942 karma · joined May 18, 2013
Me: Where do you manufacture your products? Company: We used to manufacture them in Canada but we shifted to China. But rest assured, our quality is the same and blah blah blah.
So my point is, we do not have a choice. You can boycott Apple or Sony PS4 now, but it doesn't end there.
In other places in the article, it repeatedly talks about how talking about drones is considered by the NSA as "propaganda." This perhaps also shows the power trip the NSA is on. "You dare question what America does? You must be a commie!".
http://static.fsf.org/nosvn/stickers/DBD-Sticker_002-jmt.svg
Me: You should care about these things. X: But I have got nothing to hide! I don't care. (Then I get the look, "Do you have something to hide?") Me: OK. Since you have nothing to hide, please give me your Facebook password so that I can go through your FB inbox. Also, your Gmail and Skype passwords would be good to have, since you have nothing to hide.
Never fails to work.
I think the issue is that people tend to place certain "trust" with the government and that their information won't be misused and have this notion that the government can't do no wrong. But they tend to forget that there are people in a government.
Every year a new phone is released, which has marginal improvements over the previous ones. But you know what? People will still buy it and Apple knows that very well.
But then, if you look at it, probably nothing is 100% secure ... not even SSL perhaps, but we still use it. I think what he means to say is that the technologies we use to keep us secure may not be 100% foolproof, but still using a HTTPS connection instead of plain-HTTP is better. Of course, this depends on who your adversary is.
In this case, I agree with you -- he should have mentioned this.
Great movie BTW.
The answer to that question is also here. You have the NIST, a government entity that is opposing another government entity, the NSA, because the former does not agree with the latter's practices. We should not forget that the government is not one cohesive entity and this is an example of that.
SSDs are getting better now, but are they as reliable as HDD? Can anyone shares his/her expertise on this?
Why? :)
Why? I do not have a Facebook account or a Twitter account. Why do most web services insist of having one of these accounts? I do not want to keep my "high score" for the imaginary Internet points. I do not want to see how others are doing. I just want to take the quiz.
You just lost someone who would have definitely played this game and spent time on the site.
Great idea though. I have shared this with my friends.
The problems it has are clearly discussed in multiple places -- websites, research papers, etc. I don't think it can be more sound than that.
> You're routing your data through several strangers, who are all volunteers and may be individuals who support anonymity or governments who are trying to break it, relying on them discarding logs in order to preserve your anonymity.
It doesn't matter. That is the entire idea behind Tor.
> However, there are several problems. The data coming out of the exit nodes is unencrypted. There are also lots of ways that data can leak at your endpoint. For instance, many programs may make DNS queries that don't go through Tor, so what you are looking up may be leaked.
The TBB already takes care of this. So unless you use some crappy third-party browser, you are safe from these problems because they know about it and they have been fixed.
Of course the exit node is not something you can trust. But your argument does not always hold true because TBB ships with HTTPS Everywhere by default. So almost all major websites will automatically use HTTPS and therefore the exit node sniffing your connection is rendered useless. Now if you are sending out your information over plain-HTTP, then yes, you will have it compromised.
> Furthermore, Tor doesn't sent data at a constant bitrate. Someone who can monitor traffic on a large portion of the network can correlate it across points.
Because Tor is a low-latency network, timing analysis is easy to perform if the entry and the exit node are controlled by the same entity. Now this depends on whether the NSA runs Tor exits or not and I cannot answer this question.
> Finally, due to the nature of routing traffic between several points, a fairly limited number of exit nodes, and the encryption, Tor is fairly slow. So most people won't really be able to use it on a day to day basis, making mere use of it somewhat suspicious, and likely to subject you to more scrutiny.
Anonymity loves diversity. Tor has a diverse userbase and it is getting better. I do not think it is that slow -- surely we can't expect it to be as fast as your normal internet connection -- but it is not bad either. I think FWIW, given what it does and what we need, there is no better solution so I think we might as well stick to it than trusting some proprietary software.
The NSA is a different case. We do not know anything about it, except from the leaks. But we do know things about Tor.
a). Actively developed, follows the best principles possible. Open discussions in IRC, active mailing list, developers who respond to queries.
b). Highly researched by some of the best universities in the world. Cambridge and Waterloo come to mind instantly.
c). There has not been a single case of mistrust on their part that should make someone suspicious about them.
The day Tor does something like this, not only they lose their funding, they lose users and they become a dead project. With so much reputation at stake -- and they are respected people in the community -- Dingledine and Mathewson doing something like this? I don't think so.
No, definitely not. Science should never be above questioning, or be subject to fanboyism.
My point was -- people keep bringing this argument up time and again but do not bring any proof to the table. The code is out there. Don't you perhaps think that the professors at some of the most reputed universities in the world who research on Tor would perhaps eventually find some alleged backdoor, given the code goes through so much scrutiny? I maybe wrong of course but some proof of this would be good. Honestly. And I am not being sarcastic, I have donated money and if I ever found out that something remotely like this is happening, do you think that people like me or the organizations who fund Tor will give it any more money?
a). For all the bundles, they are signed by the Tor developer who packages them. The signatures are clearly visible with the downloads.
b). Most importantly:
Tor is moving towards deterministic builds: https://blog.torproject.org/blog/deterministic-builds-part-o...
Different people build the Tor Browser Bundles on Gitian (look it up), and they will have the same hashes. So unless ALL of these people are lying, if their hashes match, you can be convinced that it is the same binary as you would get by compiling it.