HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tellsomething

-2 karma · joined January 3, 2024

submissionscomments
tellsomething··on U.S. cities opt to ditch their off-street parking minimums
I will read the article later on, only skimmed it.

I don't trust the numbers though.

I've noticed in my area that companies congregate near their nexus. Attorneys will get an office near the tribunal, accountants near the IRS building, etc. Also, big companies will set their headquarters in the state capital but earn money from all over the place.

This makes it seem like the capital "makes" all the money though it's actually just fiscally declared in that place.

I suspect that chart shows the same thing. Eg. perhaps the gutters may not be covered from the home tax, but that person goes to work someplace, spends money elsewhere and maybe has a company registered elsewhere in the city.

Though, I do agree that overinvesting may happen for infrastructure. I don't buy it though that, for example, suburbs are inherently a subsidy.

tellsomething··on U.S. cities opt to ditch their off-street parking minimums
> One can like one tradeoff more than the other, but the fact that infrastructure means subsidy, and that urbanism choices are picking some people's interests over others is just factual.

You do have a point.

But, do you think cities prosper in spite of this subsidy? It seems like an investment that pays off in second error effects. I mean, why aren't cities without infrastructure growing like mad? Because it's not possible and cities with infrastructure outcompete them.

Only way to make this work is if you outright ban infrastructure and then make competition impossible in that domain.

tellsomething··on U.S. cities opt to ditch their off-street parking minimums
It will sure do great to inflation when your plumber has to take the bus and instead of having 5 customers per day only has 2.
tellsomething··on U.S. cities opt to ditch their off-street parking minimums
Seems silly to think infrastructure means subsidising. Why don't you switch to dial up so that all the cables underneath the ocean can be slowly removed in order not to bother wild life over there?

But really, your whole life is sustained by providers driving. Taxes in the city comes from humans being able to physically move their bodies to the right location.

I mean, wouldn't it be ideal to get all the benefits of a complex industrial society without a complex industry? It sure would.