HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tjradcliffe

2,541 karma · joined June 17, 2014

Poet, physicist, engineer, author: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1422
submissionscomments
tjradcliffe··on Leonardo da Vinci’s resume
> I see so many job applications that are exactly a laundry list of achievements, and nothing about what the applicant could do for me.

There is another side to this, which is that many job ads don't provide anything like enough information for candidates to do that.

Most job ads tell us what skills are desired, and a tiny bit about the industry the company works in, and even less about the specific project the candidate would be focused on. It's difficult for me to tell you, "I can bring your galambosian robotics framework to the next level by applying the latest Fibonacci refactoring techniques!" if all I know is "we're a leading-edge company working on bringing killer robots to the masses!"

Furthermore, the cover letter will in many cases be screened by an HR wonk who isn't qualified to judge any of that.

So the approach of a cover letter that points up specific expertise that may apply to the position is often the best a candidate can do. "My work on galambosian robotics frameworks has definite application to the world of killer robots" is at least as much "pointing out past achievements" as "telling what I can do for you", but without a lot more information than companies are willing to give, it's difficult to make it better.

The hiring process is profoundly broken.

tjradcliffe··on Female Chimps Seen Making, Wielding Spears
They may not be, as others have pointed out, but on the other hand, humans have disrupted their environment and put them under extreme selective pressure of various kinds. We have also reduced their population, creating a greater likelihood of inbreeding, which allows new variations to spread very rapidly throughout the remaining population.

So it isn't our observing them that is relevant. We may be putting pressure on them that is driving their evolution, and evolutionary change can happen very rapidly when the pressure is high.

tjradcliffe··on Female Chimps Seen Making, Wielding Spears
If you ever want to have real fun, point this out to a doctrinaire feminist who is heavily invested in the idea that men are more violent than women because in the primordial landscape men did most of the hunting. I did this to a freind once, quite innocently, and she ended up so angry she could--in her own description--barely speak.

There is a whole literature in a particular brand of feminism (mostly associated with the radicals) that simply takes the association of hunting and interpersonal violence on faith, whereas in fact we're pretty sure men are more violent than women because of mate competition. The fact that we observe hunting behaviour amongst female chimps (who are less violent than male chimps) and female bonobos (who are far less violent than chimps, and no more violent than male bonobos, who also hunt) makes it clear that hunting behavior has nothing much to do with interpersonal violence.

This makes good sense from an evolutionary perpsective: killing a member of another species is a profoundly different kind of selective event than killing a member of your own species, particularly in a social primate like proto-humans where the individual you kill is likely to be closely related to you. The selective pressures on the two behaviours are almost completely disjoint, but to believe the feminist myth--or the equally silly pseudo-evolutionary anti-feminist myths that preceded it--you have to believe they are somehow related.

tjradcliffe··on Yes, You Can Catch Insanity
Iatgrogenic (treatment-caused) disease is a leading cause of death, although estimates vary quite a bit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iatrogenesis#Epidemiology

Doctors are rightfully conservative. There have been eras (the '50's, for example) where this was not such a big deal, and the results were generally not good. Today's doctors are still working in the shadow of those events, with even more powerful tools.

So while I do see the point you are making, it isn't really that odd that doctors are loathe to treat in the absense of a diagnosis.

tjradcliffe··on How FPGAs work, and why you'll buy one (2013)
There have been periodic bursts of FPGA hype over the past several decades, and they have all fizzled out for precisely the reasons you cite.

"FPGAs: they're the technology of the future, and always will be!"

tjradcliffe··on SpaceX Plans to Land Next Falcon 9 on Solid Ground
As has been pointed out almost endlessly over the past day, almost all the mass in the rocket is in the lower end by the time it hits the pad, so despite what anyone can imagine it isn't that hard to keep it vertical.

The hard part is landing it softly enough and vertically enough that it won't break or fall over due to residual velocity. Once it's down, in low seas, the few degrees wobble of the barge won't have an effect.

Or in other words: I can't imagine SpaceX engineers haven't worked all this out in detail, and I can't imagine SpaceX would be trying this if they didn't have good reason to think it would work, and I can't imagine that SpaceX engineers aren't professionally competent, so, based on the standard "what I can't imagine can't be true", Shotwell is spouting irrelevancies.

This is the problem with imaginary arguments: if anyone thinks that what they can or can't imagine is relevant to what is true, they have to yield the argument to me, who can't imagine there is anyone in this day and age who still beleives that.

tjradcliffe··on Space X CR6 First stage landing
This.

This video is one of the most beautiful things I have ever seen. This is not a failure. This is an incredibly rich mine of data on how to do better next time.

This is how we improve the world, and it's beautiful.

tjradcliffe··on Stephen King: “Everything You Need to Know About Writing Successfully”
It's an excellent book, and I highly recommend it, but it's also very personal and idiosyncratic in much of its advice. King is a writer of a particular type, and he's talking about the way he writes, which may or may not be the way you write (it's almost completely antithetical to the way I write, which is why I learned so much from it.)
tjradcliffe··on Ghost Rockets – A crowd sourced UFO investigation
Given that the term "flying saucer" seems to be a misnomer from Kenneth Arnold's report that described the motion of the observed object as being "like a saucer skipping on a pond" and his sketch of the object shows something that looks a bit like a flying wing (http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/4376/798/1600/Kenneth%20A...) which notoriously have a bucking or skipping motion in the air, it would be fairly weird if a disc-shaped object were involved. Edit: there's some speculation it might have been the German Horten Ho 229: http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs70/i/2011/159/e/d/horten_ho_229...

It would be like you giving me an inaccurate description of something based on someone else's report, and me mangling your description into something that just happened to be very much like the original. It's not impossible, but you'd have to be pretty optimisic to call it remotely plausible.

tjradcliffe··on If We Dig Out All Our Fossil Fuels, Here’s How Hot We Can Expect It to Get
The world has always been about to end, and there have always been people ready to make money scaring people over it. This time is no different. In fact, we are better equipped to deal with our current problems than any generation of humanity has ever been.
tjradcliffe··on Sell in May, and go away?
Given it's an analysis of the S&P500 you just buy/sell SPY and follow the index. Not that I recommend that, for reasons other people here have pointed out.
tjradcliffe··on The Null Professor (2014)
Not at all. It's "Some (maybe many) people will require an implausibly large amount of will for learning to code to be a worthwhile use of their time."

Like anyone who has pursued a diversity of interests fairly seriously over decades, I've found that some things are really easy for me, others not. I'm an excellent poet, if I do say so myself, and although I've worked hard at it, it comes easily to me. But after forty years of steady practice I'm pretty sure I will never be much of a prose stylist, no matter how hard I work at it. I can tell a decent story, but when I look at people like Iain Banks or David Mitchell I recognize that they "get it" in a way I probably never will, no matter how much effort I put in.

So the belief that force of will can overcome all obstacles is not one that I subscribe to. It can help, but some obstacles are simply too big. It is an open question if this is often the case with regard to learning to code, and while I think it is, the lack of any independent measure of "getting it" makes my position implausible. As such, all that would take to convince me otherwise would be a way of teaching CS1 that didn't routinely result in the traditional bimodal mark distribution.

tjradcliffe··on The Null Professor (2014)
The one thing I don't see in stuff written by people who are committed to the idea that everyone can be taught to program is before-and-after mark distributions, demonstrating how we can get rid of the apparently robust bimodal distribution that has dominated first year computing courses for decades.

It's great to contend that everyone can be taught to program, but decades of research have yet to answer the question of "How?" Or even "Why?" Many people have very strongly felt opinions, but there is a surprising paucity of data.

The idea that some people get it, some don't is not at all ridiculous: it is a perfectly plausible hypothesis given the robust bimodal mark distribution seen in first year computing, which differs from what we see in math or the sciences. The problem is no one has been able to find anything that correlates well enough with this to be predictive, and if "not getting it" and "getting it" were features of humans we might expect to be able to measure them in ways other than teaching first year computing.

On the other hand, no one has ever been able to get rid of that bimodal shape (so far as I know), so there is an equal and opposite knock against that hypothesis.

I lean toward the "inherent" hypothesis and have some ideas as to what might underlie it, but would be easily convinced otherwise if anyone could actually generate an intro computer curriculum that resulted in a mark distribution that looked more like what we see in first year math or physics.

tjradcliffe··on The Null Professor (2014)
There is a considerable literature on 'the CS1 problem' in education. It is a long-term, robust observation that the marks in first-year computing courses in university are strongly bimodal in a way that is not seen in other, comparably difficult subjects.

Here is a discussion of a paper (with link to the paper itself) that looks at these issues: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1338

And some follow-on, where I build a simple model that reproduces the biomodal mark distribution under the assumption that there is a single characteristic that is uniformly distributed amongst the population but that exhibits a threshold when it comes to programming: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1471

My bet is there's one (or a small number) of characteristics that are possessed in different degree by people and that if you fall below some threshold you will have a hard time learning to code. I liken this to height with respect to getting over a wall in an obstacle course: for people who are tall enough, it'll be easy. For people below some threshold it will become increasingly hard. There are two other variables that matter (strength and weight) so it may be difficult to pull out height as a single parameter, but some linear combination of height, weight and strength should be a good predictor of ability to get over the wall.

No one has found such a small set of factors for programming ability yet, but I'm not aware of anyone testing the things that are likely to be important, particularly a) ability to follow instructions; b) ability to create a set of instructions for a task that, when followed by a person unfamiliar with every element of the task will result in its successful completion; and c) ability to arbitrarily use anything to represent anything else.

tjradcliffe··on Ask HN: Which book are you reading these days?
Fiction: Nicholas Nickleby (Dickens). Dickens' prose is like a sugared donut. Rich and enjoyable in small bites, cloying as a steady diet, so this is heavily interspersed with other reading.

Non-Fiction:

Global Crisis (http://www.amazon.com/Global-Crisis-Climate-Catastrophe-Seve...) Excellent history of the climate disaster known as "the Little Ice", and the social, political and economic disruptions it produced. Due to where the records are best, lots of stuff from China, some from Japan, and various parts of Europe (particularly England) but it takes a genuinely global perspective on a decades-long event that may have reduced the human population of Earth by as much as 1/3. Data rich and extremely well-written, it gives some insight into how humans are apt to respond and adapt in the face of climate change (the first generation or two is not pretty, but new institutions, attitudes and adaptations do come along.)

Loneliness (http://www.amazon.com/Loneliness-Human-Nature-Social-Connect...) Recent science on the effects of social connection and the lack thereof, by one of the premier researchers in the field. Highly recommended for people who are feeling out of the loop (I work at home and recently changed cities, and recognized I was lacking a bit in human contact even for someone who is very comfortable on their own.)

The Civilization of the Middle Ages, Norman Cantor: a somewhat dated by still useful account of medieval civilization, from it's Roman roots to the early Renaissance.

Other recommendation: http://www.amazon.com/Darwins-Theorem-TJ-Radcliffe/dp/099375... Speculative fiction with big ideas (the nature of god, the role of science, the universality of evolution) and character-driven action (I am the author, so take the recommendation for what you will.)

tjradcliffe··on What the Deer Are Telling Us
> As for an overpopulated animal, I imagine there must be a better way to deal with that than allowing people to shoot them.

A) Why do you imagine that?

B) Why do you think what you imagine is a fact that's relevant to this discussion?

Our imaginations suck. This is just a fact. We can imagine a dozen impossible things before breakfast, and then fail to imagine a dozen possible things after lunch.

This is why the discipline of science is so important: it forces us to test our imaginings before asserting they are interesting or relevant, at which point they are no longer just imaginings, but evidence.

To the question at hand, hunting is, on the evidence, one of the most efficient, most effective, most humane ways of limiting the population of wild animals. As well as contributing to conservation efforts financially, hunters are a tool used by fish and wildlife departments to limit populations that would otherwise face periodic catastrophic crashes due to disease and starvation. There are other ways this can be done, but they are in general more expensive, less effective, and less humane. It's hard to kill animals like deer, and the fact that there are people willing to pay for the privilege of doing it is a boon to wildlife management.

tjradcliffe··on 'Silicon Valley Is Coming' Warns JP Morgan CEO
Yet in other countries similar processes are no where near as painful, so the claim that "having human beings involved necessarily makes things painfully in efficient" is not very plausible.

For reasons I don't understand American government systems tend to be very difficult and painful to deal with. This not unique to the US, but in the developed world most other nations have seen improvements since the '70's. The US, not so much.

Getting a driver's license or health card in Canada used to be pretty painful. Today it's very streamlined. You still have to deal with people face-to-face, but the process has been designed to be quick and efficient.

tjradcliffe··on I Quit: What really goes on at Apple
They can't. As the comment before yours pointed out: after about three weeks, those six overworked people are so inefficient that they are getting less done than six people would working regular hours.

Long crunch times (more than two or three weeks) are strong evidence of deliberately abusive management, who are willing to lower productivity below what it would be with a 40-hour work week for the sake of their egos.

tjradcliffe··on I Quit: What really goes on at Apple
The very notion of "cost centres" vs "profit centres" is incoherent. If a function is necessary for the longevity of the business, it is a profit centre. If it is not, it shouldn't be part of the business.

Treating business units that book revenue as "profit centres" only makes sense if the revenue they book is entirely due to goods and services supplied by magic elves. Otherwise, <em>the work done to enable that revenue to be booked is part of the profit-generating business</em>. Letting internal cost accounting say otherwise is a recipe for bad business.

So the first part of the solution is to drop the cost/profit dichotomy, and actually have CEOs focus on understanding their business. This is an unrealistic suggestion, I know, but I can dream.

tjradcliffe··on Unit tests fail when run in Australia
> There is only one calendar system in use at one time.

This is useful, but technically false. Go tour graveyards around Boston. You'll find stones with two death dates on them from the mid-1700's (most of the US changed in 1752).

tjradcliffe··on Ken Knowlton
"What the world needs is a massive consortium from science, math, social sciences, history, philosophy, religion, economics, business, politics -- to devise downsizing schemes, justified by world systems simulations, leading to safeguards, stockpiles, backups, plans-B, austerity triages, etc. The effort would need to be vastly multi-disciplinary and international."

To say this is "not likely to happen", as he does in the next sentence, is an understatement. Not only won't it happen, it wouldn't work if it did.

I can't think of any case in the past 2500 years when anything resembling this kind of "change everything" top-down command scheme has been tried and has not resulted in unmitigated disaster. This kind of approach has failed whenever it is tried, from Alexander's empire to the Crusades to the Soviet Union to the modern social-environment movement. Huge sweeping changes, driven from the top, that resulted in failure, war, starvation and suffering.

The Malthusian argument that even though everything has been getting better for hundreds of years, everything is about to get much, much worse also requires extraordinary evidence at this point, given it has failed so many times as to be counted as an extraordinary claim.

Might there be a grindingly ugly end to global civilization in the next few hundred years? Sure. It could happen.

Can it be prevented by any kind of massive top-down command scheme? On the overwhelming bulk of the historical evidence, probably not.

Could it be prevented by increased urbanization, empowering women, and technological improvements? Quite possibly, as those things are the drivers of so much good over the past several decades. They have the advantage of not being known to fail for pretty well-understood reasons, unlike massive top-down command schemes.

tjradcliffe··on The Problem of Publication-Pollution Denialism
Found it! "Cyanide and Happiness".

http://explosm.net/comics/3557/

tjradcliffe··on The future of the postdoc
This is not a shortage of people, it's an unwillingness or inability to raise salaries to the point where your group is attracting the people it wants.

I appreciate that the ability to pay people enough to attract them is a problem that is very difficult for institutions and organizations to solve, but living on a sub-standard salary with no job security and few career prospects (how many tenure-track opportunities are expected to open up in the next five years for the people who would fill those positions?) is a difficult problem for highly skilled post-doctoral candidates to solve, too.

tjradcliffe··on The future of the postdoc
As complete nonsense from people who believe the labour market should be replaced by socialist managers able to dictate the price independently of actual supply and demand.

These people are often described in the press as "business leaders".

tjradcliffe··on Why I Love Haskell: An Example
None of these are both a) special to Haskell and b) necessary to solving this problem in a clean way. So no, he did not. It's also worth pointing out that the last point contradicts the first.
tjradcliffe··on The Problem of Publication-Pollution Denialism
Since outside of math the goal of science is not proof but plausibility, this would not be an effective approach. Science is the discipline of publicly testing ideas by systematic observation, controlled experiment and Bayesian inference, and as such is aimed at changing the posterior plausibility of some proposition, not "proving" anything. Proof and certainty are the Alchemist's Stone: philosophers sought after them for thousands of years the way alchemists sought after the secret of turning base metals into gold, never realizing that the fundamental problem wasn't in their methods (although their methods had problems) but in their goal, which was impossible and wrong. We should seek knowledge, not certainty.

The range of means by which that can be done is huge (though considerably less than "anything goes") and there is a definite role for work that is exploratory and speculative, up to and including stuff that is almost certainly wrong but worth publishing because a) the error is not obvious and b) publishing creates the opportunity for others to respond to it, hopefully putting the error to rest for good and all. Some of the early work on the "no cloning" theorem was motivated by publications of this type (it turns out if you could clone a quantum state you could use entanglement to communicate faster than light, and there was a series of papers in Physics Letters in the late '80's proposing to do just that.)

So trusting in the self-correcting ability of the discipline of science is fundamental to its progress, and therefore insisting on some alchemical standard of "proof" as the goal for publication would fatally cripple the scientific enterprise. For science to work we have to be tolerant of the publication of error.

But we need to keep the rate of erroneous publications down to a manageable level. Peer review and society membership were ways of doing this in the past. They have broken down today, and we are still casting about for new ways to keep the error rate well above zero, but not so high as to swamp everything else.

tjradcliffe··on The Problem of Publication-Pollution Denialism
This has always been a problem, and "trusting papers written by people I know, or who have worked with people I know" has always been an adequate solution for people in the field, whatever the field is.

But with the democratization of scientific communication in the Internet Age, as well as the massive over-production of people with PhDs in the sciences relative to the number of academic jobs available, the number of accessibility of bogus publications has skyrocketed at the same time as the pressure to use them has increased enormously. Meanwhile, the amount of good science has stayed pretty much constant, so the good/total ratio is dropping precipitously.

So while insider information is still effective for us, it's much less so for others, and in particular the popular science press <em>and the majority of the people who read it</em> are interested entirely in page views on the one hand and being wooed by the "next amazing breakthrough!" on the other, rather than anything to do with actual science.

There was a comic someplace (should be xkcd but doesn't seem to be) saying of the average reader if "IFLScience" and similar sites, "You don't love science, you just want to look at its ass as it walks by." This is not the worst of all possible worlds (in other places they want science to never show its face in public, much less its ass) but it does create an environment where science communication is hard, and the proliferation of bogus journals and people willing to publish in them is problematic.

It wouldn't hurt for hiring committees to have an explicit rule that anyone who has published in a problematic journal has that publication counted against them, but mostly there needs to be some better form of triage than conventional peer review (which is weak enough as it is) or we're going to drown in papers debating the number of angels than can dance on the head of a pin, and lose that one weird trick that discovered by a post-doctoral mom that actually solves an interesting problem.

tjradcliffe··on Difficult, Dated, Frustrating, Prophetic – Teaching Thomas Pynchon
It isn't described as "difficult to understand" but "labyrinthine and recursive: full of noise", and that's an accurate description:

"One summer afternoon, Mrs. Oedipa Maas came home from a Tupperware party whose hostess had put perhaps too much kirsch in the fondue to find that she, Oedipa, had been named executor, or she supposed executrix, of the estate of one Pierce Inverarity, a California real estate mogul who had once lost two million dollars in his spare time but still had assets numerous and tangled enough to make the job of sorting it all out more than honorary."

This is loaded with irrelevancies (full of noise) no matter what the "single thought" it is supposed to convey might be. If it's about her role as executor, why the detail about the kirsch in the fondue at the garden party? If it's about the garden party, why the anecdote about the loss of two million dollars?

And given that "profluence" is a term specifically associated with Gardner, it is no surprise that an essay that opens by discussing Gardner's opinions should use it. It doesn't mean "flow" but rather the way in which fiction actively draws us forward in a continuous waking dream.

tjradcliffe··on Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Monument in Brooklyn
There have been many different opinions expressed here with regard to how quickly a politically innocuous statue would have been taken down, with different people claiming "it just makes sense" that such a statue would/wouldn't be covered and removed as quickly. This is a nice illustration of why the human intestine has such limited epistemic utility: my gut and your gut will rarely agree and there's no way based on gut feel alone to decide which if either is correct in any given situation.

So the right thing to do now is to put up a politically innocuous statue and see how long it lasts, or to find cases that are closer to this situation than graffiti, which is both commonplace and relatively less obtrusive, and less likely to be taken for an "official" statement of anything.

I used to live beside a park where a local artist erected an extremely strange Transformer-like statue in a central location that took several weeks to be removed, but it wasn't in the US and it was in the poorer area of a small town, so there are too many differences to draw any useful conclusions from it.

tjradcliffe··on Promoting Health and Longevity Through Diet
Unfortunately "easy to imagine" doesn't imply "particularly plausible", although it's an association we all (including me) tend to make. It's easy to imagine that bloodletting is a useful treatment, or that $SOME_GROUP aren't as $SOME_CHARACTERISTIC as $SOME_OTHER_GROUP, but the number of such easy-to-imagine ideas that stand up to public testing by systematic observation, controlled experiment and Bayesian inference is extremely small.

So while I don't disagree that it's easy to imagine that our ancestors had intermittent access to food--men of the Piraha people in South America, who live pretty Stone Age lives, are apt to go without food for a day or two just because they can, for example--that doesn't go too far toward increasing the plausibility that such circumstances were common enough to have a significant evolutionary influence, particularly as the evidence for positive effects for women is somewhat weaker than for men, and pregnant and nursing women have more continuous caloric requirements than others (random site with some links on women's response to IF: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/women-and-intermittent-fastin...)

In contrast, we are pretty sure humans evolved as opportunistic hunter-gatherer-scavengers, able to survive on diets and dietary schedules that were extremely variable, from mostly plants in some places to mostly meat in others, and fairly steady food supply to fairly intermittent, all without there being a vast range of average lifespans between them. This suggests that our dietary optimum is broad and shallow, whereas a great deal of dietary research seems aimed at the belief that our dietary optimum is narrow and deep, so if we could just discover the precisely right diet we would live in good health for substantially longer.

This may be the case, but my personal bet is that in my lifetime a) no such discovery will be made and b) it will continue to be extremely lucrative selling this implausible idea to the public in various guises, from "superfoods" to weird eating patterns.

Of these, intermittent fasting seems at least to be a reasonably effective way of dealing with the caloric overabundance we live in the midst of in the West, and is also well within the (arguably very broad) envelope of our evolutionary adaptations. It is also at the very least benign and quite possibly marginally better than many alternatives.

← PreviousPage 7 of 25Next →