HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwaway287391

673 karma · joined October 13, 2013

submissionscomments
throwaway287391··on A restaurant owner who asked for 1-star Yelp reviews
Seemingly unpopular take on my experience with various review sites:

1) In the US, Yelp's reviews of restaurants have a significantly higher correlation with reality than any other review site. Google reviews are okay.

2) In Europe, Yelp reviews are mostly by American tourists and are sparser and higher variance quality-wise. Google reviews seem to be generally the best in Europe. (Canada might be a toss-up between Yelp and Google.)

3) In both continents TripAdvisor reviews are pretty much meaningless. I've been to multiple restaurants on TripAdvisor with ~4.5 that have absolutely sucked in terms of both food, service, and atmosphere.

I don't have much experience with reviews for local businesses that aren't restaurants or outside of the US/Canada/Europe. But in the US, for all of Yelp's supposed manipulation, their reviews are noticeably better than other sites'.

throwaway287391··on Differences between the word2vec paper and its implementation
I don't have much to say to most of this, but I'll point out that I didn't and couldn't have downvoted you as none of my throwaways have >=500 karma or whatever the threshold is.
throwaway287391··on Differences between the word2vec paper and its implementation
You're right, I misread that part.
throwaway287391··on Differences between the word2vec paper and its implementation
What? This has nothing to do with bugs in the code that would've affected the original author's ability to run the original experiments described in the paper. The user I replied to is talking about things like hard-coded data paths and wanting to be able to run the code at the press of a button on any platform. The expectation for this level of cross-platform compatibility is difficult to achieve for engineering firms with millions to invest in making it work properly. He's mad that individual machine learning researchers don't always do a great job of making it happen for their cutting-edge research which was a difficult enough engineering task to get running on their machine.
throwaway287391··on Differences between the word2vec paper and its implementation
This sort of thing is aggravating to read. Frankly it comes off as really entitled. As researchers, the expectation is now that we not only have to do the research and write a paper like the good old days, but we have to release the code too. Okay, fine. But now that's not enough either -- the code has to be well-documented and clean. Ugh, alright, fine -- it's going to take me a few extra weeks of not doing research, but I'll clean up all the code, rerun experiments to make sure it all still works like before, and add a bunch of documentation. But no, still not good enough -- it has to run at the press of a button in your particular programming environment. If we don't know how to write a script (or couldn't be bothered to spend the time writing one) to check that the data is on disk and, if not, crawl a website to download some huge dataset in one click, test our code on your OS, your CPU/GPU/TPU/..., etc., we were being "insincere" with our open-sourcing efforts.
throwaway287391··on Google – My Activity
I'm sorry, but ... are you (and others here with similar reactions) serious? You don't think Google knows when you skip a song in Google Music? How do you think recommendations work exactly? I thought this was HackerNews, not my grandpa's Facebook feed.
throwaway287391··on Foreign Minister Taro Kono to ask media to switch order of Japanese names
> In every formal context, the "family name" is how you should address someone. (You do not address the queen of England as "Mrs. Windsor", and Saddam Hussein preferred to be known as "Saddam", which is not a family name.)

Don't these "falsehoods" just become ridiculous at some point? Like, am I really supposed to carve out special cases in my shitty app's business logic for the Queen and Saddam Hussein?

throwaway287391··on Procrastination is not a time management problem, it is an emotion
> Tip: to make your git logs look socially acceptable to co-workers and management, don't commit at 3AM Monday morning, wait until 9AM.

You mean commit locally any time, and then squash your commits into one big one with a socially acceptable timestamp before you push?

throwaway287391··on Salesforce enables ‘modify all’ in user profiles
> * Enforce style rules with a linter/test, like "UPDATE must have a LIMIT"

As someone who has never had access to a DB with any serious number of users, can you explain this one further? What if you really do want to update every row? Do you just do LIMIT INT_MAX or the like, and just force people to write that so that they always know they're updating the entire table? Or are you saying you should only ever use UPDATE on a known finite (and small?) number of rows?

throwaway287391··on Low-Income College Students Are Being Taxed Like Trust-Fund Babies
These criteria are really shitty for some people. My middle class parents spoiled me and paid for the entirety of my college tuition and expenses, but I had friends from families with similar income whose parents completely refused to pay for any college expenses, and they had to survive on whatever scholarships and student loans they could get, but couldn't get any FAFSA aid. I'm not sure what the alternative is, and I'm sure they were more privileged than many/most of the people who do qualify for FAFSA aid, but it still felt really unfair to me.

I guess they should've gotten sham marriages to qualify as independent? (Why is marriage a qualifying criterion for independence? Seems really antiquated to me...)

throwaway287391··on The Relationship Between Profanity and Honesty (2017)
> The honesty of the status updates written by the participants was assessed following the approach introduced by Newman, Pennebaker, Berry, and Richards (2003) using LIWC. Their analyses showed that liars use fewer first-person pronouns (e.g., I, me), fewer third-person pronouns (e.g., she, their), fewer exclusive words (e.g., but, exclude), more motion verbs (e.g., arrive, go), and more negative words (e.g., worried, fearful; Newman, Pennebaker, Berry, & Richards, 2003). The explanation was that dishonest people subconsciously try to (1) dissociate themselves from the lie and therefore refrain from referring to themselves, (2) prefer concrete over abstract language when referring to others (using someone’s name instead of “he” or “she”), (3) are likely to feel discomfort by lying and therefore express more negative feelings, and (4) require more mental resources to obscure the lie and therefore end up using less cognitively demanding language, which is characterized by a lower frequency of exclusive words and a higher frequency of motion verbs. Equation and usage rates in this study are summarized in Table 2.

> Newman et al. (2003) achieved up to 67% accuracy when detecting lies, which was significantly higher than the 52% near-chance accuracy achieved by human judges. Their approach has been successfully applied to behavioral data (Slatcher et al., 2007) and to Facebook status updates (Feldman, Chao, Farh, & Bardi, 2015). Other studies have since found support for these LIWC dimensions as being indicative of lying and dishonesty (Bond & Lee, 2005; Hancock, Curry, Goorha, & Woodworth, 2007; see meta-analyses by DePaulo et al., 2003 and Hauch, Masip, Blandón-Gitlin, & Sporer, 2012).

So it's all purely from linguistic analysis of the status updates. Seems like a stretch to me but I wouldn't doubt the overall result is true.

throwaway287391··on L.A.’s Elite on Edge as Prosecutors Pursue More Parents in Admissions Scandal
Sure, but if we're actually talking about donating a building (maybe I took that too literally?), we're talking about 3 kids a year, tops. It would barely change the 2nd decimal place in an acceptance percentage at a lot of schools.
throwaway287391··on L.A.’s Elite on Edge as Prosecutors Pursue More Parents in Admissions Scandal
The amount to donate a building probably covers the cost to expand the student capacity of a university by several dozen students. With the donation they could easily afford to accept everyone they otherwise would have accepted and also accept the one rich kid and still come out way on top. So I'd be surprised if they did this -- though not shocked.
throwaway287391··on Study finds Reddit’s ban of its most toxic subreddits worked (2017)
If you think this kind of thing is hard to find on /r/The_Donald, you've either never visited it or are (possibly willfully) in denial.
throwaway287391··on P = NP Proofs: Advice to claimers
> It wouldn't be quite so bad if there were a huge repository of already proven theorems you could pull from.

What about things like Metamath [1]? (Not sure if there is a more mature similar effort, Metamath is just the one I've heard of.) It seems like it has quite a lot of the "thousand other trivialiaties" you mentioned, but maybe it's still not enough to make a real dent?

[1] http://us.metamath.org/index.html

throwaway287391··on Animating URLs with JavaScript and Emojis
I realize everyone hates videos on HN and probably scrolled right past it, but this guy is hysterical. Worth watching the first couple minutes at least.
throwaway287391··on Berkeley Blue – Accelerating robotics through low-cost hardware
It seems to be on the very cheap end if it would qualify as an "industrial robotic arm" (I don't know if it does). I found this paper from 2012 [1] with a list of "Low price industrial robotic arms" (Table 2) and the cheapest one there is $17k.

[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/241632269_A_brief_s...

throwaway287391··on Canada’s legal pot is going well
> You are the boogeyman to the people who oppose legalisation. One of the rare people who didn't smoke simply to obey the law and are now getting stoned because it's legal. :P

As a pre- and post-legalization smoker, I always thought this was a naive view. Having to deal with a sketchy flaky street dealer (not to mention finding one to begin with) is absolutely going to turn a lot of people off of smoking. And speaking from experience, waiting on an empty street corner for 20-30 minutes for your dealer to show up (because he's always late) gives you a lot of time to introspect and question your choices...

It is really nothing like walking into a clean retail store with regular business hours, display cases, and pretty young cashiers. The street dealer situation makes you feel like a lowlife piece of shit who has a lot of growing up to do; the legal retail situation makes you feel like a yuppie walking into an Apple Store. I wouldn't be at all surprised if this new option led to 2 or 3 times as many people smoking. And to me, that's completely fine (really, good for me since it makes it more socially acceptable).

I think the smokers who believed that legalization didn't offer a more appealing purchasing option for a ton of people must be the 24/7 stoners who only have other 24/7 stoners as friends and can't imagine not having immediate access to weed.

throwaway287391··on Congress Is About to Ban the US Government from Offering Free Online Tax Filing
Ugh, I hate this argument so much. It's the argument Grover Norquist goes around making to every Republican in Congress that that (in addition to Intuit's lobbying efforts) to stop this from ever happening. (There's a great episode of Planet Money [1] about it.)

In addition to just about every major country other than the US, California already has this and it's absolutely fantastic. I've literally never heard anyone who's actually used it complain about it and say they'd rather not have the option of filing their taxes in this way.

Imagine if your cell phone bill worked like US federal taxes. They would send you a blank sheet of paper and make you write down your minutes, texts, and megabytes for the month, and any other applicable fees you might owe, calculate the total bill yourself from that, and send a check for that amount. The provider already knows what you owe and calculated it themselves; they just aren't telling you, and you're threatened with additional fines or burdensome audits if your calculations don't match theirs. This causes you weeks of anxiety and dozens of hours of lost productivity every year. (Paraphrased this argument from the subject of the Planet Money episode.)

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/03/22/521132960/epis...

throwaway287391··on Motel 6 to Pay $12M after Improperly Giving Guest Lists to ICE
Is GP getting downvoted because we're assuming this isn't what they meant?
throwaway287391··on Texting Means Never Having to Say Goodbye
> Yes, I think smartphone keyboards are obviously much better than a dumbphone

Really? I could imagine some (or maybe even most) people are faster on a smartphone, but for me it's "obviously" worse.

I'm tremendously slower on iOS/Android on-screen keyboards than I was with T9. I could text really fast using T9 on a hard keypad without even looking down at the screen, despite only really using it heavily for a year or two. Then I got a Blackberry Curve, a kind-of-but-not-really-smartphone with a full hard QWERTY keyboard -- there I was similarly fast.

Then came the iPhone and screen-only Android phones and I got much slower and less precise, and touch-typing is a total crapshoot. Despite having used them for almost 10 years now, I don't think I've ever recovered to anywhere near the speed I had with even a T9 keypad.

I think the key difference is a hard keyboard (or even 10 digit keypad). I'm not saying smartphones aren't enough of an improvement in other ways (obviously, since I've chosen them over dumbphones for a decade), but I really miss the haptic feedback of actual keys.

throwaway287391··on Human Contact Is Now a Luxury Good
Wow, thanks for sharing your actual experience. When I made my sibling comment (about being jealous of city kids as a burbs kid) I admittedly thought it was probably at least a bit of a "grass is greener" thing, but "great" to have confirmation that the burbs really are as relatively bad as I thought. :|
throwaway287391··on Human Contact Is Now a Luxury Good
From your link, (1) it was a 9 year old, and (2) I don't see anything about CPS calls or any similar panic.

> Skenazy's April 1, 2008 column in The New York Sun, "Why I Let My 9-Year-Old Ride the Subway Alone," described her making the controversial decision to let her son take the New York City Subway home alone, which was completed without incident.

throwaway287391··on Human Contact Is Now a Luxury Good
I could be wrong, but my impression is that those CPS calls are a chiefly suburban phenomenon.
throwaway287391··on Human Contact Is Now a Luxury Good
I grew up in the burbs and found it absolutely "dreadful" as far as being able to do things outside without a car. Now that I live in a city, I often think about how much happier and freer I would've felt as a child growing up in one. (I had similar feelings when I actually was a kid and watched cartoons like "Hey Arnold!" set in cities. I was so jealous of those kids.)

As a 12 year old in a city you can walk to a park or get on the metro/bus and visit some friends or go see a movie etc. In the burbs if your parents aren't home or are otherwise unwilling to drive you somewhere you're basically stuck at home counting the days until you turn 16.

throwaway287391··on What the Hell Is Going On? Effects of Information Abundance
I've read internet comments from many of them, met a few of them, and am friends with one. My friend regularly sends me articles from Brietbart and other conspiracy mongering outlets who write entire articles based on Jason Wohl tweets. People who consume /r/The_Donald, chain emails, and propaganda outlets like Fox News, Breitbart, and the like are Trump's base. They are typically not podcast-listening thinkpiece-reading latte-sipping yuppies.

Here, watch this BBC video [1] where they interview Trump voters about their views on the "mainstream media" (by which you quickly realize they mean anything that doesn't deal in pure pro-Trump anti-librul propaganda). Here's an article [2] on a study showing that pro-Trump people specifically like to consume fake news shared via Facebook.

But personally I didn't really need a study to tell me any of that -- how do I know? I live and breathe and observe the world and people around me...

And yes, this is a generalization and not true of every single Trump voter. Obviously. All I really claimed was that Trump supporters will definitely be a minority of readers of a blog like this.

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-us-canada-38191313/no-tr...

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/feb/06/sharing-f...

throwaway287391··on What the Hell Is Going On? Effects of Information Abundance
Really? You genuinely think it's plausible that roughly half of the readers of this blogpost are Trump supporters? I'm really not taking an outlandish stance here... this post will have most of its traffic driven by HackerNews and Reddit, where California is an outsized plurality of the American audience, which went overwhelmingly to Clinton in 2016 (and even more overwhelmingly so in the densest parts of California where the overwhelming sub-plurality of HN/Reddit traffic comes from: the Bay Area and LA). Even if you believe that, all else equal, the average Trump supporter's media diet is about the same as the average non-Trump-supporter's, the demographics of these aggregators alone makes it more or less statistically impossible that what I'm saying isn't true.
throwaway287391··on What the Hell Is Going On? Effects of Information Abundance
I get why you'd think it's rude/unnecessary, but I don't think it's a generalization to say it's very unlikely that anywhere near half of the audience of a blog post like this is on Team Trump. I'm sure there are Trump supporters that read and digest this kind of content regularly, but any familiarity with the typical cultural attitudes and media consumption patterns of Trump supporters makes it obvious that that's far from the norm.
throwaway287391··on School is all about signaling, not skill-building
> Finishing school is signaling that you are person that shows up in the morning for classes

Not sure about others but I tried my damnedest not to take morning classes unless I absolutely had to -- most semesters I had nothing before 11am or noon. The flexible scheduling was one of my favorite things about college. I did take one 8AM class and thinking back I have no idea how I didn't completely bomb it -- I showed up pretty sparsely after the first week or two.

throwaway287391··on Implementing a Neural Network from Scratch in Python
"set_to_random_numbers" is much less descriptive than np.random.normal...the former doesn't tell me what distribution the random numbers come from. Agreed that the weights should be stored in a list or the like in real life rather than duplicating code for each layer, but the examples in the blog post are clearly intentionally minimizing abstractions as much as possible so that an untrained reader can immediately tell exactly what each line is doing. It's obviously not intended to scale to larger models.
← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →