HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thirteenfingers

395 karma · joined May 15, 2013

musician and sysadmin/programmer

Not to be confused with the Reddit user of the same name, no relation as far as I know

submissionscomments
thirteenfingers··on On Facebook and YouTube, classical musicians are getting blocked or muted
I've posted about this here before, but a lot of people who upload their own videos of classical music on youtube and get copyright-warned or copyright-striked are too spooked to file a counter-claim. If it was a bot that automatically filed the claim against you, there's a very good chance the claim will be automatically lifted if you counter-claim.

Yes, youtube will give you a big scary warning about how repeated violations could mean your account is shut down. Every time this happened I went ahead and submitted counter-claim anyway. On all but one occasion the copyright claim disappeared immediately. The one exception required a bit of escalation but I still wound up on top (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22488897 if you're curious).

I understand a good many people simply do not feel comfortable risking their youtube account being shut down from contested claims, but I suspect that for many the risk is a lot lower than they realize.

thirteenfingers··on Ask HN: Is YouTube Working Properly?
Northeast US. Actually it appears to have come back maybe two or three minutes after my first comment.
thirteenfingers··on Ask HN: Is YouTube Working Properly?
It's down for me. Tells me my channel "has no content". I have a live stream scheduled in less than 24 hours - keeping my fingers crossed this is resolved quickly.
thirteenfingers··on How coffee became a modern necessity
Very disappointed that the article doesn't mention that about 1734 Johann Sebastian Bach actually wrote a secular cantata (often called the "Coffee Cantata") telling the story of a father trying to get his daughter to stop drinking coffee.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schweigt_stille,_plaudert_nich...

https://www.bachvereniging.nl/en/bwv/bwv-211/

thirteenfingers··on A music discovery site used in over 1M videos and games
Yes. Even among those who hope someday to make music their living, many will opt to forgo immediate profit for experience and exposure alone.

My personal attitude (in general, I haven't contributed to this site) is that it's incredibly difficult and even soul-sucking to try and earn a decent living in music performance, let alone composition, so I don't even try. Instead, I have a day job - I work in IT for my alma mater - and in return for reduced time available for music, I get complete freedom to pursue the musical projects I want at my own pace. This way I can be sort of my own patron. Sure, getting paid for music would be nice, but I'm not going to insist on it for a given project unless that was the only way to make said project worthwhile to me, in which case I probably wouldn't undertake it in the first place. I suspect there are a good many freelance musicians nowadays who also take this approach.

thirteenfingers··on Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system
Classical pianist here. I've been through youtube's broken copyright enforcement system several times. I'll post a video of myself performing some composition that is in the public domain and it'll get "identified" as a copyrighted recording by someone else. Of course youtube doesn't give you an option for "mistaken claim", you have to choose between "this content is entirely my work" (which isn't quite true in my case, since I didn't write the music) or "this video counts as fair use". I typically select "this video counts as fair use" because it's the least untrue of the available options. Nineteen times out of twenty the claim disappears immediately. (I don't even monetize my videos. I just don't want ads on my videos at all, and I especially don't want ads on my videos if the revenue is going to some completely unrelated party.)

There was, however, one time when I had to deal with an escalated claim. The piece in question was the slow movement of Dvorak's "New World" Symphony. The Symphony has long been in the public domain. However, the slow movement was adapted into the song "Goin' Home", which is still under copyright, and there is a long-standing myth that the song was the inspiration for the Symphony rather than the other way around. Thus when I challenged the copyright claim on my New World video, the claimant came back and insisted their claim (on "Goin' Home") was valid. This notice was of course accompanied by the scary warnings about how if I persisted it could count as a strike against my youtube account.

I called their bluff. I responded with links to every online source I could find showing that Dvorak's work came first and was in the public domain.

I don't know what I would have done had they continued to dig in their heels. Happily, they ended up releasing the claim - days before their claim would have expired anyway - with no elaboration. I'd be curious to hear from anyone else who stuck it through the scary youtube warnings and what the outcome was.

[EDIT: thanks for the clarifications on "own content" and "fair use". I never thought of it that way, but now it seems obvious.]

thirteenfingers··on Music for Programming (2011)
I'm a pianist with an active performing schedule and I'm the same way. I'll listen to music at work if I have relatively mindless tasks to get out of the way, but when it comes to actual coding or anything requiring careful thought, forget it. All music ends up being distracting, either because I really enjoy it or because I find it really annoying.

I'd be curious to know if there are any serious musicians here who can concentrate on writing code or any other similarly mentally-intensive task while listening to music.

thirteenfingers··on Tom Lehrer at 90: a life of scientific satire
A year and a half ago, an actor-singer friend of mine and I decided to give a concert of our personal favorite Tom Lehrer songs. Turnout was tremendous. The bulk of the audience was of that age where they would have been in high school or college when they first heard him, but there were plenty of older and younger people too. It's fantastic how his songs continue to resonate with people after so long.

The problem with performing Tom Lehrer's music nowadays is that your potential audience basically falls into two groups: those that know about Tom Lehrer, and know all the intros and lyrics by heart already, so they don't laugh quite as much anymore; and those who don't know about Tom Lehrer and don't get his humor.

thirteenfingers··on Brian Eno: Composers as Gardeners
Classical composer and performer here. You just hit upon the one aspect of my chosen genre that drives me batshit insane.

I've had countless arguments with other performers about how rigid one has to be when performing any given classical composition. I'm told over and over again that, for example, Glenn Gould's unorthodox interpretations "aren't musical", but when I press my interlocutors for a justification of that statement, all they can offer is "it's not what the composer intended", which only begs the question. Composers aren't infallible, and they definitely don't always see or hear all the possibilities inherent in their own music.

The whole division-of-labor between composer and performer is, I think, both a strength and a weakness in classical music. It's a strength because it's allowed composers to concentrate on exploring the possibilities of musical ideas and working out something marvelously and intricately crafted in advance. It's a weakness because it encourages this hard-set absolute-textual-fidelity mentality among performers, and discourages them from really leaving their individual mark on a performance (unlike in jazz). The great classical composers are among my heroes, but they weren't gods, and performers shouldn't treat them as such.

thirteenfingers··on Brian Eno: Composers as Gardeners
Fellow composer here - I completely agree, and I suspect the great classical composers often felt as much, that their own musical ideas led them in a totally different direction than they originally intended.

My personal feeling about Eno's approach is that it almost deserves a different label than "composing" - maybe "incubating" (you know, like a startup incubator). For me, and I suspect for a great many music lovers, "composing" implies a process that may be evolutionary to some degree but is still overseen and directed from beginning to end by a particular artist. Contrast that with the case of traditional music from $REGIONAL_CULTURE where the process is more truly evolutionary as songs are passed from one generation of bards to another.

(I don't mean to say that Eno's approach to making music is somehow less legitimate than any other. It just seems better described by some other word.)

thirteenfingers··on Whether You’re a Democrat or Republican, Your Social Media Is an Echo Chamber
I think that's a great approach. Personally I haven't been on social media for a couple years now (for various reasons including concerns over data privacy) but I considered having all those opposing views at hand to be one of the principal benefits of social media - in fact, that was the main reason I stayed on social media as long as I did.

> Such a thing was not very possible to do before social networks

I would say it was definitely possible, it just took a bit more effort. (Since leaving social media I've made a point of reading left-wing and right-wing opinion sites side-by-side. It's very illuminating.)

That said, it does seem like for the average user the tendency is for social media to become an echo chamber.

Edit: formatting

thirteenfingers··on How Anxiety Warps Your Perception
Likely third-party voter here:

(1) I suspect every voter has a threshold of evil-ness beyond which they simply can't in good conscience vote for Candidate X, even if Candidate Y is evil-er. For me, we've passed that threshold.

(2) I don't live in a swing state, so my vote already has only symbolic significance. As such I'd rather go on record voting no confidence in either Clinton or Trump, and vote for someone that I think would actually do a reasonable job if by some miracle they became president.

(3) I know Gary Johnson and the other third-party candidates have no chance of winning - _this_ time. I accept that (in my opinion) we're screwed for at least the next four years no matter whether it's Clinton or Trump, but if as many votes as possible go third-party this election, maybe - just maybe - third-parties will gain enough credibility to have a reasonable chance next election, or else the two major parties will finally get the message and pick better candidates.

thirteenfingers··on Why we should all learn from the ancient Greeks
> mostly philosophers

No wonder you say you can find the Greek stuff "pretty boring." There's so much more to Greek literature than philosophy. Try

* Homer - the closest thing the Greeks had to the Bible, yet so different in spirit in that it raises unanswerable questions about the Greeks' beliefs, without affirming them

* Aristophanes - slapstick humor

* Sophocles, Euripides, Aeschylus - the great tragedians

* Herodotus, Thucydides, Xenophon - some of the greatest historians ever, although they fall somewhat short of our modern standards for historical rigor

* Lysias - mainly valuable as a record of the Greek legal process

* Lucian - for satire (if you don't like philosophers, you'll love Lucian)

thirteenfingers··on Why the name?
Great fun. One minor nitpick - the story of "Apache Server" being originally derived from "A Patchy Server" is a long-standing myth; the name was originally intended to be a tribute to the Apache Native American peoples. The Wikipedia article on Apache (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apache_HTTP_Server) includes a link to an interview with Brian Behlendorf (http://www.linux-mag.com/id/472/) where he explains how the story arose.
thirteenfingers··on The Retro-Computing Society of Rhode Island
Website not responding at present (for me). Google cache:

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:eck8H7O...

thirteenfingers··on Adventures in Piano Building
Thanks for that - I've never seen that book before but it looks incredibly thorough and comprehensive.

Another book on the subject is Arthur Reblitz's classic "Piano Servicing, Tuning, and Rebuilding: For the Professional, the Student, and the Hobbyist" which I do own and highly recommend.

http://www.amazon.com/Piano-Servicing-Tuning-Rebuilding-Prof...

thirteenfingers··on An opinionated guide to Scheme implementations (2013)
What specifically are your reservations? - I haven't played around with many Scheme implementations besides DrScheme/DrRacket so I'm not questioning your judgement, I'm just genuinely curious.
thirteenfingers··on Circle of fifths and roots of two
Players of bowed stringed instruments run into this difficulty too. When playing with piano, cellists often have to tune both their lowest and highest strings to the piano, and then sort of average out the discrepancy in the two strings between.
thirteenfingers··on The NY Times endorsed a secretive trade agreement that the public can’t read
Previous discussion regarding the original EFF article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6692833
thirteenfingers··on Ask HN: What happened to the The Matasano Crypto Challenges?
How long ago did you sign up? It took them two or three days to send me the first set.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2