HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tgb

5,680 karma · joined September 9, 2012

submissionscomments
tgb··on The ‘Zelle fraud’ scam: how it works, how to fight back
I don't understand how 2FA would stop this attack. The attack described involves phishing for a one time code like what most 2FA methods give.
tgb··on Taproot, Bitcoin’s long-anticipated upgrade, has activated
So it requires one on-chain transaction per pair of parties instead of one per transaction? Clever and I suppose useful but seems a little limited in use, given that the funds are locked the whole time. Good for two parties that frequently have transactions going in both directions?
tgb··on Taproot, Bitcoin’s long-anticipated upgrade, has activated
I'm missing how you can have a transaction that is not broadcasted but that prevents a double spend. Can't I give two different people signed transactions for the same bitcoins? How could the second recipient know I've already spent the balance on the first? Apologies for the no-doubt naive questions, it just sounds impossible.
tgb··on Taproot, Bitcoin’s long-anticipated upgrade, has activated
I'm confused then, doesn't this still need one transaction in the block chain for every transaction?
tgb··on Taproot, Bitcoin’s long-anticipated upgrade, has activated
Does this stop a double spend?
tgb··on If You Have Writer's Block, Maybe You Should Stop Lying
Yeah it feels like the author is strawmanning what "I have writers block" means. It's not that they've forgotten every word in the language. They have thoughts. Those thoughts are probably like "I hate this writers block, ugh what to say, what to write, I'm having block...". Doesn't matter if they wrote that out, no one would want to read it. And we all know there are too many "meta" pieces out there about the author's struggles with writer's block - please don't subject us to another one!
tgb··on Suppose I Wanted to Kill a Lot of Pilots (2020)
Surely the architect working on this building is the one to listen to about this building.
tgb··on Pyjion – A Python JIT Compiler
It certainly is good, but I've never found a great dev setup. It seems like you have to force a full recompile of all cython in the project any time you make a change. At least that was the stated process for the statsmodels library. And it was always a little unclear whether I was running the latest code or hadn't yet actually compiled it.
tgb··on Decline in effectiveness of all three US Covid-19 vaccines over time
On your first comment, as far as I know the big contributor seems to be the Delta variant which arose and became prevalent in India at a time when it had very low vaccination rates (and from a different vaccine). In a hypothetical world without vaccines, we'd still have delta and just be worse off. I don't see any reason to attribute this to selective pressure from vaccines.
tgb··on The Engineered Student: On B. F. Skinner’s Teaching Machine
I just finished reading Don't Shoot the Dog by Karen Pryor, which is apparently a classic popular account of animal training based off Skinners ideas. It's pretty interesting but a little too self congratulatory. The short summary is:

- punishment usually comes too late and also makes the trainee dislike the trainer and so makes future training harder

- rewards should come immediately at success

- since most rewards can't be given immediately, develop a cue (a "clicker" is popular) which you give at the immediate moment that informs them they're about to get the reward. This bridges the time span between act and reward, and the cue itself becomes valuable to the trainee later

- variable rewards often work better

- trainees in a rut can sometimes be jolted out of the rut by giving them an undeserved reward jackpot

- teaching a trainee to not do something is harder but one strategy is to teach them to do it on command. Then simply don't never give them the command. Most behaviors die out once trainned to command except when commanded

- or train them to do something that is incompatible with the undesired behavior

- bizarrely, stopping doing an undesirable task can be reward enough to train them to do the undesirable task. I'm not super clear on how you do this in practice

- giving cues and rewards too late is a common error. It's counterintuitive because you often must interrupt the behavior you are training. Rewarding your dog for sitting will cause the dog to stop sitting, but you must do this. Waiting until the dog stops sitting is too late since then you are rewarding the stopping of sitting, not sitting itself.

- all of this applies to humans (if you don't let them know what you're doing) and also to yourself, supposedly

I'm trying to train my misbehaving cat. We're making some progress but it's not as fast and magical as the book makes it sound (my inexperienced training skills likely contributing).

I'm also learning Mandarin and a lot of what I've learned is through apps like Anki. Feedback is instant. But it doesn't really feel that rewarding to get a card right, so I'm not sure how successful it is in a Skinnerian sense. Teaching machines are here and work but I think they're still suboptimal.

tgb··on Google introduces mandatory 2-Step Verification for Google Accounts
What app is it?
tgb··on What is the inverse of a vector?
I was also wondering this. But note that x^y is always perpendicular to x, so really only has two degrees of freedom while you need three to recover y (knowing x). Add in the dot product part to make up for it.
tgb··on What is the inverse of a vector?
Yes, only three. As defined, two bivectors are equal if their areas are equal and if their oriented planes are equal. Therefore two more degrees of freedom are absorbed by taking rotations of the two vectors in the plane.Along with the rescaling the author noted, we're down to three from six.
tgb··on What is the inverse of a vector?
You're right about that being wrong, and the author makes the same mistake consistently, but otherwise it looks correct. Some steps have details elided where it maybe should have been noted that things were being skipped, but with correct results. I think it's wonderfully written and a great exposition.
tgb··on Why is houseplant advice so bad?
I assume rotating isn't for the health of the plant but for giving it a more symmetric and fuller appearance.
tgb··on What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?
Sure it's not 100% of the time but that's besides the point still. Isn't NIFO a bad fit for the times when per-unit costs are decreasing? And since this happens fairly regularly it seems like a bad choice period, or at least not obviously better than FIFO or LIFO.
tgb··on What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?
But my point was that variable but decreasing costs seem to throw NIFO off too. Aircraft are the extreme example but I'm sure the first of Tesla's latest car model costs more to produce than the thousandth. Not even counting capital expenses but just by things running smoother with practice. NIFO seems to fall short here too.
tgb··on What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?
Is "NIFO" really the right way to do accounting? If you sell the government one aircraft carrier, the cost of producing a second one will be much lower, so NIFO doesn't seem to fit there.
tgb··on Large Language Models: A New Moore's Law?
That's how many it takes to "represent" a neuron. But what does that mean and is it relevant? I haven't checked the original research, but if it means to model the results of a neuron, then it's not relevant (unless you're trying to do brain uploading). Two ANNs with different activation functions will need a lot of nodes to model a single node of the other network, but they have comparable computational power. We don't need to match the neurons to match the computational abilities.
tgb··on Why I Hate Frameworks (2005)
So what do carpenters use for analogies?
tgb··on Why Mathematics is Boring (2007) [pdf]
I actually find the forced structure of most non-math journals to be pretty terrible for readability. Why are results and methods forced to be separate? It means you have to play the 'connect the dots' game of figuring out which parts of the methods refer to which part of the results. This is obvious to the writer but incredibly challenging in some circumstances for a less-informed reader. Math papers do not have such forced separation and have clearly numbered claims and proofs.

An example is a paper with several mouse experiments. In results it'll often have a single section saying that mice were raised such and such under conditions A or B. They were treated with X or Y and samples were collected after certain times. But was Y treated on A or B mice? From results its clear that X was done on both but no mention for Y. I guess A is more the default and they'd have specified B if that were the case, so probably A.

tgb··on Strict Id Laws Don’t Stop Voters: Evidence from a U.S. Nationwide Panel
I got mine in April and it involved standing in line for an hour before being let into the DMV to sit in line inside. It cost something like $50, too. I wouldn't call it convenient.
tgb··on Reversal of cognitive decline: A novel therapeutic program
PMC is where papers go that are required to be open access due to funding or chosen to be open access in the life sciences, generally speaking. It's the official place for these and a legal copy. Sci-hub generally isn't. If you support Sci-hub you might as well save them the bandwidth for serving papers that are genuinely open access. And supporting PMC is good to support the further expansion of actually open access papers and the funding of them.

PMC also makes everything uniformly formatted which is often a benefit, though sometimes equations can be worse.

tgb··on Up to 600 watts of power for graphics cards with the new PCIe 5.0 powerconnector
True but doesn't change the conclusions dramatically, does it? If a heat pump is twice as efficient as electrical heating then you're still displacing half the wattage from your rig with reduced heating.

On the other hand, taking heat into account just makes matters worse in the summer, and I haven't known a gamer who takes half the year off.

tgb··on Clean environment could become U.N. human right
Interesting. Can you expand on an example of a 'new' human right that would be authoritarian in nature? I don't really understand the "right to development" example. It looks like it was adopted by the UN already in 1986 and I'm not sure if the authoritarian implications.

https://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/righttod...

tgb··on Conterintuitive facts in mathematics, CS, and physics
Only sort of true. It doesn't make sense to compare n dimensional volume to n+1 dimensional volumes, so the limit of the volume of an n-sphere isn't meaningful. The limit that does make sense is the ratio of volumes of n-sphere to an n-cube. That that goes to zero is maybe not so surprising.

In particular, it's equally valid and frankly nicer to define the unit n-sphere to be volume 1 rather than the unit cube. Do that and we see that this statement is just saying that the n-cube grows in volume to infinity, which makes sense given the fact you point out that it contains points increasingly far from the origin.

I have a hobby of turning surprising facts about the n-sphere into less surprising facts about the n-cube. So far I haven't met one that can't be 'fixed' by this strategy.

tgb··on Is this the simplest (and most surprising) sorting algorithm?
What's the optimal sorting algorithm for your Bridge hand? Sorting and holding 13 cards is tricky enough to make me wonder.
tgb··on Is this the simplest (and most surprising) sorting algorithm?
Of the five "obvious" words, two of them are used to say that something is not obvious and your last two examples are something entirely different. The uses here seem quite reasonable. But these words should be helpful, not insulting! If it's not clear, as the author claims, then you've likely misunderstood something. No point pondering it for twenty minutes, better go back and reread the statement first.

But of course they do get misused and there's not much more demoralizing than getting stuck on something 'obvious.'

tgb··on Curiosity Is Better Than Being Smart?
Do you know if there is a non-self-reported 'trait curiosity' factor? I.e., regardless of how curious they say they are, are some people just curious about more things than others? And if so, does that correlate with intelligence? That would match my intuition.
tgb··on Edge.org's Annual Questions
Do these questions have explanations? Almost none of them sound to me like plausible "last questions" so I'd like to know what the askers were thinking.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →