HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwaway642

4 karma · joined January 16, 2024

submissionscomments
throwaway642··on Modern misconceptions about medieval warfare
I simply replied to a statement that was false. We have a good understanding of why pyramids were built, and it does not match your statement.

You made the following statements:

1. Pyramids were built so kings could live forever

2. The Egyptians saw that this did not work, but continued to build pyramids.

The first statement is not true. The pyramids were built for the after-life. This invalidates the premise for your second statement, as the Egyptians could not verify that it worked in the after-life (or that there even is an after-life).

Now that you see my reply in a different context, your castle analogy is also not relevant.

throwaway642··on Modern misconceptions about medieval warfare
> Egyptians built pyramids in order that their kings would live forever

Pyramids were built for the after-life. Not as a way to extend their life on Earth. Nobody could verify if it actually worked, so it's mostly a question of faith.

> Stone Age people painted the animals they were going to hunt on rocks so that the pictures would entrap the animals' spirit

That's just speculation from historians. It may be that they are right, but there are also other theories. One other theory could be that it is a way of giving thanks to the animals, and a way to honor their loss. Personally I don't think there is a single reason why they painted animals. People have always had different motivations