HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

terracatta

1,314 karma · joined March 1, 2011

CEO of Kolide, creator of honest.security

Twitter: @jmeller Github: terracatta

submissionscomments
terracatta··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (November 2021)
Kolide | Multiple Positions | Remote | Full-time | C, C++, Objective-C, Golang, Ruby, Rails

Kolide enables organizations to achieve their security and compliance goals by practicing the tenets of https://honest.security. Instead of locking down devices, Kolide enables teams to communicate their organization’s security recommendations using Slack. Tailored notifications enable them to fix serious problems that cannot be fixed with automation alone, while educating their employees at the same time.

We recently raised a Series B and looking to increase our engineering capabilities. Positions include Endpoint Specialist, Endpoint Engineer, and Full-Stack Rails Engineer.

Our current head-count is 8 FTE so this is a great opportunity to get involved in a startup that has PMF but with nearly a guaranteed outcome of having a massive impact on the business.

* More about us here: https://angel.co/company/kolideco

* Jobs information here: https://angel.co/company/kolideco/jobs

* Email: jobs@kolide.co

terracatta··on Ruby removed “Participants will be tolerant of opposing views” from its CoC
It sounds like you attended a poorly run conference that was not able to accommodate your disability and still refused to accommodate you after you were forced to self-advocate

All conferences I've been to are good about offering suggestions for near-by childcare or even on-site child care for all parents. If that wasn't offered, that's more evidence the conference wasn't run well. It's not appropriate to have a 1 year old babbling over a speaker giving a presentation and the organizers should have quietly spoke to the person caring for the child and removed them from the situation.

I don't think that has anything to do with CoCs.

terracatta··on Why Firefox has been in decline for 12 years
> You succeed by giving users what they want, not telling them what they should want

This closing statement is missing so much context that it's misleading.

When you have more than a handful of users, their wants will eventually conflict, often directly. (Ex: Tabs on top vs Tabs on Bottom). Other times a majority of users will ask for things that provide fleeting short-term benefit but in the long-term could kill your product (ex: We need Flash support on Firefox Mobile). Telemetry and research helps you consider the needs of a silent majority, but it can alienate the vocal minority that proselytize your product. To appease both, you need to come up with a clear vision, validate it's right, and then ruthlessly steer your product toward it.

If there is a vision for Firefox, I don't know what it is. So why, as a user, should accept Firefox's many faults today when Mozilla has failed to paint a clear picture of tomorrow?

terracatta··on Firefox to regularly nag users to change their default browser
I think this zero-sum game thinking, where Firefox is either the default browser or it isn't, is antiquated.

While I'm not necessarily representative of a broader population, I find that I prefer different web browsers based on what I want to do in my browser.

For example, I really like Safari for shopping because of its first class support for Apple Pay on my Mac. I just tap my finger on the sensor, and I'm done.

When I use Google Meet, Safari doesn't work great, so I will boot up Brave or Chrome.

For reasons that are unclear to me, Firefox renders pages with extremely rich and bright colors that jump right off the page. So I love using Firefox for browsing pages with a lot of photos or interesting graphic design.

Apps like https://www.choosyosx.com have helped make workflows like the above a bit easier, but are far from perfect. I wonder if there is a place for Mozilla to explore a way to make the UX for multiple browser vendors even better. I think many people would love to have Firefox as their default browser for 80 - 90% of the web, but not 100%.

terracatta··on Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Instagram for children [pdf]
Youtube is designed to extend engagement beyond the intended initial video the user wanted to view.

Beyond a basic rating system with parental controls, the algorithm does not care if the videos are inappropriate for children. Given enough time with a child, the algorithm will lead them down a rabbit hole where they eventually reach strange videos portraying their favorite fictional characters in vaguely sexualized situations, or videos containing anti-science propaganda and/or promotion of harmful conspiracy theories.

Allowing young children to use YouTube unsupervised is demonstrably a bad idea.

terracatta··on Software development is a loser’s game
This is the type of practical experienced based advice that was missing from the original post.

I completely agree with you.

terracatta··on Software development is a loser’s game
> If we invert software development, the goal isn’t then to write code that works, it’s spending time on avoiding writing poor quality code and bugs.

This line is packaged to sound really insightful, but is it?

The goal of software development is to create software in support of some greater mission. That mission might be to make someone's life easier, to make money, to advance human knowledge, or many other things.

If I write no software today, I've also written no new bugs. But have I made any progress toward achieving the mission?

Feels like this person is very frustrated with novice engineers writing buggy code and has assumed a gatekeeper role to protect the integrity of the codebases in which he holds responsibility. It may be a necessary role at his organization, but I just don't agree with the cynical and depressing message.

terracatta··on Crystal 1.0 – What to expect
I love the idea of Crystal but I remember reading that compilation times can balloon very quickly for moderately sized apps.

Can anyone who writes Crystal today dispel or confirm that information? I imagine the inferred typing makes building a fast compiler really tough.

terracatta··on jQuery 3.6.0
I write a lot of B2B apps that have tabular data views. For all of its quirks, DataTables (https://datatables.net) does a great job and with the right plugins offers all the features my customers expect (re-ordering/resizing columns, column based search, fixed headers, fixed columns, item selection, etc.) DataTables requires jQuery.

Lots of other vanilla JS table plugins out there but I can't find one with all of those features that work when they are all on.

terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
> It doesn't really change the point, though, because this isn't a bypass or flaw in the encryption system

But it does. If what you stated earlier was actually the truth, then FileVault would be enabled on far more devices and your point about the post not really being as big of a deal as we are trumping it up to be would have some merit.

If we had written a blog post saying "Data on Encrypted iPhones can be trivially accessed unless a passcode is enabled", I would agree with your point because...

1) There is no historic context that Passcodes and encryption were considered the same thing.

2) There are no tools that confuse the differences between a passcode being set and encryption being on.

3) It is extremely difficult to set up an iPhone today without a passcode.

But none of those things are true on the Mac. Back in reality, a significant number of devices set up by organizations do not have FileVault enabled by default. Once you take that new fact into consideration and add the facts conveyed in the linked blog post and multiply it by tens of millions of Macs, you now have a high probability outcome that an organization will lose a device, act as if the contents are inaccessible to the thief, and learn later that the were acting on bad information.

It's a big deal to folks who could be caught up in the above scenario. We wrote the post for them.

> I know that there's a long history of attention-seeking blog posts from companies selling products

When you have something important to say, seeking attention is warranted. Just because we sell something doesn't mean it is correct to dismiss everything we say. HN is primarily a community of startups and hackers. Both are folks that may have found this content relevant.

We wrote this post because we have unique visibility into a substantive issue that requires educating MacAdmins about these differences so they don't get tripped up during an incident.

Tools like MunkiReport and Osquery are incredibly popular among these communities for collecting attestations about devices. This is especially true for shops who do not feel comfortable paying for a full MDM solution. The fact that these systems may cause admins to believe their devices have FileVault enabled, when in fact they do not, is a serious problem.

> but you're trying to make a reputation as an honest security company and I think that marketing is a key component of that

It's ok if we don't agree that this post is important or that the level of urgency is warranted (I think it's a super big deal, but I don't think I can convince you of that fact). That said, there is nothing dishonest happening here. We could have easily patched this issue for our customers, explained it only to them and moved on. We wrote the post because it's information we thought needed to be out there.

The error I made was assuming people knew that FileVault is not on by default in very common scenarios. We've amended the post which I think adds valuable context about that.

That said, I appreciate your thoughts.

terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
> It sounds like there was a regression at some point

You are continually asserting incorrect information about this topic.

The behavior I describe where skipping iCloud setup causes FileVault setup screen to not be shown as always been the case. There has been no regression.

Source: https://derflounder.wordpress.com/2014/10/25/new-filevault-2...

terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
I just wiped a new M1 device and set it up from scratch using the latest version of Big Sur. If you skip iCloud setup you are never asked to turn on FileVault. When you skip iCloud you are never told this will result in FileVault being disabled.

I took photographs of the entire process if you'd like me to provide proof.

I am the CEO of Kolide. An employee wrote this article because....of our customers who do not fully manage their Macs, the amount of them without FileVault can be as high as 1/3 of the entire Mac fleet. That number tracks with the UX of the setup screen I mentioned above. Esp for privacy conscious orgs.

terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
The problem is the FileVault is not enabled by default in certain situations (like if you skip iCloud setup when you first turn on a new Mac). Even though FileVault is off, popular tools like osquery will report them as "encrypted".

Yes that's technically correct, but not likely what the person querying means.

terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
FileVault is not offered to a user setting up their Mac to the first time if they skip iCloud. People in a work setting will often skip this step because they aren't sure...

A) If they are allowed to connect their personal Apple ID to their work laptop

B) If this will sync personal files to their work laptop (which might be undesirable)

For personal devices, FileVault is now often on, but unmanaged devices specifically for work use? A sizable amount do not have FileVault.

In the past this wasn't a big deal, but now we have tools conveying that these devices are encrypted, when in fact, their data can be trivially accessed.

terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
See my reply to the parent, FileVault will not be offered if you skip the iCloud setup, which many folks not wanting to mix their personal-life with their work laptop will skip.
terracatta··on M1 Macs SSD “Encryption” trivially bypassed unless FileVault is enabled
If you skip Apple ID (which is an extremely common situation in a privacy conscious employee) you are not offered FileVault.

In my experience, it's extremely common to see FileVault disabled on unmanaged workplace Macs.

terracatta··on GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus in a phishing test
This is beyond the pale, way worse than the scenarios I've seen in the while when I wrote https://honest.security

We HAVE to as an industry disavow & replace this behavior with techniques to build trust between the security team and the rest of the employees.

The people, not the technology are the real eyes and ears on the ground. They are a massively beneficial resource for a security team of any size. Why would you squander that relationship with cheap trickery and deceit?

terracatta··on Firefox Was Always Enough
Are there things that have gotten worse? Yes Are things way more complicated? Yes

But net overall? I believe it's better than 2005 and even 2010. Meaning, I would not want to revert back to 2010 and start building back up from there. There is too much good we would lose in the process.

I have no idea if my opinion is shared by the majority, but I am very optimistic about the future of the web.

terracatta··on Firefox Was Always Enough
I think Safari is going to have the market cornered on technology pessimism (aka privacy features) and browser performance per watt on macOS and iOS.

Google is rapidly locking down enterprise by building in tight integrations with Google Workspace/G-Suite (see: context aware authentication).

In 10 - 15 years the web should be better than it is today. The first step in their recovery is to convey what their vision of the web looks like in 2035 and commit to Firefox being the first browser to make it a reality by 2025.

terracatta··on If you can't play the new VR version of Myst, why not play the Apple II demake
The Witness (by the same person who developed Braid) felt very Myst-like to me as well. Highly recommended, the puzzles are incredibly clever and a lot of fun to solve with a partner.
terracatta··on Chrome Is Bad
The only clue this domain might be newer is he mentions the 16inch MacBook Pro which first came out in 2019.
terracatta··on I accidentally built a spying app
One time a friend and I built an app for a weekend hackathon competition called Rails Rumble.

At the time (2010), link shortening services were all the rage, but they were being used to obfuscate malware links. To fight this, we wanted to create a link shortening service that couldn't be used for malware. Instead of redirecting to a webpage, it broke the page apart into its core elements so you could see what it was about before you visited it. If the site had photos, we even put them into a nice looking image gallery that you could peruse.

We finished the project in 72 hours and got an honorable mention for the competition, but we didn't win. A month later, our free server hosting we were given for the competition was about to expire. I logged in to spin the whole thing down.

Poking around the DB a bit, I realized our little weekend project had thousands of links shortened and the traffic for the site was actually exceeding the limits of the server. Looking at the URLs, I realized they all had one thing in common; they were all porn sites. The simple inclusion of the image gallery had inadvertently created a porn scraping service. It was like your browser's reader view, but perfect for adult sites!

It was so obvious in retrospect, but sometimes in your rush to build an idea, you can be completely blind to its true nature. This time it was amusing, but the next time it could be dangerous, and the lesson always stuck with me.

terracatta··on Apple Acquires Fleetsmith
I understand where you are coming from but it's more like, "standby while I share something my team and I have been working really hard on that is relevant to the news and who are interested in MDM".
terracatta··on Apple Acquires Fleetsmith
CEO of Kolide here.

This announcement couldn't have come at a crazier time...today I planned on announcing our intentions to enter the MDM product space.

Our MDM is meant to be a new fresh take on device management that puts end-users in the driver seat. It's user focused device management and we are applying everything we've learned from our security product to the management space.

https://blog.kolide.com/kolide-mdm-for-those-that-dont-need-...

If you are interested in trying out what we are releasing later this year, read the post, and get on the list https://www.kolide.com/mdm/

terracatta··on Apple rejects appeal from email app Hey
Source? I believe you, but I am interested in learning more and I'm not finding anything. Would love to read if you have a link handy.
terracatta··on Apple rejects appeal from email app Hey
> The same is done by restaurants for things like Uber Eat/Postmate: they have their prices on their menu, and a marked-up price on these platforms

I do not believe Apple's tax for IAP applies for physical goods or services. Only digital products or goods. If those companies are charging more, it might be for another reason.

> 3.1.5 Physical Goods and Services Outside of the App: If your app enables people to purchase goods or services that will be consumed outside of the app, you must use purchase methods other than in-app purchase to collect those payments, such as Apple Pay or traditional credit card entry. Apps may facilitate transmission of approved virtual currencies (e.g. Bitcoin, DogeCoin) provided that they do so in compliance with all state and federal laws for the territories in which the app functions.

> but couldn't they markup the In-App-Subscription by whatever % of cut Apple is taking?

They can do this but they are not allowed to inform their customers on the iOS app that the prices are lower elsewhere

> Section 3.1.3(b) Multiplatform Services: Apps that operate across multiple platforms may allow users to access content, subscriptions, or features they have acquired elsewhere, including consumable items in multi-platform games, provided those items are also available as in-app purchases within the app. You must not directly or indirectly target iOS users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase, and your general communications about other purchasing methods must not discourage use of in-app purchase.

terracatta··on Apple rejects appeal from email app Hey
This letter is actually astonishing. In this letter Apple:

* Chastises them for making free apps in the past

* Reminds them they've had to distribute their apps for free (almost as if they should be grateful and now give them some money)

* States they would accept their app if it provided unrelated functionality or access to competitor products (who are oddly not subject to the same rules).

* Implies that everyone is following the rules but them (which is demonstrably false even if you accept the "Reader" and "Business" definitions they provide)

Also, according to DHH, they leaked this letter to the press before sending it to the Basecamp CEO. Nice.

The argument is so strange, it's almost as if "email" is a special term of art that causes Apple to categorize this app in a way that is not is not consistent with other SaaS products. Even with that said, there are no other similar email apps like Superhuman that are subject to these rules. If I was a Chat or Email based SaaS company CEO and I relied on the iPhone to complete my multi-platform value prop, I would be very worried about this happening to my already approved app.

terracatta··on GE switches off light bulb business after almost 130 years
Yeah it's definitely part of a pattern of behavior that started with the ouster of Immelt.

Basically the start of their downfall was Trian Partners, an activist investor, bought $2.5 billion of GE stock in 2015 with the express goal of GE taking on a ton of debt to do share buybacks and raise the dividend

https://steveblank.com/2017/11/01/why-ges-jeff-immelt-lost-h...

terracatta··on GE switches off light bulb business after almost 130 years
GE is literally selling the metaphor for innovation and ideas for $250 million. It's also the last Edison original business.

Curious what others think, but I think they undervalue the brand value they are eroding by divesting from all of these low growth business that were the building blocks of their once great brand?

terracatta··on Grab your crayons, it’s coloring time
Another similar idea I saw recently https://colorthisthing.com/
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →