HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tominous

1,196 karma · joined February 11, 2016

submissionscomments
tominous··on Infant simulators don't prevent teen pregnancy
For me, if you wanted to simulate the worst part of having a baby, it would be a random alarm clock (5+ times a night) with a ridiculously complicated off switch. Maybe with sprays of bodily fluids. A cross between sleep deprivation torture and that number-entering bit from Lost that stops the world from exploding.

Every baby is different and every parent is different, but:

- You may not get restful sleep for a couple of years after the birth (my daughter didn't go to bed easily and sleep through until 3 1/2).

- If you breastfeed, you may not get your body back for a while yet. Even if you don't, it is exhausting catering to the whims of small kids. I'm a guy and my body is tired every day after carrying two kids around.

- There are new and exciting forms of pain waiting to be discovered.

Luckily the memories fade pretty quickly - I got a rude shock when the second came along and reminded me of what it's all about.

tominous··on GitHub lost $66M in nine months of 2016
FWIW the phrasing I use with clients is "fixed-price for successful completion of the following objectives" so it's a bit of a moot point.

I do think you're overstating the research though. Many studies of unconscious priming haven't been replicated, and psychology as a whole is very subject to publication bias. [1]

Anchoring is a real effect, and I'm a fan of Kahneman (especially prospect theory), but the evidence about "incidental" influences is very weak.

[1] http://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-f...

tominous··on Go to the Wrong Hospital and You’re 3 Times More Likely to Die
Another data point: 30-day mortality rates for high-risk acute heart patients are lower during the dates of national cardiology meetings, i.e. when the top doctors are away.

http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullart...

tominous··on Scientists engineer mice genomes to lengthen their lifespans by 30 percent
Yes and tetracyclines like doxycycline affect mitochondrial function and may confound the research in that way too.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2015.02.034

tominous··on GitHub lost $66M in nine months of 2016
That's good advice, but I don't think getting paid to produce a specific result is anchoring to "free". I guess it depends on how precise the scope is. If it sounds vague and up to the client's discretion, that they just want free work on spec, then run away. But if it's easy to define and measure, then it's a useful way to signal competence and avoid anchoring to a rate instead of the business need.

Anyway, I'm happy to say that I avoided this customer (and others that care excessively about timesheets) and I have no regrets.

tominous··on GitHub lost $66M in nine months of 2016
Too true. I had a potential client who had already spent months and a bunch of money on external consultants regarding an intermittent identity management integration issue. They heard about me through word-of-mouth.

I offered a fixed-price "no win, no fee" rate equal to about a week of my normal hourly rate. I thought it was a great deal given how much they'd already spent, plus it gave some certainty to them around something could have been very messy and open-ended.

The client got hung up on, "What if Tom only takes an hour to solve it? What an expensive rate! What a rip-off!" They were more concerned with seeing me put in time and effort than actually getting results.

tominous··on Vitamin pills don't work and may be bad for you
Not necessarily; see radiation hormesis [1]. Small amounts can be beneficial even if large amounts are harmful.

We also know there's a link between more sunlight and less incidence of other types of cancer. It's still unknown whether this is mediated by Vitamin D or other mechanisms.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hormesis

tominous··on Vitamin pills don't work and may be bad for you
I'm a huge fan of taking pharmaceutical shortcuts, but a small amount of daily sunlight gives you much more than a vitamin D tablet. There are benefits in mood, sleep, and eyesight. Plus the many fun things that can be done outside alone or with friends.

I used to think that going outside (and exercise in general) was something I had to "make time for" and spend energy on. These days I realise that going outside actually boosts energy. I work to live, not live to work.

tominous··on Bose Hearphones
This Reddit comment [1] suggests that people who work around CRTs a lot have a "notch" on their hearing tests at the CRT frequency of 15.734kHz. So yes it is possible.

On the other hand, you probably don't want the tinnitus that often comes with noise-induced hearing loss. Better to be able to turn off the noise (or wear earplugs) than to hear it all the time.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1tepwv/why_is_t...

tominous··on The Distribution of Users’ Computer Skills: Worse Than You Think
"You must use Firefox 10 or higher."

Unexpected impasse. Multiple steps. Requires navigation across multiple pages and applications.

Just taking the test is a Level 3 task.

tominous··on Who Lives with Their Parents?
mental illness (though I think someone did and is doing this to me)

With apologies to patio11 [1], we really do need a word for "A denial which is phrased in such a fashion as to make listening observers think it is more likely, not less likely, that the thing being denied actually happened."

That said, very insightful comment otherwise!

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13034011

tominous··on Young blood does not reverse aging in old mice, UC Berkeley study finds
My guess is that the effect of the inhibitors is not linear with concentration.

Imagine that the effective (deleterious) dose of these inhibitors is, say, 10% of the amount found in old mice. So an equal exchange between two mice is enough to provide an effective dose to the young mouse, but not enough to eliminate an effective dose to the old mouse.

tominous··on Many LASIK patients may wind up with glare, halos or other visual symptoms
I'm not an ophthalmologist but I did a lot of reading and talking to optometrists when I couldn't quite get a prescription I liked. It was one of the tests I considered.

For what it's worth I solved my own issue by insisting on a slightly stronger prescription (-0.25) for my myopia. It's well worth a try, especially for driving at night. The easiest way to tell if it would help is if green traffic lights look significantly blurrier than than red traffic lights in the distance.

tominous··on Many LASIK patients may wind up with glare, halos or other visual symptoms
Apply a cycloplegic such as atropine to the eye to force the eye muscles to relax and focus as far away as possible. Then use a retinoscope to shine light on the retina and observe it while adjusting lenses over the eye.

And of course slightly older babies have ways of communicating without words! https://youtube.com/watch?v=84-Cuc-Tz2o

tominous··on The year you were born predicts flu risk
That explains tiny variations, but the article is talking about a shift to a new variant which requires a different immune response.

The question is why did this new variant "completely replace" the old ones in the population, instead of just operating in parallel?

The only thing I can think of is that the old flu variants were in decline already due to herd immunity, but the article seemed to imply there was more to it than that.

tominous··on The year you were born predicts flu risk
> [In 1968] a pandemic of H3N2 influenza, known as the Hong Kong flu, completely replaced the H2N2 and H1N1 seasonal influenza strains that circulated earlier.

I'm curious about the idea of flu viruses completely replacing each other. Do they interact or compete for resources in some way? Could we design a very mild flu which would replace other variants?

tominous··on Gwen Ifill has died
I'm not a doctor but have been dealing with cancer in the family. I think we will soon see much more use of fine-needle techniques in cancer treatment in novel ways.

Perhaps the next big thing will be an oil-and-gas engineer adapting drilling, guiding and visualisation technologies to the very small scale.

Directly killing the cancer cells is often futile because you can't kill them all, but we could also use this tech to:

* take samples of the the tumour and its microenvironment to analyse and guide treatment

* inject biological agents into tumours (e.g. T-Vec)

* inject "broad-spectrum" immunotherapies (ipilimumab, various cytokines) which may be too dangerous to use systemically

* insert radioactive grains or auger targets as an adjunct to enhance immunotherapy

* apply local electroporation to enhance the uptake of chemotherapy and breakdown of tumour cells, again to enhance the immune response (e.g. ImmunoPulse)

* take samples in order to grow personalised treatments in the lab for later injection (e.g. dendritic cell therapy)

* provide safer options for dealing with complications like pericardial effusions.

tominous··on Berlin Is Bringing Back Subway Trains from the 1950s
The communist murals are also timeless (but seriously, well worth a visit: the subway stations in Moscow are beautiful).
tominous··on Researchers reach human parity in conversational speech recognition
The other day I asked Siri, "Remind me to pick up [daughter's name]" but it interpreted that as, "Remind me to pick up pussy." A more context-aware engine would realise we don't even have a cat. On the other hand it made me wonder to what extent Siri is trained on real-world data from other users.
tominous··on Why Your Next iPhone Won't Be Ceramic
The author goes to the trouble of using the phrase "takt time" and linking to its definition but then misuses it. Assuming non-stop operations and 1 million units a day, the takt time (average time between unit starts) is about 85ms, not 3-4 minutes. Assuming a cycle time for interior milling of 240s, the difference is a factor of about 3000, which matches the estimate for the number of milling machines operating in parallel.
tominous··on Ask HN: I'm an old programmer, do I qualify for diversity consideration?
Thanks for confirming what I suspected in the first place: that anti-discrimination laws actually reduce employment in the protected classes. I.e. if it's harder to fire someone you'll be less likely to hire them.

You seem to have read an awful lot into what I said! We could have had an interesting exchange about whether the drop in employment and the added compliance burden are worth the special protections, higher average pay, etc of those who still manage to get a job. Anyway, maybe some other time!

tominous··on Ask HN: I'm an old programmer, do I qualify for diversity consideration?
A manager wouldn't care if their company were sued for a pattern of discrimination based solely on the numbers, because it is extremely hard to prove a pattern, even harder to prove intent, and the burden and blame would fall on the company not the individual.

By contrast a specific anti-discrimination claim would be very personal, very damaging, and (according to your scenario) completely unexpected and uncontrollable.

It's well known that (rational or not) uncertainties of this kind are weighted very highly and such situations trigger avoidance.

As to evidence, I offered an example of the type of evidence that would persuade me and you were the one that claimed it was contentious. So please don't put that label on me.

Regarding social change through laws, I can offer cases where social change came before changes in laws (e.g. blasphemy, slavery, child labour, apartheid) and cases where laws have not produced the desired social change (e.g. prohibition, drugs). I think the burden should be on those who promote certain laws to show that they actually help overall. Every law has a cost, especially one that produces so much uncertainty.

As to being rational, my other original point was that in a market those who act more rationally succeed, grow, gain influence, and crowd out their competitors. This is the kind of bottom-up change that I believe is actually responsible for social change.

tominous··on Ask HN: I'm an old programmer, do I qualify for diversity consideration?
Thanks, I appreciate your points: (a) that in many cases discrimination laws have resulted in a positive outcome for the person discriminated against, (b) that the modern workplace is better than in the past and (c) that people are trained on the relevant laws, which presumably influences behaviour in a positive way.

I can't argue with point (a) because that's obviously true. But as with the Linux/SFC case I mentioned, sometimes a win is not worth the wider cost. The risk of a licensing lawsuit causes companies to shy away from free software. Does the risk of a discrimination lawsuit cause managers to shy away from protected classes?

Point (b) is also true but we don't know if it's due to the laws, or due to the general change in society that prompted the laws in the first place. Yes this is a hard question. I was hoping there might be some natural experiments out there: similar jurisdictions with different laws or different timings.

Point (c) is interesting. You say that many offices are trained on the law, but then shortly afterwards you say that most employers don't know the relevant laws. In addition, we don't know whether the training improves the situation. For example, a recent Australian Defence Force study [1] suggested that "The level of anti-Muslim sentiment among individuals who have received cultural sensitivity training is, if anything, higher than among those who have not" (with caveats about sampling bias, but in the end leaning towards "no relevant differences" in the sample groups).

It would be interesting to see any similar studies regarding attitudes before and after anti-discrimination training in the workplace. Are managers more or less likely to hire from a protected class after such training?

My point about lawful excuses and rationality is that people who are truly discriminatory will find ways to get around the law, so there will be minimal positive impact, while people who are rational will find that the law disincentives hiring from a protected class due to the increased risk.

[1] http://www.army.gov.au/~/media/Army/Our%20future/Publication...

tominous··on Ask HN: I'm an old programmer, do I qualify for diversity consideration?
I'm curious as to whether these laws make a positive difference in practice.

If someone is truly racist/sexist/ageist then they could probably invent a lawful excuse for their hiring behaviour anyway. On the other hand, if they are rational then (a) they would already benefit from hiring these workers cheaply because the demand is lower, so they would win in the market, and (b) the discrimination laws would increase the expected cost due to the increased potential for lawsuits.

It reminds me of the recent Linux discussion about how lawsuits are poisonous to the community and cause companies to avoid participating. [1]

Does anyone have any empirical data on the actual outcomes of these laws?

[1] https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/ksummit-discuss/...

tominous··on Noms – A versioned, forkable, syncable database
Adam Leventhal (DTrace, OpenZFS) took a look at building a FUSE filesystem on Noms using Go.

http://dtrace.org/blogs/ahl/2016/08/09/nomsfs/

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12255450

tominous··on Be Kind
I can't resist chiming in with another Endymion reference: the Hyperion Cantos by Dan Simmons. Fantastic series.
tominous··on Exploring CLI Best Practices
I like having the option to use both short and long forms. For common tasks the short form becomes second nature and saves time. For scripting or rare tasks I appreciate that the long form is self-documenting and less prone to typos.
tominous··on The terrorist inside my husband's brain
The problem with metaphors linking the human body with society is they are essentially fascist. The "parts" have no value and the "whole" is supremely important.

So it is incumbent on people who use these metaphors to remember that in society the "parts" (i.e. each individual) do have value. Otherwise it's too easy to turn things around and say, "Terrorists are like disease, we must kill them all; that fast-growing ethnic group is like cancer, we must cut it out."

I don't blame the author in this case as it's a very personal account, but readers should be sure to keep the distinction in mind.

tominous··on Goldman's Libya Salesman Was a Little Too Good
As per my other comment, on the face of it, it does seem illegal under laws in the US and UK such as the FCPA. Maybe someone could clarify though.

To add some more, there is an affirmative defense to the FCPA that it is ok to give gifts/payments that are lawful according to the written law of the country [1]. Libya has some laws against corruption but they are rarely enforced and may not have been in place at the time [2].

Anyway, it seems strange to me that this article is about a new legal theory of "undue influence" and a salesman being uniquely "too good" when the concept of bribery has been around for thousands of years. Maybe the article could have said something like, "Libya screwed itself over by not having anti-corruption laws, and therefore it's trying a different legal approach."

[1] https://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/fcpa.pdf

[2] https://www.state.gov/documents/organization/230900.pdf

tominous··on Goldman's Libya Salesman Was a Little Too Good
I'd expect firms that are based in the US or UK would be subject to laws against bribing foreign officials, e.g. the FCPA:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Corrupt_Practices_Act

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →