287 karma · joined July 28, 2024
Accounts of businesses and governments are without VAT except for the most generalized cash flow tables. My own government reports both numbers (with and without VAT) in cases where this matters. I'm quite surprised yours doesn't do this. But yes, you're right - in your situation the actually spent amount would be different by the VAT rate.
Since people are apparently unable to do that, talking to people is the next best thing.
> Then, of course, If I produce pistol (as a company), and buy metal, and make a pistol, don't I end up paying VAT on the "added value" ? in other way, even if a company sell to other companies, the VAT% (10% or 90%) does or does not affect profitability?
No, profitability is not affected in any way. The consumer always pays, not any company in the chain of raw material to consumer product. VAT is irrelevant to them, it's just some bureaucracy that needs to be taken care of, but nothing else. It could be 110% and they wouldn't care - VAT is separately on top of the invoiced price and you never treat it as your money, you're just holding it for the government for up to 30 days.
> Then of course you sure have some percentage of buyers who cannot claim VAT (is it small, only consumers? what about not perfectly legal business.... )
Any business can claim VAT back if they choose to. Some countries allow small businesses to say "I don't care, don't bother me, I will eat the difference". This results in losses to the small business, it's done because the paperwork is really hard to do - takes a lot of time and money (you need an expensive tax advisor in many everyday cases). The usual limit of this is around 50k USD of yearly revenue. Above that, it's necessary to fill the VAT forms.
You're basically saying "I don't want to consider other ways to produce energy so you should stop doing all the fun stuff you do". Nobody is ever going to agree with that, and you're going to antagonize people from even trying to be environmentally conscious.
"Yeah I'm so happy I have a job paying 500 USD per month, and I am so happy my 1.5-room flat rent is just 350" is a very common thing to hear where I live. The tax rate is 35% btw.
Also, try to find newer statistics at least. 2016 was around the local maxima, everything went to shit - very noticeably - during and after covid.
De-growth will most likely lead to more CO2 emitted per person. Only high technology can change this.
VAT is a tax levied on consumers, not companies/industries. Companies get it from consumers and forward it to the government, that's an optimization of enforcement, it doesn't mean companies pay it out of their pockets. Government pays companies back whatever VAT they paid on stuff they bought. It would make no sense for the government to pay VAT to itself when buying such expensive stuff; this is again a process optimization, not some fundamental change of how the tax works.
Why would you need lobbyists when you have Putin just behind the door?
The setup wasn't fiddly at all. I had to fiddle much more with ordinary PC laptops. Any distro should be mostly fine - Ubuntu, Fedora, Arch...
But this isn't even about this particular half eaten sausage. A dog doesn't know the difference between a pristine sausage and a half eaten one, to them it's just meat. And the point is that dogs should be taught to never eat any meat on the street - because they can't think "uh, looks half eaten, probably fine".