HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thymine_dimer

21 karma · joined December 10, 2018

submissionscomments
thymine_dimer··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
Doesn't this just suggest that the next frontier for powerful AI models is to ask challenging questions, not simply solve them?

Terry even says this: "In fact, it is now the identification of a promising problem which is the scarce and precious resource."

The creativity and insight needed to ask a question that Terry gets excited about is the next step. Perhaps OpenAI should create a set of challenging questions and offer a prize to solve them.

thymine_dimer··on WorldClaw Agentic 3D open-world generation at scale
The water levels don't change seasonally..So I'm guessing it's a very high rainfall area? In which case erosion and nutrient leaching are bound to be issues for the agentic farmers. I wonder if they've thought to build soil with perennial ground cover species..

But as I say this, I realise the tree species seem to change very dynamically from season to season. So I'll have to assume either the temporal rate of change is actually a lot slower than one would expect in a model like this (allowing large tree species to regenerate annually), or there are new coniferous flowering tree varieties in this universe.

thymine_dimer··on What Comes After Vibe Coding
"What comes after vibe coding" is a different question to the one you're answering. Feels like your answer is about better vibe coding: I'm using a tiered document system. It's just docs all the way down. Seems to be working for me, ask in another ten years.

What comes after vibe coding? At some point the AI will be asking humans if its new software saves us time and whether we'd pay money for it. Until then, there'll be some level of humans-asking-AI to solve a problem, probably with coarser and less detailed spec at each step.

thymine_dimer··on The Adolescence of Technology
Is 'contextualised pretraining' a solution to baking in human alignment?

You can only post-train so much... Try telling a child that martial arts isn't the solution to everything right after they've watched karate kid. A weak analogy, but it seems very clear that the healthy psychological development of frontier models is something necessary to solve.

Some good insights could come from those working at the coalface of child-psychology.

thymine_dimer··on Size of Life
(Uninsightful comment but I’m gonna put it here anyway) The US spelling of haemoglobin is all kinds of wrong. Love the site. Would love some algae in there though. Perhaps a desmid or diatom?
thymine_dimer··on How elites could shape mass preferences as AI reduces persuasion costs
It’s a great process where I live. But you’re right. Doesn’t scale to populated areas.

Wonder what the potential microbial turnover of lawn is? Multiply that by the average walk length and I bet that could handle one or two nuggets per day, even in a city.

That’s a side hustle idea for any disengaged strava engineers. Leave me an acknowledgement on the ‘about’ page.

thymine_dimer··on How elites could shape mass preferences as AI reduces persuasion costs
Quite a tangent, but for the purpose of avoiding anaerobic decomposition (and byproducts, CH4, H2S etc) of the dog poo and associated compostable bag (if you’re in one of those neighbourhoods), I do the same as your mum. If possible, flick it off the path. Else use a bag. Nature is full of the faeces of plenty of other things which we don’t bother picking up.
thymine_dimer··on Shifts in diatom and dinoflagellate biomass in the North Atlantic over 6 decades
Finally some phytoplankton on the front page...if only for a second.
thymine_dimer··on Good Writing
Dear Paul, I'm sure it has been said elsewhere in the comments, but ironically I struggle to agree with this essay...which happens to be nicely and succinctly written.

I'm arguing that it's your own bias generated from the synthesis of your own idea that selects for sentences that effectively express the idea, and nothing to do with the writing itself.

The anecdote about the puddle who suddenly gains consciousness and remarks that the world is so perfectly formed around it, that it's proof of divine creation, seems to apply here.

The author generates an idea and is trying to articulate it. A well written sentence or paragraph that flows, pleases the author. This is because the idea they are trying to express is done in a satisfying way.

Thus the more pleasing the writing to the author, the more efficiently it articulates the original idea. It's the author's bias, based on their own idea, that defines the level of 'pleasingness'.

Lastly, Paul, do you think the LLMs are any less satisfied with their confident and irrational hallucinations, than they are with their more well supported claims? Further, if you weren't aware that the output was ridiculous, would you be able to tell a accurate statement from a false one?

Thanks for the essays. Love them.

thymine_dimer··on Ask HN: What's the best implementation of Conway's Game of Life?
Next time I'm discussing the ol' "are we part of a simulation?" dilemma, I'll pull this up