HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

terra_t

990 karma · joined February 9, 2010

submissionscomments
terra_t··on Why I feel like a fraud
I was talking with a professor about my work on the bus last night and mentioned that having faith in what I'm doing is what makes me possible to do it.

He shared that he's a born-again Christian and he's thought about faith is important in what he does, since you've never got any guarantee that a research project is going to be successful.

I'm a pagan, so I like the Japanese word "Haruhi" which means "full of spirit." (It's been popularized in the U.S. by a post-modern recent anime which I can't decide if I like or not.) But it's an important thing. For the idea I'm working on, I find that being "Haruhi" makes me invincible... I used to be a terribly anxious person but I believe in what I'm doing so much that nothing bothers me.

Quite funny, my business plan from the very beginning assumed that the system I was building would soon become more than the sum of it's parts, but I was quite amazed to see it happen... For me it's a miracle.

terra_t··on Immigration for Startups
Why not conduct your business in Canada or, alternatively, try hiring a few of the millions of U.S. citizens that are out of work?
terra_t··on What if We Gave Toddlers an 'F' in Walking? (Why Math & Science Ed is Absurd)
There's some truth in that (creative destruction and all) but we've also seen an incredible concentration of wealth from about 1980 onward. Much of this has gone to people working in just a few industries, such as finance and law.

What we've seen is an expansion of the bottom and the top and a "hollowing out" at the middle. The system of private retirement accounts based on 401K and IRA accounts has largely failed. The largest asset that many in the baby boom generation will have in their retirement will be their Medicare benefits.

The ultimate interpretation of the financial crisis is that the financial sector is currently unable to match capital with places where it can be invested properly. The power that this sector has over government and the culture of impunity surrounds it makes it possible that this situation will stretch on for another 10 to 30 years.

Sure, failing industries in the recession are going to create a few opportunities for people to do amazing things in the next 10 years or so, but look for rapid advances in A.I. to essentially wipe out white collar work within 20 years.

terra_t··on What if We Gave Toddlers an 'F' in Walking? (Why Math & Science Ed is Absurd)
From a systemantic perspective, the "purpose of a system is what it does" not what it says it does.

A large number of people are chasing a small (and decreasing) number of good opportunities so a major function of education is to weed people out and make them blame their failures on themselves, not to maximize the development of human talent.

We have a "meritocracy" that occasionally allows an exceptionally talented person to rise, generally allows the mediocre to inherit the status of their parents, and sometimes puts the kibosh on non-housebroken children of the elite.

Athletic coaching tends to be a lot more honest. Few of us expect to be judged on how we do in PE classes and extracurricular sports, we do it for fun, and hopefully give it our best. Good coaches work in that spirit.

Now, if you're one of the lucky people who'll go far in sports, performance is open ended (the top score isn't 100%) and, unlike schoolwork, you need unique training to develop your potential.

terra_t··on What if We Gave Toddlers an 'F' in Walking? (Why Math & Science Ed is Absurd)
The best physics class that I've seen (and that I've taught) is the Physics 101 autotutorial class. Students get three chances to take each test, but they need to get a passing grade on each unit before they move on to the next. This is contrast to the usual physics course, where the average grade on a test might be 35, but they do it on a curve so that 35 gets you a B-.

The class is aimed at premed students, and experience shows that Physics 101 students do better on the MCAT than students who take a conventional class aimed at premeds. Because it's aimed at premeds, there's a heavy dose of fluid mechanics and other subjects that often get missed in intro physics.

It's particularly fun, as a teacher, to work with students to "debug" their thought process. So often I'd hear "I understand the concepts but can't do the problem" but then once they started explaining how they tried to solve it, I'd see that they missed important concepts.

terra_t··on Why I feel like a fraud
There is no "typical entrepreneur".

If you look at wall street traders, Fortune 500 CEO's and other populations that have been through intense selection processes you'll find very homogeneous populations.

If you look at entrepreneurs, you'll find confident people, anxious people, short people, tall people, thin people, fat people -- all kinds of people. That's because entrepreneurs select themselves rather than being selected by a bunch of people who want to select other people like themselves.

terra_t··on The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
It depends on where you go. Jon Kleinberg's class on algorithms (and classes based on his book) is great. I don't think every CS student gets access to that quality of construction

As for database design, OO-design or concurrency, my experience is that you've got to spend two years or so building that kind of system before you're an asset instead of a liability. Some students might really get that much work in during their educations, but they won't all entirely.

In 1992 I took the only CS course that I've actually taken, and it was a course in comparative programming languages that introduced OO programming through Ada (a thoroughly obsolete form) and spent a lot of time on logic programming with Prolog. Now, I think Prolog is beautiful and my recent work has led me to believe that (20 years later) we're going to have to go more in that direction, the fact is that for practical purposes, Prolog is a dead end.

And then at the graduate level it's all about fads. At one top CS school there's nobody interested in the semantic web and description logics because that's all "dead stuff from ten years ago." In the engineering library at that school, I can find five units of modular shelves filled up with conference proceedings that plod endlessly about IP QoS, despite the fact that none of that has ever seen the light of day. Anybody with a pulse can think of ten or twenty other research areas that ought to be vastly more productive, but, somehow, resources never get allocated for them.

In terms of the actual needs of the workplace, what it takes to be productive ~is~ detailed knowledge of the details that are relevant now. Why are Facebook and Google having a crazy bidding war for employees (other than the fact that they've got too much capital?) -- it's because they're building stuff on a scale that nobody else is and you can't get experience building at that scale elsewhere.

terra_t··on The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
One root of the economic crisis in my mind is something like the way the game monopoly terminates -- at some point all of the money winds up in one person's hands. Some economic inequality is advantageous over no inequality (there's got to be some reward for success) but too much inequality leads to a "hard stop." We've had 30 years in which a handful of professions (finance & law particularly) have prospered while the rest of us have fallen behind. If these guys were just buying supercars, that would be one thing, but they've bought political power and made our government so ineffective that, on some days, I wonder if we'd be better off with a system like China's.

And as for being cheated, I started out my professional career with the deck stacked against me. Perhaps I was stupid to do that. Stupid to be reading Issac Asimov for a kid and to think that the child of a construction worker would have any chance to become a scientist in the 1990's.

terra_t··on The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
I've worked for a series of employers whose motto is "be as little as you can be". For instance, one place was a relatively young job shop that spent freely on cheap praise, pizza, junk food, cookies and such, but didn't want to invest in my well being or professional development in any way. (For instance, health insurance, sending me to a conference, etc.)

The general pattern is that there's a glass ceiling that you can only get through by being an entomologist, a second-rate salesperson, or whatever it is your organization values. IT isn't it.

And no, I'm not stagnating. I'm starting my own company.

As for chasing young people away, they're chasing themselves away.

So far as being angry, Americans should be getting angry -- 30 years of conservative orthodoxy have all but destroyed the American Dream. I see a lot of complaining about my position in your comment but I'm not seeing what you say the root cause is... I'd like to hear that.

terra_t··on According to the IRS you are a private contractor employed by Google
The guy's a dumbass. If you're making money off your site, it's a business, just that simple.

It does cost a few 100$ every year, but if you get income from anything other than W-2 jobs, you'd better have an accountant.

  I've definitely had little accidents in my filings and minor trouble with the IRS but my experience is that,  with the help of an accountant and some common sense,  these problems can be worked out easily
terra_t··on The irony of the US economy: no jobs and no one to hire
Rand, your post is repeating the same garbage about job training that's been universal for the past 30 years (See "The Job Training Charade" by Gordon Lafer,) with a little dash of age discrimination just so you'll fit in with the hacker news crowd. (I know a lot of people who are in their 30's, 40's and 50's who've successfully learned new skills)

Communications of the ACM has hand-wringing articles in every issue about "Why don't students want to study CS?" They never mention the elephant in the room -- that these students are hearing from computer professionals in their 30's and 40's who all of a sudden find they are working a dead end job.

