264 karma · joined February 19, 2016
I buy a few years used and drive it until it's either not dependable, maintenance is too expensive, or parts availability is a problem.
That's too reductive.
The WSJ cannot "forget to mention" a manuscript that wasn't published when their original articles came out.
The manuscript in question, an observational study, shows that Theranos has higher variation than standard labs for some tests, and that those tests are those that someone familiar with the field might suspect that a finger prick might have higher variation (e.g., lymphocytes).
The power of this manuscript is limited (in part because of Theranos not actively participating in peer-reviewed science like it's peers), but at a high level, it would hint that a physician sending a patient out for some particular labs would be wise to apply extra scrutiny to those lab values if the testing was by Theranos.
For the engineering PhD programs (chemical, biomedical, electrical, and mechanical) I'm familiar with at (what was once termed) Carnegie R1 universities, the split ends up being around 50/50 for academia vs industry track after graduation. For bio at the same schools, I saw the same as you, near unity for academia. Of my engineering PhD cohort, I was the only 1 of 14 who founded a startup.
So on that first paragraph, are they implying that the journal should have provided Theranos with a copy of the manuscript for review and comment? Maybe I'm not reading that charitably, but that's not how the system works, and I don't think scolding the journal (page 3) over manuscript decisions is an appropriate response.
The second paragraph is strikes me as a bit rich considering the reputation Theranos has for secrecy. As best I can tell, they still haven't published the more detailed information on their technology that they promised when the WSJ first broke the story?
Were I the editor, I think my response might be along the lines of "you raise some excellent points, and so we invite you to submit a research manuscript for accelerated review".
Interesting. What mechanism or phenomenon are you proposing would be happening? Why do you think sampling order has more influence than the sample method (venipuncture v. finger prick)?
> Further, when the baseline (i.e. other labs) also have varying results, its fair to call into question the whole study.
Why? That's an expected outcome when dealing with multiple testing labs.
I was in the alpha and had to delete it from my phone, it was too addictive. It's disappointing to hear that they're having money troubles, their game is pretty unique and deserves a better fate.
I'm in the latter category and to this day I can't safely drive in most cars with a sunroof. Things have improved a lot over the last 20 years or so: it used to be I couldn't fit into any sedan less than full-size, whereas now many sedans other than subcompact are okay.
For the second part, it is standard advice from the granting organizations themselves to contact whomever is overseeing the solicitation (for DoD, they're the "topic author") to establish a good working relationship. Does someone who has a previous history have an advantage? Yes, in the same way that a SV startup founder with prior experience has an advantage seeking funding for a new venture.
For the first part, SBIR/STTR emphasize research, and a PhD (or equivalent degree) is the standard academic research qualification. Teams having technical members without PhDs but with significant domain experience are funded all the time. You're right that having research credentials is necessary, but it's not in itself sufficient. If I put together an application for an area in which I have no prior research experience and no preliminary data, I would expect my application to not be scored.
> In other words: Not a single Silicon Valley college dropout or "college-interruptus" need apply as the process seemed to exhibit favoritism towards members of the aforementioned club.
I don't see it as favoritism, I see it as a mismatch in experience and expectations. My "research currency" (PhD, publication record, patents, grantsmanship experience) isn't worth much if I were wanting to work at a SV startup because I don't have a GitHub account (or so I am led to believe). The kind of currency that an SBIR/STTR values naturally tends to be held by people with PhDs (or equivalent).
It's also important to remember that SBIR/STTRs are highly competitive. A few years ago, I applied to an SBIR from the NCI that ended up funding 1% of applicants that cycle!
In context, those numbers don't feel that big to me.
SV has its own jargon, and not being from SV, I think it's fair to want to clarify what is meant by a capitalized phrase like "Hard Tech" in case there is a deeper meaning known to those inside SV.
I don't think that's fair, unless ornamentation isn't considered a "use". Gold is pretty close to ideal for a primitive (and contemporary) jeweler/artisan because it's atypically easy to work with: it can take intricate detailing, it takes a high polish, it doesn't tarnish, it has a pleasing unusual color and unusual density, and it's forgiving (can be melted down). If gold were as common as dirt, it'd still be a preferred medium for ornamental purposes.
I think it's a gross oversimplification to state that the avionics software is developed in C/C++: the avionics software is using a subset of C and/or C++, along with support tools, system engineering models, code reviews, V&V, etc. As I see it, there isn't that much difference on this sort of project if one were to use Ada or Java instead of C or C++: the support tools may be somewhat simpler, but the overwhelming majority of the SDLC activity remains unchanged.
I'm not clear what causes this radar system defect, I didn't see it described in the source article, but a defect in design (for example) would seem likely to occur regardless of the programming language selected.
Also, I'm curious to hear what your proposed alternative would be and why?
The majority of defense contractors I know don't spend time in the "programming community" in their off hours, both because it's contractually too cumbersome to do so, and because they're doing other things in their spare time. They may spend time in the "defense community". It's very different culturally from SV.
> just because I don't use node js, ruby, or perl in my work doesnt mean i have an excuse to not know that they even exist. how can you choose the best tool for a job if you only know C++ and Ada?
node.js, ruby, and perl are not acceptable for use on real-time systems nor safety-critical systems.