Even then, certain searches would automatically get flagged for review.
We can go back to giving people direct and unaudited SQL access if you’d like, but I’d prefer some more accountability, even if the downside is organizations being able to use data _they already have_ more effectively.
It’s a giant federated search engine... that’s about it. They don’t even hold any data themselves, it all stays on site with the customer.
Putting up two candidates in the election is a guaranteed way to never win again with our current system. All you’ll do is split the vote for your party, handing the win to the opposition wrapped up with a bow.
Neither party has any incentive to address it tho, since it benefits them both both equally. They hate each other and are as separate politically as they can be (often times taking a position just to spite the other party). But with only two parties with any real chance of winning, they’re chances are better and arguments easier to make than when facing a half dozen parties spanning the whole political spectrum.
So we go from more extreme liberal to more extreme conservatism leader, like America as a whole is manic depressive. We’re more polarized as a nation than we’ve ever been before, including the lead up to the civil war.
But now politician is a career, not a duty. And people make decisions that protect their careers. So in the current world we’ll never see an alternative vote introduced giving moderate candidates a shot. We’ll never see a change to the electoral college to make it so that votes against a “safe state”’s party matters at all.
I’m not calling for unrest. Lord no, that’s against the law. All I’m saying is that there is a real risk of it happening due to the current climate, but maybe that’s not entirely a bad thing.
"And then I see the disinfectant where it knocks it out in a minute. One minute. And is there a way we can do something like that by injection inside or, or almost a cleaning? Because you see it gets on the lungs and it does a tremendous number, so it will be interesting to check that. So that you're going to have to use medical doctors.”
Your only possible argument for him not suggesting the injection of disinfectants is that it’s barely a coherent thought, like most of his brainless dribble.
But if your defense for stupid statements is that the president of the United States is illiterate, you need to take a hard look in the mirror.
Maybe it’s time for severe political unrest.