HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thraway180306

157 karma · joined March 6, 2018

(formely) Helpful News got renewed to its season eleventy while also jumping the shark
submissionscomments
thraway180306··on The Universe Is Not a Simulation, but We Can Now Simulate It
Of course it is falsifiable. If you can't specify in what way you recover physics from your simulation and what computation actually occurs in your simulation then, apart from the word "simulation" making no sense, you don't have any theory to either formulate or test at all. There, falsified for you. In particular cellular automata fit that description. It has been beaten to death since the 80's and leads nowhere, unless of course anybody counts Wolfram a (new kind of) scientist.

Same problem we have in quantum gravity. We just can't recover known physics from anything at all, any combination of theories at all it seems. That includes all known instances of computation, it just blows up.

Also, Church-Turing has nothing to do with basic problems here, in particular because eventual simulating computation would be unlike computation we know (which again, makes the word lose any meaning here).

thraway180306··on In a world of digital nomads, we will all be made homeless
Wow, citing The Economist as neutral news, that's something. Probably about you.
thraway180306··on Dissolving the Fermi Paradox
doubt that Eric Drexler is clueless or malicious

Someone however, does not.

https://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2010/08/24/nano-nonsense-...

thraway180306··on Are real numbers really real?
I noticed you consistently misspell Reuben Hersh's surname. Sorry I haven't corrected you when I first saw you doing that on HN close to a decade ago, assuming you might soon self-correct if only by glancing over the book you hold so dear.

As for the book by Constance Reid, Gian-Carlo Rota's review entitled Misreading the History of Mathematics is all that should be said of it.

thraway180306··on Are real numbers really real?
There are no equations and no citations to relevant formalisms so your guess is good as anyone's.

The author had a spat with arXiv who, while not being a peer-reviewed venue do their best to keep out the crackpottery, rejected some of the stuff coming from his vicinity. Gisin's complaint was loud, ended up published in Nature, and now it seems anything goes.

Then went a flood of similar gems. Such like over-the-top argument for physical time (deep problem formal in nontrivial ways), because thinking requires time thus obviously https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.01497 (doubtful any creative time went into that). I think figure 5 therein anwsers your question best as the author can.

thraway180306··on Are real numbers really real?
In physicist's ontology, as you surely know, that's just an appeal to Bekenstein bound.

Not really being a mathematical result, it is a consequence of thermodynamics and classical (continuous) gravity. Einstein equations can be recovered from thermodynamics and Bekenstein bound as an assumption and that's all there really is to it.

thraway180306··on A Linguistic Enclave in Central Europe
Please. Stop. You write with letters. Wars are waged writing letters. Also thinking is a tool of war. Therefore stop, don't trouble yourself, and be at peace.
thraway180306··on A Linguistic Enclave in Central Europe
Sorry, but none of your sentences make any sense.

What is fought about with Austrian dialects? What is the consensus mechanism, what does the notion of individual expression of power mean? You mean self-expression is a power structure? Did you just hereby invent this notion, or is it some echo of power structures inherent in language stereotypes passed as having anything to do with dialects?

What is obsessive about differentiating, what is "establishing basis of cultural peace". These make no sense to me at all.

I indicated nothing, just repeated concrete examples you choose to ignore for the second time. Then instead of giving your own you choose to muddy the waters with some incomprehensible original philosophy.

thraway180306··on A Linguistic Enclave in Central Europe
Sorry but what is implied apart from your ignorance? Given are concrete examples: Germanisation and Russification, nothing implied.

What are examples of your cultural wars? Anecdote about some villagers? Appeal to human nature? Where and how did it manifest in the history concretely as a cause?

Upthread @lkubner links to interesting piece he wrote about multicultural history of Poland where there was no war over any of this for many centuries. 30-year war on the other hand had less to do with Germans fragmented into 200+ states than with enforcing religious homogenity.

thraway180306··on Eugenics never went away
I don't think Lior believes in his post

You may even think he didn't in fact wrote it. Just before you redefine what it means to think, don't tell anyone.

thraway180306··on Eugenics never went away
Look at the definition, there is no possible way you can equate heredity with heritability unless you can't math, sorry. There's no moral sentiment to appreciate in understanding this definition, just education.

Denialism of the variance it isn't either, the issue is it's fallacious reification. That would be a concern for explanatory power and drawing conclusions even if actual statistical research into these very poorly understood mechanisms weren't so spurious on mathematical level (which was my initial interest).

thraway180306··on Eugenics never went away
The methods weren't "just" morally wrong but a bunch of hokum rationalized as science.

Just like yours.

Heritability does not mean heredity. Even taste is heritable. Results of the GWAS crowd are so bad that Plomin recently truned to praising his levels of signal for being not worse than social sciences. This is astounding from someone previously selling behavioral genetics as a rigorous science up there with actual genetics.

Don't even get me started on IQ https://liorpachter.wordpress.com/2018/06/04/low-iq-scores-p...

thraway180306··on Eugenics never went away
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/iceland-eliminated-syndrom...
thraway180306··on A Course in Machine Learning
I'm not questioning your analysis of behavioral psychology of the herd, but this particular example, prof. Hal Daume of University of Maryland and Microsoft Research has been long associated with the field, though not particularly neural networks, since way before the current hype.
thraway180306··on Severely injured worker sues Tesla
So what you say is either the contractor has to subsidize the restaurant, or coerce employees to do it. Gee, wonder what business contractors are in.

Another question is what business the “restaurant” that can't even hire the cooks is in.

thraway180306··on What does social science have to offer the data industry?
DeepDream is an apt example on a deeper level of analogy. What they wanted was an advance in the important topic of interpretability/explainability. Offshot of a failed experiment turned into the subfield of style transfer and pretty pictures. That became a success of AI somehow, one to talk about and dazzle audience with.

About the OP ignorance, well, statistics started off as a social science, so maybe self professed data scientists while looking into social sciences, ethics and psychology, could also look about history.

thraway180306··on “There is, unfortunately, no such thing as a truly neutral stance on inclusion”
To the mods credit they did make @yummyfajitas go away. Took them years of, as you say, unevenly nice language, but finally they did.
thraway180306··on Before cancer kills, it cheats
biology have computation at the core?

Doubtful. You can to computing with DNA http://dna.caltech.edu but it is still debated if the actual role of DNA is being a code (some recently weasel out form that stance by saying it's an “app”, like there's a difference, machine code being a code). Coding theory applied to DNA yields inconclusive results. Galois theory usually has power over any kind of information encoding, cryptographic, computable or not. One constructed one for DNA convinced mathematicians it's not the way to go at all. If it's computation it's nothing like what we mean by any model computation, you may as well say it's magic instead of making stretched analogies.

About OpenBSD and evolution, that's so fetch... these folk invented the attack in the first place, not evolved a response to some market force in the early oughties. Broadly I don't think designed systems are in business of evolving, otherwise living organisms could perhaps evolved electro-hydrostatic instead of hydraulic power system with a pump being a single point of failure.

thraway180306··on Asian-Americans Suing Harvard Say Admissions Files Show Discrimination
where HN community are based

A vague question

The numbers depend on how you measure 'user' and 'location'

Gets a vague answer.

My question was specifically about the commentariat not eyeballs.

I don't think myself as worthy of an answer specifically to me. I think it would be for the best benefit of others if not buried in some obscure thread.

thraway180306··on Asian-Americans Suing Harvard Say Admissions Files Show Discrimination
It is heartening to know you do gather information of this granularity.

Why not make it available?

thraway180306··on Asian-Americans Suing Harvard Say Admissions Files Show Discrimination
HN is a majority-international site

Sorry, but is this claim based on pageviews, or the origins of the comments being posted?

It's not like guardian.co.uk/international is in fact international news and opinion.

thraway180306··on Supertasks
> You don’t need any theory about infinity

It's not about them, nobody wished them. They came as necessity.

> Everything can be done using approximations

Approximations are analytical animals.

> with bounded error

I don't know how to bound errors without analysis.

> in finite steps.

By usage I didn't mean occasionally computing. (This is not free of problems. BTW you'd be horrified to know even finite purely combinatorial mathematics leads to irrational polytopes, ending up with infinities.) But using as a cornerstone of theory that allows for reasoning of epistemic value i.e. one affording symbolic manipulations that behave in a guaranteed way. Taking differences instead of differentials doesn't matter (why people bother if it were that easy). Whereas Finitism just shifts infinities elsewhere ending up with ultrafilter.

> You have a very strange definition of “real”

I didn't realize I used one. Or that reality has a definition (old problem in philosophy).

Or that it matters. Irrespective of what reality is mathematics can be ① real, ② have different being still connected to reality, ③ or be unreal with some mechanism for reasoning to cross the boundary to reality. First and last are troubling. Issues with the middle one is why there is a philosophy of mathematics at all.

> “real numbers”

Real numbers of course are called so for being perversion that they are. Do try get rid of them. Two centuries people have failed and still try intensely. They need a cheer.

> Every mathematical use of completed infinities inherently involves “mysticism”

I don't see what you could possibly mean. Any specifics?

Other than a lazy trollish attempt at obverting my position. To remind it is that Fictionalism absolves one from studying internal mechanics of fictional things. (Other than stop such worries, what use of invoking it?) You say mathematics is the same. In fact worse: mysticism gets in at every other point, inherently. (Why do I even bother replying…) Is it a cult? I assure you whenever a garden variety idol has deep feelings about eternity and numbers, there is a pushback https://arxiv.org/abs/1211.0244

Mathematics is a study, deals in mysticism as much as accounting: when infinities arise, their need and utility are studied, employed and scrutinized as generously as quantitative easing. If you find baffling mysticism plaguing your understanding, there is no shortage of philosophical equivalents of Bitcoin.

thraway180306··on Supertasks
It depends on your reality of course. It might be the physical reality, whatever that is. Or your own-er reality which might not be logical for example. There are things invariant between realities of course, like the physical experiment and mathematics.

But if your reality upholds logic, you'd have to be very careful as not to take any consequence of your usage of the Fourier transform to be a part of your reality or its description. In which case why use it at all?

Using it is, like I said, an ontological commitment inviting infinities into your system. You may not ascribe them physical meaning, or may renormalize them out, but you can't deny them (do try! though attempts at mathematical ultrafinitism are plagued by problems, whereas finitism, or various less purifying forms of constructive mathematics lead to infinities in just slightly different places).

What you may deny is the reality of the description (that is of you perceiving your reality) whatsoever as Fictionalists do.

thraway180306··on Supertasks
Mathematics is tautological, by definition. In what sense anything within a tautological system can be an abstraction? It's a whole package. There is no à la carte Fourier transform without philosophical commitments.
thraway180306··on Supertasks
Infinity and moreover a hierarchy of infinities is very real and has real consequences. You want your Fourier transform to work, you have to quantify infinities (this was in fact what prompted development of set theory: how to make Fourier analysis precise).

Supertasks are real too. If you take Turing machine something like the lamplighter group pops up at the other end and you have no way to handwave that away.

Unless of course you subscribe to Fictionalism as your philosophy of mathematics, in which case stuff still has consequences just your epistemological stance changes from studying them in favour to some kind of mysticism that absolves you from the effort.

thraway180306··on Applied Category Theory
About ML-related research, Fong also piqued my interest earlier with his categorification of almost PGMs. Though it didn't inspire him or anyone to bring effective methods of algebra to PGM and improve the base theory, making the exercise really shine. So like with many categorification research it's just a 72-page statement „it can be done”.

Brendan Fong (2012) Causal Theories: A Categorical Perspective on Bayesian Networks https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.6201

thraway180306··on Ask HN: Resources to learn real analysis?
This is sometimes called inquiry-based teaching or Moore method, and… there is a textbook advertised as adhering to this particular style, Carol Schumacher's Closer and Closer: Introducing Real Analysis, haven't had it in hand though.
thraway180306··on Ask HN: Resources to learn real analysis?
Law+Math degree is definitely on the weirder side of things I've heard (and I endorsed Oxford's joint CS and Philosophy). But in that case I may allow myself to make an equally far stretch connecting something lawyerly with real analysis (that isn't about RA utility in data science for law enforcement). About how model theory shapes logic. It is advanced (practically algebraic geometry now) and not really related any more, but the basic issue came from set theory and analysis: models of infinitesimals, like in Keisler books. Since then it came to encompass and classify all logic-based mathematics (not every creative reasoning in mathematics is logical! though papers always are) and more exotic logics such as the „default logic” sometimes employed by lawyers.

It's Bressoud BTW, I endorse that too. Along with TW Körner „Companion to Analysis: A First Second and Second First Course” with Lang or Zorich as base. I wouldn't be as insistent on pencil at all times if it were to prevent broader reading or just expanded skimming.

thraway180306··on Ask HN: Resources to learn real analysis?
Also Shilov.
thraway180306··on Ask HN: Resources to learn real analysis?
Rudin is a good breviary rehearsal if one already almost-knows and feels the material. People with certain inclinations may get a warm fuzzy feeling how things neatly fit together as if by omniscient design. Otherwise it is a crossword puzzle to amuse the god himself.

You may get a feeling you understood things (and earned that), but you are wrong. When I ask people what they really remember Rudin from, what specific piece of proof they learned specifically from his main and baby books, I hear only vague answers. There is a pretense of “teaching to think” by omission, also common in some dated textbooks, but I personally would leave that to professionals over at philosophy dept. and focus on clear exposition leaving neatness for examples. OTOH if you are predisposed to lauding yourself for how smart you (or Rudin) are for figuring all the tricks (knowledge of which stays at this level), you are in for ego boost (or bust).

Especially for real analysis his treatment of Lebesgue integral is worse than just about anyone else's I know (also, in 21st century it's time for better integrals like e.g. Henstock–Kurzweil). The only thing worse is again Rudin's own treatment of differential forms.

In professional mathematics Rudin is renowed for numerous many things, among them the Rudin–Keisler order in the theory of ultrafilters and ultraproducts. It is a sign about reading order. Because as it happens Keisler also wrote a textbook, and from a diametrically opposed perspective. Equally far fetched in the other direction, one of intuitionistic non-standard infinitesimals. I think being a product of certain totalising era of uniformisation in mathematics these texts are complimentary.

For a reader interested in somewhat extended real analysis I would recommend Lang, Bressoud, Körner („Companion…”).

Mentioned Terence Tao book from weblog-notes for his original RA course is also freely downloadable as pdf.

Finally Strichartz is overly chatty wordier antithesis to Rudin.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →