HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tjradcliffe

2,541 karma · joined June 17, 2014

Poet, physicist, engineer, author: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1422
submissionscomments
tjradcliffe··on I would have hired Doug, but...
I don't see that at all. I started out when "structured programming" and "recursion" were both exciting concepts. OO came along and over a ten year period went from "useful for UI" to "the One Ring To Rule Them All" and while the shine wore off a bit, it really did help.

Today Functional Programming is introducing all kinds of new ideas and approaches, and while I often find FP people over-earnest and irritating, I'm still able to recognize that they offer something new, even if it isn't all they think it is.

Impure functional languages like Haskell have shown that it's possible to get many of the advantages of a purely functional language while still being able to implement side-effects, which is an amazingly cool trick despite Haskeller's annoying insistance that their side-effect-ful "language" is "purely functional" even if they have to redefine "language" to make it true.

This is true of all the supposedly "pure" functional languages, which universally come with caveats that amount to "disregarding all the sex I've had, I am a virgin", but that's just a somewhat off-putting quirk of the community. The languages themselves are full of interesting ideas that are being adopted by less purity-obsessed languages, and this is a good thing in the same way that the OO-purism of SmallTalk drove other more mainstream languages to adopt OO ideas and bring them in adulterated form to the unwashed masses (which had the nice side-effect of driving the purists nuts, and who doesn't want to see that?)

So I personally get the feeling that it's a great time to be alive and active as a software developer. We're barely out of the "bash rocks together to make hammer-like-thing" era of programming, and we get to be part of the most explosive growth phase of the most important technological growth curve in human history: the algorithmization of work.

tjradcliffe··on The programming talent myth
Every human ability has a natural distribution of what for a better word we can call "talent". This is as true of running or tennis as it is of coding. To claim otherwise is to tell people who aren't naturally very good at tennis that they are moral failures for not working hard enough at it, which is insulting and demeaning as well as false.

Furthermore, there is evidence that the ability to code is non-linearly dependent on some fairly uniformly distributed basic abilities. The bimodal mark distribution of first year software courses is evidence of this. It is trivial to reproduce it using the assumption that the underlying skill-set is uniformly distributed, but there is a threshold of ability below which coding becomes very hard: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1471

There is a very simple way to disprove this hypothesis: find a way to teach coding that will get rid of the bimodal distribution of marks, which has been vigorously attacked by educators for decades without progress. The things we have learned in that time are:

1) It doesn't matter how passionate the teacher is about believing that "everyone can learn to code"

2) It doesn't matter what language is used

3) It is very hard to predict who will be good and who will be bad.

Because of this, there are three reasons we know cannot be the source of the problem: the attitude of the teachers, the langauge used, or the number of years experience prior to university. If any of those were the cause the extensive research on this issue would have revealed them in the 80's.

I'm prefectly willing to believe that most people can be taught to code, and if I can be shown evidence of a teaching method that gets rid of the bimodal distribution I'll happily abandon the barrier-to-entry model I've proposed in the link above, but until then, it can't be called anything less than a plausible hypothesis. Certainly not a "myth".

tjradcliffe··on What we know about the EmDrive and Cannae Drive
> Why can't we admit that what we currently know only seems impressive to a few moderately advanced apes but in reality it is likely only tiny drop in the bucket compared to the knowledge our universe holds.

Because that would be to deny without any reason but empty speculation that what a small group of scientists have done in the past 300 years is a singularly impressive achievement, adding more to human understanding of the universe than far large groups have done over far longer spans of time.

People don't know very much aren't impressed by what the discipline of publicly testing ideas by systematic observation, controlled experiment, and Bayesian inference has taught us about the world, and they radically under-estimate how much we know, instead comparing the vast and wonderous extent of our actual knowlege with their own fantasies of what might be known one day.

I look back at the science of the 1800's and I'm impressed by how much they knew, how much they did. I expect scientists a century or two from now will look back and think the same of us, while the ignorant people of their day will dismiss the thoughts and judgements of scientists of that time as nothing much compared to the fantasies of the ignorant.

tjradcliffe··on What we know about the EmDrive and Cannae Drive
Except the non-locality of QM is irrelevant to a device that is apparently a closed cavity. Simply because the same word is used does not mean the underlying concept is sufficiently similar in both contexts to be relevant.

Local momentum conservation is foundational to all of physics: it is embedded in Newton's laws, and you can't get much more foundational than that. As such, if anything violates it the degree of "extraordinary" would be beyond anything ever seen. Far beyond superluminal nuetrinos.

So the previous posters are correct: momentum conservation, which is generally used to mean "local momentum conservation", is as deeply foundational to physics as Newton's laws, and the kind of observable-only-by-statistical-inference non-locality seen in QM is not known to have any impact on it.

As such, it would be earth-shaking at the deepest possible levels of physics if this result were correct. That does not mean it is wrong--although that is certainly my bet and that of virtually every other working physcist--but it's important not to understate what a big deal it would be, because understanding that opens up alternative ideas regarding how to test it.

This is neither arrogance nor dismissal, but an understanding that anything that violates local momentum conservation, via QM or anything else, and also lets the rest of physcis sail blithely on, manifesting no measureable effect of any kind on any of the millions of diverse and precise experiments that have been performed, is astonishingly implausible.

Could it happen? Sure. But it's really easy for laypeople to radically underestimate the implausibility of such claims, as was done all the time in the cold fusion community.

Nor does reproduction of the effect say anything very much about either the underlying theory (such as it is) or the actual cause. Lots of things can create forces of micronewtons, and given how utterly implausible the claim is, most physicists are starting with a prior barely above epsilon. As such, the amount of evidence required to update our belief to something close to unity is going to be huge. Laypeople, who start with an unreasonably large prior because they are ignorant of how fine-tuned such novel physics would have to be to never show up anywhere else, will require less evidence.

tjradcliffe··on Ask HN: How to not base self worth on your own work?
As others here have said, look for meaning in your life in other places, both in the way you do the work (process-orientation) and in your relationships.

But there is an important lesson you'll have to learn to make any of that work, which is nicely summed up in the considerably under-rated "Julian Comstock" by Robert Charles Wilson: "Just because nothing lasts doesn't mean that nothing matters."

Everything you do, everything you are, is transient. The work you are doing to day will be bitrotted away to nohthing in five or ten years. The relationships you have will grow and change, and just as surely they will die, or the people you have them with wil die, or you will die.

The appeal of religion is that it's a trick that allows people to live with this reality, but the cost is extremely high. The challenge for those of us unwilling to accept the epistemic and moral compromises religion entails is to find ways for our lives to be meaningful that don't require quite such massive self-deception or accepting even a tiny bit of moral authority based on things that "just made sense" to pre-modern high-status men who knew less about the world than the average intelligent high-school student today.

Looking inward--meditating and whatnot--doesn't help much on the transience issue, because everythat that you are will also pass away. It can help on some practical things, though, including developing an awareness of all the good things we have simply by being clever enough to be born in the right time and place.

Looking outward, to help others, to contribute to the world, to develop a braoder network of social connections that are not purely self-indulgence (although a life without self-indulgence is a life not worth living) can help, although it comes with all the frustrations of dealing with human beings. No good deed goes unpunished.

I'm not a natural helper or teacher of others, but I've found the greatest satisfactions in my life have come from mentoring and managing in ways that make people's lives a bit better. One of the things that makes that work is an awareness that if I help someone learn something, the good I've done will last. The potential positive effect of mentoring goes on pretty much indefinitely, long after I've been laid-off from my job or my project has been shelved or my girlfriend has dumped me or my marriage has ended or my friends have died or all the other things that really do happen to people in the course of a long, full and successful life.

tjradcliffe··on Mercurial: Onward and upward
I have had the same experience as you.

I used git for a couple of years and definitely had regular wtf moments. Switched to Mercurial and they just went away.

The complexity and counter-intuitive (to me, at least) nature of git's model was a major barrier to entry.

I still use git now and then because github is so popular, but for a small team on a moderate-sized project I really prefer Mercurial for its ease of use.

tjradcliffe··on How Old Do I Look?
I'm thinking that wasn't the issue with the photo of my girlfriend, taken in natural light, that estimated her age to be 20 years more than it is...
tjradcliffe··on How Old Do I Look?
The results on every photo I tried were ludicrously wrong. The closest it got on photos of me was about five years older than me, but it ran anywhere up to 20 years too old.

The same thing on photos of others I tried: a 22-year old man was estimated to be 49, a fifty-year-old woman--who is generally considered to look young for her age--to be 69. Those are ages that no one would ever guess based on looks.

So I'd say the algorithm needs a little more work.

tjradcliffe··on Ask HN: Do you feel like you're in a filter bubble?
The suggestions here to track down a diversity of sources are good, but I'm increasingly finding that as soon as I've read a source for a while I come to recognize that it is living inside a filter bubble of its own and start discounting a lot of what I'm reading.

The only places I can stick with are the large, old, mainstream media sites: BBC, the Atlantic, the National Post (in Canada). Each of them has biases and a definite editorial policy, but they are all still making some kind of attempt to be objective about the news they choose to report, where by "objective" I mean "they don't ignore obvious facts, flat-out lie about stuff, or deliberately cast stories in terms of abstractions that make them look like something completely different from the way they'd look if you focus on the concretes." They also tend to provide background pieces to major stories that look at multiple perspectives on them.

These organizations all have some notion that what they are doing involves helping their readers understand their world. Most other places see their mission primarily in terms of either entertainment or influence.

Maybe I'm just old, but keeping those sources for news and following a diversity of people--including a number of mainstream media print reporters and several academics, particularly economists--on Twitter to get personal views of events and ideas seems to be working OK.

With regard to "new content", there are only a few new ideas in the world. Every startup story on HN is going to have some similarities. Every science story likewise. Tech stories even moreso. Our ability to communicate has increased by... how much? A million-fold?... in the past thirty years, but our ability to find things to say has stayed the same. It follows from this that most of what we find online is repetition and drivel (including, likely, this comment).

tjradcliffe··on Lake Michigan Is So Clear Right Now Its Shipwrecks Are Visible from the Air
I swam in Lake Ontario near Kingston from the mid-80's up to a few years ago and never had an issue, although after heavy rains in summer there could be pretty high E. coli load near shore due mostly to ducks and geese (solution, swim off a dock).

Fecal matter from birds--like the scads of corrmorants around Kingston--is rich in nutrients, and while agricultural runnoff can be a problem Lake Ontario doesn't suffer from it particularly, and even without it there are plenty of altnernative nutrient sources.

tjradcliffe··on Are we all born with perfect pitch?
No. The inference from "every baby in this study has perfect pitch" to "every baby has perfect pitch" is as unwarranted as "every person I have ever met is handed so ambidextrous people don't exist."

Most babies may well have better pitch than the vast majority of adults. To claim therefore that every baby has perfect pitch is sensationalist, unwarranted, and almost certainly wrong. Very poor science-reporting.

The interesting question, as always, is what the distribution is, not sweeping and almost certainly false categorical claims ("All members of category X have property Y!")

tjradcliffe··on Six works of Computer Science-Fiction
Or any of Stanislaw Lem's books of "fables for robots" like "The Cyberiad".
tjradcliffe··on A systems theorist explains what’s wrong with standard models of intelligence
> In this scenario, our choices, over the course of a century or so, become ultimately non-existent.

You need to explain how choosing to let apps make certain types of decision removes all choices whatsoever. As it stands, you make it sound like a carpenter who is using a nail gun instead of hammer has stopped driving nails.

tjradcliffe··on Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricatures of his thought (2013)
The difficulty with these claims is that nowhere is there a counter-example to any of the supposed systems of oppression that keep us in thrall. It is a purely utopian analysis that rest on the false belief that humans can be free of the structure that various discourses impose on our relations.

By focusing the analysis on the supposed binary oppositions within and between discursive identities, a great deal of practical, compassionate, utility is lost for the sake of smashing global industrial capitalism with the unrealizable dream of replacing it with some kind of utopian society.

tjradcliffe··on Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricatures of his thought (2013)
And just because people took their kids doesn't mean they didn't find it frightening. The two claims have literally nothing to do with each other. It's like saying people pay good money to see horror movies so they aren't scared of being hacked to bits by psychopaths.

Native peoples in the Great Lakes region mostly enjoyed torturing prisoners of war to death in variously fairly horrible ways, often over days. The whole tribe participated and it had something of the carnivalesque atmosphere the link you provide mentions. Yet there is also evidence that fear of capture loomed very large in the minds of warriors because of the fate that awaited them.

One of the things the post-structuralists (especially Derida, who is really nothing but a troll) are good at is distraction and indirection. Foucault's bloodthirsty descriptions of torture in D&P have no scholarly value and could easily be replaced by a one-or-two-line sketch of the reality without loss of utility... except that people would then read the rest of the book in a less aroused state of mind, and would be more calmly critical of his unsupported and frequently implausible claims.

tjradcliffe··on Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricatures of his thought (2013)
Yet no one doubts Brainfuck's Turing completeness, and it can be easily demonstrated to anyone with a passing familiarity with the langauge.

The post-structuralists, on the other hand, are trolls. They claim grandiose results that fail Chomsky's simple personal test, and similar personal tests of many others, myself included, who have a demonstrated capacity to understand ideas across many fields, including in my case epistemology with a knowing subject, which comes close to some important post-structuralist or post-modernist ideas regarding subjectivity.

But the "critical theoretic" political program is so important to post-modernist program they they deliberatly distort their accounts and ideas for the sake of goals that have nothing to do with the topic at hand, and results in the whole body of their work being incoherent nonsense with a few gems embedded in it. There are well-meaning people who see the gems and argue passionately that the rest of the mass simply must be meaningful and important, and there are people who correctly observe the incoherence of the mass and miss the gems.

These two groups then spend a great deal of time fighting with each other, while those of us who have picked up the gems and moved on are ignored by all.

tjradcliffe··on ‘Gods’ edging out robots at Toyota facility
Not all resources will be non-scarce, though, so this kind of one-size-fits-all thinking is misleading.

Nor are all alternatives to capitalism socialism. Socialism is also known to have very severe problems in application, particularly how to incentivize socialist managers to behave like capitalist ones in most circumstances, driving innovation and maximizing productivity. Socialist managers have somewhat different contstraints on them from capitalist managers, and nominally different long-term goals, but they are more similar than you might think.

The thing is: we know how to make capitalism work in a range of varieties, from the Scandanavian social democracies to the mess that's Texas. We have never seen a successful system of public ownership of the means of production (which is what socialism is, and nothing else). It has been tried in a variety of places and times, and it has always run up against fundamental problems of managerial incentives and political corruption at levels that make most capitalist political economies look pretty good (which is saying something!)

So looking for non-socialist means of distributing wealth in a society that is unequally post-scarce is a good idea. Today wealth is distributed almost exclusively through paid work, but that is a relatively recent invention. I'm not suggesting a return to feudalism or anything like it, but think we should be willing to consider variations in social order that are at least that large-scale, because the difference between what is coming and industrial capitalism is going to be at least as big as the difference between industrial capitalism and the semi-feudal societies that preceded it in many places.

tjradcliffe··on ‘Gods’ edging out robots at Toyota facility
Thanks for the nice summary. No way was I going to click on a headline that read like this one!

There are two kinds of jobs that robots will have a hard time replacing: these sorts of high-skill, creative, intution-and-experience heavy tasks; and low-skill but mechancially awkward tasks.

In both cases, the key to job survival will be that it's something of a niche. Anything remotely generic will be taken over by machines. So for example we'll still see certain kinds of literature generated by humans, but 100% of financial reporting, political reporting and sports reporting will be automated. More sophisticated commentary of the kind that Nate Silver does might last, but the Paul Krugmans and David Brooks of the world will be engineered out in the next decade or so by bots that troll the web for stories and generate canned ideologically-loaded commentary based on a smattering of data sources.

At the other end, jobs like fruit picking will be completely automated because it's a common task that can be implemented with a relatively generic machine, but cleaning houses will remain the domain of humans because houses are such awkward, complex spaces. Once we have a humanoid robot with very good AI that'll change, but I'm a little doubtful about seeing that in the next few decades.

tjradcliffe··on An Aspiring Scientist’s Frustration with Modern-Day Academia (2013)
Newton was ridiculed by his peers (or at least his contemporaries). Part of the reason why people tell the story of Halley convincing Newton to publish the Principia is that Newton hadn't published anything after the reception of some of his early work on optics.

For example, one of Newton's observations was that the spectrum cast by a prism he'd bought at a local fair was elongated. Being Newton, and therefore given to extreme of care, he had arranged the prism in a room that was about twenty feet long and was struck by sunlight coming through a pinhole in a shutter. This is not a simple thing to arrange, and because the Earth is rotating the correct geometry lasts quite a short time. But it allowed him to see the elongation of the spectrum.

The problem was that received wisdom said the spectrum should be circular, as it was cast by a circular beam. Some of the replies to Newton's paper were on the order of, "Well, I held up a prism and took a quick look and it seemed ciruclar to me! Mr Newton is a fool."

Science is always going to be like this. People are mostly idiots (I certainly am, most of the time.) But the author's point is that it is worse now, and that the institutional incentives that make it worse are pretty clear. Get a couple of beer into an older scientist and they'll often tell you that they couldn't have gotten an academic position in the current climate.

Furthermore, similar incentives are in play all over the world--althouhg a friend in the Far East tells me things are better there because universities are still trying to build reputations so they are engaged in more fundamental research rather than just grant-writing.

Given this, and given we depend on science to solve some of our biggest problems, and given we have a lot of smart, passionate, dedicated people going into the sciences to solve those problems, an institutional structure that fails to deliver on the promise of giving those people a meaningful career solving problems that matter is a serious problem for Enlightenment civilization.

tjradcliffe··on An Aspiring Scientist’s Frustration with Modern-Day Academia (2013)
Even if the author realizes that, it doesn't change the fact that what they are doing is mostly admin and management, not science.

I left academia--more-or-less--after doing several post-docs and taking a hard look at an employment landscape where colleagues who were at least as good as me were taking offers from second- or third-teir institutions because that was all that was available. I knew some of them were profoundly lonely and struggling in those positions, outside of the charmed circle of the top teir they had comfortably inhabited for so long.

Beyond that, there was the realization that unlike the profs who trained my generation, people my age pursuing tenure were rarely getting into the lab. They couldn't afford to. They had to stay relentlessly on the track of paper and grant generation, as well as committee work, if they wanted to succeed.

I would be a really bad fit in that job. I got into science because I love the hands-on act of "disturbing the universe", in Freeman Dyson's memorable phrase, and even in the improbable event that I landed a tenure-track job (improbable in part because as a post-doc I tended to work on problems that interested me, rather than ones that would lead to lots of publications) I would end up spending most of my time doing stuff I wasn't very good at and didn't much enjoy.

It's one thing to say that "every job has a certain amount of work involved" (there are always less appealing things you have to do in the name of the stuff you enjoy) but when a job is mostly stuff you aren't suited for, it's not a good idea to pursue it.

This is the fundamental problem of modern academia: researchers are getting shunted into managers and administrators as soon as they get on tenure track. While the age they make the transition to tenure track is going up, the length of active research careers is going down. Hands-on research scientists who are active over the full length of their career are almost always in some kind of permanent research associate position, free from the vagaries of tenure and promotion. They are the people most of us who go into the sciences want to be, but the positions available for them are few and far between.

We need serious, genuine academic reform so that there are more positions available for career scientists who do science, rather than careerists who transition to managers and administrators the moment they become assistant professors.

tjradcliffe··on Postmortem of Venture-Backed Startup, Sonar
Everything is a stupid idea unless it works. No one can tell the stupid ideas from the smart ones until after the fact.

Facebook and Twitter: both stupid ideas that now have dominant market positions. The iPhone was "too late, too expensive, too lame" to take off when it was first released, at least in the opinion of some professional pundits.

These lessons or observations are all OK, although I'd say that figuring out what people are willing to use or pay for is and always will be a huge unsolved problem. Sometimes you build something for a market that turns out not to be there.

There are two types of technology: ones that everyone wants and no one knows how to do (think SpaceX) and ones that everyone knows how to do but nobody knows anyone wants (think Facebook).

Everything in the social media/mobile space is a lot more like the second kind. There's not rocket science. It's all HTML and CSS and .js and nosql and whatnot. But knowing what people are willing to buy into, out of all the infinite things we could do with those parts, is a mystery.

tjradcliffe··on Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010
The E-mini S&P futures market is incredibly illiquid, which is why one guy can game it this way. Look at the current volume on the June 15th contract: http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=ESM15.CME+Interactive#sym...

It's 343! That's zero to a good approximation.

So this guy found a low-volume market that he could game with large sell orders above the current price that he would cancel (automatically, eventually) so he had a low (but crucially: non-zero) risk of actually having to sell at that price. Others would see the large sell volume and sell themselves, driving the price down. He would buy at the lower price, stop placing sell orders and watch the price bounce back up, absent his manipulation.

This is likely illegal in the letter of the law as written in 2010, and fair enough. Illiquid markets are easily subject to this kind of thing and if you want people to invest in them maybe you need to police them against it. Whatever.

But to call this "the cause" of the flash crash is like saying my neighbour's love of fireworks is "the cause" of my house burning down after I deliberately poured gasoline all over it. Sure, maybe my neighbour should have been more careful, but they had a reasonable expectation that my house would be ordinarily fire-proof, and behaved accordingly.

And of course this guy dominated the market when it was falling rapidly: his algorithm would have a field day in such an event, placing and cancelling multiple sell orders as fast as it could all the way down. So to cite that as some kind of evidence is to put effect before cause.

The only way this could have "caused" the flash crash is if a whole lot of large trading algorithms were using E-mini S&P futures as a a major input, and doing that--using such an illiquid, easily-manipulated market to drive large orders--that is criminal. Or should be.

tjradcliffe··on A New ‘Wrinkle in Time’
Exactly. "Writing is re-writing". The final draft, not the first, should be presumed to represent the author's best intentions. And authors actually do exist, and do have intentions, and can communicate those intentions, however imperfectly and incompletely.

Cutting something from the final draft of a work signals the author's intentions pretty clearly: they believed for whatever reason and by whatever standard mattered to them, that the work was better off without it. That may have been for artistic or commerical or political considerations, but whatever they were, they were the author's and it behooves us to honour them.

People who claim that authors do not have intentions or that those intentions cannot ever be known to any interesting degree seem to feel that they themselves are able to author works whose intentionality is fully decipherable. This is odd, not least because if communication between author and reader was not possible, it would follow that encryption is not possible, because encryption does nothing but interrupt the communication of the author's intentionality to the reader. An encrypted message can still be read as a string of random charcters, but none of the author's intentionality can be inferred. If the process of reading didn't involve inferring the author's intentionality, this would not be a problem, and an encrypted version of "A Wrinkle in Time" would be functionally identical to a plain-text one.

tjradcliffe··on An inch-long universal text encoder
There's also the issue of gravity waves, and don't get me started on the Planck Length. I believe the vendor's claims for the encoding of arbitrarily large document collections are considerably overstated!
tjradcliffe··on Nice Downtowns: How Did They Get That Way? People Made Them
Vancouver. Even some of our smaller cities have pretty OK downtowns (Kingston, Nanaimo...)

Liveable downtowns are definitely a matter of policy, not history.

tjradcliffe··on An Experiment in Purely Functional IO for Clojure
But the whole point of Haskell is to make claims that confuse the unitiated, isn't it? Because that's excactly what every tutorial that claims "Haksell is a pure langauge" is doing when it then goes on to say "Haskell can do I/O" without explaining that unlike every other language the unitiated reader has ever encountered, Haskellers have chosen to define "the langauge" in such a way as to exclude "the runtime".

I really don't get why this point is not made clear in all Haskell discussions up-front, but instead Haskellers insist on repeating the empty mantra "Haskell is a pure language" as if they were using the term "language" in the standard way rather than redefining it in a carefully constructed way so as to make their claim true.

This is terrible pedagogy on par with people who introduce negative generalized temperature or resistance without first explaining that they are generalizing the concept. And it obscures one of the coolest aspects of Haskell, which is that it is an impure language (using "language" in the standard way, which always includes the runtime) that has very cleverly packaged its impurity such that reasoning about the code still gets most of the advantages of purity.

"Haskell has a pure syntax that is interpreted by an impure runtime" is more accurate and far less confusing.

tjradcliffe··on Hevea Project – Flat tori finally visualized
The infinite layering of corrugations is required regardless, because the "true" surface has undefined curvature. They are doing an approximation to that of arbitrary precision.

This is a really delightful peice of work. The existence of surfaces with the curvature undefined everywhere is an easily described concept that comes up fairly frequently in topology, but I'd always assumed it was just impossible to visualize them.

tjradcliffe··on A 1969 New Wave Sci-Fi Novel That Made Correct Predictions
Agreed. Banks was basically writing fantasy-horror, and while beautifully written the Culture novels I've read are one long litany of awfullness, despite the essentially utopian setting.
tjradcliffe··on A 1969 New Wave Sci-Fi Novel That Made Correct Predictions
Conversely, the ability of people to get almost any peice of information at any time anywhere has wiped out a vast number of traditional plot devices, which makes things surprisingly difficult for the modern story-teller. It has opened up new landscapes, but because communication and knowlege are so easy now the kinds of stories we can tell in them are very different.

My own "living in the future" story: I have a number of friends who have family involved in the space program, including a couple of astronauts. I was hiking with one a few years ago and she commented on a big family gathering at Thanksgiving, mentioning, "Of course so-and-so wasn't there because he's on the space station." It just made me pause and take stock, while the ten-year-old me did backflips because I was living in the future, and it was good.

tjradcliffe··on A 1969 New Wave Sci-Fi Novel That Made Correct Predictions
Pretty much every Brunner novel I've read sucks, though I've not read The Sheep Look Up or Stand on Zanzibar. From what I recall after reading a few (whose titles I do not remember) the important thing for Brunner is that everything come out badly, no matter how contrived or tortured the plot becomes to achieve that end. It makes his work boring and predicable, as well as despressing, and the contrivance is unartful and awkward.

Brunner hated the possibility that technology might solve any problems: he was opposed to Cold Fusion before it became obvious it was nonsense because he thought it would enable cheap, easy, consumption with a small environmental footprint, so people like him wouldn't be able to tell the rest of us how aweful we were for enjoying ourselves. There is a great deal of Puritanism in his work.

With regard to these "predictions" I have to agree with the assessment that failed predictions are being touted as successful ones. Fuel cells are not batteries, for example. And the US is hardly "beset by terrorists": that is simply proganda by the security-industrial complex. There have been terrorist incidents, but far more people have been killed in the excessive and poorly thought out response to those incidents (the invasion and occupation of Iraq in particular) than were killed in them.

Likewise, extrapolating that Europe would be united when there was a blueprint and long term plan already underway to do this is not a great leap of the imagination. It's more curious that American SF authors tended to see the world as either having a single government or a bipolar distribution of power rather than a multi-polar world, which has long been more probable.

← PreviousPage 6 of 25Next →