HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

theluketaylor

2,182 karma · joined February 10, 2015

submissionscomments
theluketaylor··on What’s the difference between Derek Jeter and preregistration?
That’s all certainly true, and he should have moved to third for A-Rod, and yet he is still a hall of fame calibre player, which don’t exactly come around every day.

Despite his -9.4 dWAR, his 96.3 oWAR still leaves him well beyond the 60 WAR HOF barrier.

Jeter is such an odd player since he is simultaneously one of the best to ever play the game and massively overrated. I’m not sure there is another baseball player who fits that description.

theluketaylor··on Why car wheels are so flat these days
Some cars have had inboard brakes to reduce unsprung mass. Alfa Romeo did it a lot in the 70s and 80s.

There are a lot of downsides, like maintenance is a bit of a nightmare.

theluketaylor··on Why car wheels are so flat these days
Hub motors will be common on scooters and other small electric vehicles, but it will never make sense on full sized cars. The size of motor required to move a car with the acceleration and speed modern traffic demands just won't work in a hub. Reduction gearboxes and axle-shafts already represent a pretty tiny fraction of the total mass of drive units on EVs and there are no mass savings coming on motors that will somehow get them into the range of acceptable unsprung weight, even axial flux motors.

The whole industry is working on tighter integration of the drive unit components to reduce things like cooling circuits, length of high voltage cable runs, and the total mass of the components required to move the car. No one is working on splitting the motors out into the hubs.

As you point out, unsprung mass is bad. Especially for something like a motor it's beyond bad, it's a complete killer of ride quality and reliability. As sprung mass the entire drive system can be isolated from all the knocks and oscillations that happen from driving around. A hub motor will get crashed and bashed around and have a miserable MTBF. The occupants will hate the car since it will have awful handling and hitting even moderate-sized bumps will be terribly unpleasant. Lighter stuff like scooters can get away with hub motors since there just isn't that much mass to begin with, but cars are huge now.

Aptera is planning to use hub motors, but their car is the vapourist of wares and relies on being counted as a motorcycle under regulations. Their basic engineering just doesn't work when scaled to a 3500 pound car and beyond.

theluketaylor··on Toyota patents plans for EV with manual transmission and clutch
Only using first gear for hard launches helps, as does the fact they are using dog clutches in addition to traditional friction plates.

The coolest part is the rear motor can be completely mechanically decoupled from the axel so it can just coast. Most other EV just shut of power to the motor, but Taycan can freewheel on the rear axle.

Jalopnik did a huge in depth on the whole powertrain that is really interesting.

https://jalopnik.com/an-extremely-detailed-look-at-the-porsc...

theluketaylor··on Germany’s ultra-cheap train ticket saved 1.8M tons of CO2
The current GO Expansion to turn the greater Toronto area commuter rail into a true regional rail is a great project, and is using knowledge and expertise from the German rail network. It will electrify the trains and provide all day frequent service throughout the network that will mean not really needing to bother checking the schedule. It also flies in the face of statements that say european style rail isn't possible in north america, since the basic plan is modelled on German S-Bahn.

Just this weekend I drove 1 hr to the edge of Toronto, then got on the subway to downtown for a Blue Jays game. Once GO expansion is done I'll be able to make that same trip on a single train in less time then it takes to drive.

High speed rail from Quebec City to Windsor is a project we should absolutely be funding as the population and travel patterns of the corridor would easily support it. Start with Toronto->Montreal with a spur to Ottawa, then as phase 2 extend to Windsor and Quebec City.

theluketaylor··on Saying goodbye to my parents’ library
Contact with his collecting friends is an excellent suggestion.

I'd also recommend considering distributing some of the collection to friends and relatives. Something small like a single cuckoo clock could be a great memento to remember them by. It's not a burden to take one clock the way a whole collection would be, of course people should still be asked if they would like to have it rather than being voluntold.

My great uncle had a wonderful collection of beautiful old hand tools and made a point of distributing a portion of them to his various relatives and friends who had expressed interest. The bulk of the collection went to the relative who was his son in all but fact, but I have some lovely calipers and a handmade hammer that have a cherished place among my tools. Far from a burden, I remember uncle Mac fondly each time I see them while grabbing some pliers or a drill.

My grandmother has made us go around putting sticky notes with our names on all the stuff we want when they downsize or pass. Everything else will go to goodwill or the dump. The secretary desk my grandfather fished out of the dump in the 60s is a hot commodity that everyone is trying to lay claim to.

theluketaylor··on Saying goodbye to my parents’ library
John Hodgman says the difference between hoarding and collecting is a display case.

A display case limits the number of objects that can be in someone's collection at a time. Good collectors get to a reasonable collection size and then operate on something like a one in, one out policy.

Sorry you had to go through that huge burden. I had a hoarding grandparent (not anything to that extent). It was painful to dispose of as the belongings were filled with mold and everyone got sick while throwing it away.

theluketaylor··on How to Nationalize the Internet in Canada
That's my dream for internet infrastructure here in Canada. A national crown corporation that owns huge fiber runs across the country and undersea/cross border runs with other countries. Provincial crown corporations handle runs between cities and out into rural areas. Municipal departments own the runs to each address within their cities. It's paid for by selling access to Bell, Rogers, and any smaller independent ISP that might want to exist. Government doesn't actually supply internet to anyone; they just own and maintain the physical infrastructure since that's a natural monopoly. Competition happens at the edges by providing various services like internet access, with equal access among ISPs to use the shared infrastructure. With the immense cost of runs to each address eliminated, small ISPs would be reasonably easy to found and compete with the big players. We have groups like Teksavvy already, but they are so beholden to Bell and Rogers they can't truly compete since the big guys act like the mafia.
theluketaylor··on The end of the manual transmission is near?
Used and vintage Ferrari's have premiums on the manual version if you can find one. They pushed the F1 gearbox hard from its introduction with the 355. Ferrari hasn't even built a car with a manual transmission since 2012, and in the mid 2000s manuals were under 10% of their builds. 599 was the last car they made with a stick, and even that was only 30 of 600 cars.

Porsche was ready to kill their manual with the 991.1 911 GT3 being PDK only, but there was enough outcry they brought it back for 991.2 and 992. The recently unveiled 992 GT3 RS is PDK only since it's a true track car and PDK puts in faster lap times. Even the revived GT 6-speed only accounts for a fraction of their builds and the 7-speed is hardly ordered on the regular 911 at all.

theluketaylor··on The end of the manual transmission is near?
And the EV Macan due out in 2024 will be even more screen. I'm sure it will have the same 3 screen setup as Taycan, with the curved instrument cluster, landscape main dash screen, and portrait lower screen for HVAC and charging controls.
theluketaylor··on A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage
There are tons of HVDC interconnects and transmission lines in place, many of which are already over 1000 km long. Many of these projects have been in place for decades. Breakthroughs in solid state HVDC are making it easier and cheaper all the time, but it's not some fanciful science fiction technology. It's a key element of existing power grids already.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_HVDC_projects

theluketaylor··on A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage
Tons of their dams are in northern Quebec in the middle of nowhere. People who have never been to the Canadian Shield have a tough time imagining just how many rivers and lakes there are. It’s basically endless.
theluketaylor··on A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage
New England and upstate NY don't generate nearly enough power for their own needs and buy excess power from Ontario and Quebec. Quebec in particular as Hydro Quebec has a terrifying amount of hydro generation and always has tons of excess. A big chunk of the clean energy in the northeast US comes from Canada.

Super cool tool that shows the CO2 intensity of various grids and where power is flowing:

https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/US-NE-ISNE

theluketaylor··on A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage
Indeed. Solar is so cheap (and the price keeps falling) needing to build an extra 15% bigger solar farms is a total non-issue. By the time some projects go from planning to ground-breaking that extra 15% might be free due to costs plummeting.
theluketaylor··on A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage
If whole solar or wind farms find themselves sitting idle someone will drop off some containers nearby to split water into hydrogen or run a data center or something else that drinks power and skip the grid middle-man. Over-idle is not going to be a real issue; someone will always find a way to use of excess power.
theluketaylor··on A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and with little storage
Losses wouldn’t be bad with HVDC, with the added benefit of HVDC ties not needing to be frequency synced across the entire grid, so you have some opportunity to increase resiliency.

I don’t think it’s a one-sized fits all solution. There will be places where storage will make sense, and other where longer distance transmission makes sense. I think the reality is it will be a mix of both, along with a nice diverse mix of generation methods.

theluketaylor··on Application submitted for US molten salt research reactor
Some buddies who work on CANDU tell me they have tritium contamination everywhere as a result of this. From what they tell me it's not really a big safety issue, mostly more annoying than anything.
theluketaylor··on Ask HN: Why do you trust electronic voting machines?
I would certainly agree first past the post is a deeply broken system. I’m strongly in favour of reform there, but am increasingly concerned that any replacement needs to be as simple a counting process as possible to ensure everyone fully grasps it. Nothing is worse for trust in the electoral process than distrust in the counting mechanism. If there is anything to be learned from 2020 it’s that elections are actually about showing who lost and not just who won. If people don’t agree on who lost chaos ensues.
theluketaylor··on Ask HN: Why do you trust electronic voting machines?
The early push to electronic voting in the US after the hanging chad debacle of 2000 did include electronic only voting machines in a number of states. Congress allocated all sorts of funds for states, but almost zero oversight or rules about secure machines and processes.

Those early mistakes have been corrected and I believe you are correct, all voting machines in the US now produce a paper trail.

> multiple checks and balances where they confirm that final votes make sense

A term we heard a lot in the lead up and aftermath of the 2020 election was 'risk limiting audits'. It would be irresponsible not to have a strong audit program in place to verify the count, which is what I believe you're referring to.

The fact the US runs 50 independent elections is an interesting double edged sword as a Canadian observer. I'm used to incredibly simple ballots administered by either Elections Canada or Elections Ontario. The US has massively complex ballots administered by their state for county, state and federal office.

In some circumstances the US system makes nation-wide election fraud nearly impossible (election fraud does happen and is different from so-called 'voter fraud' that doesn't). The small scale of some offices and elections does make election fraud more achievable on some scales.

A new weakness has been revealed. Various local election officials (particularly Secretaries of State) wield enormous power to affect the process and outcome of the election. Elections Canada runs exactly the same election under exactly the same rules in every polling place across the country. Experiences state to state, county to country, and even at different polling places within a county can vary wildly in the US. This is exacerbated in Presidential elections by the fact only a handful of states are actually up for grabs in the election. A Secretary of State in any of Pennsylvania, Florida, Georgia, Nevada, Arizona, Minnesota, or Michigan potentially has the power to throw the next election into chaos. 2024 is not going to be fun and I'm not even American.

theluketaylor··on Living on a Reduced Income in 1868
Makes it all the more notable she thought they would never afford a car and how much of an inversion we’ve had between the price of manufactured goods and labour in under a century.
theluketaylor··on Living on a Reduced Income in 1868
Not just 19th century; this persisted well into the 20th as well.

Agatha Christie wrote in her autobiography about in post Great War Britain a servant being a necessity but that she wasn’t likely ever going to be rich enough to afford a car.

https://fullstackeconomics.com/why-agatha-christie-could-aff...

theluketaylor··on The Dymaxion car: Buckminster Fuller’s failed automobile
XL1 was limited production as there was only ever going to be 200 offered to the public. VW almost certainly lost money on every single one, and probably not a small amount. XL1 was part of the Ferdinand Piëch era of money-losing halo cars to demonstrate VW group's engineering excellence. Bugatti Veyron and VW Phaeton were other cars to come out of this obsession.

XL1 is an interesting 'what-if' of cars. If VW doesn't get caught cheating on emissions we would likely have gotten some kind of successor to the XL1 that was actually truly a production car. Certainly VW would have at least tried a few production diesel hybrids. Instead they became the first large established automaker to fully commit to a battery-electric future.

theluketaylor··on Electric vehicles are way more energy-efficient than internal combustion
Yes, it takes more energy to build a BEV than an ICE car. It's not massively different and the lifetime emissions of a BEV are still lower than an ICE car even on a pretty dirty grid.

good breakdown: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RhtiPefVzM

theluketaylor··on Electric vehicles are way more energy-efficient than internal combustion
Newer chemistries like LFP do not use rare earth metals and have far higher cycle times.

It is true that building an EV in the first place does embody more carbon, but the payback time is not that long (under 15,000 miles with a clean enough grid and under 50,000 even on the dirtiest grids). As the grid and supply chain decarbonizes that embedded carbon of manufacturing will also drop.

An EV gets cleaner as the grid you drive it on decarbonizes. An ICE vehicle will emit for its whole lifespan and will get worse fuel economy and emit more particulates, SO2 and NOX as it ages.

Anyone who claims EVs will save the planet is deluding themselves, but electrified transport needs to be one of many, many steps we take to decarbonize.

theluketaylor··on The Reason Why Are Trucks Getting Bigger
Current Ranger is really far closer to the F-150 of 20-30 years ago than the Ranger of the 80s.

Even the Civic and Corolla have gotten huge. 2004 Civic was 4455 mm long and 1720 mm wide. The new Civic is 4674 mm long and 1801 mm wide. The new Civic is actually bigger than the 2004 Accord (which was 4665 mm long and 1760 mm wide)

theluketaylor··on Things I learnt doing stand-up comedy
That's a specific type of expectation confounding that comes from a dangling modifier. English is particularly good at creating these types of sentences and it leads to some of my very favourite jokes.

If the lady had said "Can you spare a few minutes to discuss supporting cancer research" there isn't any ambiguity in the sentence and then no joke.

Community used these to great effect. For example:

Britta: Yep, I’m getting serious. I got a backpack, got a new notebook. Oh, I got one of those see-through yellow pens so I can do that thing where you colour in the words.

Shirley: Highlight?

Britta: Probably the backpack.

theluketaylor··on The Reason Why Are Trucks Getting Bigger
F-150 11th gen (2004-2008) SuperCrew 6.5' length: 5,989 mm, width 2004 mm

F-150 13th gen (2015-2020) SuperCrew 6.5' length: 6,190 mm, width 2029 mm

CAFE is a huge driver of truck sizes and this has been known for many years. There is consumer demand in there as well, and once one of the big three go bigger the rest have to follow, but if the CAFE rules didn't take size into account it would be far, far harder for auto makers to increase the size since there is a fuel consumption penalty for more mass and frontal area.

theluketaylor··on The global housing market is broken, and it’s dividing entire countries
Canadian here who is in favour of truly punitive vacancy taxes. Our housing crisis has been ignored for decades and now drastic action is required on a number of fronts, including combating vacancy (I'd also like to see zoning laws and development objections in urban areas die in a fire). The issue is now so acute I'd be in favour of vacancy taxing any address in major metros that isn't someone's filing address with CRA. At the very least the owner should need to demonstrate there is a long term, legal tenant at any address CRA didn't get a filing from.

Vancouver tried, but I don't think they aimed high enough; many speculators just view the tax as the cost of doing business and subtracted it from their gains. At least it's up to 3% now; the 1% initial was way too small.

Added bonus if we measure vacancy right it will kill the short term air bnb market at the same time. I have no issue with people renting their home out a few weeks a year while they are on vacation for some extra cash, but it's heinous there are apartments owned solely for short term rental when tons of people can't afford homes.

theluketaylor··on Ask HN: How to utilize excess energy in remote areas
I'd love to see way more effort and subsidies going into thermal batteries. We don't need to invent any new technology since it already exists. Thermal batteries can use pretty mundane, low impact materials, so the downsides of mining and manufacturing scale of chemical batteries don't apply. Thermal batteries can't solve the problem on their own, but we can build them now at huge scale pretty cheaply.
theluketaylor··on Heat pumps are efficient and eco-friendly. So why are they so rarely used?
Resistive heat is staggeringly expensive to operate in cold climates and the people most often using it are renters who have no choice. The heat pump law and subsidy I'd most like to see is for retrofitting rental units with heat pumps, especially in places where the renter is paying for utilities. Make sure the landlord can't block the improvement (or force them to do it and cover some costs).

I like carbon pricing in theory as a market solution, but it really only works when the person paying the extra cost can make different choices about their usage. Those of us rich, old, or lucky enough to own homes can retrofit for efficiency as we see fit. Renters are stuck with whatever heat source, air sealing, and insulation they draw in the lottery, especially in the current housing crunch. If the renter is also paying the utilities the person with the carbon-pricing incentive to make improvements isn't allowed to and the landlord has no reason to change.

← PreviousPage 10 of 22Next →