HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tks2103

166 karma · joined February 8, 2013

submissionscomments
tks2103··on India blocking climate talks: Warsaw, Bangkok, and Kyoto negotiations
Absolutely not.

"Civility" when discussing colonialism is just stacking the deck in favor of the colonists.

Read my post again. What is insulting? Describing behavior as cowardly, and then backing it up with two points that remain unanswered?

I could understand if the posts were baseless rants directly insulting the person I replied to with no content whatsoever, but that is not what happened.

All of the words in that post were appropriate, given the thesis.

tks2103··on India blocking climate talks: Warsaw, Bangkok, and Kyoto negotiations
The sense of injustice changes the way emissions should be cut across the population.

Western countries just want to have more stuff at all costs. The developing countries know this, from direct experience in recent memory. So they are not going to play ball.

It is extremely critical to understand that the reasons the developing countries are not playing ball is different than the reasons developed countries are not playing ball.

tks2103··on India blocking climate talks: Warsaw, Bangkok, and Kyoto negotiations
Bullshit, dude. You are being a coward.

Does Rome or France conquering England have an effect on the way we should manage global emissions policy or not? Because if it doesn't, why are you mentioning it?

Do the different circumstances that India has during industrialization mean they should take a greater role in limiting their emissions or not? Because you mentioned just two items, medicine and technology, which are both positive. And you didn't indicate how they relate to emissions.

Instead of slipping in minor irrelevant facts that betray your bias, just state your opinion.

tks2103··on India blocking climate talks: Warsaw, Bangkok, and Kyoto negotiations
India was also colonized.

You aren't being unbiased when you point out medicine and technology, but not colonialism.

tks2103··on The fight against sexism is not a free pass
The pull request was titled "Removed use of gendered pronoun". I think that's a key fact missing from your summary.

I mean, there isn't really a whole lot of information from Ben here except two actions, the rejection and then the reversion.

Did he look at the title and think "I should reject a PR titled 'Removed use of gendered pronoun' because the act of removing a gendered pronoun is trivial"? Did he just look at the diff and think "This is a couple of characters, not important." Did he see the change and think "I can't wait to marginalize the shit out of these women reading my documentation!"

There's just not a lot of info from Ben. And now because of all this bluster, there is likely not to be.

Seems like a bunch of drama, rather than a fruitful discussion.

tks2103··on When income grows, who gains?
Infrastructure is very complicated.

Typically if you have a guy build a road and you let that guy control the pricing, he charges a lot because he has a monopoly. That transfers wealth to the road builder at the expense of all the would-be businessmen who would build institutions that use the road.

So societies use governments to control a relationship between the manager of the road and the people that use the road. The price to use the road dips because of the enhanced bargaining power of the people that use the road through the institution of government. Typically governments even subsidize the unit cost of using the road by paying the road manager directly up front, because the corresponding increase in business is worth it across a society.

I think that if you have a system that focuses on individuals and their relationships to roads and road builders without regulation by a large third party that represents all members of the society, you'll get a situation where the road builder uses the monopoly power to price road usage so highly that business investment is hampered. Usually people use government institutions to manage this sort of thing, and usually it works pretty good.

I think this is pretty basic stuff, no?

tks2103··on When income grows, who gains?
No, I am not equating government and society. I am questioning the simplistic view that a person can exist today and succeed independent of the society they grew up in.

What do you mean government is a foreign body on society? Society is made of people, and people usually make up governments.

tks2103··on When income grows, who gains?
What?

I'm willing to pay Apple for a smartphone. Why would I pay them for life? Even if I did pay them for life, what would that have to do with anything?

Nowadays, everyone uses roads. If you claim today that you are a self-made person that doesn't owe anything to anyone, I could just point out that roads exist and without them you would not be successful. I guess Genghis Khan was pretty successful without roads, but what does that have to do with anything?

Right now, other people make things that allow individuals to succeed. Right now, if you succeed and claim other people did not have anything to do with it, you are lying to yourself and everyone else.

Edit: And therefore, the idea of a rich man who made his money 'honestly' is too simple to be useful in any framework that manages a modern society. The definition of 'honest' is missing.

tks2103··on When income grows, who gains?
I don't understand what you are trying to say in the first paragraph.

You can easily say that no one would be successful without roads or electricity, so there is always some percentage of a person's success derived from society.

Society lowers the cost of innovation far more than any perceived hurdles it may place in front of people, in all but the most extreme cases (like Syria maybe?).

So, what do you mean?

tks2103··on Carry Your Instrument On The Plane – It's The Law
Holy crap I did not even fathom the possibility that someone could be indignant about a person wanting to travel with his or her musical instrument.

I mean, I really don't understand this. Do you like hearing music? Do you like people playing instruments? If that is the case, then you need to expect that the situation in which a person NEEDS to take his or her instrument as a CARRY ON on an airplane occurs VERY OFTEN.

Seriously, there's a guy in this thread complaining about not being able to carry on his desktop computer, as if that were comparable to a guitar. There's another guy complaining about 'information ethics'.

The idea that a person will get any amount of hassle at all for taking an instrument on a plane directly causes less music to be made.

Music is much more important than the minor whiny bullshit people are bitching about in this thread.

tks2103··on Turntable.fm shutting down - new "Turntable Live" introduced
yeah good service to point out.

the playlists on turntable were an organic composition of the community in the channel. the user was directly involved in the creation process. the playlist changed to reflect the people in the channel. it was an entirely social gathering (when it started anyway), as if you got 50 music heads into a room and asked them to rock out.

songza is purely curated. for that reason, it misses the social aspect. songza is more like hiring an extremely inexpensive dj. other users dont get to interact with the playlist content.

different approaches to the same problem, but i believe the real innovation is in combining humans minds and experiences in searching the song graph. songza does not do that. turntable did.

songza still cool tho!

tks2103··on Turntable.fm shutting down - new "Turntable Live" introduced
Turntable dunked all other music streaming sites in playlist quality for the simple reason that the intelligence behind song selection resided in humans rather than an algorithm.

It was a specific application of the general idea that social recommendations are more powerful than algorithmic recommendations. I don't know how valid the general idea is, but when it came to Turntable, it worked. People search the space of musical works much more effectively than algorithms.

And then Turntable did nothing with that power. They had high quality playlists being minted by the thousands on a daily basis, and I could not access any of them.

At least for a time, they were focused on live engagement. Unfortunately, it's just too hard to grow a music streaming product that demands each listener be present to click a button for every song. I loved the service, but I also have a job. I cannot be on the site all day long. At the risk of being presumptuous, I would guess that the product leaders were blinded by their devotion to live engagement.

Focusing instead on their brilliant, yet simple, solution to the problem of "What song should go on next?" would have been the right call. But they did not walk this path.

As for their new product, which predictably focuses more intently on the live engagement aspect, I am unconvinced. Turntable Live provides a subset of the functionality that Twitch.tv does, with less reach.

Best of luck to them. No doubt, they are an extremely talented team.

And I'm really, really going to miss Turntable. Kickass idea. (yeah yeah plug.dj, whatever)

tks2103··on A new report clarifies some misconceptions about the U.S. medical system
Nobody cares how hard doctors think they work.

Goods are priced based on their value to the consumer, not based on their cost to the manufacturer.

I don't know how health care is priced, but the idea I should internalize sympathy for the education burden on a doctor into the cost of my bill is asinine.

tks2103··on Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy
Yeah, I'm a native English speaker.

The sentence you quoted is not impossible to read, but it is more difficult to comprehend than it should be. A simple rewrite will make it more clear.

Many of the sentences in the article are much worse.

tks2103··on Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy
The writing style and grammar in this post interfered with my comprehension. In the end, I was unable to finish reading it.

Some examples:

"Giant, heavy electronics items that Amazon sometimes ships for free when the shipping cost is clearly non-trivial and cost more than the usual thin margins on such goods are another."

"But if you sell a glass of lemonade for $2 and it only costs you $1 to make it, and you decide business is so great you're going to build a lemonade stand on every street corner in the world so you can eventually afford to move humanity into outer space or buy a newspaper in your spare time, and that requires you to invest all your profits in buying up some lemon fields and timber to set up lemonade franchises on every street corner, that sounds like a many things to me, but it doesn't sound like a charitable organization."

"The vast vast majority of products Amazon sells it makes a profit on."

It should be relatively easy to rephrase most of the language. For example, the last sentence should be worded: "Amazon makes a profit on the vast, vast majority of products it sells."

I think it would be worth it. I can't understand a lot of the post without effort.

tks2103··on Welcome, Freshmen. You Don't Deserve to Be Here
I am an Ivy League alum from late last decade.

My financial aid grant was approximately 75% of tuition (before considering any federal loans).

I filed a FAFSA, and some direct paperwork required by the University. The paperwork amounted to less than 10 pages each year. I am not including the paper count of tax documents from my family.

There were several financial aid officers, but I worked closely with one. At every step of the process she was available to answer questions. I made several mistakes in my paperwork, even one after submission. My aid officer helped me with each issue.

My father passed away when I was in school. After I reported this to my University through my financial aid officer, they immediately waived all remaining tuition requirements (excluding those covered by federal loan grants). I did not pay a dime after that.

My family made about $60k a year, before my father's passing. $30k after. We own a house. I think we were middle class, but I am not sure how that is defined.

I got my aid officer a cake every year.

tks2103··on Huge victory in New York for Nigel Warren and our host community
I did not think the incentives for landlords through, it seems. I think I agree with you that the market would not find a solution that would practically preserve the right of a renter to AirBnB his or her place.
tks2103··on How Open Should a Startup CEO be with Staff?
You are arguing more with an imagined opinion and worldview than you are arguing with the comment that you replied to.

The comment you replied to refers to the perceived difference between what "the startup mythology" promises and the reality that many software engineers at startups are given in hard benefits.

Some software engineers at startups work 100-hour weeks because they think they will receive massive compensation in the form of stock. They perceive the stock they have already received to provide a much larger amount of raw wealth than it would if they crunched the numbers. They perceive that their company might provide them with much larger grants of stock if they perform exceedingly well in building the product. Sometimes their bosses guarantee them that they will receive a massive cut of the company, if they just work a little bit harder for a little bit longer.

I don't know how common situations similar to the above are, but they do exist. I imagine many folks reading Hacker News have been on one or both sides of the table in that situation (stock-granting and stock-receiving). I believe that is what the comment you responded to is criticizing.

Nowhere was there a comparison made to victorian textile workers.

Nowhere was there a claim that '(not) getting as rich as you thought' was the worst complaint about the software industry.

You made the latter two arguments up, and then knocked them down.

tks2103··on Huge victory in New York for Nigel Warren and our host community
I betcha the market will take care of the "random people" thing.

There will be some buildings that advertise as "No AirBnB places". They will capture some portion of the market that is interested. If the law does not support a landlord doing that, we could probably work something out.

There will be other buildings that allow AirBnB type short-term renting. I can think of lots of folks that would like that type of housing, or be fine with the rent decrease that would probably be associated with it.

My opinion, the "random" people allegation is a problem in people's minds more than it is a problem in real life.

tks2103··on Timeline of NSA Domestic Spying
I believe I read somewhere that Edward Snowden tried to express his concern over the extent of domestic surveillance to his boss at the NSA, and in response his boss revoked his access to key systems.

I can no longer find anything that indicates that. I also do not see it listed in this timeline.

Does anyone know if Snowden went to his boss at the NSA before leaking to the Guardian?

Also, I heard that Snowden posted a rant to a blog post about his concerns under his internet handle. I cannot find that anymore either.

tks2103··on Phil Fish and the Internet’s war against creatives
Do you believe that stating a problem clearly has no value? What about identifying the 'correct' problem?

If you believe someone has the same goals as you, but is attempting to solve the 'incorrect' problem, is it pointless to point out the discrepancy?

I don't think so at all.

tks2103··on Phil Fish and the Internet’s war against creatives
OP and I disagree on what the problem is.

OP believes society does not do enough to cause people to be creative. That kind of problem has one kind of solution. Perhaps the very grant that Phil Fish used to initially fund his development of Fez would qualify.

I believe people that make death threats are solely responsible for their actions. They need to be held accountable. There are tons of ways to hold them accountable.

One such internet community built solely around internet gaming is Lethalfrag's Twitch.tv channel. You can see for yourself the quality of commentary on his show. He has spoken at length about his methods for maintaining a solid community. He does not do it by providing people with a creative outlet.

But I shouldn't have to point out an example of a successful internet community to assert what the problem is. I think it is in the ways in which we hold people accountable for their actions. Maybe you do not believe that is the problem.

In any case, I cannot imagine you believe the problem is that we do not make it easy enough for people who make death threats to be creative. That's an awful lot of grace we give a person before expecting them to change their behavior.

tks2103··on Phil Fish and the Internet’s war against creatives
My greater point was that I don't think "we should actively encourage people to pick up a creative hobby" in response to those people making death threats.

There are already people who are choosing to pick up creative hobbies. Those people make games. People that make games get crucified by gamers who do not like their decisions. Those gamers make death threats.

The people who make death threats can easily enough make something creative. Certainly there is no larger barrier for them when compared to someone like Phil Fish. I do not think we need to make it easier to expect better behavior from someone who is making a death threat.

We need to prioritize the people who made the extra effort to actually get up and make something over the people who chose to directly threaten the lives of the creator.

tks2103··on Phil Fish and the Internet’s war against creatives
I'm not sure that the responsibility lies with people or society at large.

Do you believe people on Twitter do not have the resources available to attempt creative works?

Furthermore, do you believe that, without being creative, it is not possible for a person to refrain from telling a game designer to kill himself?

I believe that individuals making death threats or rape threats on the internet are generally making individual choices with full knowledge of the repercussions. I do not believe they have any reasonable excuse justifying their actions. The responsibility for understanding and identifying how deeply they can damage another human is solely theirs.

tks2103··on Why I abandoned my startup
"The question left me sick to my stomach." "I went to bed that night with my head spinning." "...I had been living... in the 'trance of fear.'" "I knew that I was powerfully unhappy..., but I was powerless to do anything about it" "That revelation liberated me." "I was buying my life back."

dude, reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeelax.

sounds like you are about to do some cool stuff. excited to see what you come up with.

but, just so you have a different perspective, this is what i heard: you are leaving one company to start another company. the new company does water stuff, and you really like that.

tks2103··on Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In”
"I didn't want to say anything, but, I heard this Greenspun guy is a maaaaaaaaaaaajor douche."
tks2103··on Jaron Lanier: The Internet destroyed the middle class
which book would you recommend?

he's austrian right... are there better or worse translators for his books?

tks2103··on State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed
restating the thread:

steve19: 'legally you cannot export blueprints about weapons without an export license'

glenra: 'how did this manage to survive first amendment challenges?'

nness: 'how would this be a first amendment issue?'

in nness's comment, i am assuming 'this' is 'exporting blueprints about weapons without an export license'

in other words: 'how would exporting blueprints about weapons without an export license be a first amendment issue?'

you restated this as: 'how is censorship of speech a violation of freedom of speech?' first amendment issue very easily transforms to freedom of speech, but 'exporting blueprints about weapons' does not easily transform to 'censorship of speech'

nness question is essentially 'how does exporting weapon blueprints relate to freedom of speech?' it is not an absurd question.

you responded by equating 'exporting weapon blueprints' with 'censoring speech' with no argument, presupposing the conclusion from the question. ergo, begging the question.

tks2103··on State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed
don't beg the question.

there's no need for cursing.

tks2103··on State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed
why did someone downvote this?

it's literally a one liner question, and some intelligent responses were posted as a result.

im baffled.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →