HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwaway_USD

538 karma · joined March 24, 2020

submissionscomments
throwaway_USD··on Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps can charge restaurants
>If people don’t understand that a middleman adds cost as an adult, then that is an education issue.

I think the point is that middlemen are now using deceptive business practice to obscure the fact they are involved and in many ways cannibalizing direct business to the restaurants using "dark patterns". In the case of middlemen changing the phone number of the restaurant on services like Yelp/Google Maps without the consent of the restaurant should be fraud...its almost like I go to a bank and put my ATM machine in front of the bank ATM machines and charge customers withdraw fees...then claiming well I am a 3rd party of course I had fees (even disclosed it in order to proceed), while ignoring the totality of the circumstances.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>Loans always have delayed payment terms, you're being willfully obtuse

And how often do they have forgiveness terms?

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>It is not true that entire loan is forgiven if the payroll percent is met.

Where did I say that?

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>the economy started tanking because people stopped going out and spending money.

People continued spending money...mortgage/rent; car loans/insurance; food; etc...

>giving people money wouldnt fix this.

PPP didn't fix it did it?

There is an eviction and foreclosure crisis looming...giving people money may have done a better job than PPP in avoiding this coming disaster.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>I don't know anyone who's had even a single dollar forgiven yet.

This is what I meant by political couching: Do you know any one who has paid back a single dollar?

>These are loans.

Fine care to loan me $1M and I'll pay you back 20% with interest.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>The idea that it's one giant money suck for businesses with no immediate return to the economy is not really accurate - it's not a zero-sum game.

No one argues $600B wouldn't help the economy. Can you point to where I said PPP will not help the economy?

Most people are starting to understand the fraud involved with PPP and understanding those funds could have gone to individuals and the money would have found its way back into the economy just the same...only faster as its not distributed out over 8 weeks with 25% reserved for non-payroll business expenses.

Of course there are arguments for why the money should have gone to businesses as it did and not people...but you don't hear any lawmakers making those argument publicly and if you do its limited to "we are saving jobs." My argument, if you feel compelled to call it that, is that there is no proof these jobs have been saved unless delaying unemployment by 8 weeks is considered a job.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>Most of them will owe ~20% of the loan back to their lender since they had minimal other expenses.

That was my entire point is that the loans were designed to forgive a minimum of 75% of the loan, but it is 100% forgiven if they limited their loan application to 8 weeks of payroll.

All the people you know took 20% more for salary than they were supposed to and they should pay it back. Even based on your personal experience you should know this isn't the way to describe the program:

>These are loans. They are two year low interest loans. They have to be paid back unless some or all is forgiven.

Rather in your personal experience most of the loans will be 80% forgiven.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>"what about the nail salon who has 14 employees and took 5-10M?!?!".

If true that is an obvious case of fraud and you are making my point, the only time a loan will be repaid is if the money was spent on things other than payroll...which amounts to fraud.

Who cares if its a nail salon? Math is math, if you have 14 employees the maximum eligibility would be 8 weeks of payroll with a cap at $100k salary + up to an addition 25% for non-payroll expenses. $5-$10M for a business with 14 employees is fraud on its face.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>So it kind of irks me to see some people frame this like a large percentage of these loans will be paid back.

I constantly see this..."its not free money, its a loan, and the money will be paid back with interest, just like in 2008."

No, its free money for businesses, many of which will fail and let their employees go anyway.

Then you hear people claim how somehow it was a victory to keep people off unemployment for 8 weeks, but not a single person can explain why that is such a benefit. Its sort of like saying hey when Corona virus began I stopped flights from Country X and saved 10's of thousands of lives...maybe deaths were delayed but there is no evidence they were prevented.

throwaway_USD··on Searchable PPP Loan Data
>These are loans. They are two year low interest loans. They have to be paid back unless some or all is forgiven.

This is a highly politicized way to frame PPP loans. Its more like: "These loans are forgiven, unless you scammed the government." These loans were specifically designed to be forgiven, a minimum of 75% of the loan was to be for payroll and if used for payroll (what it was supposed to be used for) that portion of the loan will be forgiven.

>Just because a company took a 1M loan, doesn't mean it will be 100% forgiven.

Again this is so carefully worded to send a false signal...true "it doesn't mean" it will be 100% forgiven. But again the goal is for at least 75% to be forgiven up to 100%. The idea is businesses were supposed to get a loan with 75% allocated to payroll expenses and the extra 25% to approved non-payroll expenses (example: rent) and the portion used for payroll should be 100% forgiven...which in many cases will be the full amount of the loan, because many businesses didn't add an extra 25% for non-payroll expenses and just took the forgivable payroll portion.

Basically the only reason/way these loans would be repaid is if business took out the loans and spent the money on non-payroll expenses...that should be fraud and result in jail not a nice cushy 1% interest rate for people committing fraud.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>The economic shock was caused in part by a government-imposed shutdown of economic activity in response to a pandemic.

No, the economic shock was caused by businesses being over leveraged and not having cash reserves. I keep hearing how this was the greatest economy the World has ever seen, how good could it really be if businesses are existing paycheck to paycheck?

>Which is why another aid package will probably be passed in July.

Exactly why taxpayers and not businesses should have received the lion share of the bailout funds.

>businesses had to exist prior to February 15, 2020

Look up shelf corps or ready corps. There is rampant fraud with respect to the PPP loans, including by law makers, none of them will end up in jail.

throwaway_USD··on MS will ban Forza players who add the confederate flag to their digital cars
>Do you not believe that people can stand on a public street corner and express their ideas freely, where many people will likely see and hear them?

The Government can restrict you on the street corner too. Take Covid, states/counties/cities/municipalities across the country are enacting curfews, so violate the curfew and they will arrest your chilling your speech...assuming you consider that an edge case as well, then just read the case law from the good old "soap box" days, which deal exactly with people setting up their soap boxes on the corner to talk to the public and yes the government can regulate that speech to a certain extent.

>Are you suggesting that the only way to exchange free speech online is for each passerby to create their own website and respond on their respective websites?

Do you have a website? Can I freely post on your website without your consent?

>Where is the online public square?

The web is the public square, you want to set up your own soap box (website) do it, but you have no right to take over someone else's soap box (website), and if they do give you some rights to stand on their soap box they certainly can place restrictions.

>if you think having domain name and hosting is a public square, then you are ignoring all of the precedents of those things being removed by private entities.

You are ignoring self hosting from private servers.

throwaway_USD··on MS will ban Forza players who add the confederate flag to their digital cars
>While I agree, please direct me to where I can speak "in the public domain" online.

Same place as with pre-online TV and radio I suppose.

Free speech doesn't guarantee you an audience at the time and place of your choosing.

Take public buildings like a Courthouse or City hall, sure you have Free Speech rights, but good luck interrupting a court hearing to get your message out (without being held in contempt by the Judge (the government) and thrown in jail). Or try getting your message out at mid-night when the building is closed.

Then as others have said, what is stopping you from registering your own domain and posting your message there? If the government infringing your rights in that regard?

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>Do grocery baggers and bar tenders benefit from an economic depression?

People need groceries even during a depression. Its often said alcohol is recession proof, in fact alcohol sales seem to thrive even during a pandemic.

I'll tell you what isn't

>Do you think Obama made the right choice to stimulate the economy in 2008? This is exactly the same thing.

Actually Bush took out a Stimulus of ~$800-900B before he left office and then Obama took our another $800-$900B when entering office. And I would say the vast majority of people I speak with would rather have seen the banks fail rather than taxpayers bailing them out (for massive fraud they perpetrated to issue bad loans/mortgages and then package them up and sell them to others knowing they were "toxic assets"). Banks used taxpayer money to buy their competitors to concentrate the market and fund foreclosure litigation to foreclose on the taxpayers that bailed them out. In hindsight most people agree the Bush/Obama bailouts should have gone directly to the homeowners, but it was considered a "moral hazard" encouraging bad behavior in the future, whereas ironically they didn't see the moral hazard in rewarding the banks that bear the most responsibility.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>Sorry, I don't really understand why this is a problem. The alternative would be laying those people off and paying them via unemployment anyways, right? The idea was to keep people tied to their employers

If the alternative was laying people off, that is the free market at work. And there is no "keeping employee tied to their employers" as you claim, it is just free money to businesses for 8 weeks of payroll (+25% extra for non-payroll expenses like rent - so taxpayer paid rent for businesses, where is the taxpayer paid rent for taxpayers?). There is no promise or guarantee business will keep employees or even remain open beyond that 8 week period.

Finally, and most importantly, you touch on it:

>paying them via unemployment anyways, right?

Yes, this was about: 1) free money to businesses and 2) hiding the real unemployment numbers.

It was not about employees, if it was there are much better ways to go about it. At minimum law makers wouldn't have been allowed to pass the bill, create a brand new business, and obtain PPP loans for these new businesses (which would normally be prohibited, but both law makers and their family were excluded from these prohibitions against conflict of interest)

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
The 2 largest numbers on their balance sheet are:

Reserve Bank credit: 7,009,664

Securities held outright[1]: 6,115,130

[1] Includes securities lent to dealers under the overnight securities lending facility (when people talk about JPow money printer go brrr...this is what they are talking about and nearly every night for 2 months after the FED got the $4T overnight the markets would skyrocket)

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>Forgiveness of PPP loans is contingent on keeping staff on payroll and salary levels constant. So it's very much targeted at helping main street.

Helps main street? Businesses just got free money from taxpayers. Sure for the forgiveness you have to spend 75% on payroll, in many instances what the amounts to is a business owner paying themselves 8 weeks of salary with taxpayer money and then that loan being forgiven. In the instance it actually goes to employees, again taxpayers basically just paid for 8 weeks of your payroll (these helps politicians by keeping unemployment numbers artificially low for 2 months, and keeping people off the temporary Covid unemployment benefits), the jury is still out if any of these employees will remain employed after 8 weeks (or we will see unemployment again be flooded with millions of applicants, only the extra $600/week won't be there).

>my impression is that that's mostly worked out

Its as much of a scam as the NINJA (no income no job applications) were leading to the financial crisis, people just formed businesses made up salaries and got a free 8 weeks of said salary (up to $100k salary). Or the fact that law makers and their families have specifically been exempt from any ethics review for conflict of interest, and in some cases law makers set up brand new companies just to obtain PPP loans.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>Everyone I know would choose their entire retirement fund over a one time check of $18,000

I am assuming you don't know a single person in the 40% that don't have $400 saved up for emergencies.

>it does feel like we got less that we deserve, but stimulating the stock market was absolutely the right move.

It isn't without merit...until you look behind the curtain at OZ. The stock market was already in a bubble and we just inflated the bubble even more. P/E ratios in the public markets are beginning to make revenue-less tech unicorns look reasonable.

>a majority of Americans have a 401k

Ok, so they have a conflict of interest in the matter (25% of Americans have no retirement). Of those with a 401K aged 35-44 the median balance is $22k (so its pretty much a wash for them). Then on the very harsh side of things, the free market side, you risked your money by investing, if a portion of your portfolio includes stock in overvalued companies with runaway P/E ratios that didn't have cash reserves to whether the storm, you invested poorly and you should expect taxpayers to bailout your poor investments.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
Fine if you want to add the amount for subsidizing the Unemployment Insurance from the CARES Act the numbers again:

$4T to the FED to prop up the stock market

$700B in forgivable loans to small businesses (PPP program)

$300B in taxpayer stimulus checks

$260B in Unemployment Insurance subsidies

>suggesting that we could all have received $18K is disingenuous. Proper response should be targeted where needed

It is not disingenuous at all to say taxpayers should have received the lions share of these bailouts (bailouts being paid for by taxpayers), or at minimum its not disingenuous to say taxpayers (not law makers beholden to corporate interests) should have dictated where the bailout funds go...I would say it is disingenuous to claim taxpayers would have sent 8x the amount they received to the FED to prop up an overvalued stock market that was already at record highs.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>They're in the form of low-interest loans, they aren't just handing out money to corporations.

This is false as related to the PPP loans ($700B program, to put that in perspective during the 2008 financial crisis law makers passed an $800B stimulus to prevent total financial collapse). Its argued the banks paid that 2008 money back with interest (I won't touch that claim), but the PPP loans ($700B) are intended to be forgiven.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
>But, it just highlighted how many people are working and not earning a living wage in the first place.

Exactly, we allegedly had the best economy the world has ever seen, record high stock prices/markets, and lowest rate of unemployment.

But the reality the economy was revealed to be weak and not even capitalism (capital based ownership) but some form of debtism (some form of financial servitude, in lieu of ownership). In the best economy ever and 40% of the population couldn't afford a $400 emergency. Our public companies with their record stock prices needed $4T for the FED to "stabilize the market" (political speak for taxpayers are buying these stocks at these overvalued prices). Customized taxpayer bailouts for entire industries that don't have any runway of capital to service their debts.

throwaway_USD··on Hazard pay in focus as essential workers earn less than the jobless
From the time Congress passed the $6.2T Bill that gave $4T to the FED to prop up the stock market, $700B in PPP loans; and and estimated $300B to the people ($1,200) stimulus checks, it should have put things in perspective.

Ideally the stock market wouldn't have been propped up and the PPP loan program would have been more legitimate to save real small businesses (just wait until all the fraud comes out of this thing). If all that money instead went to the people/taxpayers they would all have received an $18,000 stimulus check instead of $1,200, I think this would have been the best move possible (and maybe some form of healthcare coverage for the uninsured, being in a pandemic and all instead of pretending providing coverage to the uninsured would be taking away their freedom to be uninsured).

throwaway_USD··on San Francisco apartment rent prices are dropping fast
I see, AirBnB properties are being converted into traditional rental units increasing supply.

If true, then this may suggest there is very good reason to have regulations on short terms rentals, like AirBnB, which have increased rent around the country to the detriment of affordable housing.

throwaway_USD··on San Francisco apartment rent prices are dropping fast
No, removing rental properties from the market to do short term rentals lowers the supply of rental properties, so AirBnB actually has the effect of raising rental prices. Nevertheless, my understanding is AirBnB and the short term rental market are not exactly doing well during the Pandemic, have you been AirBnBing during Covid?
throwaway_USD··on San Francisco apartment rent prices are dropping fast
Rent is falling across the country...Do you believe unemployment skyrocketing to somewhere between 20-40 million people across the Country preceding the rent price crash is coincidence? Do you have an alternative hypothesis why rent across the Country is dropping? If its not a drop in demand...that would suggest the entire Country increased its housing supply at the same time.
throwaway_USD··on A Renaissance painting reveals how breeding changed watermelons (2015)
Its not that I haven't seen white or purple carrots, rather learning they were bred to be orange for royalty.
throwaway_USD··on California agency blocks release of police use of force, surveillance training
If you want to claim a copyright, then good luck with the in the private market, but if you want that big, fat juicy government contract (i.e. taxpayer dollars) there should be concessions.
throwaway_USD··on A Renaissance painting reveals how breeding changed watermelons (2015)
Here is an article depicting a couple other fruits and vegetables pre/post domestication.

https://www.sciencealert.com/fruits-vegetables-before-domest...

My favorite was learning the carrots weren't originally orange but purple or white. Corn may be shocking to people. In my opinion the banana has many similarities to the watermelon in terms of the "holes" and filling out post domestication.

throwaway_USD··on Reddit started banning accounts that voted for content “against their policies”
>I don't really get reddit's efforts to clean their site.

You don't get why a online forum might have an interest in ensuring every other post isn't a dick pic?

If you can understand that, maybe you don't, then you DO understand their interest in moderating their own website whether or not you agree with their moderation standards in practice. A dick pic may be obvious to you...but so long as the picture depicts someone >18yo then it is legal and free speech.

>They sometimes come up with measures like this, while routinely ignoring the development of horrible communities that they're aware of...

Again isn't it their right to determine what forums/threads dick pics may in fact be appropriate and which threads forums they aren't and should be moderated/removed?

throwaway_USD··on People have stopped going to the doctor and most seem fine
This is like a cruel joke...its like saying if you are not diagnosed with a disease you don't have it.

All anyone need to look at is the incidences of people getting a chronic condition as soon become medicare eligible. Its like magic people are healthy, then they receive Medicare and they get chronic conditions...no they had the chronic condition they just weren't diagnosed and treated until Medicare eligible.

Medicare Patient Chronic Condition Statistics:

Over one half of beneficiaries less than 65 years had two or more chronic conditions compared to: Sixty-three percent of those 65-74 years, • Seventy-eight percent of those 75-84 years and, • Eighty-three percent of beneficiaries 85 years and older.

If people were covered and had access to care then the incidences would dramatically go down, instead we all but ensure by the time they hit Medicare and the taxpayers pick up the bills they have multiple expensive chronic conditions that have gone undiagnosed and untreated for years.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →