HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thebooktocome

1,613 karma · joined May 6, 2010

submissionscomments
thebooktocome··on Wizards of the Coast Releases SRD Under Creative Commons License (CC-BY-4.0)
Morality clauses aren’t compatible with any Creative Commons license as far as I’m aware.
thebooktocome··on NYC jails want to ban physical mail, then privatize scanning of digital versions
> you’re changing the goalposts

Post one: The death penalty is always wrong because it can be handed out in error and cannot be revoked.

Post two: The death penalty is always wrong because it can be handed out in error and cannot be revoked.

No goalposts have changed in the making of this thread.

thebooktocome··on NYC jails want to ban physical mail, then privatize scanning of digital versions
I’m supposed to take comfort in the fact that you’re more violent in hypothetical situations?

The death penalty will always be executed with a certain false positive rate. Willing it as a form of punishment necessarily entails willing the death of innocent people, who crucially can’t be brought back in the event that the state realizes it was mistaken.

thebooktocome··on NYC jails want to ban physical mail, then privatize scanning of digital versions
“Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement.”
thebooktocome··on Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing bonus
Centuries of capitalists hoarding capital.
thebooktocome··on An Update on the Open Game License (OGL)
Yes, I agree with everything you wrote here. I was a bit sloppy above.

I believe the wood elf you’re thinking of is Thranduil.

thebooktocome··on An Update on the Open Game License (OGL)
> Humans look very much different from monkeys

Didn't stop generations of racists from making offensive comparisons. Doesn't stop them from continuing to do so.

Racism's value system doesn't care about rationality or truth.

> On a similar absurd reasoning one could claim elves in lotr are racist because the have light skin.

Amusingly enough, Tolkien did in fact hold racist beliefs, despite his fervent opposition to the Nazis during WWII. Both of those things can be and are true. His elves are very explicitly Old Norse expys (read his letters if you don't believe me) and his constant fawning over them (as pale, beautiful, skilled, and wise) in contrast to orcs (as dark-skinned, ugly, brutish, and enslaved) was criticized then and is still criticized now.

> If you mean to it's always possible to twist anything into being offensive.

It is justified to take offense at something that is, in fact, offensive.

thebooktocome··on Emergency measures needed to rescue Great Salt Lake from ongoing collapse
Maintaining the Great Salt Lake is the topic of the article.
thebooktocome··on Investors conclude that Tesla is a carmaker, not a tech firm
The lack of tactile buttons increases distraction considerably.

I cannot activate most controls on a Tesla without taking my eyes off the road.

They also seemingly refuse to keep the GUI stable for more than three or four months at a time.

thebooktocome··on Dinner for one: A little-known British comedy famous in Germany
No, most Americans don’t perceive him as naked, any more than they do Bugs Bunny or other anthro mascots.

I think it’s the accent. His voice actors are pretty hard to understand sometimes.

thebooktocome··on MIT faculty adopts “Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”
You do kinda have to reckon with them, somehow, when they start vandalizing electrical substations, forming armed militias, and the like.
thebooktocome··on Against Method
> He often gets lumped together with continental thinkers and post-modernists like Foucault that he has nothing to do with.

He has a lot to do with them. One of the themes in Derrida’s “The Truth in Painting” revolves around the maxim, “there is no passe-partout (a master key that opens all locks).” Foucault’s “Madness and Civilization” is partially about the lack of a single axis of “Reason”, which would presumably be the antonym of a similarly univocal “Madness”.

thebooktocome··on Twitter rules change bans any location-identifying information, even if public
You're misreading the policy. It defines the subsequent bullet points as "private information", it does not restrict the scope of those bullet points to some other external definition of "private information".

More explicitly, legally speaking, "the following types of private information" means "the following list of things, which we are calling private information", not "the following list of things, when they are considered as private information (defined elsewhere)".

thebooktocome··on Twitter rules change bans any location-identifying information, even if public
> Under this policy, you can’t share the following types of private information, without the permission of the person who it belongs to:

. . .

> live location information, including information shared on Twitter directly or links to 3rd-party URL(s) of travel routes, actual physical location, or other identifying information that would reveal a person’s location, regardless if this information is publicly available;

This bullet point has none of the caveats that you are hinging your defense of their policy on.

thebooktocome··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
Yep, my mate curbed his front passenger wheel that way. But I dunno how you fix that without LIDAR sensors mapping the terrain around the vehicle.
thebooktocome··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
Tesla’s FSD is so terrifyingly bad at routine tasks (I used it for six months before giving up) that it’s natural to assume whatever closed track testing they did was ineffective. Or perhaps they did a lot, I don’t know—but it doesn’t feel like many of those lessons learned made it into the “production” system.
thebooktocome··on New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations
See, I’m old enough to remember holding my breath to get past a throng of chain-smokers when they’d gas out a restaurant or clog the front of a store.
thebooktocome··on New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations
Arresting ~20% of the Maori population (the number that smoke according to other comments in this thread) might not be received well.
thebooktocome··on The school that grants your PhD thinks it’s too good to hire you
This is a white lie at best. I’ve never sat on a hiring committee that cared about diversity of thought.
thebooktocome··on The school that grants your PhD thinks it’s too good to hire you
“The best” here is measured by reputational vibes—not research value added.
thebooktocome··on The school that grants your PhD thinks it’s too good to hire you
Higher education is just paradoxes all the way down.

Public universities funded with taxpayer dollars that take primarily out-of-state and international students. Too good to recruit from local high schools.

Professors hired supposedly for their merit as researchers, chained to massive teaching loads with little autonomy.

Adjuncts. Just, everything about adjuncts.

Journals too prestigious to give permanent access either to the public who ultimately funded the research, or the academics who did the work, or even the other academics who reviewed that work for free.

It all sucks. We desperately need a new model. But the sunken cost of the current system and the perverse incentives keeping it afloat are too great.

thebooktocome··on Premium .dev domain with Google costs $850
Chinese mobile carriers used to (and may still) do exactly this. Numbers with multiple 8’s were more valuable because 8 is lucky, whereas a single 4 (a homophone for “death”) meant a reasonable discount.
thebooktocome··on Google admits to violating federal law and plans to keep doing it
Doesn’t take that much time to slap a fraud alert on your credit and force this bureaucratic process of theirs to trigger.

Probably isn’t worth the legal fees though.

thebooktocome··on California greenlights jaywalking. It’s a step in the right direction
It doesn’t seem likely that a minor misdemeanor jaywalking ticket, very rarely enforced (at least, as far as I have seen), would really budge the needle either way as far as the overall frequency of jaywalking is concerned.

So rest assured. Your precious insurance premiums are safe.

thebooktocome··on Why is the state of mathematics education so abstract and uninspiring?
> Because mathematics, like most tertiary disciplines, has always been taught in a teaching style suitable for the 5% of the audience who aim to go on to be mathematics professionals (who then teach mathematics).

I'm reminded of Lockhart's Lament, https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament....:

> "Um, these high school classes you mentioned..."

> "You mean Paint-By-Numbers? We're seeing much higher enrollments lately, [...]"

> "And when do students get to paint freely, on a blank canvas?"

> "You sound like one of my professors! They were always going on about expressing yourself and your feelings and things like that—really way-out-there abstract stuff. I've got a degree in Painting myself, but I've never really worked much with blank canvasses. I just use the Paint-by-Numbers kits supplied by the school board."

thebooktocome··on The Anti-Promethean Backlash
Hypothesis: Oil crises increase the political power of fossil fuel extractors, which can then use regulatory capture to prevent competition.
thebooktocome··on The truffle industry is a scam
The article points out that “natural aroma” is doing some heavy lifting.

“The use of the so-called "natural aromas" is a particularly sneaky trick. The artificial flavoring most commonly used in truffle products is the petroleum derivative mentioned at the beginning of the text, meaning "natural aromas" are a marketing ploy to make you believe that the flavor was naturally derived from truffles. It was not, and God knows where it comes from, as no one is willing to reveal the information.”

Real truffle is not shelf stable, the flavor degrades within a week.

thebooktocome··on The sinister attempts to ‘decolonise’ mathematics
Yes, Egypt and Rome and Byzantium were empires. “Colonial power” in common parlance almost always means a European nation using naval superiority and tech imbalance to extract wealth from distant colonies.

By your definition, almost every native civilization of the Americas is a colonial power. Something has gone awry. (I’m not certain what “lands that were not ethnically theirs” means absent the doctrine of terra nullius, which also postdates any ancient empire.)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_colonialism

“Colonialism in the modern sense began with the "Age of Discovery", led by Portuguese, who became increasingly adventuresome following the conquest of Ceuta in 1415. . .”

thebooktocome··on The sinister attempts to ‘decolonise’ mathematics
It amuses me that of your three examples, only speaking English is a product of colonialism.

Chairs were known in ancient Egypt, the fork in Byzantium. Neither is a colonial power by any reasonable definition.

thebooktocome··on Your Organization should run its own Mastodon server
> Literally nothing meaningful has changed about Twitter in the last few months.

But things probably will change meaningfully in the near future. You’d have to ignore everything the new CEO is saying, in order to believe otherwise.

People trade futures options all the time.

← PreviousPage 7 of 28Next →