HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwaway_jobs

518 karma · joined March 21, 2020

submissionscomments
throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
The point being addressed was fear of murder/assault From officers being a primary concern over fear of murder/assault from non-officers...I think we want to look at absolute numbers, you are either going to be murdered or you aren’t and assuming every single police killing was a murder 90% of murders are committed by non-officers. Why would we need to look at how many murders per 100,000?
throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
> - By your numbers, 10% of the killings are done by police officers. - Police officers account for much less than 10% of the population. Hence, a random police officer is much more likely to kill you than a random person.

It’s odd you would say I’m playing a dangerous game...we are talking about murder, and if you or a loved one is murdered there is a 90% chance you will be murdered by a non-LEO. Not to mention we are playing a dangerous game by converting all justified police killings to murder.

throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
So take Eric Gardner’s death in 2014, NYPD had him in a chokehold his last words “I can’t breathe”...justice dept refused to bring changes, I won’t get into right/wrong (murder/justified killing) but hell AG Barr sides against the justice dept.
throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
> That really doesn't matter that much.

I assure you it matters to the victims and their families.

And I don’t disagree about the morality of police abusing their powers...but a death is a death and a tragedy is a tragedy. No one is celebrating the death of their loved one no matter what the killers skin color or occupation.

> That is so much worse than a stranger doing those things.

Again it’s not like the victim of a sexual assault is saying thank god I was rapped by a non-officer.

throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
I don’t know about the ratio being 100:1, but You are right these are Classified police killings not murders...that said, also consider George Floyd’s death was on track to be swept under the rug as a Justified police Killing until the protests.
throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
> That ratio should be over 100:1, not 10:1, and certainly not 9:1.

I can’t say what the ratio should be...How do you know what that ratio should be?

You say cops should not be a “situation”, not sure what that means but for many of them responding to crimes is exactly what their job entails.

In other words As it relates to your ratio, is is possible a police office is 10 times more likely to encounter a murder/violent criminal in the act than a citizen? I don’t know, but that seems reasonable and probably jacks up to 100:1 to intervening to stop a crime.

I’m really not one to ask, I’ve been on all sides of it: I’ve been arrested (multiple times, including for the victimless crime of possession of marijuana); I’ve been the victim of an armed kidnapping; I’ve represented criminal defendants as an attorney. I can certainly say even being the victim of an armed kidnapping I felt more victimized more by the detective after the fact Than by the kidnapper, I can also add I felt more victimized by the insurance company of the gas station I was kidnapped from and their attorneys than either the kidnapper and detective (they literally destroyed the video of the crimes against me, falsely tried to cover up their destruction of the video claiming it never existed, claimed I falsely alleged the crimes and paid they same detective to testify the crimes happened to me across the Street from the gas station).

throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
As to murder:

White Murder victims: 3,499 (2,854 of the victims were killed by other whites)

Black murder victims: 2,870 (2,570 of the victims were killed by other blacks)

2019 police killings by race:

White deceased: 370

Black deceased: 235

throwaway_jobs··on My family saw a police car hit a kid, then I learned how NYPD impunity works
> because from their point of view the police are the people most likely to assault or kill them or their children on the street, more so than random criminals

I don’t think that is framed correctly.

Black or white statistically you are far more likely to be killed (or assaulted) by non-police Of the same race as you.

I think everyone knows that, and to say police are the most likely to assault of kill black people takes the wind out of the sails of the legitimate issues. In other words police represent an additional threat to one of the groups and not the other, but in either instance the police are not the most likely perpetrators to either group.

throwaway_jobs··on People have stopped going to the doctor and most seem fine
Even in the case of asthma, I think a doctor would hopefully not treat it like cookie cutter Health care. Surely there are standards and best practices, but then there is also the actual practice of medicine.

Standards might suggest 1 year is fine, but he Generally a doctor might want to see young (Kids) and old patients more often than a otherwise healthy adult, perhaps the doctor has reason to belief seasonal allergies/pollen may be effecting patients more in a given year, and (not to give doctors to much credit)again the idea the doctor has concerns with a given patient’s track record of adherence Issues and/or medication related hospitalizations.

throwaway_jobs··on People have stopped going to the doctor and most seem fine
> Those appointments should only occur if there's an issue that requires new dosing or a change of medication.

But isn’t that a little bit of Monday morning quarter backing? In other words how does a doctor know if a therapy/Rx needs to be modified for a chronic condition without a doctor visit and in many cases blood work?

In fact a 6 month therapy for a chronic condition would suggest The doctor has extreme confidence in the patient to adhere to their therapies...statistically about 1M hospitalizations occur in the US per year (Coating billions) because of lack of medication adherence (and these are only those cases resulting in hospitalization), how many more simply result in a sicker patient without a hospitalization event?

throwaway_jobs··on Ask HN: Google won't remove my site URL from random business using it on Maps
Your impression isn’t wrong, it is a jurisdictional issue, but let’s say you are right generally; however, it’s law so:

Consider small claims handle most evictions, your impression would be right an eviction isn’t an “injunction”, but what is an eviction in practice if not an enjoining the tenant from continued possession and an order to vacate a property.

This case might just seek relief in the form of a monetary judgement In the complaint, but in practice what is that judgement but an injunction/order for google to stop any continued act causing damages.

As I noted at pretrial the parties are encouraged by the court to settle and usually at pretrial/trail the parties do a mandatory mediation (again that is jurisdictional but either way statistically Over 90% of cases will settle). In practice these settlement agreements will typically reflect additional terms such as agreement to stop engaging in X or otherwise continuing any act that damages the party as outlined in the complaint, and terms denying admission for any of the claims as outlined in the complaint.

In practice image it playing out where the damaged party here gets an award for monetary damages against google and Google pays but they allow the impersonating “business” on google maps to continue to Impersonate the the damaged party by associating the website/marks with the impersonating business. Google may play the nameless, faceless corporation with no decision makers, but to don’t let them fool you. I personally imagine this thread hitting the front page Here gets google to do something.

throwaway_jobs··on The Power of Crossed Brain Wires: Synesthesia makes ordinary life marvelous
This kind of reminds me of my brother. Carrabbas (an Italian chain restaurant) brings out their bread with a small plate of herbs/olive oil for dipping the bread...and from the time we were kids he loved it and always described it as tasting like “Christmas”.

One might think this is just an association of flavors, but he never associated any particular foods from Christmas with the herbs but to him is tasted like the actual holiday.

throwaway_jobs··on Ask HN: Google won't remove my site URL from random business using it on Maps
It sounds like someone is impersonating you on Google’s services, you put Google on notice you are being impersonated (your Mark infringed) and as a result you are suffering (legal) damages and google’s official response acknowledges this and simultaneously says they have no duty to prohibit infringement of your mark on their services and they have no duty to provide accurate information to their end users/the public.

In other words in the old phone book days, imagine if you were to list your business in the phone book but next to your business was a competitors phone number so they get all your business...you put the phone book on notice and they just say sorry we have no duty to provide accurate information.

Many have said get a lawyer to send a letter...that’s a waste of time while you will continue to be damaged. Get a lawyer to file a small claims case for damages and injunction. A few benefits: 1) you could probably get a lawyer to do it on contingency (no out of pocket expenses for you, they would get a % of damages if and only if they win); 2) small claims cases can often fly under the radar of big companies and so maybe as soon as 20 days after filing you get a default judgment; 3) if the do respond a small claims case means 1 thing to them, their attorney’s fees will exceed your damages so they will probably look into it and resolve it; 4) if they want to fight it (which would be stupid if your claims are legit) small claims are extremely expedited, typically there is no formal discovery and it’s just a pretrial (where the parties will be encouraged to settle) and then a trial (possibly a mandatory mediation at pretrial or at the court on the day of the trial).

throwaway_jobs··on Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Like-Minded People?
Well of course in addition to free speech the 1st amendment includes other rights such as freedom of religion (Separation of church and state), freedom of the press, right to assemble and right to petition the government for grievances. In its plain wording “the government shall make no law...prohibiting free speech...” but people get hung up on that when we know government can in fact pass all sorts of laws that limit free speech and in my experience I can get even the most die hard “absolutists” To agree certain speech should be illegal (this typically stems from the fact people don’t understand what “speech” is from a legal context).

I stand by what I said, people should read the case law.

While you say the danger is young people being emotional in their bubble, I think you will find every generation says something similar about the next generation.

Why I encourage people to read the case law is because it provides historical context for these rights and how the law is actually applied. I think one of the biggest dangers, is failure to educate ourselves especially learn our own history (history of our laws or otherwise). The point of studying history is so we can hopefully avoid the mistakes of our past...yet as history suggests we will continue to neglect history and make the exact same mistakes.

throwaway_jobs··on Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Like-Minded People?
One of my favorite phrases comes from the obscenity cases, and I tend to use it as often as I can:

“Appeals to (Your) prurient interests”

Many other jokes to be made at the expense of the justices on these cases, Which get far dirtier, such as the pinnacle case being Miller v California which was essentially about mail order dildos/sex toys, one would have thought double-sided dildos were about as obscene as it gets at the time, and yet leave it to the justices to develop the Miller Test which is coincidentally a “three-prong Obscenity test”.

throwaway_jobs··on Freedom of Speech: A Right for Everybody, or Only for Like-Minded People?
I wish people would take the time to read 1st Amendment case law.

I think people would be shocked, even when the court get it wrong, the justices and opinions explore the subject in a depth that laymen will go their entire lives never exploring or understanding. Plus the bonus of it being maybe one of the more interesting areas of law factually.

Some of the major topics I suggest looking at/googling:

-1st amendment restricts the government from infringing speech Not private parties (I.e. you say something about my wife/kids I can shut your mouth, maybe I will face criminal/civil penalties for damaging your face, but not for chilling your speech)

-the marketplace of ideas (perhaps my favorite concept in free speech)

-government can restrict Speech based on time/location (i.e. require permits for using public spaces or limiting your access to public space such as closing a park at night and arresting you for trespassing preventing you from distributing your speech when/where you want)

-“Fuck the draft” (just lol) vs burning draft cards

-obscene speech (porn - Imagine the justices Getting together with their popcorn and watching porn together...they still can’t define it, “but they know it when they see it”)...this extends to child porn too

I’ll leave it there, have fun!

throwaway_jobs··on Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50
I’m pleasantly surprised you went with 50, as opposed to Medicare age. It just shows you aren’t going after only the easy Medicare dollars. Of course you can still capture that too (see the Silversneakers program as an example).

Just like economic gap that is growing in the US there is a major health gap growing too. For those with resources 50 is like the new 20 as many of men are now “juiced to the gils“ with testosterone provided by their doctors (I see it a lot in Miami, and I’m sure it’s proliferated in tech companies/cities too, just something about money and ego I think), then for the have nots it’s this age where many are just holding out to become Medicare eligible to begin treating their chronic conditions and they are only suffering and getting worse in the meantime.

One day, if I am ever financially independent (unlikely), I have resolved to dedicate my life to health/wellness for children, with a very specific goal of type 2 diabetes prevention. I really have no idea why, I never got T2D, but it breaks my heart especially in children. If you ever expand in this direction, I’d be the first to apply in any capacity.

Good luck!

throwaway_jobs··on Berlin Gold Hat
I think their is ample evidence showing in the historical context some beliefs are referenced as religions and some as cults.

In fact especially in a historical context cult is akin to a social movement and don’t refer to religions at all. And the word cult is only aligned with religion in the modern context.

throwaway_jobs··on Berlin Gold Hat
> one is no more sacred to another

In the article these hats were associated with a “sun cult” not a “sun religion”.

Generally the way the words cult and religion are used, one has a connotation of legitimacy And reverence and the other a negative connotation suggesting illegitimacy.

throwaway_jobs··on Berlin Gold Hat
> religious rituals

Far to generous...in this instance it’s a “sun cult”

It’s kind of funny the worship of the sun, which a) actually exists; and b) is responsible for life on earth (not to mention stars generally are responsible for the elements that make up life) is cult status...but if you worship a “God” that is entirely faith based and more akin to a invisible friend, that is a sacred religion.

throwaway_jobs··on Diluting blood plasma rejuvenates tissue, reverses aging in mice
Why would you think they were referring specifically to mammals? Mammals isn’t mentioned once whereas species/animals is used very broadly In the context of very broad ideas of evolution.

In either case, the hypothesis suggests animals should live longer in the wild than in captivity. So let’s take the only mammal that isn’t more likely to die from age/don’t die from old age, the naked mole rat. We don’t understand why they die and any given day there is a 1 in 10,000 chance they die at any age. In captivity they should have the same lifespan as lab rats (6 years); however, in the wild the have an average lifespan of 17 years and in captivity that expands to 30 years (again in contrast to the hypothesis where wild animals of the same species should live longer than those in captivity).

throwaway_jobs··on Diluting blood plasma rejuvenates tissue, reverses aging in mice
> A species that goes years without losing any blood, is effectively operating its body in an evolutionary out-of-spec configuration. It might work, for a while; but it wasn't heavily optimized for.

I think your/the hypothesis fails...take certain species of jellyfish that are biologically immortal, they don’t have blood at all.

Coincidentally they are considered top of the food chain, so another knock to the hypothesis.

throwaway_jobs··on Millions of abandoned oil wells are leaking methane, a climate menace
The real question would be how much did the owners of these oil companies pocket before declaring bankruptcy.

It’s exactly as the commenter says...taxpayers fund schools that buy land; the school leases mineral/oil rights to private companies (Likely self dealing with these leases too); private energy companies take the public land resources and pay themselves profits leaving the entity insolvent and then files bankruptcy protection; taxpayers Are left liable.

What incentive does an oil company have to not liquidate the company after they exhaust the well and seek bankruptcy protection? In other words say it cost $10M to properly close up the well, you have that in the bank but you pay it to the owners as profit instead of covering the well, company is now insolvent and receives protections.

Why would any oil company not do this on public lands? Do you think these owners disappeared or just set up new companies and got new leases on new public lands rinse and repeat?

throwaway_jobs··on Millions of abandoned oil wells are leaking methane, a climate menace
> now they expect pity, which they do not deserve.

So what you are saying essentially is the school board/county should file bankruptcy so taxpayers are stuck with the liability...then we can extend your argument to the taxpayers for their failure to avoid the risks of funding/operating schools and insuring against them.

Do you feel that way about all the workers/businesses Trumps bankrupt businesses failed to pay by seeking bankruptcy protections?

throwaway_jobs··on For black CEOs in Silicon Valley, humiliation is a part of doing business
> I’m in Australia and I think these are largely US concepts.

Based on that statement alone I think I can accurately conclude you are not an indigenous Australian (aboriginal).

Seems they share quiet a lot in common with native Americans from stealing of their lands/displacement, mass killings, enslavement By colonists, to ongoing racism that continues to carry on today.

throwaway_jobs··on Venmo and Paypal Are Stalling Urgent Efforts to Bail People Out of Jail
> If that were true, bail would be adjusted much more aggressively to match available resources.

Nearly 40% of all defendants out on bail are ROR (no money required). Maybe it should be more or “more aggressive”, but few in my experience know that much or what ROR even is.

Bail is otherwise pretty uniform (within each jurisdiction) based on the charges (sometimes a defendants past charges will be considered in the amount as well as ability to abscond).

I see your point about matching the bail to the defendants resources...but it would just encourage attempts to abscond and skip trial. I was the victim of a kidnapping and the defendant got bail ($350k or so) and posted bond (paid 10% to a bondsman and they postEd the full amount). In reality the defendants mom posted the bail, the amount (even though not his money) was a deterrent for skipping trial, but he had nothing so if the amount was say $350 instead of $350k there would be no reason for him not to attempt to abscond, but even he wouldn’t run and harm his own mother financially. Still within 7 days Of posting bail and being released he violated the terms of his bail and was rearrested anyway.

throwaway_jobs··on Venmo and Paypal Are Stalling Urgent Efforts to Bail People Out of Jail
Their are tons of factors pushing a defendant to a plea...bail/bond are not one of them, perhaps you could explain.

There are cases where the defendant is in jail pending trial gets a bail set and can’t afford it, then gets a plea that would result in his release so he takes it...but that in no way is the primary purpose of the bail to force the plea. I don’t think you would ever find such a case where the defendant hasn’t waived their right to a speedy trial. But feel free to link such a case.

throwaway_jobs··on Intermittent fasting works – not only for weight loss but also for heart health
> At least understand how ketosis works and why it isn't our default mode of metabolism

It is the default metabolism.

1. All things being equal if you do not introduce any calories into your body you will naturally be in ketosis.

2. The only way to be kicked out of ketosis is to elevate blood glucose levels/spike insulin. Sure that is nearly everyone now, but that doesn’t make it the Body’s default...you need to eat a certain way for that to happen, historically there really wouldn’t have been a ton of available options to Eat Foods to kick humans out of ketosis until humans began farming grains and cereals.

3. Perhaps most importantly your brain can run off of ketones or glucose, very few things can cross the blood brain barrier, and ketones are far more efficient at crossing the blood brain barrier and powering the brain.

throwaway_jobs··on Police have been spying on black reporters and activists for years
> What measure of proof do you require?

At least some before I label someone a racist. Like I said he might be racist but I didn’t see anything to label him that.

Just because he is a white cop pulling over a black driver Doesn’t make him racist. If everything was the exact same but the cop was black would you label him a racist or just a dickhead cop?

I said many times I’m not ok with the stop, but based on the stop and questions I was clearly a bias of being rental/out of towner (which is wrong too, but doesn’t make someone a racist)

Forget what proof I need, what did you see that makes him a racist? You think he has never stopped a white person for no good reason and asked them similar questions (Maybe, but I doubt it)?

throwaway_jobs··on Venmo and Paypal Are Stalling Urgent Efforts to Bail People Out of Jail
True, but keep in mind the bail money serves a purpose other than keeping people who can’t afford it in jail pending trial...it is collateral to deter defendants from absconding.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →