HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tcarnell

269 karma · joined July 24, 2009

Tom Carnell - CTO & Co-founder ETFmatic Ltd - UK/EU robo-adviser

Tom Carnell

submissionscomments
tcarnell··on My Email Canary
I like the idea - but please do not confuse this with security. While the canary might be activated, all of your genuine information has also been compromised.

I have thought about the security issues with gmail, especially for mobile devices (they can be easily stolen).

It would be really REALLY great if Google offered several account access levels - I could use a 'read only' account for my mobile device, which could also only give me access to the last 1 hour of emails for example. and seperate account access for use with 3rd party services (facebook, gtalk apps etc)

tcarnell··on Boot a linux kernel right inside your browser.
Awesome - so could you run a web-server from within the browser? Would it be possible to connect to an instance of jslinux remotely?
tcarnell··on JQuery 1.6.1 released...
Sorry, should have summarized changes:

1.6.1 addresses backwards compatibility issues with new 'attr()' and 'prop()' behaviour added in 1.6.

This means that code written against 1.5.2 will work 100% against 1.6.1 (this was not the case with 1.6).

So to many people this is quite an important update.

tcarnell··on Why Donald Knuth Checks E-mail Only Once Every Three Months
Email is broken and ugly. We are constantly trying to bend email to be a useful productivity tool - to me the idea of filtering emails by text found in the subject for example as a way of organizing/categorizing emails demonstrates just one of the sheer inadequacies of email.

Email is also incredibly insecure, how many people have sent emails to the wrong people? you mistype an email address, or select the wrong 'John Smith' from the address book and you've just sent top-secret confidential files outside of the company walls.

Attaching files should be a thing of the past, we should simply reference files within email text - again, much better for security because only authorized people will actually be able to access the files, rather than with attachements where all recipients (even erroneous recipients) can a). view the document, and b). very easily distribute the document to unauthorized persons.

I am astonished that corporations continue to use email as the basis for internal communication.

I really hoped that Google Wave could have killed email - or at least replaced gmail with something more useful. However, the failure of Google Wave demonstrates again that Google are not 'inventive' - they just take existing ideas/products and improve on them. shame.

...maybe the people that replace email with something appropriate will be the next Google...

tcarnell··on Techniques To Simplify Sign-Ups and Log-Ins
...so really what I am saying is that I can not think of a reason to ask for address, city, security questions, usernames etc at registration time.
tcarnell··on Techniques To Simplify Sign-Ups and Log-Ins
From my experience of building web applications only two pieces of information are EVER required at registration time:

1). Email address - unlikely to be forgotten and is useful, ie you can then contact the user

2). Password - so the user can access the site. And I agree, dont ask twice for this, as long as you have a password reset feature.

Any further information can be obtained once the user is inside the system - and full explainations can be given as to why particular information is required.

And never use captcha! There are a millions tricks that you can employ to avoid bots.

tcarnell··on Google Trends shows sudden decline for Google.com
seems to have happened across other google sites too:

http://www.google.com/trends?q=google.co.uk%2C+google.es%2C+...

tcarnell··on What are some startup ideas that persistently fail?
...what is a search engine if not a recommender of content?
tcarnell··on What are some startup ideas that persistently fail?
I would have said that Microsoft Excel does a pretty good job at making programming easy for non-programmers - spreadsheets are also one of the first ever computer desktop applications.

However, I do believe that the Drupals and Joomlas of the world wont be around for long - I dont ask an electrician to wire-up my house and do it in a way that I can maintain/alter the system in the future without expertise.

tcarnell··on What are some startup ideas that persistently fail?
Essential reading: http://www.paulgraham.com/ideas.html :-)
tcarnell··on What are some startup ideas that persistently fail?
There is a difference between a bad 'idea' and a bad implementation of an idea.

Early search engines were pretty bad (Lycos, Altavista etc) - why? because the idea was bad, or the implementation was bad?

I would say that if all dating sites fail in the same way then maybe there is a brilliant opportunity to build one that works...which is what google did with search engines.

tcarnell··on Osama bin Laden Is Dead
- ETA, Spain: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ETA_attacks
tcarnell··on Simple algorithms
Nice! Great idea for a site - actually, I kinda had a similar idea when I registered "algolution.com" - the idea being to have a library of algorithms AND people can add implementations in different languages and of course vote up which are the best.

In addiation I had thought to add a 'live run' feature so that you could actually run 1 or more algorithms together and compare performance/memory usage etc!

hmmm... if we defined an API for running a piece of code and returning results, we could build a series of independant web applications that could run sandboxed code in different languages live on the web...

tcarnell··on Ubuntu Unity usability testing results and analysis
Great post! I started using Ubuntu Unity on my netbook, however, I had first installed Ubuntu Desktop and added Unity later so I can switch between them at loging time.

I think that Unity is great! Really encapsulates the spirit of a netbook - a small, versatile and fun communications device. I have an asus 1005pe - which I can also highly recommend.

tcarnell··on The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race
well if you sampled the 6 billion people in the world, yes, rich people drink alcohol.

I think its a bit like saying 'rich people drive Ferraris' - yes, of course! having a lot of disposable income will obviously lead to the ability to purchase luxury, non-essential items like alcohol.

tcarnell··on The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race
good point - of course I absolutely believe humans (as well as every other living thing on Earth) as still evolving. And of course evolution happens all the time, with every generation evolution must be happening. And I've written genetic algorithms to find solutions to problems so I know that evolution is not intrinsically a slow process.

My point really was that evolutionary changes in these time-scales are very unlikey to significantly affect society (changing to agriculture etc).

Thanks for the response and the great links!

tcarnell··on The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race
Just to clarify, 'evolution' is the process of change that takes many, many millions of years - time frames of 15,000 years are not evolution.

As Ricky Gervais once desribed, in evolutionary terms, modern man is still equviliant to a shaved chimp!

tcarnell··on The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race
If we take 'happiness' to be the fitness function of human evolution and a driver for adaption then I think it highly unlikey humans would ever change to become less happy. Infact, I might suggest that human happiness (amount of) is likely to be the one thing in common to modern civilizations as to those 200,000 years ago.

In addition, be careful to use the word 'evolution' with timeframes as miniscule as 200,000 years - the author correctly uses the word 'adoption'.

tcarnell··on [dead]
Regarding design, I would add Donald Norman's The Design of Everyday things - entertaining and you wont look at the world the same way again!
tcarnell··on StripeSpotter, open source barcode scanner for Zebra's and other animals
Nice - could also have a Tartan scanner (to identify Scottish clans) or a tree trunk scanner to age a tree, or a wood grain scanner to identify different types of wood...
tcarnell··on World's Most Admired Companies
Yeah, I remember my mum telling me years ago about Nestle and their various practises in Africa - outrageous. One of the least ethical companies I've ever heard of. But lots of big companies have questionable ethical practices (Shell, Apple, GlaxoSmithKline)...
tcarnell··on World's Most Admired Companies
...and where's BP? :-)
tcarnell··on World's Most Admired Companies
Interesting to Nestle there:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nestl%C3%A9_boycott#The_baby_mi...

(thanks for posting)

tcarnell··on Ask HN: Which language should I use to build a Desktop app these days?
Thanks! Yeah, Mono looks like a great solution - it's wining so far!
tcarnell··on Ask HN: Which language should I use to build a Desktop app these days?
That sounds like a great idea - I use the desktop Yammer app, which is an AIR application, but it doesn't seem very stable or have a rich UI - would this approach have other limitations like being 'sandboxed' (not being able to read/write files etc)?
tcarnell··on Ask HN: Which language should I use to build a Desktop app these days?
Can I use scripting languages like Ruby or Python? Is this a good idea?
tcarnell··on Enabling the real-time web with LiveDirectory.org (an early release)
Thanks for the extra-reading, I will definately take a look at those.

However, I will add that the whole 'pubsubhubbub' thing is very unfriendly (including the silly name) for the people that would be it's most valuable users, ie the people that are generating interesting, novel and valuable online content...

...So in addition to the fact that LiveDirectory is already up and running and working with JSON as the data language, it also aims to make life as easy as possible for BOTH the content publishers AND application developers.

Actually, I see think that LiveDirectory is only an intermediate step until website generally get more 'interactive'. What would be cool is to have a standard like:

http://somewebsite.com/services.json (or services.xml)

whereby the 'services.json' file would describe what 'actions' and 'data' is available programatically ('search', 'subscribe', 'contact details', 'product catalog' etc).

ch, I really appreciate the feedback, this is exactly why I posted this on HN! Please don't think of my response as being in anyway aggressive or defensive :-)

tcarnell··on Enabling the real-time web with LiveDirectory.org (an early release)
Thanks for the question!

I think that PubSubHubbub is mainly for integration with feeds (RSS, ATOM etc) - correct me if I'm wrong! So the PubSubHubbub is somewhat restricted. So I would say the difference between PubSubHubbub and LiveDirectory is that with LiveDirectory the data that is passed around is JSON, which means that:

1). It can be almost limitless in its structure (using combinations of objects, arrays, string, numbers and booleans) - RSS & Atom have very fixed data structures, so if you want to represent some other data structure, for example a client list, your latest special offers or your company office addresses you're out of luck.

2). JSON data is often far easier to parse and process than XML, so the callback notifications are much more 'developer friendly'.

tcarnell··on Enabling the real-time web with LiveDirectory.org (an early release)
I built LiveDirectory.org as a first attempt at providing a real and practical way for anybody to publish and manage their own content so that application developers can easily build real-time, event-driven web applications.

LiveDirectory aims to implement a WebHook style system, but with a real and practical application that is designed to be used, and be useful.

LiveDirectory is currently at a very early stage of development, but I am most interested to see what the HackerNews community think of the general idea...

tcarnell··on Wiki for tools to scrape website data
Nice project! You might cQuery useful for more complex content extraction:

http://cquery.com/

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →