HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thereddaikon

2,503 karma · joined January 12, 2021

submissionscomments
thereddaikon··on Ed Sheeran demonstrates how copyright is destroying musicians
Most people only define violence as kinetic and physical. Mean words are not violence no matter how often sociologists say it.
thereddaikon··on The “baseline” scene in bladerunner 2049 was written by Ryan Gosling (2022)
Artificial humans as in they are flesh and blood like biological humans but are engineered. More like the clone troopers from star wars but they are designed to do all sorts of jobs not just soldiers and they aren't direct clones of real people.

Rutger Hauer's character Roy Batty is a soldier replicant. He was made for combat and even talks about it in his tears in the rain speech at the end. Because he's a soldier model he has greater physical features than biological humans. Stronger, tougher etc. He deals with Deckard without trouble.

Another replicant in the film named Pris is described as a "basic pleasure model". I think you can figure that out.

Replicants form a slave underclass in the world of Blade Runner and the Tyrell corp markets and sells them. The replicants in the movie are part of the latest "nexus 6" line. Sounds like smartphones but they were going for a consumer product feel.

thereddaikon··on The “baseline” scene in bladerunner 2049 was written by Ryan Gosling (2022)
Replicants aren't robots. They are artificial humans.
thereddaikon··on Voyager as Technosignature
I see someone has read the road not taken.
thereddaikon··on Necrobrands – Digital End-Stage Capitalism
The onus is on the critic to provide a better alternative. But all I ever see anyone propose is the same tired marxism that has been proven time and time again to be even worse. Its a lazy argument.

Perhaps we need to go back to first principles. Both capitalism and socialism are materialist. This is probably the wrong framework to structure society. It made sense when we became industrial. But we are now post industrial and at least in the global north rapidly approaching the possibility of post scarcity.

thereddaikon··on Experian is a pile of dark pattern garbage
What Canada did to those protesters shows why you don't want it to be government controlled.

Its a sticky problem because both options suck. Would be best if we could manage to do away with the system entirely. But good luck. The financial sector holds way to much power in our society. They usually get what they want.

thereddaikon··on SVB shows that there are few libertarians in a financial foxhole
They are getting it from liquidating the assets of the Bank. There are three parties who are "owed" here. The depositors, holders of debt and investors. Depositors are being made whole. Anyone who holds secured debt will get what's left. Owners of unsecured debt and investors are left out. Which is fine by me.
thereddaikon··on AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency
MacOS has seemingly gotten worse over the years not better. Features removed. Interface has been changed for the worse. The drive to unify the desktop experience with iOS. I could go on.
thereddaikon··on B2B startups stop innovating the day you give power to product managers
I've worked with good and bad PMs and this jives with my experience.
thereddaikon··on Half of Americans now believe that news organizations deliberately mislead them
This is mostly due to local news stations being lazy and regurgitating copy without doing any work on their own. The way news works involves stories and information being piped from party to party. Much of it comes from the AP or major national news bodies. Having seen how the sausage is made for these small local outfits, they are often run on a low budget with limited staff, old equipment and little bandwidth for their own editorial work outside of specific local news. Anything larger is likely going to be a copy paste job. The same is true for the weatherman. He's mostly just reading what the weather service puts out.
thereddaikon··on Bing: “I will not harm you unless you harm me first”
Yes but due to the nature of ML trained tools that isn't as straightforward as it would otherwise be. OpenAI has gone to great lengths to try and fence in ChatGPT from undesirable response but you can never do this completely.

Some of this testing is just that, people probing for the limitations of the model. But a lot of it does seem like people are misusing the software and aren't aware of it. A contributing factor may be how ChatGPT has been portrayed in media in regards to its purpose and capability. As well as people ascribing human-like thinking and emotions to the responses. This is a Chinese room situation.

thereddaikon··on Bing: “I will not harm you unless you harm me first”
Yeah while these are amusing they really all just amount to people using the tool wrong. Its a language model not an actual AI. stop trying to have meaningful conversations with it. I've had fantastic results just giving it well structured prompts for text. Its great at generating prose.

A fun one is to prompt it to give you the synopsis of a book by an author of your choosing with a few major details. It will spit out several paragraphs and of a coherent plot.

thereddaikon··on Google employees criticize CEO for “dumpster fire” response to ChatGPT
Microsoft's demo wasn't perfect but everyone worth listening to has been saying ChatGPT is fallible this whole time. It was well within expectations.

Google however came in with a different expectation. I remember something about one of their execs disparaging OpenAI over inaccuracies before. If you are going to sling mud, you had better make sure you don't have the same problem. Or it makes you look like a fool.

thereddaikon··on Connecticut parents arrested for letting kids walk to Dunkin' Donuts
They aren't disenfranchised. Everyone knows which way California will go so they don't spend a lot of time campaigning there. Candidates have a limited amount of time and money. So they focus on the swing states. My state also votes pretty consistently and therefore doesn't get much campaigning. I don't feel like I am disenfranchised for it.

And for everyone who is crying about the popular vote, there is a very good reason we don't do that. It was recognized from the start that if you do a strict popular vote. the more populous and wealthy areas would always call the shots and would dictate politics to the rest of the nation. At the time that meant Virginia. But it doesn't really matter who, the principle still holds. This was a compromise between populous areas and rural areas in order to get the union formed.

If you switch to a pure popular vote then the nation would be run by a handful of mega cities like NYC, LA etc. That's not democracy. The system we have prevents that while still allowing for populous areas to matter. Getting rid of the electoral college would remove one of the main compromises our federal system is built on and in my opinion would be fair grounds for any state to secede. It would be comparable to throwing away parts of the Bill of Rights.

thereddaikon··on CNET's AI journalist appears to have committed extensive plagiarism
Art is a skill that takes time to master. There are college level classes on mastering the human form. Just because most people are bad at drawing hands doesn't mean they don't understand what a hand is. That's a fundamentally different problem than what AI systems have.

As for the bikes, I'm not surprised most people cant recall the exact shape or design of a mechanical object they don't use or work on every day. I'm sure a hobby cyclist could accurately lay out one.

thereddaikon··on CNET's AI journalist appears to have committed extensive plagiarism
>I still don't understand the purported difference between "sounds smart" and "is smart".

Its easy to see in practice with AI. Look at AI generated images and how they just cant get human hands right. Everyone knows a human should have 4 fingers and a thumb on each hand. But the AI does not understand that it is drawing a hand with those parameters. It is making something that sort of looks like other things it has been trained with.

The same is true for text generation. A common description for Chat GPT I've seen catch on is calling it "confidently wrong". It will string together words that sound good but it doesn't actually have any understanding behind them. Its logic is in stringing words together. This is more akin to a good con man faking knowledge than an expert explaining a topic.

thereddaikon··on The strange and awful path of productivity in the US construction sector
In my modestly sized city nowhere near California or New York the problem has nothing to do with building costs and predates the rising costs of building materials. It has everything to do with poor city planning and a lack of building permits for middle income housing. Plenty of over priced McMansions and plenty of half occupied apartments. Not enough normal houses. So the market became irrational. People buying houses site unseen even before COVID. And property values going way up.

Another contributor to the problem was outside speculators buying residential properties. Specifically Berkshire Hathaway and Zillow come to mind. But I'm sure others were doing it too. It should be illegal.

thereddaikon··on The strange and awful path of productivity in the US construction sector
Affordable housing has little to do with the cost of building the house.
thereddaikon··on Japan's hydrogen strategy does nothing for decarbonisation: study
>This doesn’t make sense to me. Hydrogen is not an energy source

Hydrogen is often compared against batteries. Those aren't an energy source either. I haven't seen anyone seriously propose hydrogen based powerplants. I have seen plenty talk about hydrogen fuel cells as a potential alternative to BEVs and a potential way to get around the multiple short comings of lithium batteries. Fuel cells of course have their own problems. But we've yet to come up with an alternative to gas engines that are as long ranged, quick to fuel, reliable, cost effective, safe and performant while also being net zero or negative carbon.

>So the only way this seems like a win for Japan is if electricity were cheap, battery EVs were not economical, and the loss associated with electrically synthesized hydrogen didn’t matter.

I feel like you are handwaving the issues with BEVs while focusing on the issues with hydrogen. I'm not sure which at the end of the day will turn out to be better. But right now BEVs are incapable of becoming the defacto solution for the simple fact that the battery packs wear out and replacing them will total the car. You can't develop a working used market this way. And lower income individuals simply can never afford to use them. The fact that car markers are going out of their way to design platforms with batteries that are difficult to replace exacerbates the problem. But even if they were easily swapped, their high cost and the fact they are tied to the vehicle means a large chunk of the market can't afford them. And nobody is talking about this.

thereddaikon··on Apple offers $970 in trade-in value for $52,199 Mac Pro
Lenovo seems to be doing alright. But Apple has one big difference from IBM, they control the software side. So allowing generic Macs wouldn't turn them in to IBM. It would turn them in to Microsoft.
thereddaikon··on Apple offers $970 in trade-in value for $52,199 Mac Pro
There was a brief moment in the 90's before Jobs returned when Apple allowed MacOS to be licensed to third party system integrators. Naturally, the companies that popped up to sell generic Macs were massively under cutting Apple. Their prices have never been something that could stand up to direct competition.
thereddaikon··on The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early galaxies
Dark matter is the umbrella term for the observed discrepancies. MOND is one possible possible explanation for DM. The paper you linked doesn't compare MOND to DM, because that doesn't make any sense. It compares MOND to ΛCDM which is a competing explanation.
thereddaikon··on Japan, US to step up cooperation in developing next-generation nuclear reactors
I dont think its accurate to equate floating trash and something dissolved in solution. Their behavior is likely to be very different.
thereddaikon··on Japan, US to step up cooperation in developing next-generation nuclear reactors
Not directly. More that they fund groups that are anti nuclear.
thereddaikon··on ‘My power’s low’: NASA’s Insight Mars lander prepares to sign off
>If you're asking why they don't add them I've provided some speculative reasoning based on my experience in adjacent industries.

See, I don't see it that way. You didn't state it as "here are some possible reasons". You formed your argument as "this is why what you are proposing is wrong". Without actually being an authority on it and knowing if that's true.

Neither am I. But we should be able to discuss hypotheticals and come up with ideas as to possible solutions and their drawbacks. I'm sure there are very good reasons why they don't include them. But, having worked in the aerospace industry although nothing to do with NASA or spaceprobes, I find arguments about budget or building just to the mission unsatisfactory. I'm pretty sure there is an engineering challenge that makes it unworkable or unpractical and you and I are just ignorant to it.

There are obvious benefits to the ability to clean solar panels on Mars. And Space probes tend to be more over engineered than people give them credit for. Yes they are built to extreme margins to optimize capability for low weight. But that capability is great. We are talking about the same engineers who replaced the perfectly workable airbag solution for the skycrane which was far more complicated a solution because it promised to land the vehicle softer and give it a better chance of making it to surface unbroken.

So I can only conclude that there is some kind of engineering problem that prevents it. Maybe Mars dust is more like Moon dust that dirt on Earth and its akin to tiny razors? Brushing it off could damage the solar panels.

That's just me spitballing.

thereddaikon··on ‘My power’s low’: NASA’s Insight Mars lander prepares to sign off
Show me a Mars rover that was still functioning but didn't get a mission extension so was just left to do nothing and decay. I doubt you will. If they are still working they are practically guaranteed a mission extension because the cost of continuing to operate a rover that you have already placed on mars and paid for is marginal relative to the mission. The most expensive part is designing and building the probe and then getting it there.

>At the end of the day the best way to ensure mission success is to put the mission first, not future missions, not "nice to haves", put every dollar you have into making the prescribed mission as perfect as possible. You're suggesting the equivalent of "Navy SEALs sometimes get caught in larger than expected firefights, so each man should lug an extra 1000 rounds of spare ammo into combat just in case". And they could, but that would slow them down and endanger the immediate mission, even if only slightly.

That's a massive exaggeration. I am not advocating for a contingency to every possible failure mode. I am pointing out that we clearly have one very common failure mode that can be solved and likely get us far more utility for little investment.

If you are going to compare it to Navy Seals, what I am suggesting is more akin to "Navy Seals can get shot. That's not good and these are highly trained specialists that don't grow on trees, we should probably give them body armor to give them a chance to survive being shot." And we do give them body armor. Yes it adds weight. Yes it costs more money. But more come home to complete more missions.

Yes a mechanical solution to remove dust from panels adds weight and cost but it can be the difference between an otherwise functional probe dying one day due to low power or dying years later once its electronics fail.

thereddaikon··on ‘My power’s low’: NASA’s Insight Mars lander prepares to sign off
Seems a bit shortsighted to me. Given that if they avoid a catastrophic failure before landing these things seems to consistently last beyond the originally planned mission, they should be building them with mission extensions in mind.

Not putting all your eggs in one basket of course. Shit happens and probes are still lost even today. But a simple device to remove dust such as a vibration function, a small blower fan or something else seems to be a major value add.

Even if it costs $1 million extra to do, it costs far more to build the rover and send it there so you are still saving money.

thereddaikon··on The Fermi paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the contact era
Why would they bother making a sim that big if it was empty? Even No Man's Sky is full of cookie cutter creatures.
thereddaikon··on The Fermi paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the contact era
Von Neumann was much smarter than I but for such a calculation you have to make so many assumptions as to make it worthless. How can we possibly be able to predict what happens to a civilization in 10 million years?

And yes I am aware of Von Neumann probes. But as someone else pointed out there may be secondary effects we aren't even aware of.

thereddaikon··on The Fermi paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the contact era
I think the answer is pretty obvious, we are the precursor species.

Or it could be any number of things other than nobody out there. For example, advanced life could be out there but it might be rare enough that you only end up with a handful of space capable civilizations at any one time. The milky way is a big place. If we assume that ultimately there isn't a clever way around the speed of light then two civilizations on the opposite side of the galaxy will never encounter each other.

Or maybe its rare enough that you are only likely to have at a time in a galaxy.

Or maybe the prerequisite tech to thrive on an interstellar level means they simply aren't detectable by out primitive sensors. Poor backwards humans, still using the electromagnetic spectrum to measure things!

Hell, we could have a Prime Directive situation on our hands too. Although I think that one is really really unlikely.

← PreviousPage 7 of 23Next →