HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thowarray

6 karma · joined October 24, 2017

submissionscomments
thowarray··on Chip Hall of Fame: Atmel ATmega8
Great microcontroller, shitty article.
thowarray··on 11-year-old girl inspired by Flint water crisis creates cheap kit to test lead
> Sure, but what's wrong with that?

Everything!

* You teach the child dishonesty (taking credit for someone elses work can terminate your academic career). * In this particular case, the child becomes the face of a marketing campaign (that's her actual contribution: selling a product). * Stories like this one put pressure on other children because their parents buy it hook line and sinker and want the same for their children.

thowarray··on 11-year-old girl inspired by Flint water crisis creates cheap kit to test lead
Ok, another wunderkind story. At the age of 11:

* Knows how to program Arduino

* knows how to write Android Apps

* has a working understanding of chemistry

* is able to infuse carbon nanotubes with chlorine and build a disposable sensor from this.

* understands marketing enough to promote her product via the app stores (there really is no other reason for using a smartphone instead of three colored LEDs to display results).

Is anyone really buying this?

Here's a more likely story:

* Parents see scientific curiosity in her daughter, as well as the will to help people.

* Parents see a fear of lead in water and therefore a market for testkits

* Parents see that testkits already on the market suffer from being unreliable in untrained hands/too difficult to use.

* Parents have the idea for a better, "digital testkit", but that turns out to be way more expensive than anything that is already on the market.

* Parents then spoonfeed the idea to her daughter. They do the work, she gets the credit (and probably thinks that she did most of the work).

* The media picks the story up because "awwwww ... smart kid", resulting in free marketing for what would otherwise be a totally overengineered/overpriced product.