There's a huge demand for inexperienced out-of-college engineers that will work for cheap (for instance, equity that probably won't materialize), not demand health insurance, and work 80 hours a week on "charge of the light brigade" projects that lack any semblance of project management. There's very little demand for experienced engineers who realize that management is full of it.

There's no educational institution that produces people with the skills it takes to develop today's web sites. Often CS graduates get a bunch of 20-year old pap about algorithms and never learn a thing about project management, modern distributed systems, and all the little details from CSS to the management of social systems. People get those skills working in the school of hard knocks, and a lot of those people (like myself) have been doing it for 15 years and we're not going to take crap from anybody.

When it comes to inequality, it's dawning on people that higher ed is part of the problem, not part of the solution. The few remaining "good" and "secure" jobs in this country are open to people who graduate (as undergraduates) from Harvard and Yale. The entrance of women into the workforce has doubled the opportunity of employers to play out their racist and classist impulses.

terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
It's not 100 trips for the same resource, it's 100 round trips for 100 ~different~ resources that are required to construct a page. Cacheing won't help, and in fact, http caching is one of the #1 obstacles in AJAX programming. People who write AJAX APIs are always using cache-busting methods to make sure that browser caches don't screw up their apps with stale data.

The GET model is acceptable for data access (unless you want to radically reduce round trips -- one answer to this is to "virtualize" the REST model and let an app ask for N chunks of data in one request) however, it's bad for data updates, where you're better off exposing operations that exposing data directly.

Security, for instance, is easier to implement if you expose operations because security rules most frequently govern state transitions: to apply security rules in purist REST, you're always having to write comparisons between the old state and the new state and you've got to test for every single possible thing that could break security, even combinations of things that would be harmless by themselves.

If a security-sensitive operation is exposed as an operation, the implementation of security rules is much more clear.

terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
You read the article? The first thing he does is call POX "level 0" and "the swamp".

Generally, real http APIs from companies like Amazon, Flickr, Twitter, etc. are POX-RPC APIs, the idea is that you're exposing operations, not data structures.

REST is a castles-in-the-air exercise in exploring the dark corners of the http specification and exposing data directly instead of exposing operations on the data.

terra_t··on Breakfast is Overrated
Let's put it this way.

If people wanted something naturally, the government and industry wouldn't have to run ads incessantly promoting it.

Personally, I've made the discovery that breakfast is the only meal of the day I can skip. By the morning, my body is adapted to running off my stored energy reserves and it's not screaming at me that I need to eat.

The fact that so many authorities are constantly screaming "eat breakfast", "eat breakfast" suggests to me that there's a hidden agenda to push breakfast foods, just like the U.S.D.A tries to push cheese on people.

terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
And if you do that you're really writing POX, with any true-REST features being fifth, sixth, and seventh wheels.

Other than systems that post documents that describe state transitions, REST is all about having an inappropriate coupling between your API and your underlying data models.

terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
Sure, there was a time he spent a lot of time building OO systems. I don't know how much time he's actually spent building ~distributed~ systems.
terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
I saw a nice example that covered the classic "bank account transfer" case. The answer was that you POST something that's like a deposit slip.

Some systems, like the Kuali accounting system, use a document-centric approach to business software. You can have a workflow that's much like a traditional paper-based system, so this can make a lot of sense. You can overlay this on top of REST to solve many of the problems that REST has, but then you end up with much of REST being just a fifth wheel.

As for ranges, lately I've been sketching up a hypertext system that has some inspiration from Ted Nelson's Xanadu system. In particular, hyperlinks can be made to and from arbitrary ranges in documents, without touching the documents directly.

You can certainly encode ranges in a URL, so something like

/conference_room_3/time_slot_7,time_slot_12

might be POSTable to

terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
I know who Martin Fowler is. I love his "Refactoring" book.

On the other hand, once you get famous, you can go around and get big $ telling people what they want to hear and you can lose your edge.

If this is representative of his work these days, he should preface it with something like "I'm not a doctor but I play one on TV"

terra_t··on The one true REST explanation
I find it hard to believe that he's built real systems that work.

Yes, "decomposing services into multiple components" works well when everything is living in the same address space, but if you want to build fast and reliable systems, minimizing round trips is important.

If I didn't have anything better to do and if I liked dealing with idiots, I'd hang my shingle as a high-priced consultant who helps "enterprises" dig their way out of the REST morass. Just last year I managed to speed up an application 100x by switching from REST to POX. In this case, the app was doing thousands of round trips for no good reason other than architectural purity.

In the real world, composite operations should be done, more or less, in transactions. For instance, in one user authentication system I've worked on, there are about ten database updates to create a new user. There really ought to be one "createUser" call that creates the user. You could probably get away with not having database transactions if you're talking to the database locally, but in a distributed app on the wider internet, you just can't expect to do ten communications in a row and have it work "reliably enough".

terra_t··on Battle of the Business Cards
It's just not interesting and informative enough.
terra_t··on An Open Letter To Business People
Why do we always hear about non-technical cofounders looking for technical co-founders, rather than the other way around?

Is this like some singles bar where 80% of the people are male?

I for one would like to find a hustler who really knows how to hustle.

terra_t··on Theoretical Physics, In Your Own Time
I don't see the problem is that there are gaps, it's that it's just too much stuff. The reason it seems spammy to me is that it's a big dump of stuff that isn't well categorized.

To really get on top of all that stuff is a huge project, and the best way you're going to do it is by solving problem sets for a few years.

From my current viewpoint, I'd pick something really specific (say, modern models of quantum black holes) and try to develop the straightest line to it. Of course, I blew 9 years getting an undergrad and grad degree so I've got that base.

terra_t··on Battle of the Business Cards
I'm just astonished at how much blatant link bait is getting voted up on HN these days. It's starting to look like Digg.
terra_t··on Theoretical Physics, In Your Own Time
Does this guy have a voting ring? Speaking as a physics PhD, this is really on the edge of blogspam.
terra_t··on Things You Should Do Immediately After Launching a Website
uhhhh... i can't believe so much blogspam is getting in here
terra_t··on Wearing a mask = being more confident.
I made it halfway through Meisner training in acting before life got in the way.

One thing I got out of it is this trick of overlaying my avatar in the virtual world with an image of somebody else, often a cartoon character.

It may sound crazy, but I gain the ability to do all kinds of things that I wouldn't do otherwise: for instance, my most powerful character greatly increases my animal charm and also my functional (physical) flexibility. (mostly because she can play through the pain) Unfortunately she's not a very nice person in she's got high blood pressure.

terra_t··on Sears Randomly Has Awesome Zombie Catalog
the people at the Sears by me (the shoppers and the workers) look like this everyday.

i remember the time I bought four tires and the guy who sold them to me was struggling with the cash register. he only charged me for one tire and argued vociferously when I pointed out his mistake -- i'm honest but i'm not all that assertive so in the end I got three tires free.

of course, the manager of the auto center at that Sears also always had his Camaro jacked up and was working on it whenever he had free time.

terra_t··on Protect Your Site with a Blackhole for Bad Bots
I've worked at two places that did this.

One place was run with an iron fist by the meanest physicist on the planet, a guy who eats nails for breakfast and always asks the toughest question at the seminar. His attitude was "delete 'em all and let got sort 'em out"

The other place was my own personal network of websites, where I was trying to keep spam-harvesting robots from getting my email address. I had a process that had several steps to protect the page that had my address on it, one of which was a 'tripwire' which would instantly block any stupid robot that followed one of the hidden link.

I can say that I've gone for years without getting any email complains about difficulties reading my email address ;-)

terra_t··on Ask HN: What is so special in working for Facebook?
I've had people try to offer me stock options in the kind of companies that would never go public too. It's a very popular option for shady businesspeople with M.B.A.'s.
terra_t··on Ramen May Lead to Chronic Illness Study Says
I think of myself as Rocky Bilboa making a comeback.

I've got to go up against you punks and win, so I train hard and watch my diet.

And who's to say what's natural? The withering muscles of a pencil-necked geek who sits in front of a computer all day and into the night? Or the massive frame of my brother-in-law who works on a road crew?

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →