HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomtheelder

2,019 karma · joined July 26, 2016

submissionscomments
tomtheelder··on Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music
I haven’t seen the video, but I assume what it’s getting at is that if you have like a simple 5 over 4 polyrhythm and you speed it up sufficiently you’ll start to perceive it as a major third.

I kind of also think that’s a little meaningless since while tempo for a beat and pitch for a tone are both sort of frequencies we perceive them completely differently.

tomtheelder··on GitHub Actions could be so much better
I think they framed it accurately and you are instead over complicating. Language for scripts is a decision that virtually every team ends up making regardless. The other questions are basically all irrelevant since the scripts and actions are both stored in repo, and therefore released together and versioned together.

I think the point about maintenance cost is valid, but the thesis of the comment that you are responding to is that the prebuilt actions are a complexity trap.

tomtheelder··on Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Left Should Talk About It
But I see it discussed in left leaning media all the time. Topics like male suicide rates, loneliness, and social pressure against showing emotion come up over and over again.
tomtheelder··on Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Left Should Talk About It
This just doesn’t line up with my experience whatsoever. For my friends on the left it’s a common topic, and I see it discussed in left leaning publications all the time.

I wonder when I see these characterizations of the left if they are coming from social media. I’m not on any social media aside from this site I guess, so I’m not sure if that’s what’s going on. The folks on the left that I interact with in real life are definitely a very big tent group.

tomtheelder··on Unity’s new pricing: A wake-up call on the importance of open source
And what I am saying is that they absolutely are not designed to do different things any more. That used to be the case, but Unreal has fully eaten Unity’s lunch here in a technical sense. The engine’s roots are in AAA first person, but they have grown it far, far beyond that. It is now a fully capable general purpose engine for anything from 2D puzzlers to AAA FPSes.

There just are not games any more for which Unity offers any legitimate advantages over Unreal. Unity has been incredibly stagnant as an engine for pretty much a decade, while Unreal has expanded its capabilities and feature set to now virtually fully encompass those of Unity. The idea that they are designed for different things is just out of date.

In 2023 I think the only legitimate reason to pick Unity, and this is a very good reason for what it’s worth, is experience with the engine. I say this as someone who published games in Unity in the past and has transitioned to Unreal. They are both general purpose game engines serving the same teams and the same games, with the exception that Unity cannot support truly top end games.

tomtheelder··on Unity’s new pricing: A wake-up call on the importance of open source
They really don’t at this point. Unreal has reached a point where it’s a better choice than Unity for nearly every single project. There’s still these pervasive beliefs that Unity is better for 2D or better for small teams, and it just isn’t true.

The one exception is junk mobile games, and even then I think Unreal is a completely reasonable choice.

Unity has been well and truly left behind with the gap widening every day and they know it.

Their coexistence is a legacy of a time where Unreal had not widened its viable use cases beyond triple A style 3D games, but that hasn’t been the case for years now. It’s just taking a whole for developers to catch up, and obviously there’s a lot of inertia with Unity projects and experience.

tomtheelder··on Analyzing Starfield’s Performance on Nvidia’s 4090 and AMD’s 7900 XTX
I think all of those issues you listed were absolutely present in the Morrowind/Oblivion period. Really I don’t think it’s that Bethesda is a shadow of its former self. I think it’s that Bethesda still is its former self. The industry and our expectations have moved, but they really haven’t.
tomtheelder··on Effectiveness of wearable activity trackers to increase physical activity
Sources suggest 3-4000 steps on average for Americans, so an extra 1800 is actually a pretty big deal. 40 minutes of walking is no small thing for many.
tomtheelder··on Ask HN: Why is home property information so public?
It shouldn’t, but real estate disclosure isn’t the problem there.
tomtheelder··on The worst programmer I know
I actually don’t think that’s what the author is arguing. They are arguing that certain metrics that are valuable to measure at a team level become less useful or even misleading if you zoom in too far to an individual level. Story points being a good example. Useful when talking about a team, not useful when talking about individuals. That’s a more nuanced point, and one that I definitely don’t think is obvious to everyone.
tomtheelder··on VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
Out of curiosity, why would you opt for a steel frame? Durability?
tomtheelder··on ISPs should not police online speech no matter how awful it is
Presence of citations has near zero meaning in terms of goals of the writing or bias. These are so clearly opinion pieces. One is bordering on an attack piece.
tomtheelder··on How South Korea’s birth rate dropped below Japan’s
Then why does the birth rate steadily go down as you move up the income curve? My experience is that my wealthy adult peer group just has almost no interest in having children while my high school friends, many struggling badly financially, all already have families.
tomtheelder··on ISPs should not police online speech no matter how awful it is
Amendment to the post you are responding to: any reason aside from membership in a protected class.

Political belief does not, and absolutely should not, constitute a protected class.

tomtheelder··on ISPs should not police online speech no matter how awful it is
Following all my opinion, but easier to write without constant hedging:

IMO public discourse is less controlled by private corporations/organizations now than at basically any other point in our history, with the possible exception of like, 10 years ago.

There was never previously any realistic method for a private citizen to gain a platform to meaningfully influence discourse. Traditional media _literally_ defined the narratives in play. I’d argue that a whole lot of the ideological carnage and polarization going on is directly a result of the “democratization” of public discourse.

While there was some oversight, the reality is that news media still had basically total control over whatever narrative they were interested in pushing.

In fact, I’d argue that a lot of the ideological chaos and subsequent censorship we have seen recently is precisely a result of private corporations losing control of public discourse.

tomtheelder··on ISPs should not police online speech no matter how awful it is
I would have to disagree with the characterization of two opinion blog posts from relatively unknown authors as “unbiased sources.”
tomtheelder··on Live worm found in Australian woman’s brain
It is very safe, but that doesn’t mean the risk is zero. The fact that stories like that have become major news stories kind of illustrates how unusual it is these days.
tomtheelder··on Live worm found in Australian woman’s brain
Honestly Lyme disease is blown way out of proportion. It’s not all that hard to check for ticks to avoid it, and the course of the disease with treatment really just isn’t particularly serious for most who get it. There’s even growing skepticism around the presence of some of the reported sequelae.

The big things if you are in a Lyme disease area are to check for ticks and just go to the doctor if you either have the rash or symptoms.

Regularly taking antibiotics is awful for your gut health, somewhat risky from an antibiotic resistance perspective, definitely risky from a C Diff perspective, and probably wouldn’t even help very much since you do need to take them somewhat promptly after infection.

tomtheelder··on Live worm found in Australian woman’s brain
Firstly, not all worms are created equal. The most common worms in NA and Western Europe (like pinworm) just aren’t that serious.

Second, absent actual testing, the risk/reward of deworming is very much a function of the likelihood that you actually have one or more of these worms. That probability is too low in, say, the US to give routing deworming positive expected value. It’s telling that even routine testing isn’t worth the time/cost.

Thirdly, it’s not like… _exactly_ clear that all of these parasites are a problem in the first place. Many of them are frequently asymptomatic with negligible long term consequences. There are even those who believe that the near eradication of hookworm and its minor gut immunosuppressive effect in the developed world is the explanation for much higher rates of inflammatory bowel disease. I that one, but the general idea is that a lot of these worms just don’t actually cause much harm.

And lastly, deworming medications aren’t exactly a joke. They can have serious risks associated with them. Overall it just doesn’t make any sense to routinely deworm in the developed world.

tomtheelder··on Fresh evidence of ChatGPT’s political bias: study
Things that people within a demographic happen to believe is pretty much exactly what bias is. Bias isn’t like… a bad thing. Everyone is biased toward their own viewpoints.

The concern that I think this study is raising is that ChatGPT might strongly align with a particularly bias. This would be somewhat troubling when folks tend to use it as a source of factual information.

tomtheelder··on Car Bloat: “Huge Cars Are Terrible for Society”
Yeah my Kona EV falls into the comically silly class of “sub compact SUVs.” Also known as: this is a hatchback, but we know Americans won’t buy it unless we pretend it’s an SUV.

Previously I owned a proper hatchback, and the dimensions are extremely similar. The hatchback was even a little longer.

tomtheelder··on Car Bloat: “Huge Cars Are Terrible for Society”
While that’s true, a relatively small portion of Americans live in an area where that’s a serious concern. Yet go to any suburb and you’ll see huge numbers of SUVs.
tomtheelder··on Car Bloat: “Huge Cars Are Terrible for Society”
Even if that’s true, it’s an absurd reason to own a truck.
tomtheelder··on Car Bloat: “Huge Cars Are Terrible for Society”
20-25 miles highway is absolutely appalling. Like shockingly terrible. A conventional ICE minivan would get 10-15 extra mpg with additional room for passengers, and would cost less. A reasonably sized hybrid would easily get double the mileage.

In my opinion, full size trucks are the absolute worst vehicles on the road in terms of those trade offs. You get pitiful gas mileage, a tiny cab, high prices, and the thing is absolutely massive despite most folks only generally using a tiny portion of it at a time.

IMO the only justifiable reason to drive a pickup is if you tow or carry extremely volumes of stuff on a near daily basis.

tomtheelder··on Remote work requires communicating more, but less frequently
IMO you try these in order:

- Direct feedback to the manager about your needing space to work and their disruptive behavior.

- Same feedback to their manager.

- Look for new jobs.

There’s no way to solve this that avoids direct feedback and the possibility of confrontation.

tomtheelder··on Tell HN: I think I found Toyota's battery
I agree with the previous commenter. If you level 2 charge at home you have to drive a pretty preposterous distance to ever have range issues. Road trips are another story, but they are infrequent.
tomtheelder··on Reasons Not to Be a Manager (2019)
> There is a reason vast majority of football coaches/managers are former players

The reason there is nepotism. It’s insanely difficult for anyone without preexisting connections to get any sort of coaching opportunity. I definitely think ex players make worse coaches, generally speaking. They just have an almost insurmountable leg up.

I do think eng managers should be technical, though. Not because I think you need to have done a job to manage it, but because they are frequently asked to make what amount to being technical decisions.

tomtheelder··on Remote work on HN: Who is hiring? – 69% jobs in 2023 are remote
Anyone sane should oppose _some_ unions. They don’t all make sense/provide positive value. Looking at you, public sector unions.
tomtheelder··on American universities have an incentive to seem extortionate
The tone of this comment is totally inappropriate for this site. The end is an intentional attempt to insult and incite.
tomtheelder··on Signal president says company will not comply with U.K. ‘mass surveillance’ law
That’s a less common meaning of the word interpolated, meaning to change, usually with the connotation of corrupting. Typically I see it used to describe text, but it makes sense here too.
← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →