HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tenthirtyam

129 karma · joined May 26, 2021

submissionscomments
tenthirtyam··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
My expectation is that there'll never be a single bust-up moment, no line-in-the-sand beyond which we'll be able to say "it doesn't work anymore."

Instead agent written code will get more and more complex, requiring more and more tokens (& NPU/GPU/RAM) to create/review/debug/modify, and will rapidly pass beyond any hope of a human understanding even for relatively simple projects (e.g. such as a banking app on your phone).

I wonder, however, whether the complexity will grow slower or faster than Moore's law and our collective ability to feed the AIs.

tenthirtyam··on Review of 1984 by Isaac Asimov (1980)
One of my most fascinating reads of all time was "Brave New World Revisited" (1950s I think), a follow-up of "Brave New World" (1920s I think) by Aldous Huxley. Similarly, the point then was how the mass media and TV would eventually be used to mislead and deflect populations' attentions.

Such innocent times when we thought the TV could be evil.

tenthirtyam··on A list of fun destinations for telnet
I just checked and ancient.anguish.org is still online. Port 2222.
tenthirtyam··on Are two heads better than one?
What if, in the event of a tie (just Alice & Bob), we always decide to trust Alice. Would that not improve our probability of guessing the tie correctly, i.e. back to 80% success?
tenthirtyam··on Quill OS: An open-source OS for Kobo's eReaders
I bought a kobo for myself about 18months ago and I'm hooked. I have since bought two more for gifts and 3 friends have bought them on my recommendation. I have never before been such a vocal (if unintentional) ambassador for a tech gadget.

Why so passionate, I hear you ask? Pretty much exactly the reasons you specify - unlike other hardware, I actually can do what I want with it.

And now I'm wondering what this Quill OS is about. Thanks Kobo!

tenthirtyam··on Coffee linked to slower biological ageing among those with severe mental illness
Hmm, sorta similar for me except my normal is only one cup per day. Every now and than (say every few months), I get up to two, then soon three cups per day and I start getting migraine. Then I think to myslf, "boy, I gotta quit coffee forever", and so I do. Then I get headaches from withdrawal, but that only lasts a few days. Typically, I stay off coffee forever for about two or three weeks, and the cycle repeats.

So... if you want to cut back, just persevere for a few days of no coffee. The statistics don't lie.*

* sample size = 1

tenthirtyam··on Trains cancelled over fake bridge collapse image
I also think not a hope, check Brandolini's law[1]: The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law

tenthirtyam··on GrapheneOS is the only Android OS providing full security patches
I'm not knowledgeable enough -- what would it take to escape the Apple/Google duopoly?

I'm imagining a future where you buy a smartphone and when you do the first configuration, it asks you which services provider you want to use. Google and Apple are probably at the top of the list, but at the bottom there is "custom..." where you can specify the IP or host.domain of your own self-hosted setup.

Then, when you download an app, the app informs the app provider of this configuration and so your notifications (messenger, social media, games, banking, whatever) get delivered to that services provider and your phone gets them from there accordingly.

Is there anything like that in the world today?

tenthirtyam··on All the Way Down
This seems the most concise and precise answer to the question of "why". At some stage, somehow, self replicating molecules appeared in the primordial soup*. Everything since then has just been improvements (or maybe complete overhauls) to that process.

*How (or why) this step occurred is another intriguing topic.

tenthirtyam··on Self-hosting a Matrix server for 5 years
IIRC it is possible to have some clever encryption so that the person you sent your message to can prove to their own satisfaction that it came from you, but they cannot prove to anyone else that it came from you. Which gives you plausible deniability; you can always claim that your contact forged the message.

Can't remember what the algorithm is called.

tenthirtyam··on All praise to the lunch ladies
> raw cucumber, lettuce and tomatoes on the side of a plate

Jeepers, I love a plain salad - no salt, no vinegar, nothing at all added is fine. Maybe a little olive oil but no problem without it. It's all about what you're used to.

We (self, wife, children) stopped adding salt to our cooking years ago - pasta, rice, potatoes are cooked without salt and they taste fine. As you might expect, when some people eat at our place I stare in impolite amazement as they empty the salt shaker onto their plate and, on the other hand, when I eat elsewhere the food is sometimes so salty as to be barely palatable for me.

tenthirtyam··on Palisades Fire suspect's ChatGPT history to be used as evidence
Just wait until AI is advanced enough that you can buy an AI best friend who will be with you all your life. I'm reminded of Decker's AI hologram friend in Blade Runner 2049. The only thing they got wrong was she was not collecting data for the megacorp.

Thinking again, the AI will certainly be "free".

tenthirtyam··on Vertical Solar Panels Are Out Standing
Biggest disadvantage is that we don't have central heating during powercut - would require more invasive rewiring and more power than I care to draw from inverter with single battery. But gathering around wood stove and telling stories by candlelight is nice, eh?
tenthirtyam··on Vertical Solar Panels Are Out Standing
I have a rebranded kstar inverter which has a "backup" output and I had the electrician wire that output to 6 sockets around the house for fridge, well water pump, and internet connectivity. When the grid is on, the backup is fed by the grid. When the grid goes off, the panels deactivate and the backup is instantly (like a UPS) powered from the 5kWh battery. I can then manually switch off the grid connection to the inverter and re-activate the panels. It should be enough for backup loads more-or-less continuously although I should buy a better fridge and a winter storm might need us to reduce water consumption and disconnect internet.
tenthirtyam··on Four-year wedding crasher mystery solved
Maybe more like dialects of Latin? :-)
tenthirtyam··on Standard Thermal: Energy Storage 500x Cheaper Than Batteries
That's a fair question and I've not done the math. Does "overall cost" include long term usage - I suppose it does or it wouldn't be "total".

For example, I spent a bunch of money to install solar panels, house insulation, and soon a heat pump. They each have, respectively, about 9 year, 30 year and probably 15 year payback time at today's energy prices, so depending on lifespan and future energy prices it's an open question if it would've been cheaper just to stay as I was.

But there's the comfort factor (heat pump should regularize house temps) and security factor (still warm & cosy during a power cut). I'll allow myself a little feel-good factor of carbon emission reduction too. Maybe these can also apply to the question of using a heat-pump in the dirt-as-thermal-storage scenario here.

I suppose overall I'm of the mind we should be collectively treating carbon emissions as the highest priority and using a heat pump here might aid that?

tenthirtyam··on Standard Thermal: Energy Storage 500x Cheaper Than Batteries
Oh! You're right, I hadn't realized. But... wouldn't it be more efficient with a heat pump and exploit the 2-4x COP? Ok, maybe I get it now: heat pump wouldn't work at the high temps they are achieving. Thx.
tenthirtyam··on Standard Thermal: Energy Storage 500x Cheaper Than Batteries
I really can't help but think there might be a fundamental problem here. If heat loss in dirt is so incredibly slow, and we use a heat pump to extract that heat, then wouldn't it be equally slow to replace the heat extracted? (absent heat injection, i.e. reversing the heat pump's operation in summer)

Has anyone looked at the subsurface ground temperatures after days, weeks, months, even years of heat pump operation?

I do seem to remember seeing one article on the subject showing that after one winter the subsurface temperature had declined enough to materially affect the heat pump's COP. But the timescale didn't extend to multiple years.

edit: found this one: https://pangea.stanford.edu/ERE/db/GeoConf/papers/SGW/2024/M...

In one of eight cases studied where heat flow is unidirectional (cooling load only) over a 20 year timescale the authors find:

  "the mean ground temperature ... increased from 21.87 °C to 26.18 °C, ... . This significant rise could have a potential impact on the performance of the system in the later years of its operational life."
The other 7 cases showed weaker or negligible long term variation.

An additional graph shows COP variation over 15 years and the worst case shows a decline of perhaps 10% (just eyeballing it).

Surprisingly, some cases showed a long term improvement in heating COP - presumably the injection of summer heat into the soil made for warmer soil than just sunshine and natural diffusion?

So my takeaway: "it depends." :-)

tenthirtyam··on 36B solar mass black hole at centre of the Cosmic Horseshoe gravitational lens
Interesting. Given that the horseshoe shape is due to gravitational lensing of one far off galaxy ~19 Gly away by another "only" 6 Gly away, wouldn't that mean that any motion of those galaxies, or our galaxy, would realign the lensing and alter the shape of the horseshoe?

So... how long before we see the shape change? How fast do galaxies move anyway?

tenthirtyam··on How to trigger a command on Linux when power switches from AC to battery
Shouldn't we programmers be just typing "++"?
tenthirtyam··on Graphene OS: a security-enhanced Android build
I can understand the GOS' rationale in choosing only the most secure phones. However, I'm more concerned about privacy, and not so much about security. It'd be great to have something like a "GOS-Lite" which accepts some security compromises in order to bring privacy to more people. (And yes, I understand that lower security means less privacy from targeted attacks but even GOS depends on OEM blobs, right?)
tenthirtyam··on What happens when housing prices go down?
In Ireland, politicians (make appearances of) are making a lot of noise about building more houses to address the severe shortage of housing supply (and consequent runaway house price inflation). However, my take is that the root of the problem is exactly what the author here describes, to wit, the minimum housing a person can buy is (for the most part) a semi-detached two- or two-and-a-half-bedroom* house on two floors. There are precious few one-bedroom apartments or anything similar on the market, meaning that single persons entering the market are competing with couples or young families.

I don't understand the details but I'm told the origin of this is that regulations have rendered apartments of any size unprofitable to build (anyone with more insight here?). Pretty much the only housing Ireland gets are sprawling suburban housing estates. I'm reminded of this graphic, 100 houses Vs 100 apartments [1].

* By 2½ bedrooms I mean two bedrooms plus a very small "box room" barely big enough for a single bed and a small wardrobe. Frequently used as either a storage room or small home office.

[1] https://i.pinimg.com/originals/78/f5/94/78f594ebb9216e50e396...

tenthirtyam··on Staying cool without refrigerants: Next-generation Peltier cooling
Ah, you've discovered the Built-in Orderly Organised Knowledge device [1]. Juse wait until you dicover PENCILS!

[1] https://cool.culturalheritage.org/byorg/abbey/an/an21/an21-8...

tenthirtyam··on Problems the AI industry is not addressing adequately
You'd need to define "comprehension" - it's a bit like the Chinese room / Turing test.

If an AI or AGI can look at a picture and see an apple, or (say) with an artificial nose smell an apple, or likewise feel or taste or hear* an apple, and at the same identify that it is an apple and maybe even suggest baking an apple pie, then what else is there to be comprehended?

Maybe humans are just the same - far far ahead of the state of the tech, but still just the same really.

*when someone bites into it :-)

For me, what AI is missing is genuine out-of-the-box revolutionary thinking. They're trained on existing material, so perhaps it's fundamentally impossible for AIs to think up a breakthrough in any field - barring circumstances where all the component parts of a breakthrough already exist and the AI is the first to connect the dots ("standing on the shoulders of giants" etc).

tenthirtyam··on Judge rejects Meta's claim that torrenting is “irrelevant” in AI copyright case
I'm inclined to agree here. LLMs do not use just a paragraph here and there in accordance with fair use, but rather uses the entire body of work to train itself.

Or am I misunderstanding something about LLMs?

tenthirtyam··on Interstellar Flight: Perspectives and Patience
Indeed. It's a certainty that Mars is far far less hospitable than Earth even in the worst of the climate change outcomes. I suppose the most useful thing about colonizing Mars would be for species survival - e.g. the Giant-Asteroid-Strikes-the-Earth-but-luckily-not-Mars scenario.

In any case, a nearby planet or its orbit would seem to be the most logical place to start for any supervillain species seeking to colonize its galaxy. :-)

tenthirtyam··on Interstellar Flight: Perspectives and Patience
Like "Rendezvous with Rama" by Arthur C Clarke: A mysterious cylindrical spaceship arrives at planet Earth from outer space.
tenthirtyam··on Interstellar Flight: Perspectives and Patience
I recently read "Delta-v" and the sequel "Critical Mass: A Novel" by Daniel Suarez. They're very much fiction but there is a certain amount of science underpinning the arguments and I enjoyed that aspect. And the author even states that he's trying to get across, with solid arguments, why humanity should begin planning asteroid mining ASAP. In brief, the arguments are:

Firstly we're now at a point where we have lots of cheap energy available, principally chemical. Depending on many factors it's conceivable that we are in fact at or near peak human energy output (e.g. WW3 or civilization collapse - the next iteration of civilization won't have so much cheap oil to exploit).

Secondly LEO is not yet full of junk, meaning that it's trivial to find launch windows to LEO and beyond. That could easily change very much for the worse in a relatively short time (I infer decades from the books).

Finally it's unrealistic to expect us to colonize the Moon or Mars using only Earth-mined materials. You can launch a spacecraft to Mars easily, but to launch a small city's amount of construction equipment and raw materials is beyond our capabilities.

Conclusion: now is the best time to mine asteroids. We can do all of the processing and much of the construction in LEO (or even better at Earth-Moon or Earth-Sun lagrange points) and then, with relatively low delta-v, we'd actually have a chance of becoming an interplanetary species!

But, the novels warn, the window of opportunity will eventually ("soon") close. Well worth the read.

Maybe someone else more familiar with the arguments, who has also read these novels, can offer a critique?

tenthirtyam··on Octobass
The interwebz once told me that the human eye resonates at 19Hz or so, which apparently when triggered is very useful for inducing a sense of fear.
tenthirtyam··on WhatsApp introduces ads in its app
I had this problem some years ago. Eventually I just told everyone I would be uninstalling whatsapp on date XX/YY, which I then did. Some people installed signal and stayed in touch, others didn't. Life didn't change much. Now I'd like to move to my own matrix server but I think appx 0.0% of my social group would follow me down that rabbit hole. :-(

More extreme, a friend of mine one day eliminated his cellphone entirely but kept Skype on his laptop. So now it's email or nothing with him and sadly it's been nothing for some time now.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →