HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tnzm

199 karma · joined March 26, 2021

https://bluffcorps.org

So, now you're onto me, huh?

submissionscomments
tnzm··on Hello Yarn 2, Goodbye node_modules
CommonJS is a great module system if you're using JS for scripting Unix (which it excels at). Is there a good reason to use ESM though? I've been half-joking that it's the "extinguish" phase of Microsoft's EEE strategy for JS.

I know one legitimate reason is "tree shaking" (source-level LTO when bundling modules). Dumber, static import/export statements probably simplify that in some way. Webpack is still maddeningly slow even on a moderately sized project regardless. Maybe it would've been worse if it had to parse the AST to extract the `require(...)` calls.

One change that ES modules introduced, I think, for no other reason than to be backwards incompatible, is changing the behavior of the default export (`export default foo` transpiles down to `module.exports.default = foo` instead of `module.exports = foo`).

Other "ohai guys this is the new normal now" kinds of changes are making the dynamic imports async-only (after not supporting them for a while) as well as changing the behavior of module resolution. Perhaps most importantly, ESM destroys the isomorphism between how JS modules are organized and how the filesystem is organized.

And the cherry on top is called TS-ESNode: https://github.com/K-FOSS/TS-ESNode because TypeScript modules and ESM are the same thing yet you need to somehow find this third-party shim which is required for them to work together at all. It's enabled by wrapping the interpreter, just like Yarn2's new dependency resolution.

tnzm··on Tortured phrases: A dubious writing style emerging in science
This is a social problem around the shared use of a technological resource. I'm reminded of the old saying, "computers can only solve problems that are created with computers".

But then again you can view _all_ solutions to social problems as inherently technological in the broader sense; I adhere to that paradigm.

tnzm··on Under the skin of OnlyFans
Right now, certain media outlets have been promoting a "debate about sex work". As usual, this is meant to shutdown any productive debate on the subject. You seem to start with a preconceived notion that "sex work" is harmful and people need to be prevented/protected from engaging in it. As with any aspect of our society, there are too many feedback loops involved here for anyone to have an opinion which is not based on anecdotes and propaganda, except the sex workers themselves (maybe!)

So let's discuss the general case instead.

Stigma and ostracism are very ancient tools for ensuring compliance within a social group by threatening members with social exclusion; however, quicker/earlier stigma prevents non-conformity earlier, but it also locks people out "on the outside" quicker/earlier. Stigma is also easy to abuse - it's the perfect excuse for hurting someone who you see as "less than human" due to their stigma, and then blaming them for it.

If you're betting on a civilization collapse scenario where in-group cohesion is the decisive factor for survival, it would be rational for you to uphold stigmatization of any behavior that diverges from the established rituals of your in-group. Our present civilization, however, has decided that social exclusion is harmful in the general case, and (quite haphazardly) is trying to remedy _that_.

As our systems become stable enough to support people safely "going further" with their diverse, even mutually incompatible lifestyle choices, the logical conclusion would be to eradicate stigma and replace it with a more humane way of nudging people away from potentially harmful actions.

tnzm··on The data privacy paradox and digital demand
A study of privacy preferences within a Chinese walled garden? Talk about selling refrigerators to the Inuit...
tnzm··on Conspiracy: In Theory and Practice
That's what you need true believers for: cannon fodder. Unlikely for someone to chicken out if they're already heavily emotionally invested in the idea of achieving spontaneous unity with God by blowing themselves to bits.
tnzm··on Peloton's $3k treadmill now comes with surprise 'subscription fee'
Yes.
tnzm··on Human Rapamycin Longevity Clinical Trials Begin
Chimps practice filial cannibalism too. Unless someone proves that the principles behind politics are inherent to the universe at large, I guess I'll keep my hope for transcendence.

Hadn't read that book but I'll check it out, thanks!

tnzm··on Human Rapamycin Longevity Clinical Trials Begin
I was thinking along the lines of:

* Officials accepting bribes to approve unsustainable (and sometimes directly deadly) projects, so that they can fund their kids' education

* Regular folks not speaking up against injustice because "they've got a family to feed"

* The "think of the children" card (a.k.a. "we've forcibly cultivated a set of behaviors in our offspring in order to ensure ourselves a comfortable old age, and your radical novelty threatens to disrupt that, dammit")

* Genghis Khan propagating his genome through the reprehensible acts of rape and military conquest. (Although that's not really a "compromise" but the actual essence of a kind of "warrior ethos" that some contemporary populists derive their tripe from)

Point being, it's a sort of norm to excuse acts that negatively affect the well-being of our peers by saying we're doing them in the name of the well-being of our successors. (Not like anyone's asking the successors, who might not even be born at that point. It's just "how life is".)

Barring a "Chinese brain" interpretation, the "entire world" is not a coherent decision-making entity; the majority of human beings living at any point in time have had very little say in "how the world is". World-changing economic decisions are made by a minority - who probably don't have the diabolical motives that conspiracy theories ascribe to them, but are most likely just working in the interest of their children, too (consequences to everyone else's children be damned - which is a possible symbolic meaning of the popular "paedophile cult" conspiracy theory, presuming "lizard folk" symbolize disillusionment with representative democracy, etc.)

tnzm··on Human Rapamycin Longevity Clinical Trials Begin
New lives are not inherently more valuable than old lives. You can already see this reflected in contemporary morality and the discourse around preventing human lives. After all, a life not lived is a life free from suffering.

A lot of the suffering inherent to human life is caused by moral compromises made for the sake of future generations' well-being. Instead, if the norm was living long enough to have to face the long-term consequences of your actions first hand, maybe old people could not afford to be so rigid. They would not be able to "wash their hands" by dying (and possibly leaving any wealth amassed through immoral means to their innocent heirs.)

Personally, what I'm looking forward is augmenting human cognition over long periods of time. I do worry that the result would not necessarily be any more agreeable, or even comprehensible, from our current standpoint, than (post-)modernity would be comprehensible to a caveman; but what I fear is something else entirely: I fear that people would occupy their expended lifespans with centuries of technologically augmented personal drama and sociopolitical "4D chess" - an advancement in complexity of our fundamental primate nature, but otherwise not different from what we do now.

I already find it disappointing that the most valuable thing most people have going on is their "personal" life. And an extension of this principle towards (comparative) eternity would be supremely so.

tnzm··on What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hopes $8.50 per hour
Why? Does it threaten your sensibilities?
tnzm··on Initial Stress-Derived Noun
>pawn shop vs porn shop

That one has happened to me IRL.

tnzm··on America’s Dead Souls
Real talk.
tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
Your boot, sir.
tnzm··on Feeling like a pariah, even when you’re not
No, sadly mine is the case of "bouncing off rock bottom".

But I believe that our society claims the responsibility of helping its most vulnerable members to their feet? If that's the case I'm pretty sure someone would come up with a better way to do that than "a miracle", if we'd just all put our minds to the question of how to help people regain self-control, rather than leaving them to figure it out all on their own.

The first step would be coming to terms with just how much we all rely on each other's helplessness.

tnzm··on Feeling like a pariah, even when you’re not
"You're always in control" means "others will always hold you responsible, no matter whether you're in control or not". This model is called "virtue ethics" and I consider it disconnected from reality.

If you don't know you're in control, you're not in control. It's as simple as that. In my ideal world, one who has lost their self-control or self-awareness would be helped by one's community to regain them. In reality, when normal people see your self-control faltering, they will either try to protect themselves from you or to take advantage of you. Maybe not murder you outright, but definitely get rid of your presence, which is only going to amplify the disconnect.

That is a positive feedback loop, in the pure physical sense: the more alienated you are, the more alienated you become. It's like pointing a microphone at a loudspeaker.

Any system, including your emotional well-being, generally needs a negative feedback loop: when you get too much of something, you start getting less of it, and when you get too little of something, you start getting more of it.

This is complicated by ideological hijack of the signifiers "positive" and "negative". When they say "positive", they mean "thanks for accepting our groupthink as self-evident, you will be favored". When they say "negative" they mean "you have no right to be critical, you will be disregarded". I consider this use of language untruthful and abusive.

> I choose how, and what, I show to the rest of the world, and if I want a positive feedback loop, it starts with me.

I can't even tell if this is supposed to be 1 or 2 insights, but I can tell you're right about running into the usual self-help territory. To me such sentences are quite intentionally devoid of meaning (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_clich%C3%A...), and following them to their logical conclusion would take one right back where one started, which is the ultimatum we're all born to: embrace the nonsense or perish.

tnzm··on Feeling like a pariah, even when you’re not
Damn, have you considered social experience could be the reason someone ended like that?

It's a feedback loop and the less in control you are, the less in control you are. Until you hit rock bottom. Which might not happen, and where you might bounce off, or not.

tnzm··on Feeling like a pariah, even when you’re not
Yep just kill him and then there's nobody to have that problem. /s
tnzm··on Introverts can make great leaders (2018)
I agree with your overall sentiment but it is a polarizing comment and it does not propose an alternative. If the group with worse values is better at normalizing their values, no progress is made.
tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
The keyword here is consensus. Using an append-only distributed public ledger to record your governance decisions (and be held accountable for them) is a lot like using a memory-safe language when programming. It induces non-negligible overhead, but prevents entire classes of opportunities for abuse.

The whole "blockchain-backed international treaty" example is admittedly a bit contrived though. It's kind of a "horseless carriage" thing - trying to explain to @markwkw that no "blockchain payments" would be necessary, by expanding on their mental model. (Maybe that's an unwise strategy, and I need to start just rudely dismissing people instead, but I'm not sure how that would help with comprehension)

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
To add, it's also completely legal for the powers that be to treat you like an animal if you try to make yourself independent of them.

Unlike the existing system of governance, a blockchain doesn't have the mandate to beat up people.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
Speaking as an engineer, that's what's wrong with diplomacy and politics!

EDIT: I define "reneging on the deal" as "acting as if the deal never happened".

The more governance decisions are recorded on the public record, the less opportunities there would be for parties to say "the other guy started it".

Also the deal could be set up to hurt both parties if they violate a predetermined condition. Maybe burn 5% of each party's GDP. Then they would be actually incentivized to collaborate.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
You're correct that hard AI would be necessary for the blockchain to perform autonomous arbitration in cases where human discretion is necessary.

In practice, this is solved by giving the contract the capability to query an external system (referred to as an oracle), which provides the results of the independent arbitration as an input to the contract.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
The big problem, in my opinion, is that a lot of people think we'd inevitably be beating each other up like animals, if it wasn't for the powers that be, who kindly protect us from ourselves.

And it is already legal to beat up and kill each other over a property dispute. It just has to be a large enough dispute for the parties involved to be able to afford rebranding it as a "war".

tnzm··on Universal basic income to be tested in Wales
>they care for what they think is the truth, and what support their opinions.

I'd take this one step further and say that the majority of people don't have consistent opinions about what the truth is, they only care for receiving the informational stimuli they've been conditioned to perceive as pleasant.

UBI is therefore an experiment in nomenclature. The reality of governments giving money over long periods of time to citizens whose labor is not market-competitive is nothing new. What's being tested is how it's branded: "welfare, benefits" is a humanistic, "socialist" way of branding it while "universal, basic, income" are words more in line with the rationalistic, "neoliberal" memeplex.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
> Works as well as anything.

Which is to say, just barely well enough to keep going.

And then there's the whole thing with how its scaling issues are mitigated via the platform dependency on the state's monopoly on violent enforcement. Emphasis on monopoly.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
>but, from what I understand, when you have supply chain trust issues, they don't look like "oh gee someone edited a database record", they look more like https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-03-09/trader-bu...

>Normally, in such cases of non-delivery a trading house could make a claim against a cargo’s insurance policy. But Mercuria found that just one out of seven contracts used by the Turkish company to insure the cargo was real. The rest had been forged.

Can't forge a smart contract.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
Governments A and B meet and discuss some deal. Their agreement is recorded on a public append-only ledger, which is hosted by participants worldwide. If any party reneges on the deal, that's remembered by the public record too, where no amount of propaganda can erase it. Parties confirmed to be less trustworthy are subsequently afforded fewer compromises during negotiations.

A NFT could also be minted, where people and institutions stake money on the deal and if either party breaks the agreement, the NFT is burned. So stakers are incentivized to do whatever is within their reach to make governments stick to the deal - otherwise they would lose their investments.

The way to bootstrap participatory democracy in a world that only cares about the money is to bake it into the money.

tnzm··on Microsoft is shutting down its Azure Blockchain Service
They invest on behalf of the house.
tnzm··on For those who can afford it, quitting has become the ultimate form of self-care
To add to the sibling comments, and with the risk of sounding cheesy - at least prisoners are aware that they are unfree: they are physically confined against their will by a well-defined entity for a clearly stated reason and duration. That doesn't help much with their mental degradation, except maybe making it less unexpected (although people are still surprised by the idea that prison just hardens criminals so idk.)

Outside of a penal institution, your freedom is limited by a multitude of varying affordances: behavioral nudges, implicit value judgements, unstated social conventions, and so on, which automatically limit your behavioral options. Many of these pressures contradict each other, and handling the cognitive dissonance every waking moment can slowly add up to decision fatigue.

So it is very easy to end up chasing whatever you sincerely believe to be "success", yet do it unnaturally and in spite of yourself. To compare with the prison example: it's very easy to get stuck in a situation where there is no obvious "enemy" who's keeping your stuck, and no obvious reason things are like this besides "they randomly ended up like this". And you can keep doing this for longer than the whatever the average prison term is, because you don't realize your idea of "success" is not really yours at all, it's a label you put on an unstable compromise with the totality of your being.

This is your brain on misaligned incentives. If you've ended up in such a situation, you're also probably in an environment that censures the kind of thinking required to realign them, and which offers no support with the work involved in getting out of the trap. So it's also very easy to start feeling like there's something wrong with you in particular, and slip into more chronic forms of burnout, depression, and more or less permanent mental dysfunction.

It's especially bad when a society runs on unresolved internal contradictions for a few generations - everyone's burnout adds up to a form of pervasive malaise, and the reactions can be quite brutal and senseless. Germany in the 1930s Germany or Russia in the 1990s Russia come to mind - historical periods whose horrors are usually downplayed in favor of romanticizing the struggle for survival in a society which offers no hope for a good life.

It can be draining. IMHO that's one reason why religions, ideologies, conspiracy theories, pyramid schemes, and other arbitrary value systems (including the monetary one!) manage to motivate people so well, regardless of having no ultimate basis in physical reality. They offer you a chance to extinguish all your self-doubts and replacing innumerable fickle sensors with a single value scale, so instead of suffering impostor syndrome and burnout, you end up happily believing that you're always right, and blind to any actual harm you might be causing.

So if you're currently having your brain fried by the world, remember that it's not your fault, and please do whatever it takes to resist and get yourself back to the clarity of a healthy mental state - even if that means letting go more preconceptions than you're comfortable with.

tnzm··on The Oncoming Ransomware Storm
Yep, you're alright. I like that you talk like a person and not like a copywriter.

The lack of creative (or just non-dogmatic) thinking in this place is something else though. At times it feels like there's no human in the loop, which is disappointing because this is one of the few interesting forums remaining on the whole Internet...

And even here's not immune to waves of people bulldozing over a nuanced conversation by parroting whatever ideological orthodoxy they've had to internalize to be able to successfully signal "lookit me HR I'm normaaaal".

Fitting to mention Eliza - designed to be a shrink simulator IIRC? - sometimes I wish someone developed an AI to make people reflect on their blind spots in the rudest and most efficiently disruptive way possible. Thanks to the magic of AI, the ethical concerns of doing that to someone would vanish into thin air!

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →